Mike Portnoy Quits Dream Theater

Mike Portnoy, founding member of progressive metal legends Dream Theater, has quit the band after 25 years. Widely accepted as one of the finest drummers in the music industry, his decision has come as a shock. He released the following statement on 8th September, explaining his actions:

"I am about to write something I never imagined I'd ever write.

"After 25 years, I have decided to leave Dream Theater... the band I founded, led and truly loved for a quarter of a century.

"To many people this will come as a complete shock, and will also likely be misunderstood by some, but please believe me that it is not a hasty decision...it is something I have struggled with for the last year or so....

"After having had such amazing experiences playing with Hail!, Transatlantic and Avenged Sevenfold this past year, I have sadly come to the conclusion that I have recently had more fun and better personal relations with these other projects than I have for a while now in Dream Theater.

"Please don't misinterpret me, I love the guys dearly and have a long history, friendship and bond that runs incredibly deep with them... it's just that I think we are in serious need of a little break.

"Dream Theater was always my baby...and I nurtured that baby every single day and waking moment of my life since 1985... 24/7, 365... never taking time off from Dream Theater's never-ending responsibilities (even when the band was 'off' between cycles)... working overtime and way beyond the call of duty that most sane people ever would do for a band.

"But I've come to the conclusion that the Dream Theater machine was starting to burn me out...and I really needed a break from the band in order to save my relationship with the other members and keep my Dream Theater spirit hungry and inspired.

"We have been on an endless write/record/tour cycle for almost 20 years now (of which I have overseen EVERY aspect without a break) and while a few months apart from each other here and there over the years has been much needed and helpful, I honestly hoped the band could simply agree with me to taking a bit of a 'hiatus' to recharge our batteries and 'save me from ourselves'...

"Sadly, in discussing this with the guys, they determined they do not share my feelings and have decided to continue without me rather than take a breather... I even offered to do some occasional work throughout 2011 against my initial wishes, but it was not to be...

"While it truly hurts for me to even think of a Dream Theater without Mike Portnoy (hell, my father named the band!!), I do not want to stand in their way...so I have decided to sacrifice myself and simply leave the band so as to not hold them back against their wishes.

"Strangely enough, I just read an interview that I recently did that asked me about the future of Dream Theater and I talked about 'always following your heart and being true to yourself'... Sadly, I must say that at this particular moment, my heart is not with Dream Theater...and I would simply be 'going through the motions,' and would honestly NOT be true to myself if I stayed for the sake of obligation without taking the break I felt I needed.

"I wish the guys the best and hope the music and legacy we created together is enjoyed by fans for decades to come... I am proud of every album we made, every song we wrote and every show we played....

"I'm sorry to all the disappointed Dream Theater fans around the world... I really tried to salvage the situation and make it work... I honestly just wanted a break (not a split)... but happiness cannot be forced, it needs to come from within.

"You Dream Theater fans are the greatest fans in the world and as you all know, I have always busted my ass for you guys and I hope that you will stay with me on my future musical journey, wherever it may lead me.... (and as you all know my work ethic, there will surely be no shortage of future Mike Portnoy projects!)"

Rumours stating that he had quit started circulating last week, with most fans dismissing them as false. Recently, Portnoy has been touring with American hard rock band Avenged Sevenfold following the death of their drummer Jimmy "The Rev" Sullivan in 2009. Rumours are now spreading that Portnoy will be named as a permanent member of the band. However, this has not yet been confirmed or denied.

Thanks for the report to MH400.

Comments

[Aftertime]

wow this is a shock

well the best to the bend and Mike i guess.

[NakedInTheRain]

I was devastated when I read the news.

But I do believe he deserves a break.

[Shreddaboi12]

didn't see that coming..

[Eirien]

No way! I couldn't imagine DT without Portnoy, but there's no denying his other bands are better (with the obvious exception of avenged seven fold). I'm just glad I got to see them a couple of times with Portnoy at the helm. I couldn't think of any other drummer with the stage prescence of Mike.

Best of luck to him and the rest of the guys.

[Eirien]

Oh, and fingers crossed that there will be a new LTE album at some point.

[Heavens_To_Hell]

I'm not a DT fan, but when I saw them live Portnoy held the whole thing together. Interested to see who steps into the fold now, and whether they'll continue those OCD little touches like rehearsing hours and hours of music so they can rotate the set-list by city.

[Martyfan]

Why isn't this on the front page? Really shocked. It's a shame the band wouldn't let him take a break. Dream Theater without Portnoy... hmm.

[District]

Nooooo!... What the hell are the other members thinking? A hiatus would do them some good anyway. Damn... how can they split with the man who wrote the majority of the songs, whose father made up the bands name, who's the most insane drummer ever.... hell, who can possibly replace him?

[HellBoy9393]

WHAT IS THIS I DON'T EVEN

[guitar77432]

holy jesus. I definitely did not see that coming at all. the other members are kinda dumb for not staying with him, that guy is the only reason Dream Theater are so big ... oh well, good luck to them are Mr. Portnoy.

[NightEmbers]

i hope you all had a chance to see Dream Theater at least once in your life, its one hell of an experience

[AEnima18]

NightEmbers wrote:

i hope you all had a chance to see Dream Theater at least once in your life, its one hell of an experience

I saw them, great experience. I'm so glad I did because they will never be the same without Mike. He was the driving force of the music and wrote a great deal of the lyrics. Replacing him properly will be impossible. I'm bitterly disappointed with Petrucci, Myung, Rudess and LaBrie for letting him go. RIP DT

[UnaLaguna]

Sounds like the best for both parties. Portnoy was pushing the band into a more generic metal direction, which didn't suit them.

Jordan Rudess has said that, when he was in the producer chair, Portnoy has tried to get the band to write songs which emulate other bands. Rudess has indicated that he's much rather write genuinely new, innovative music rather than ripping off other bands.

Hopefully Rudess will get a bigger voice in DT (he's been seriously underused on their last few albums), the band will once again start featuring keyboards prominently, and - as others have said - they will return to a more progressive sound.

[deconno]

I can't believe it, I'm in shock. That's the end of DT as far as I'm concerned, MP was THE man.

[ark091]

nooooo

[Hungry_Hameds]

Never really heard much of them, but it's clear from the lack of "I dont care" messages that this is the end of an era. May have to educate myself

[FearOfTheDuck]

He will return after everything he wants to do, good on him for leaving

[Lion_Slicer]

MP: "I haven't had a break in 20 years. I need a little rest."

Rational Person: "Good idea, I think I'll follow your lead as we work very hard and it would be best to continue our productive musical relationship once we are in a more peaceful state."

DT: "Go ahead lol, we don't need you"

If they don't HAUL ASS to make something ****ing brilliant beyond reason to show they really don't need Portnoy, DT is done. Also whoever they put on drums will forever be known only as "Not Mike Portnoy."

what the hell

[nicksword87]

DT don't really do anything for me but shame to see members leaving. Especially after this long. I reckon bring in Gavin Harrison. Actually on second thoughts maybe he should stay with Porcupine Tree. he is already doing lots of side projects as it is.

[iceman45]

Lion_Slicer wrote:

MP: "I haven't had a break in 20 years. I need a little rest."

Rational Person: "Good idea, I think I'll follow your lead as we work very hard and it would be best to continue our productive musical relationship once we are in a more peaceful state."

DT: "Go ahead lol, we don't need you"

If they don't HAUL ASS to make something ****ing brilliant beyond reason to show they really don't need Portnoy, DT is done. Also whoever they put on drums will forever be known only as "Not Mike Portnoy."

what the hell

+1

[Rimfrost]

The Obvious thing that should happen now: Neal Peart steps in to help the band out

Damn this is bad news, can´t imagine how they should be able to replace him. But then again Kevin moore was awesome too, and yet they found a worthy replacement in rudess. Though i would still prefer moore.

[Skinny91]

Finally, now he's not busy he can harness his true talent in my White Stripes cover band. Return my calls Mike.

[Rimfrost]

^^
I´m not sure he got enought skill to play seven nation army :p

[UnaLaguna]

Lion_Slicer wrote:

MP: "I haven't had a break in 20 years. I need a little rest."

Rational Person: "Good idea, I think I'll follow your lead as we work very hard and it would be best to continue our productive musical relationship once we are in a more peaceful state."

DT: "Go ahead lol, we don't need you"

If they don't HAUL ASS to make something ****ing brilliant beyond reason to show they really don't need Portnoy, DT is done. Also whoever they put on drums will forever be known only as "Not Mike Portnoy."

what the hell

What? No - Mike Portnoy is the only band member who's been working solidly through 2010. He brought that upon himself by taking too much work on. Why should the other band members have to wait for him?

Not to mention that DT's last few albums have been pretty stale, and that's largely due to Mike Portnoy's stubborn refusal to allow outside producers in. Portnoy's only real contribution, apart from writing drum parts, have been frankly weak lyrics and acting as a poor producer, pushing Dream Theater in a more straightforward, metal direction which doesn't suit them. Portnoy's method of writing a song is "Guys! Let's write a song like [insert band here]." Portnoy is not so much a musical artist as a music fanboy, and it really shows.

If anybody was going to quit Dream Theater it was going to be Portnoy - he very very nearly quit on the Falling Into Infinity tour.

[campbell92]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.

You're an idiot. Read the press release. It's Mike's decision and A7X didn't ruin him, themselves or Dream Theater. I thought that Mike and the DT guys were close but I guess I was wrong. DT have been my favourite band for the last 3 years and seem to be the most accurate representation of my musical taste. Everything I listen to can be traced back to them, they started it all for me. They were my first true musical obsession and have remained so throughout my high school years. Portnoy was my favourite member of the band and as far as I'm concerned, the backbone of Dream Theater. I'm glad I got to see them (traveled 12 hours just for them) this summer before the split. DT may not have been that well known to most people but I think it can be said that these guys were one of the most underrated, technically talented and well rounded bands to represent progressive rock and were huge contributors to keeping it alive the last 25 years.

[nerv]

Well too bad, but DT had a break this year and he decide to record an album and tour with A7X, if his main band is DT he shouldn't be making that band wait so he can tour with a crappy band like A7X

[soundgarden19]

That's a bummer, but he has been at it for two decades, and that takes some real dedication.

[Stu18]

It's disappointing, but this is what happens when you do too much. Sure, stuff could be said about musical direction, the band's wishes and so on, but you gotta know that the other guys got used to him doing so much and when they didn't want a break and he needed one, something had to give. Props to Mike's work and talent over the years, and whoever sits in on drums, it will change their sound. I enjoy their whole catalog, so regardless of the new sound, I'll probably enjoy it anyway.
Who knows, maybe time will repair the rift and they'll be back as they were. I hope so, Mike's an amazing drummer.

[Lion_Slicer]

UnaLaguna wrote:

What? No - Mike Portnoy is the only band member who's been working solidly through 2010. He brought that upon himself by taking too much work on. Why should the other band members have to wait for him?

Not to mention that DT's last few albums have been pretty stale, and that's largely due to Mike Portnoy's stubborn refusal to allow outside producers in. Portnoy's only real contribution, apart from writing drum parts, have been frankly weak lyrics and acting as a poor producer, pushing Dream Theater in a more straightforward, metal direction which doesn't suit them. Portnoy's method of writing a song is "Guys! Let's write a song like [insert band here]." Portnoy is not so much a musical artist as a music fanboy, and it really shows.

If anybody was going to quit Dream Theater it was going to be Portnoy - he very very nearly quit on the Falling Into Infinity tour.

I rather liked Octavarium and Systematic Chaos (album that got me into DT)... I'm just saying that if I were in a band and my friend had himself so overworked I'd be more understanding. It's not like Petrucci & co. wouldn't have anything to do, what with side projects and all. Though I understand wanting to keep DT's momentum and the reasons for both sides here. If there were a way to keep it together I'm sure they would have done it--mostly I'm just pissed and pretty shocked.

[deathofarev]

NO!!!!! this cannot be...very very sadface moment

[withoutanyname]

I almost cried reading this... wow, the rest of the guys in DT lost a bit of my respect... I can't believe this, wow, just WOW...

all the best to MP and the rest of DT, though they need to record something pretty solid, 'cause if not, they'll die soon...

[TheBadPlace]

NOOOOO!

Good for him that he's doing what he needs to, but he was easily the most enjoyable part of DT for me. Best of luck.

[trivum_rulz666]

deconno wrote:

I can't believe it, I'm in shock. That's the end of DT as far as I'm concerned, MP was THE man.

couldnt agree more DT with out Mike is like Sepultura without Max, Igor, Jairo DT should change the name or call it quits Mike WAS the heart and soul of DT ENOUGH SAID!

[Jack Darkley]

I think the only way DT can work is if they get a huge fan who plays drums just as well as Portnoy. Sort of like Judas Priest did with Ripper Owens. I think that's the only way fans will accept the change.

Overall, I just want to say that I support both Mike and DT in whatever they do.

[djtraceman]

This is bad news no matter how you look at it. DT will forever and always be my favorite band. it was somewhat simple to replace KevMo and Derek, but replacing a founding father of the band will prove to be extremely difficult if not impossible.

I wouldn't blame this on anybody i doubt it's A7X's fault. they were just as shocked as we are. besides, he never stated what projects he was doing next.

but, since we all have a theory, Here's mine:
-It's somewhat of an early midlife crisis. true, Mike is tired and worn out and we all know that. the rigorous write/record/tour schedule would wear anybody out. if that's whut he's been doing the last 20 years of course it's gonna feel normal and obligatory as the years move on. touring with Hail and A7X and doing all his other projects are new times and experiences. so after doing that so much he simply decided to he'd rather take a break from DT than have it feel obligatory and no longer fun. just look at his twitter, he's having a blast with A7X and enjoying himself, but notice they are younger than he is and i'm sure a night/day off with those dudes is way different than a night/day off with DT. he's been having fun and want to keep doing so. a short hiatus would've probably led to the craziest DT album ever. so in time, i hope the band comes to their senses and Mike returns to his and they make that album.

either way, best wishes to both Mike and the remaining members of DT.

[everjump]

I hate year 2010.

[yearzero]

Talk about being a hard guy to replace...he was one of the best drummers I've ever heard and I'm not even a fan of DT.

[ztmusic09]

Holy shit! This can't be happening! DT is one of the most amazing bands I've ever heard.....NOOOOO!!!!

[josh999x]

FUCK!

[yasman88]

UnaLaguna wrote:

Sounds like the best for both parties. Portnoy was pushing the band into a more generic metal direction, which didn't suit them.

Jordan Rudess has said that, when he was in the producer chair, Portnoy has tried to get the band to write songs which emulate other bands. Rudess has indicated that he's much rather write genuinely new, innovative music rather than ripping off other bands.

Hopefully Rudess will get a bigger voice in DT (he's been seriously underused on their last few albums), the band will once again start featuring keyboards prominently, and - as others have said - they will return to a more progressive sound.

Rudess does have a lot of say doesn't he? I hope Myung takes initiative again -- we need another Learning To Live from Dream Theater.

But having said that, I want Portnoy to be there when that happens..

[iro-bot31]

UnaLaguna wrote:

Sounds like the best for both parties. Portnoy was pushing the band into a more generic metal direction, which didn't suit them.

Jordan Rudess has said that, when he was in the producer chair, Portnoy has tried to get the band to write songs which emulate other bands. Rudess has indicated that he's much rather write genuinely new, innovative music rather than ripping off other bands.

Hopefully Rudess will get a bigger voice in DT (he's been seriously underused on their last few albums), the band will once again start featuring keyboards prominently, and - as others have said - they will return to a more progressive sound.

This. If Rudess (and Myung, I loved his songwriting) get a larger role in the writing process I won't really mind Portnoy leaving that much. Plus, with him gone they won't have any faux-growling to ruin songs with potential (I'm looking at you, A Nightmare to Remember).

[shreducator]

Wow...

[Alive@myfuneral]

He's such a talented drummer, Dream Theater will be worse off without him but i guess everyone has to take a break at some point

[AkFlare]

Really shocking. Can't wait to hear the new DT sound without Mike

[__Pent__]

Good thing I saw DT earlier this summer.

Anyways, he seems to not be saying that he wanted to leave DT forever, just that he needed a break, but the rest of the band didn't want to take a break. So, I think what will happen is that Mike will go off with some other bands for a while, while DT makes an album or two without him. Then, when he feels he's had enough of a break, he'll eventually rejoin DT.

[Broken-pick]

I'm fine with him quitting DT, at least he's following his heart.


BUT WHY THE FUCK A7X?!

[awsomeguitarguy]

dont really care about dream theatre... but i understand how big of a deal this is

[HollishGuy]

I can't say I agree with Mike's decision, but I respect it nonetheless. If he wants to do something else that's up to him, it's nothing we fans should have any say in. He played in the band for 25 years, so I can very well imagine that his musical interests and personal preferences have changed over the years to the extent that they don't fit in the Dream Theater mold any longer. It's better to part ways peacefully than split up violently. That said, I wish Mike all the best in A7X and I can't wait to hear some post-Portnoy Dream Theater stuff. Hope it sounds awesome!

[gr2ove2thmusic]

THis is the biggest travesty ever.....i love this band to bits...they are the best in the world....i have never seen the perform but i hoped i would in the next year (just moved to the US)...am absolutely gutted....wont be the same without him.....

But at the same time, i would like to wish them the best of luck and succes in their future....whatever it would be.

Go Dream Theater

[strat07]

Dream Theater
1985 - 2010

I HATE MY LIFE NOW!

[DGBnpiy]

Saddest news in years of my life. ever.

[arcwarrior]

complete shock. don't blame a7x guys. both DT and A7x now - drummerless.

i'll miss DT without MP. i like their last album and that epic song entitled count of tuscany

[toine]

It's his choice in life. I wish him all the best

[theking4everr]

This changes everything.

[....Satan]

Man this is gutting enws . I didn't even get a chance to see them live either

[Clabbe]

Wow.. Thats to sad.

[charles_ebarb]

WOW!

DT needs a haitus now. That'll give the rest of us a chance to get into the limelight now!

[Astyan]

Ruined my day, week and possibly the whole month. Such a shame.

[Offworld92]

WAT.

But, I think it's awesome that he's doing what he wants, rather than letting DT become one of those 100 year old bands where they always fight and all hate their lives. I can say that and I'm not even a fan. I have a lot of respect for them though.

I personally hope he joins A7X, because I love that band, and he did a really good job with Nightmare, he can produce a convincing "The Rev" sound.

But I would completely understand if he didn't because A7X wasn't challenging or interesting enough for him.

Then again, after 20+ years in DT, maybe that's what he's looking for. Who knows?

[x0vincent0x]

this is the end of dream theater, mike can't be replaced

[maximumrocker]

wow....
just .... damn....this week is just horrible

kamelot cancelled their tour, and now Mike breaks from DT....

[James_Het_Rules]

I have no problem with this. I love DT, and saw them June 22nd with Maiden, and they were great. But honestly, I thought their new album was bad. I'm glad to see Mike doing other stuff, and If he does join A7X, that's cool. I loved their new album, and it'd be cool to see Mike work with them on some new stuff.

[zoso2306]

well, thats the end of that chapter :/ at least we still have opeth!

[askikr91]

Stop hating. The man has been working his a** off for 25 years making challenging, technical music. Getting out of his "cage" and doing other stuff is fun and exciting for him so let it be.

[JEM9311]

NOOOOO!

[Eirien]

I do love DT, but am I the only one who thinks every side-project/spin off band/solo-project (not cover bands) any of their members do is better than what they produce together? It's a case of the band being lesser than the sum of its parts.

[Lion_Slicer]

zoso2306 wrote:

well, thats the end of that chapter :/ at least we still have opeth!

please don't jinx it

[Holoogamooga]

I agree with a lot of you about DT going in a new direction without such a demanding producer, but at the same time, there's some worry they just won't be able to produce anything themselves. I have a feeling it will get a lot proggier from here on out.

It could easily take six men to replace Mike - two on drums, one on production and mixing, one on writing, one on vocals, and one to manage tours and setlists.

As for a drumming replacement, I doubt Neil Peart would fill in. He'll stick with his own band, because that's how he is, and that's great. Gavin Harrison would be great (except he's already in two bands), and Chris Maitland could probably handle it.

[Jøhnny]

Damn, I can only imagine how huge shock this is for DT fans... I wonder who will be their next drummer, it's definitely not an easy place to replace and the new drummer will be hated by many old fans...

[HelpTravesty]

OH FOR SURE.

[98Timberwolf]

Damn... seriously mixed feelings here!

[willXromance]

There is a lot of hostility towards Avenged Sevenfold, blaming them for the departure of Mike Portnoy. Which is just a crappy excuse for many Dream Theater fans who are finding it hard to stomach the fact that one of the founding members/backbone of the band is now gone. I personally am a fan of both Dream Theater and Avenged Sevenfold. I don't blame anyone, like Mike said that 25 years of constant touring and recording gets tiring. I don't blame him. This is in no way, Avenged Sevenfolds fault. Mike needs a rest. And to you all who are hating, I challenge you to form a band and try to stay together for 25 years and see if it doesn't exhaust you.

[shwilly]

In a long history of me not seeing things coming, this one ranks pretty friggin' high, and that's DESPITE reading about these recent rumours...

Don't worry people, he'll be back. Just not for a while, and when he does it's definetly not going to be the same, meaning no more 1 album + world tour every 2 years (average)

I just wish the other guys could've granted his wish > I mean, I don't blame them for being the overproductive s.o.b's that they are (hell, if I could play and write like Petrucci I wouldn't want to sit on my ass all day either) but perhaps they should've followed Mikes example by laying off the DT for a while. It's only been a year since "Black Clouds" for f**s sake, and to be honest that record didn't show a lot of growth when compared to "Systematic Chaos"

I'm not saying EVERY band should be like Tool, but taking extended breaks every few years HAS proven fruitful to a lot of bands. You KNOW there's no way to please the true hardcore fans anyways (hell, they'd probably buy DT tickets for every week of the year if they could) and I think it's fair to say that no real fan is happy with this solution

[MegadethFan18]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.

Can you count? less than half the album is slow songs. Plus it's not like Avenged said "Mike join our band or we will kill you" he said it was an "honour" to play with them so STFU donnie.

[bass-man9712]

That sucks, but i completely agree with the man, one man can't do that continuously for 20 years and not be effected by it. He needs a break and sadly it ends up with him leaving the band. I don't understand why they wouldn't share his views though :/

[Zead2]

whats with the avenged sevenfold hate? its not like they talked him into quitting a band where he was doing most of the work for 20 odd years, and then when he decided he needed a break, they just decided to carry on without even letting him do some small parts in the future.

[gl.tch]

I wonder how many voicemails Gavin Harrison and Neil Peart have between them.

[metalheadblues]

wow that's unfortunate but hope he does some stuff with porcupine tree and opeth dude's i'm really looking 4wd to that..Good luck finding a replacement for Mike Dream Theater

[ironwolg]

i was hoping that DT would take a break so everyone could do their own side projects or take breaks or whatever, i think that would have been a better decision i hope he gets to rejoin DT soon. Maybe their next album will be good. I don't think that DT kicked him out and i don't think they wanted him to leave.

[Danucalov]

if Transatlantic release an album every year, i'm okay with that...


and he did not leave Dream Theater to be in Avenged, he said that he was thinking about that for about a year, before The Rev dies...

[Kylianvb]

Damn... Good for him though. Sure hope he comes back someday.

[Nameless742]

James_Het_Rules wrote:

I have no problem with this. I love DT, and saw them June 22nd with Maiden, and they were great. But honestly, I thought their new album was bad. I'm glad to see Mike doing other stuff, and If he does join A7X, that's cool. I loved their new album, and it'd be cool to see Mike work with them on some new stuff.

Can you imagine that? leaving DT to join A7X, Wouldn't happen of course. but this was a HUGE SURPRISE

[rip3149]

i know there will be a point in the future when he'll return. when that will be i have no idea. imagining DT without portnoy, petrucci, myung, labrie, or rudess is impossible. i thought it was over when kevin moore left back in the mid 90s but i quickly realized there were other players that could fit the band. portnoy is irreplaceable. that said i wish all parties the best. especially mike!

[Noverion]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.

Dude, its opinion. I thought their last two albums were BY FAR their best, and indeed, their self titled is one of my all time favourite albums.

I'm pissed cos DT are my fave band. I was really enjoying the direction they moved in for the last album, which is one of my favourites, perhaps I like Images and Words and SFAM better but BCASL was definately up there for me. Having said that, my least favourite albums are the ones that bear his mark the most - Systematic Chaos and Train of Thought, and so i'm certainly interested to see where they might go from here.

[flem187]

OMG!

[HardRock369]

why avenged sevenfold, that's all i want to know.

why. mike alone comes in with twice the talent the entire band has overall, and you will never be able to convince me they will write songs to fulfill the potential they have with him.

all i know is that avenged's new cd better be the greatest thing to have ever been spawned on this earth.

[Holoogamooga]

To those hoping for a Wilson/Akerfeldt/Portnoy project, the former two said they have songs written and there's no place for drums in them.

I don't doubt Mike will return to DT in the future, even if it's only as a guest drummer live or something. If Mike really wants to take it easy he could just be a studio drummer for a while, too.

[Nyhm]

dude, of course he is going to like hail!, david ellefson and andreas kisser played together

[stndrdprcdre]

I'm sure it probably is a lot more fun recording and touring with Avenged Sevenfold, but I highly doubt this is the last of his involvement with DT. This sounds more like an indefinite hiatus than a parting of ways.

[FatLouie]

If the boys are smart they had better call Thomas Lang!

[mergapoot]

holy shit, i'm just in shock.

[humperdunk]

must've realized dream theater's kinda been sucking lately

[rip3149]

their next album will do worse than falling into infinity

[Apejack Cuba]

It's not like this will make him capable of writing a good song.

[crazysam23_Atax]

I blame AX7. Their new album, except for MP's drums, sucked anyway.

[Tallica94]

OMFG!? No Mike don't leave Dream Theater!!

[HarvesterofPain]

This is the end of DT as we know it. Whether that is for better or worse is subjective and entirely beyond the point of my post.

I won't be blind enough to say that I will never listen to a Portnoy-less Dream Theater. However, seeing as Portnoy IS my favorite drummer, I will say I'm already finding it very hard to imagine the band without him.

[Mr Winters]

Never got the chance to see Dream Theater (I'm not very much into them, although I really love some of their songs) live, but next month I'll see Avenged Sevenfold, so I'll at least have a chance to see Mike.

[Uber Man]

WHAT!!!!! i may have said that five times before i clicked the link

[TsarBomba]

NightEmbers wrote:

i hope you all had a chance to see Dream Theater at least once in your life, its one hell of an experience

Saw em three times. They're alright.

[lupinitic]

i can't imagine Dream Theater without Mike Portnoy, but i respect that choice

[piszczel]

Let's just hope he won't join AX7 permanently now...

[TinyNipplesTom]

if your blaming this on avenged sevenfold you deserve to die, in my mind DT is the past and mike has probably realised that and hes most likely extreamly bored so i cant blame him for leaving but im sure DT will find some way to carry on.

[dedguy666]

I haven't really given Dream Theater a listen, but I don't know what the big deal is about Avenged Sevenfold. I can't stand that band. I don't even like their old stuff with all the screaming and that's the type of music I listen to.

[TsarBomba]

UnaLaguna wrote:

Not to mention that DT's last few albums have been pretty stale, and that's largely due to Mike Portnoy's stubborn refusal to allow outside producers in. Portnoy's only real contribution, apart from writing drum parts, have been frankly weak lyrics and acting as a poor producer, pushing Dream Theater in a more straightforward, metal direction which doesn't suit them. Portnoy's method of writing a song is "Guys! Let's write a song like [insert band here]." Portnoy is not so much a musical artist as a music fanboy, and it really shows.

This times a hundred, btw.

[agm_ultimatex]

@dedguy666 i have to agree, i dont care much for their stuff. But I loved them when i saw em live at uproar.

Read MP's post on facebook last night, i was quite sad, still am. Had trouble going to sleep last night. I can't imagine DT without him, as he's such a big driving force to the band.

[jw_4256]

what the ****! i understand he needs a break and all but dream theater without mike is like christianity without jesus, it just wont work

[vermilion444]

Who cares if he joins Avenged Sevenfold? I don't care for them either but it would be his personal decision, right? I'd think he would be more of a sellout by staying with DT when it's obviously what he doesn't want. If he's having more fun with this other band, then he should be allowed to join them without all of his "fans" pissing and crying that their lives are ruined now. Musicians aren't your trained monkeys, they are people too.

[Alibavomit]

Why god, Why!!!!!

[Root Beer]

While I'm very saddened by this, I think he did the right thing; better to take a break than produce half-hearted material. And if Dream Theater does plan on continuing, they're obviously gonna need one hell of a drummer.

[ShiningEntity]

Are people ****ing stupid? He HASN'T LEFT DREAM THEATER FOR A7X. The ignorance and presumption of some people is actually painful.

[Root Beer]

vermilion444 wrote:

Who cares if he joins Avenged Sevenfold? I don't care for them either but it would be his personal decision, right? I'd think he would be more of a sellout by staying with DT when it's obviously what he doesn't want. If he's having more fun with this other band, then he should be allowed to join them without all of his "fans" pissing and crying that their lives are ruined now. Musicians aren't your trained monkeys, they are people too.

this exactly.

[thesilentmansm]

I'm just speechless!

[matx33]

Well I'm just glad I saw them before he left.

[TunerAddict]

Most of you are selfish pricks.

A man can do what he wants with his own life. Respect his decision or gtfo. He doesn't live his life to please you. You aren't the center of the universe.

[cam-5150]

Quite frankly, I don't see how Mike could have realistically expected the guys in DT to take a hiatus at this crucial point in their career. They just scored an album in the TOP 10, which is unheard of for a relatively underground prog-metal band, they've been winning over more and more fans with each passing album and tour, and MP wants to take a hiatus because he's "burnt out on DT"??? Well, maybe if he wasn't trying to juggle 50 other side projects at the same time he wouldn't feel so "burnt out"... I'm sorry, but the guys in the band made the right decision. They were expected to indefinitely shut down the DT machine and kill all of their momentum just because one member was exhausted due to his his other many musical endeavors?! No, that's just not the way it works... I could understand if Mike wasn't doing anything else and he just wanted to take a hiatus for the purpose of resting up and spending time with his family, but that's not the case here. He's running around all over the creation non-stop with all of these other bands, and it obviously has taken a tole on his relationship with Dream Theater.

The bottom line is this: Mike Portnoy's gotta do what feels right to him, but the Dream Theater machine has got to keep going forward and progressing with or without him.

[Jak0lantern01]

As for Portnoy joining A7X: MIKE PORTNOY GOTTA EAT!

[FatLouie]

I have to say that MP is my favorite drummer so I respect whatever he needs to do. I will admit (as a DT fan) the last couple albums were good - not great. I've never been a fan of LaBrie's voice so I listen only for the music. DT has always been a band for musicians and I think at times it can be hard to meet that kind of bar - set so high. I look forward to seeing what else Mike gets into. It would be awesome if he went a completely diffrent direction such as Jazz or something and show how wide his range can be. I'm with ya Mike, whatever you want to do bro! (Sry to dbl post)

[btbamaddict]

Thankyou a7x. Oh well I guess Danny carry will have to do now

[foREVer666]

I dont see how anyone can blame A7x for this, it was his own choice. he even said he was thinking about leaving like a year ago BEFORE Rev even died, not to mention he never even said he was joining A7X to start with

[iceman45]

Lion_Slicer wrote:

zoso2306 wrote:

well, thats the end of that chapter :/ at least we still have opeth!

please don't jinx it

yeah, you jinx that, and i kill you.

[CoreysMonster]

Portnoy is gonna do what he thinks is right, and the rest of dream theater are going to do what they think is right.

I agree with Portnoy for leaving if he doesn't feel like playing for DT anymore, but I also respect DT's decision to keep on without him, but think that unless they get an amazing replacement, they will fall flat on their faces.

[Mr.Feather]

TunerAddict wrote:

Most of you are selfish pricks.

A man can do what he wants with his own life. Respect his decision or gtfo. He doesn't live his life to please you. You aren't the center of the universe.

This.

I am sad that I never got to see them live while he was with them, but it was his decision and I hope he continues to be awesome wherever he goes from here. Personally, staying with A7X is a little bit below him (don't get me wrong - I love A7X), but if he enjoyed it, and he likes the music, then everyone will be happy.

[volesky88]

vermilion444 wrote:

Who cares if he joins Avenged Sevenfold? I don't care for them either but it would be his personal decision, right? I'd think he would be more of a sellout by staying with DT when it's obviously what he doesn't want. If he's having more fun with this other band, then he should be allowed to join them without all of his "fans" pissing and crying that their lives are ruined now. Musicians aren't your trained monkeys, they are people too.

This.

[i_am_metalhead]

Honestly, I've never listened to a Dream Theater song and been amazed by the drum track. Not saying Portnoy isn't a talented drummer, but there really isn't anything about his playing that stands out in my mind.

[ibrahimasood]

swordsofplague wrote:

If portnoy joins A7X it will be the biggest waste of potential that this world will ever bear witness to.

lol this.

[NHECOS]

Didn't saw that one coming!!!

[ACIbanez120]

Hope the best for Mike and Dream Theater. Gotta hand it to him for having the balls to depart from Dream Theater. He's an excellent musician im sure whatever he does will be great. Keep on rockin' Mike.

[Gary.Blizzard]

Holy shit.

[prot]

i_am_metalhead wrote:

Honestly, I've never listened to a Dream Theater song and been amazed by the drum track. Not saying Portnoy isn't a talented drummer, but there really isn't anything about his playing that stands out in my mind.

This: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kd9p69_ah4s&feature=related

Just gotta WATCH him play some of the songs to realize everything amazing he does.

[daheck1210]

It sounds like he will return after a lengthy break. I will only lose respect for DT if they don't let him back in once he's ready.

Personally I think he's overworked and on the edge of a nervous breakdown. But mid-life crisis makes him sound not medically insane, so he's going with crisis. Remember, DT was supposed to be taking a break since the end of the Iron Maiden tour, but not Mike.

The Opeth/Porcupine Tree project duo said they wanted Portnoy initially, but he had DT. Maybe now they can have him?

And if one more person says "NO! A7X STOLE HIM!" I'm gonna go on a 5-state killing spree. A7X is not going past this tour with Portnoy on the drums and they're not even sure if they're going at all after this. They only made Nightmare because The Rev wrote 60% of the album and they finished it in his memory.

[megadeth4ever]

omg, i was just blind sighted. i was just sitting in my english class on UG, and then this. Oh well, looking forward to future stuff from MP and DT both. At least i got to see DT before, even if it was opening for Iron Maiden and not a full set, at least i can say that.

[Shredx]

Quite sad about this really, but MP deserves a break with all the other stuff with transaclantic, A7X etc hes been doing over the years, and I feel its a bit selfish of DT to take him for granted like that. I hope in the future they can join back together though.

[coco-axeman]

Well..... Didn't see that one coming.....

[legato89]

He better not have left for Avenged Sevenfold...

[Seref]

The only part of this that really shocked me is that Avenged Sevenfold is considered "hard rock."

[Wesserz]

DGBnpiy wrote:

Saddest news in years of my life. ever.

Agreed. Dream Theater was the greatest band ever. I pray they find a true DT fan to drum. All I truly hope is that he did not leave for AX7

[gilbertn923]

This does come as a huge shocker but I really don't think it'll last that long. Mike will go back to DT and he will regret this decision for the rest of his life.

[Anarchy_Ant]

This is madness...

All the best to both parties though, I will forever love and follow Dream Theater AND Mike Portnoy.

This is still a big shock however :|. Lets just hope that Portnoy/Åkerfeldt/Wilson can now do something.

[EpiExplorer]

ITS A CONSPIRACY. D:

[jamiels]

im 14 and never got to see them.

[jamiels]

jamiels wrote:

im 14 and never got to see them.

that didnt post properly.
was supposed to follow. sorry for double post

[Jastul]

This breaks my heart, I cannot possibly fathom Dream Theater without Portnoy, and can dffinitely think of no one that could cover match him that's not already fully commited to another band.
On the other hand I can see why he would need a break from the band and go work other projects with different people. I just hope he gets back on the DT machine asap, I still need to see them live and I want the classic line-up

[Tomamo5]

they should've gone on a hiatus. Dream Theater really isn't much without him.

[Wesserz]

swordsofplague wrote:

If portnoy joins A7X it will be the biggest waste of potential that this world will ever bear witness to.

AGREED!! +1

[jtdavin89]

who cares, its his choice.

[Guitar Skater]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.

MAJORITY WERE SLOW SONGS?

listen to the album first ass

[Luke200420]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

So when your album debuts #1 on the charts and stays in the top 20 for six weeks it means your career is ruined?
Nobody forced Mike to work with Avenged Sevenfold. He made the decision on his own. From what it sounds like he wanted to take a break from DT to tour with them and the rest of DT didn't want to wait so he just quit. It doesn't mean he's a permanent member of A7X.

[Skwisgaar S]

Tomamo5 wrote:

they should've gone on a hiatus. Dream Theater really isn't much without him.

Dream Theater really isn't much.

[herzeleid1995]

But... How can DT go on without him? I mean, when you make a blood pact with eldritch deities for that kind of musical prowess, losing a member can throw off the conditions of the contract!

You all DO know this means the apocalypse, right?

[bignuts20]

crazysam23_Atax wrote:

I blame AX7. Their new album, except for MP's drums, sucked anyway.

This just proves that you're hating on them for no good reason. The drum parts on Nightmare weren't even written by Portnoy.

[punker_7970]

I don't think this is the end of Dream Theater. To the contrary, it'll be the beginning of something interesting. If the band feels they can go without Mike, why shouldn't we? It'll be interesting to see how the lack of their drummer will affect their song writing. I'm also pretty sure that they can incorporate many of MP's ideas since they basically lived with the man for the last 25 years.

[sliceofpizza]

holy ball **** nooooo

[RapeFace McGee]

This is how I eased my friend, who's a massive Dream Theater fan, into the news, via text message:

Me: Did u hear about Mike Portnoy?
Friend: no wut????
Me: He died dude
Friend: WHAT????!!!! SERIOUSLY???
Me: Nah j/k he did quit dream theater, though
Friend: **** you
Me: you're less upset though, right?

[guitargodwannab]

with wut I am about to say i will be quoted and critized for this but it doesnt matter to me.

MP is a legend, simply the best drummer in Rock and Metal combined in history, with no disrespect to my fellow Canadian and Torontionian Neil Pert. Portnoy can do wutever he wants to at this point in his career and I can tell all of you this, there is no other band in the World left, excpet for A7X that would do what he has done for the past 25 years. yes we are all upset right now, but wen we look back at this in a few years and wen they reunite with MP with a kickass record, all DT fans will say "yeah, he was right for taking that break"

i totally have MP's back on this decision, i will always love DT and hope they last forever, but this really is needed. besides, i hope he joins A7X and it would be so fitting considering The Rev's favorite drummer is Portnoy (as you can hear wen they play).
Best of luck to MP, can't wait to hear wut u will be up to in your legendary career!!!

[Tim the Rocker]

Nooooo! Boolsheet!

[ordinary_story]

While this news hit me like a tidal wave, it should be interesting to see what kinda music MP and DT can do separately...hopefully he'll rejoin DT sometime in the future so the world can start spinning again.

[AllYourBass]

I love how so many people have determined Mike leaving DT means him joining A7X. News ain't news until it's news. Didn't he want a break?

Anyway, I enjoy Avenged Sevenfold but I've absolutely adored Dream Theater for nearly a decade. I'm saddened by the fact my musical idols are no longer a cohesive unit of PWN.

No matter how the fate of Dream Theater unfolds, I know (most of) the members also have solo work. As a bassist, I just want to stay tuned to John Myung. I've yet to unravel the mystery of his music and I'm not ready for him to fall away from the scene yet.

[Root Beer]

Anarchy_Ant wrote:

This is madness...

All the best to both parties though, I will forever love and follow Dream Theater AND Mike Portnoy.

This is still a big shock however :|. Lets just hope that Portnoy/Åkerfeldt/Wilson can now do something.

THAT would be about the coolest fukking thing EVER.

[DZCunuck]

'checks calendar. Not April 1st.'

Wow, never thought i'd see the day a member of that band left. At least Petrucci and co. aren't stopping work on the music. Portnoy will be missed but the band is bigger than just one man.

[DRxDOOM2309]

A7X probably makes a shitload of money from 12 year olds that just started listening to "metal" 3 weeks ago buying their music and merch. if portnoy sold out to be in gay7x then i have lost faith in the music industry

[Root Beer]

btbamaddict wrote:

Thankyou a7x. Oh well I guess Danny carry will have to do now

Hey, that's not a bad idea actually...

[Shinsen88]

Wow. Pretty shocking. I wish him the best, though. He deserves it. I'll still continue to support both parties.

[punkrocker79]

Okay Mike P is one of the sickest drummers out there and if he decides to do what he wants then good for him but dont go and take it out on A7X. Theyre the best Hard Rock band of the last decade. They suffered a huge loss when The Reverend passed and they got Mike to help em out cause he was The rev's favorite drummer. Dont sit here and blame A7x. Mike P is his own man and he can make his own decision. Personally i believe he should continue with A7x. Keep real music and real talent alive. Thats what needs to be done.

[Martin HaTh]

Fuck this shit, I never saw DT live.

GET BACK MP, GET BAACCKKKK!!!!

[me_llamo_juan]

DRxDOOM2309 wrote:

A7X probably makes a shitload of money from 12 year olds that just started listening to "metal" 3 weeks ago buying their music and merch. if portnoy sold out to be in gay7x then i have lost faith in the music industry

I don't think he solid out. As he said, he's following his heart man. It's never selling out if you're playing music you love and having a good time.

While Portnoy is not my favorite drummer and Dream Theater is not my favorite band, it's sad to see him leave. Best of wishes to him though and to the rest of the guys in Dream Theater.

[Nielo]

I can't imagine DT without Mike, but it's the truth, and now all we fans can do is keep supporting the band so that it can overcome this lost. But anyways, I wish only the best to Mike in any band he joins.

[me_llamo_juan]

punkrocker79 wrote:

Okay Mike P is one of the sickest drummers out there and if he decides to do what he wants then good for him but dont go and take it out on A7X. Theyre the best Hard Rock band of the last decade. They suffered a huge loss when The Reverend passed and they got Mike to help em out cause he was The rev's favorite drummer. Dont sit here and blame A7x. Mike P is his own man and he can make his own decision. Personally i believe he should continue with A7x. Keep real music and real talent alive. Thats what needs to be done.

The bolded parts are the ones I laughed at because they're hilarious. A7x is far from the best hard rock band of the last decade. Abd are you saying DT isn't real music?
But the rest I agree with.

[DejaSenti]

This actually just made me more curious as to who will take MP's place in DT, and what kind of new music they're gonna make.

Also, the "day after day, night after night" part in A Nightmare To Remember, and all things similar in other songs, are now officially performed by John Myung.

[kjcv]

I'm completely shocked!

[syngatesidol]

Thats a huge shock but I hope he stays with avenged because they need him and the rev would want HIM of all people in his place.

And for you guys hating on A7X, why dont you actually sit down and pay attention to their new album. Its freaking amazing regardless of how many slow songs are on it. They made a great music decision. They wrote about what they were feeling instead of appealing to the masses like everyone else did and they were proud of it. Them writing songs this way is how they were coping with his death.They did pretty much the same thing that Metallica did with Load, it just wasnt about Cliff Burton.

[Jezza40]

Wow. Good joke. Heh heh.

Guys...this was a joke? Right? RIGHT?!?

[Soccerguy]

Dream Theater without Portnoy is like chicken soup without soup. I just can't imagine who'll be able to come up with all those technical beats and everything that he does. Man I'm sad.

[Rocker_94]

Not a Dream Theater fan, but man, I'd never expected this to happen. On the plus side, for once we finally have real music news! So what now..Avenged Sevenfold full time now?

[flame843]

my top replacement ideas (however unrealistic they may be):
Danny Carey
Blake Richardson
Jason Rullo

[Nameless742]

Seref wrote:

The only part of this that really shocked me is that Avenged Sevenfold is considered "hard rock."

as apposed to? Metal?
Metalcore Maybe.
I'm a big fan of A7X and their new stuff, with all due respect, is pretty lame.
As much as I love A7X, even with portnoy they seem so musically spent.
He should join some talented metal band.

[PlayFreebirdNow]

syngatesidol wrote:
And for you guys hating on A7X, why dont you actually sit down and pay attention to their new album. Its freaking amazing

LOL

[jhart08]

DegaDeth wrote:

Fuck, this can't be happening. Fuck you A7X

[quote]campbell92 wrote:

yeah, cause the article said "avenged sevenfold forces Mike Portney to quit dream theater." Since everyone uses fail, i'm gonna stick with moron.

[Fallen_Seeker]

NOOOOO!
NOOOOO!
NOOOOO!

[Mike_Atherton]

I get the same feeling from this situation as i do when a girlfriend breaks up with me and says they never want to se or talk to me ever again...

[CPDmusic]

I respect his decision, but if he left DT for A7X, I think it was a pretty dumb decision. DT is light-years ahead, musically, as A7X will ever be. I think it would be awesome for his next project to start a super-group, with the same style of music as DT. Just my suggestion

[Thr3Elevenstyle]

really bad news: MP was an amzing drummer
really good news: no more MP backround vocals

[Soultaker05]

NOOOOO!
NOOOOO!

[Snake™]

Oh my.....

[AdriAn934]

This is heartbreaking
I truly though they all worked off each other so well, I never dreamed this would ever happen. I feel for Portnoy, because he has done all the over-seeing of the band, pretty much as manager. Maybe with him gone they'll realize how much work he put into it. I also feel bad for who ever replaces him cuz you know he won't get the time of day from DT fans. GAHHH!!!!!

WHY?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

I'm drinking tonight, and listening to Dream Theater and will most likely cry.

[Derk'ed]

Maybe the Rev can play for Dream Theater *troll face*

[thesilentmansm]

Soultaker05 wrote:

NOOOOO!
NOOOOO!

[AdriAn934]

flame843 wrote:

my top replacement ideas (however unrealistic they may be):
Danny Carey
Blake Richardson
Jason Rullo

+10000

[dantheguitarist]

I'm so glad I got to see them over the summer now.

[Koethe]

I am so crushed! wait no I'm not I hate dream theater!

[changgang666]

Fuck all of you that are blaming AX7, you know what? Mike Portnoy was one of the Rev's BIGGEST fans, and he's one of the best drummers in the world trying to fill in a very talented drummer's shoes that he respected, so what DT broke up suck it up and move on bands come and go.

[shelovemyguitar]

flame843 wrote:

my top replacement ideas (however unrealistic they may be):
Danny Carey
Blake Richardson
Jason Rullo

No. Blake needs to stay with btbam.

[Tim the Rocker]

Who´d like to mail me about why they hate A7X so much? Thx.

[MegaDTSX]

I seriously teared up a bit when reading this. I learned bass, drums, and keyboards because of how much I was/am inspired by Dream Theater.


I am sad and what is this?

[rushpython]

FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK!!!!
NNOOO!!!

[HavokStrife]

What a shock.

I love all the 'blame A7X' talk.

DT puts him through the grinder and wants more, he ends up leaving.

But he also puts down some of the best drums I've heard IN A LONG TIME on the new A7X CD, which is actually incredible--save the title track (your ****in nightmare >.

[AeroRocker]

As much as I hated their latest work, I hope he does more work with A7X. If they can start writing decent music again, Mike's incredible drumming would be a perfect fit.

[Randomrings]

dantheguitarist wrote:

I'm so glad I got to see them over the summer now.

me too, dang... this is crazy, it wasn't even four months ago portnoy was behind petrucci flippin his sticks into the air and catching em again, now this. I don't even know what to think...

but i do wonder what this could mean for avenged sevenfold too...

[Grimesy57]

How can people be so selfish? I'm shocked as well, but he doesn't do things to please anyone, and people are bitching about him making his own decisions? I bet if he stayed with DT and if their sound changed because of that all of you would be still calling him a sellout. And to everyone who thinks this has anything to do with A7X, get a life, they're great DT fans, and they happen to be Mike's very close friends. I don't know if I'm happy about this, DT will never be the same again, but if this means a possible future for a7x, then it's worth it

[Atlantis2112]

I'm very sad to see Portnoy go. But in a way, it could be for the better. Unfortunately no matter what, Dream Theater is going to be very different without Mike there, and there's always the chance they could take a turn for the worse rather than the better. But if you look in Dream Theater's history, the better Portnoy got (let's face it, he was pretty weak in WD&DU -> Awake), the worse Myung seemed to get, at least in studio. Perhaps now with Portnoy gone, Jordan and Myung might be able to shine more now. I personally could see Gavin Harrison (however unrealistically) or Mike Mangini (Steve Vai session drummer as well as drummer for LaBrie's Elements of Persuasion) as a suitable replacement.

[J Mud]

Complete shock! These guys are my heroes! I never say it coming. A7X doesn't deserve him; I hope he discontinues work with him.

[im not mental]

say it ain't so...

[Trentaru]

Im shocked but i guess we will have to wait to see if their new drummer will "help" the band or will they make it worse,


Good Luck to Mike and the Band

[MetaMorphaxx]

I just cant wait to see what he does next. Ive kinda become numb to my fav bands splitting/dieing. So this really isnt a big deal, and I bet before its all said and done he will be back with DT...

[MegaDTSX]

Grimesy57 wrote:

How can people be so selfish? I'm shocked as well, but he doesn't do things to please anyone, and people are bitching about him making his own decisions? I bet if he stayed with DT and if their sound changed because of that all of you would be still calling him a sellout. And to everyone who thinks this has anything to do with A7X, get a life, they're great DT fans, and they happen to be Mike's very close friends. I don't know if I'm happy about this, DT will never be the same again, but if this means a possible future for a7x, then it's worth it

Give some people a break man. Some of the responses are going to be be out of anger due to losing their favorite/one of their favorite bands. I'm not angry at why he's leaving, I'm just sad/angry that Dream Theater as we know it is done. They're my biggest inspiration and now its just finished, just like that.

[AllYourBass]

By the way, I've got a quick Avenged Sevenfold commentary.

I like the band. Not everything they've done, but I definitely like a good grip of songs. As a metal fan, it pleases me to see A7X has introduced the concepts of metal in a form so many mainstreamers can understand, in a radio world filled with generic, awful rock.

I consider A7X to be like the Nintendo Wii, and sometimes like Farmville: Games that attract non-gamers to gaming.

And let's face it. AS A METAL FAN and a HHUUGGEE Dream Theater fan, never forget our tastes are often "eclectic." We listen to some WEIRD ****ing music, guys. More power to A7X for bridging the gap.

[bokma]

FUUUUU-

[travislausch]

Grimesy57 wrote:

How can people be so selfish? I'm shocked as well, but he doesn't do things to please anyone, and people are bitching about him making his own decisions? I bet if he stayed with DT and if their sound changed because of that all of you would be still calling him a sellout. And to everyone who thinks this has anything to do with A7X, get a life, they're great DT fans, and they happen to be Mike's very close friends. I don't know if I'm happy about this, DT will never be the same again, but if this means a possible future for a7x, then it's worth it

This.

[wyldeshredder]

i feel incredibly blessed to have seen dream theater in july, despite them only playing for only an hour (opening for maiden in ottawa..whom they blew away pretty badly)
Regardless of whether their new drummer can play portnoys parts adequately, i think we'll see a whole new phase of dream theater.. Incredibly lucky to have seen this one.

[dinley]

NNNNNOOOOO!!!!!

[ObsceneGestures]

Eh... I don't know what to say. Good luck to MP, I suppose. I'm very anxious to see where DT goes from here...

[SparkTheEclipse]

Well it's even, some hate him and are angry, some support him. Hey I personally support him, that takes some guts from a guy to leave something he's so well known for and go with a band that some of his supporters say is such a horrible band (SOME not ALL). He definitely can bring a factor of music to them that I'm actually intrigued to see, but this is all assuming he actually joins Avenged. Personally, I think it was a good decision on his part. He can have fun and enjoy music with new people.

Think of it this way, would you rather hang out with the same people your whole life, or would you like to go out and hang with new people every once in a while? That's what I'm thinking is gonna happen with him, but who knows. I still believe he might get back with DT at some point, but for now we'll just wait and see.

[dfish]

Simple explanation...
Avenged Sevenfold = More Money

[hildesaw]

NightEmbers wrote:

i hope you all had a chance to see Dream Theater at least once in your life, its one hell of an experience

Indeed. I never really cared for them that much, but when I saw them open up for Iron Maiden this summer, they put on a really good show. That earns respect in my book.

[Rancid Ivy]

Wow, this really shocked me.

Wow.

Anyways, I think Grimesy57 is right, and I won,t comment anything else. Best of luck to Dream Theater and Mike Portnoy!

[Zeppelin Addict]

mike... noo...

[droctogonapus93]

I don't think the band should continue without him. Dream Theater without Mike Portnoy is like Rush without Neil Peart. It just wouldn't work.

[nico42]

I used to listen to DT a whole lot but lately they've been stagnating and Mike Portnoy is a HORRIBLE producer. It can only be good for their sound and creativity that he's gone.
Maybe they'll get a drummer who knows more than one fill & works with a little dynamics and a good producer, that would make them a really awesome band! Imho Petrucci and Rudess are the real highlights anyway.

[metal4life34]

RapeFace McGee wrote:

This is how I eased my friend, who's a massive Dream Theater fan, into the news, via text message:

Me: Did u hear about Mike Portnoy?
Friend: no wut????
Me: He died dude
Friend: WHAT????!!!! SERIOUSLY???
Me: Nah j/k he did quit dream theater, though
Friend: **** you
Me: you're less upset though, right?

LMFAO!

[SumFX]

Koethe wrote:

I am so crushed! wait no I'm not I hate dream theater!

This made me lol

No offense to fans of DT

[Dave_Mc]

wow

[Metallichemical]

WOW! I was devastated s well, and a shame, too. It's gonna be hard to replace him. I've just began getting into Dream Theater Since about two months ago. I feel very fortunate to have seen Dream Theater live with Portnoy (opening for Iron Maiden). Especially less than two months after I seen them!

[EpsilonJSTC]

Best April Fool's Day prank ev- WHAT THE FUCK WHAT THE FUCK WHAT THE FUUUUUCK?

[Zappanator]

It could be worse, Petrucci could have quit the band.

[olij92]

I wonder if A7X will use Portnoy permanently now, for Albums and Tours...

[bassplayer2493]

FFFFFUUUUU.....!
this royally suck donkey balls

[NWH]

i saw them on their last tour with him! this sucks

[xberserkx]

Mr_Dobolina wrote:

Two things:

1) Avenged Sevenfold sucks. Their "metal" is a branded fashion statement and it makes me sick. (Zakky Vengeance, seriously? No, are you actually ****in joking? Worst personas EVER!)

2) Too bad James Labrie couldn't have left, not Portnoy. He's a very talented singer, but his voice is more suited for pop or musical theatre over the badass entity that is Dream Theatre.

Petrucci and Portnoy are a force not to be ****ed with.

Labrie's voice was very suiting for the band up until Train of Thought imo

I still can't believe this news, but I'm sure he'll be back eventually

[[x]Huffy[x]]

DAMMIT MIKE! ;_;

[bassthunder]

Augh... hopefully DT will see what a huge mistake this is and reconcile with Portnoy. I do understand the argument that this will free up the band creatively, but that argument pales to:

a) the fact that Portnoy did EVERYTHING for the band; overseeing production and mixing, editing live videos, putting together set lists for the tours... Let's not forget he also wrote about 40% of the band's material.

b) Mike is an absolute beast of a drummer. DT is unlikely to find another player with his skill, and even if they do get someone who can cover his rhythms note-for-note, odds are the new drummer won't have the creative edge that Mike does.

In any case, I hope DT can continue to put out music regularly. It'll be interesting to see how their sound changes without Mike. Also, if Mike does stay on with A7X, it will be fun to see them evolve. They definitely need a kick in the ass as far as creativity is concerned.

[flashmdg]

this has ruined the entire decade :'(

[guitarsftw]

I don't think he'll be gone for long. What I predict happening is a DT break, and then Mike comes back after a few years, and everything is back to normal.

[GreenDaysBasser]

DegaDeth wrote:

Fuck, this can't be happening. Fuck you A7X

its not A7X's fault, it's neither DT's or A7X's its Mikes, His choice for a break.

[MaximusGigantes]

25 years? Are you serious? Damn, that's commitment. My jaw dropped reading the headline to this. Judging by the comments, there aren't too many fans here of both A7X and Dream Theater...

[Kas99]

What's all the blame on A7X??
seriously you think someone like Mike would let himself get convinced to leave DT ? if he did so it was because he wanted to, and all you blamers would've probably done the exact same thing in his situation if you felt like it.

By the way, A7X rocks, just has it's own style, if it sucked so much as you blamers say why tf would Mike even get involved with them?

[HammerForce]

TBH if he was the one who was pushing them in the mainstream metal direction, I'm fairly happy he's quit...It's not good for them

[awisinger]

Best of luck Mike!!

[Alpha_Wolf]

metal4life34 wrote:

RapeFace McGee wrote:

This is how I eased my friend, who's a massive Dream Theater fan, into the news, via text message:

Me: Did u hear about Mike Portnoy?
Friend: no wut????
Me: He died dude
Friend: WHAT????!!!! SERIOUSLY???
Me: Nah j/k he did quit dream theater, though
Friend: **** you
Me: you're less upset though, right?

LMFAO!

That is pretty hilarious.

[The\m/]

Wow, finally some music news that I care less about than Lady Gaga's endless ranting about how sex supposedly steals non-existant creativity away from you.

Honestly the only Dream Theater album that didn't make my ears bleed was Images & Words. That album was filled truly good music. Everything after that became a Narcissistic, 8+minute, constant time signature switching, technical jerkfest. I mean every album I've heard after Images&Words literally sounds like a contest among the band as to who can play the most complicated brain scrambling riff of all time. As for you Mr.James Labrie. I don't much care for your vocals good sir.

I just hope whatever music either Mike or DT puts out next doesn't suck. I won't hold my breath though.

[DreamScape]

well ****. this sucks big time, thank goodness I saw the whole band together before this happened. Good luck to Mike on what he decides to do. Looking forward to the New DT album as well. Gonna be hard to match those drumming skills and musicianship

[oz1215]

It wouldn't be so bad if he had just worked with Avenged Sevenfold on an album

[oz1215]

hadn't*

[laklok]

My God.

And i so hoped to see them live once.

[PlayFreebirdNow]

laklok wrote:

My God.

And i so hoped to see them live once.

I saw them live opening for Iron Maiden. They were awesome.

[guitarist41]

Never really listened to them. Only heard some SC tunes on their myspace page, and apparently that's not a good place to start.

I look forward to seeing Julian play with Avenged.

[Lion_Slicer]

flame843 wrote:

my top replacement ideas (however unrealistic they may be):
Danny Carey
Blake Richardson
Jason Rullo

Blake needs to stay where he is. Not to mention his style is VERY different from what Dream Theater needs.

Also this article does not have ANYTHING to do with A7x. Never has, never will.

[bagrm]

Glad I saw them live once, but not too saddened. I have hated the direction DT has gone in over their last couple albums under the direction of Mike, they were trying way too hard to be metal and sounded cheesy. Octavarium was the last decent DT record IMO, and I hope they go in a more progressive direction after this.

[Paydro91]

Portnoy leaving Dream Theater? They band might as well break up. I didn't listen to Dream Theater only for Portnoy but he did give the band all he had and I'm sure all the others did as well. But Dream Theater without Portnoy is no Dream Theater at all in my opinion.

If he ends up joining A7x that would be cool. He's already doing a great job doing Revs drums. Mike Portnoy in my opinion is the best drummer out there.

[VeNgeaNce_4444]

How can you blame A7x? Even if MP quits DT to join them, blame DT. If he had more fun playin in sevenfold then in DT, who's fault is that? I hope he writes some songs with A7x, he's the best person to replace the Rev.

[oz1215]

Revolution_87 wrote:

To all A7X haters....Looks like he finally found something interesting to drum on, EAT IT BITCHES!!!!!

He was only with them for one album.

They're still Avenged Sixfold

[kassnarok]

Skinny91 wrote:

Finally, now he's not busy he can harness his true talent in my White Stripes cover band. Return my calls Mike.

loool

[Revolution_87]

pfff lol Avenged Sixfold there's only ever been five of them knobjockey

Anyway he's CHOSE to leave dream theatre, If you're looking to blame someone blame them, Dream Theatre are obviously total d*cks if they refuse to let the guy who is the heart and soul of the band take a break, He's better of without them

[guitarsolo_17]

No.... Mike... No...

Thanks to Mike for the best concert I've ever seen.

[goldenManticore]

Really hope he joins Avenged Sevenfold permanently. Nightmare is such an awesome album.

[FerretBob]

I second the people who hope that Rudess and Myung step forward. I did love Myung's lyrics (Fatal Tragedy is one of my all time favourite DT songs) and maybe the moratorium on his work will be lifted.

Also the most recent two albums have bored me; Systematic Chaos had a couple of tracks I liked but I can't listen to Black Clouds and Silver Linings at all.
Hopefully they'll move in a prog direction. Also I grinned at whoever it was who said Neil Peart should take over. I agree, but Rush need him more.

[guitarsolo_17]

Also, good luck to whoever has to play his stuff in concerts now.. I've heard people do it. But not well.

[//babz//]

Mayb mike will make A7X actually sound good again

[Hamburger89]

Well they haven't written a decent album in quite some time. Even octavarium dissapointed me, except for the song octavarium. I doubt stuff with the other bands would be better.

Dream Theater is dead.

[Ranmanbassist18]

Im proud of Mike to sticking to what he says. Im shocked that he has left this band but im glad to hear he will not stay in the shadows. He is a very well respected drummer of our time and if its a break he needs to enjoy another path then good on him !!!! all the best and can't wait to see what he comes up with next

[blackbird51]

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.

and you call yourself a fan? somebody needs to go back to listening to the Jonas Brothers..

[fender4string]

HavokStrife wrote:

What a shock.

I love all the 'blame A7X' talk.

DT puts him through the grinder and wants more, he ends up leaving.

But he also puts down some of the best drums I've heard IN A LONG TIME on the new A7X CD, which is actually incredible--save the title track (your ****in nightmare >.

Not to detract from the greatness that is Portnoy but the tracks were actually written by the Rev. Portnoy's fills were also all judged by the band Rev worthy or not (i.e. how closely Portnoy emulated his style). Just saying.

[MountApple]

I'm not really a fan of DT but it is very sad to see him go after all this time

[JohnnyChimpo241]

Revolution_87 wrote:

pfff lol Avenged Sixfold there's only ever been five of them knobjockey

Anyway he's CHOSE to leave dream theatre, If you're looking to blame someone blame them, Dream Theatre are obviously total d*cks if they refuse to let the guy who is the heart and soul of the band take a break, He's better of without them

this.
its not avenged sevenfolds fault that the guys from DT are *******s.

[guitarman28]

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

WTF are you talking about slow songs? There's 3 maybe 4 songs on the Nightmare album that are slow. I know its a matter of opinion, but I think Nightmare is there best album yet. And like other people are saying, it was Portnoy's decision to help A7X.

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.

[mulletman619]

Mike Portnoy quit..... now theres no more dream theater!
OOMYYGOOOOOD!!!!!

[ZXMegaFlame]

I really like Dream Theater and I think it's sad that Portnoy is leaving. However, I think it's good for the band. They will probably go back to making more progressive music.

[Rockwontdie]

OMG wow I completely loved Dream Theater. Well I guess MIke's gotta do what he's gotta do. All I am saying is that Dream Theater can NOT go on without Portnoy.

[lethaldosage45]

FINALLY! Dream Theater was great, but I could not listen to any of the newer stuff as it came out, especially the last two albums. IT wasn't bad... it just didn't have that zing that the older stuff did. The music itself was tired.

[A-G-guitarist]

No way is anyone ever going to be able to replace him.

[oz1215]

Revolution_87 wrote:

pfff lol Avenged Sixfold there's only ever been five of them knobjockey

Anyway he's CHOSE to leave dream theatre, If you're looking to blame someone blame them, Dream Theatre are obviously total d*cks if they refuse to let the guy who is the heart and soul of the band take a break, He's better of without them

Rofl, I was more implying the name of the band dumbass.
Sorry you're too autistic to realize.

[ivan_2894]

nerv wrote:

Well too bad, but DT had a break this year and he decide to record an album and tour with A7X, if his main band is DT he shouldn't be making that band wait so he can tour with a crappy band like A7X

THIS is quite right... i mean, Portnoy has been doing too much over the last few years: DT, Petrucci's G3 tour, Transatlantic, A7X, Neal Morse, LTE...

He should have looked to his priorities from the first moment, which was DT right from the beggining... i mean, the guy asked for a break, and the fact is that all remaining DT has been on a couch watching TV for the last couple of months, since they finished the 09/10 tour...

I believe he took the wrong decision, he should have left aside EVERYTHING but DT: that would be the whole list i named...

However i wish the best to MP in his future projects (Except A7X lol)

[Duke_of_Chutney]

And within a week.. Headlining news...
"Mike Portnoy joins Avenged Sevnfold"

[GREENWARRI0R]

He chose what made him happier. While I despise both bands and could care less what happen to them, more power to Portnoy for doing what he wanted to do. Fans should be able to understand this, and more importantly, the remaining members of Dream Theater who have been with him for 25 years. Anyone in opposition to HIS decisions in HIS life really aren't worth his time.

[craig-sansum]

[GasPipe]

Well I didn't see that coming.

Good on him for doing what he feels is right for him, its just a shame it did not work with the rest of the band. But if the rest of the band feels they need to keep going and are not in the position to stop, I think what they did was right. Shame really.

Hamburger89 wrote:

Dream Theater is dead.

I'm very worried that you may be right.

[TwistedRhoads]

He never said that he was joining A7X for good. Both bands are great in their own way. And for those saying "Nightmare" sucked except for the drums. I hope you realize Portnoy did not write the drum tracks in that album. They were already laid down electronically, he just went back over them with the rest of the band there to tell him if he strayed too away from what The Rev was doing. Stop using that as an excuse to like the album.

[tyfurie]

DegaDeth wrote:

Fuck, this can't be happening. Fuck you A7X

wow thats immature as hell now im a harcore fan and much prefer a7x pre city of evil that said i dont believe any correlation between his tour with them and his quiting dt i think he was goin through the motions as he said and in playing with these newer bands he found that spark again and realized DT wasnt where he wanted to be anymore dont blame a7x or anyone we all as musicians change and adapt i mean look at the shoo bop bands of the fifties in comparison with the technicality of bands like animals as leaders and veil of maya music adapts as we should you should be glad to hear an artist you obviously respect and love doing what he wants

[jonnern92]

how cool would it be if mike portnoy joins a7x.

and why does people blame a7x, he have thought about taking a break from DT over a year ago, but the rest of DT wouldn't. so it ended with a split. its no ones fault except the other members of Dream Theather!!!

[oz1215]

jonnern92 wrote:

how cool would it be if mike portnoy joins a7x.

and why does people blame a7x, he have thought about taking a break from DT over a year ago, but the rest of DT wouldn't. so it ended with a split. its no ones fault except the other members of Dream Theather!!!

yeah guys, why does people blame a7x?

[CranberryJuice]

everjump wrote:

I hate year 2010.

This.

[ßorn_dead]

AllYourBass wrote:

By the way, I've got a quick Avenged Sevenfold commentary.

I like the band. Not everything they've done, but I definitely like a good grip of songs. As a metal fan, it pleases me to see A7X has introduced the concepts of metal in a form so many mainstreamers can understand, in a radio world filled with generic, awful rock.

I consider A7X to be like the Nintendo Wii, and sometimes like Farmville: Games that attract non-gamers to gaming.

And let's face it. AS A METAL FAN and a HHUUGGEE Dream Theater fan, never forget our tastes are often "eclectic." We listen to some WEIRD ****ing music, guys. More power to A7X for bridging the gap.

This. Avenged Sevenfold got me into metal when I was 13 years old. Almost four years later, I'm in my own metal band and we stuff that's a Hell of a lot heavier than A7X, but I owe me listening to metal AT ALL to them. I'm not a huuuuuge DT fan, but they were good and I'm a bit bummmed that he left.

[Warrior47]

I'm a little confused by DT's attitude. I mean, they don't want to slow down for MP, but how fast can they possibly replace him? I mean, first they need to find an amazing drummer and then that guy has to learn like all of their ridiculous technical time signature switching songs if they want to keep up their rotating song tours. At the very least that could take months or years with how much music they've put out, even for an extremely talented drummer.

[tyfurie]

AllYourBass wrote:

By the way, I've got a quick Avenged Sevenfold commentary.

I like the band. Not everything they've done, but I definitely like a good grip of songs. As a metal fan, it pleases me to see A7X has introduced the concepts of metal in a form so many mainstreamers can understand, in a radio world filled with generic, awful rock.

I consider A7X to be like the Nintendo Wii, and sometimes like Farmville: Games that attract non-gamers to gaming.

And let's face it. AS A METAL FAN and a HHUUGGEE Dream Theater fan, never forget our tastes are often "eclectic." We listen to some WEIRD ****ing music, guys. More power to A7X for bridging the gap.

this man is cool as hell

[MooseWithAGlock]

What's next in news is this cruel world? "World Asplodes Without Dream Theater"?

[evan-simpson22]

Gay..... Mike portnoy has more fun with a7x then with dt, well mike have fun making wimpy terrible metal songs instead of making works of art with top class musicians, but at least he tried to salvage the band as best as he could, i guess i sorta support his desicion

[JoshDrums26]

Dang, DT is like one of my favorites bands. I just hope and prey that Mike will one day go back to Dream Theater because nobody can replace him. And A7X is good but they don't deserve him in my opinion..

[JimJam1304]

I have to say the Portnoy's explanation was incredibly reasonable and inclusive. Kudos to him for staying true to himself. That being said, DT is going to be strange without him.

[actaderock]

i like A7X more than Dream Theater so it would be cool if such a talented man became A7X's new drummer

[*Falconer*]

Man.. I'm just stone cold shocked. What a blow.
Don't know how I can sleep tonight.. Heh....

[pwninator123]

That read like a break up note...and felt like one.

[ktulu51]

Holy freaking shit. Didn't see that coming at all. So ****ing glad I saw them with Iron Maiden in D.C.

[UnaLaguna]

ivan_2894 wrote:

nerv wrote:

Well too bad, but DT had a break this year and he decide to record an album and tour with A7X, if his main band is DT he shouldn't be making that band wait so he can tour with a crappy band like A7X
THIS is quite right... i mean, Portnoy has been doing too much over the last few years: DT, Petrucci's G3 tour, Transatlantic, A7X, Neal Morse, LTE...

He should have looked to his priorities from the first moment, which was DT right from the beggining... i mean, the guy asked for a break, and the fact is that all remaining DT has been on a couch watching TV for the last couple of months, since they finished the 09/10 tour...

I believe he took the wrong decision, he should have left aside EVERYTHING but DT: that would be the whole list i named...

However i wish the best to MP in his future projects (Except A7X lol)

Pretty much nailed it.

[jamieyawa]

cant the band just have a break? he doesnt have to go!! look at tool they have like 5 year breaks between albums/tours and are still talked about as if their fire hasn't burnt out.... dream theater can do the same... taking a break is fine, but leaving for good is bullshit!

[Joey Radical]

This is the worst news of this year, apart from the death of DIO.

I'm not mad at Mike in anyway, his happiness should go before satisfying fans. And if he's not happy in Dream Theater he shouldn't be a member of that band. However, this still does SUCK big time! I'm sure they'll still write great songs (they do have 4 legendary musicians left after all) but it won't feel like Dream Theater. And that's why this is a pretty ****ing bad day.

[nirvanafan99]

TwistedRhoads wrote:

He never said that he was joining A7X for good. Both bands are great in their own way. And for those saying "Nightmare" sucked except for the drums. I hope you realize Portnoy did not write the drum tracks in that album. They were already laid down electronically, he just went back over them with the rest of the band there to tell him if he strayed too away from what The Rev was doing. Stop using that as an excuse to like the album.

was just going to say that and i have seem dream theatre and A7x in the last 2 months and he seem to enjoy him self more in A7X then dream theatre

[wezoweez]

if mike joins avenged sevenfold it'll be the biggest waste of talent the world has ever seen. ever.

[guitarsolo_17]

April Fools

[Rockinoutman]

Its a personal choice and one has to respect that.Mike Portnoy was the motor of DT and a extremely talented and innovative musician,he will be missed.Im sure DT will carry on and the new GUY will be very focused on,if it is like that,I hope that DT will bring another Album in a new dimension to us all with over the top breaks and riffs.What if Mikael Akerfelt left OPETH,now that would be hard to replace.I read that DT will be doing a new Album in 2011 and a Tour to follow.So the "Spirit carries on " as they say.
You cant flog a dead horse,so good luck Mike and thanks for all,It was a Grand show with you,Bye !!

[SynesterSeX]

You know, i actually WANT portnoy to join a7x. It'll piss off all the pissheads here hating on both MP and a7x and make me laugh at their rage. LOL oh i can imagine it already .

['Leviathan']

Found out last night... it's terrible news, but I know Mike's doing right in his heart and I wish him all the luck in the world in his future endeavors, whatever they may be. I don't know if anyone could ever fill the void that Mike has left in Dream Theater, but it'll be interesting either way.

Good luck, Mike. While I'm devastated, I'm at the same time, happy that you're following your dreams.

[MstrGuitarPlyeR]

Well, taking out Mike Portnoy of Dream Theater is like removing the Dream of the Theater...

:c... I'll miss that Constant Motion solo Live

[espChris93]

I respect Mike and agree with his decision because i hate seeing musicians become weary and tired of their band so the music suffers. That being said DT is not DT without Portnoy no matter who they get. I hope Mike gets a new project going with a good singer(sorry JL) or continues on with Transatlantic their stuff is great

[NightmareTheory]

that sux somedthing fierce, but the rev idolized mike, so imagine how beast a7x will be with the man the rev idolized.

[Mazz211]

Revolution_87 wrote:

To all A7X haters....Looks like he finally found something interesting to drum on, EAT IT BITCHES!!!!!

Interesting my ass, They're about as interesting as watching paint dry.

[palm mute]

They ended the 12 step suite and the whole 6-7-8-7-6 pattern on their last album, I'm actually not really surprised at this news. Seems planned almost with the ending of those.

wezoweez wrote:

if mike joins avenged sevenfold it'll be the biggest waste of talent the world has ever seen. ever.

Agreed

[Jon777]

Whoa...

Didn't think I'd ever hear this.

[queenslander47]

I was shocked to hear this yesterday. Like really shocked. I can't imagine Dream Theater without Portnoy. I can't really think of them as DT anymore with Mike.

But people need to get their head out of their arse with this whole A7X thing. If Portnoy considers them talented enough to work with, that is good enough for me. He could bring a whole new edge to the band and take them in a new direction. Some of you people are unbelievably ignorant and closed minded. I often wonder why I keep coming to this site.

[BlueFuzion101]

Respect his personal choice you hating asshats, You should stick by him and support him. Just because he left DT and possibly join A7x doesn't mean you can't like him still.

[Dakkstar]

this sucks so bad. I missed them when they were with Iron Maiden in Edmonton.. and now this?! I'll never see thew Dream Theater I wanted.

[GabeWang]

good, maybe now they'll make an album that doesn't sound a THING like Black Clouds and Silver Linings.

[icesk8erqueen8]

well, my jaw completely dropped to the floor.
I never thought this would happen.
but man, if he did join avenged.... I might have some hope for the band again. because NO ONE could replace the rev. but damn, portnoy would be the closest it would get to hearing the rev on the drums again=]

[Charlie4]

One of the most impressive drummers I've ever heard, if he feels burned out a break is more than fair imo.
I doubt that this is his last with DT. Take a year or few off and he'll probably rejoin the band I think.

[BlisteringDDj]

Why are you blaming A7X? Even though I dislike the band they're not a part of this at all. Portnoy left because he needed some time off from a band he's been running 24/7 in 25 years.

Let's see how things turn out with Transatlantic, Hail! and Avenged Sevenfold. I gained more respect for him after this. Dream Theater was dead to me after Black Clouds & Silver Linings, so I'm not to sad about this...

[\m/A7X\m/]

whatever happened to just being happy for somebody doing what they want to do? Its Portnoy's choice! I wish both him and Dream Theater the best of luck for their futures

[Dobbs1968]

"Sadly, in discussing this with the guys" - "they have decided to continue without me"

What has Christ returned or some thing? ...and if so, can he even play the drums? Continue without Mike...please...

[Phoenix Reborn]

Wow...I'm sad and disappointed. But at the same time my respect for mike just increased tenfold. He left in a graceful manner, isn't being a snob, and is actually encouraging dream theatre fans to keep listening to the band...

Mike, why can't more people be like you?

[RockInPeaceDime]

He can do as he pleases, but I certainly hope he didn't leave with the intentions of finding another band with as much talent as he just left...likely won't happen.

[Axim Bassist]

WHAT!!! REALLY!!! wow...never saw him leaving coming..thats somethin...

[-xCaMRocKx-]

Wow, I don't think anyone can say they saw that coming.

As others have said, I don't think this will be permanent; it seems likely to me that he will come back a few years down the track.

It's a bit of a dickmove on the rest of the band's part though, kicking out a founding member because he wanted to take a break, even though he offered to continue doing studio work with them.

I don't envy whoever is going to replace him. It's going to be one hell of a task to learn all his parts.

[irocz1990]

He can even go play drums with Lady Gaga, his decision. I'm not a drummer but would like to see a list of drummer who can fulfill the drums duties.

[irocz1990]

He can even go play drums with Lady Gaga if he wants, his decision. I'm not a drummer nor a guitar player but would like to see a list of drummer who can fulfill the drums duties.

[maximumrocker]

syngatesidol wrote:

Thats a huge shock but I hope he stays with avenged because they need him and the rev would want HIM of all people in his place.

And for you guys hating on A7X, why dont you actually sit down and pay attention to their new album. Its freaking amazing regardless of how many slow songs are on it. They made a great music decision. They wrote about what they were feeling instead of appealing to the masses like everyone else did and they were proud of it. Them writing songs this way is how they were coping with his death.They did pretty much the same thing that Metallica did with Load, it just wasnt about Cliff Burton.

jhahahahhahahahahahahahhahahahahahah

[Dakkstar]

Danny's skills are laughable compared to Portnoy, it would only make the band sound laughable aswell. Very sad thought.

flame843 wrote:

my top replacement ideas (however unrealistic they may be):
Danny Carey
Blake Richardson
Jason Rullo

[mjosephw52]

mike is such an essential part of dream theater! i cant imagine the band without him!

[\m/A7X\m/]

mervycowan wrote:

I agree with the people saying its not avenged sevenfold's fault. It's not. But it doesn't stop them sounding like a bunch of gays. And they dress like twats.

Yeah the well known gays who are all either married or have girlfriends, good one!

[AngryGoldfish]

RapeFace McGee wrote:

This is how I eased my friend, who's a massive Dream Theater fan, into the news, via text message:

Me: Did u hear about Mike Portnoy?
Friend: no wut????
Me: He died dude
Friend: WHAT????!!!! SERIOUSLY???
Me: Nah j/k he did quit dream theater, though
Friend: **** you
Me: you're less upset though, right?

Epic lolz

Checked

[2Megadeth7]

Wow never saw this comin

[InTheFlesh!]

I'm shocked but also quite interested in the new era this will usher, both for Dream Theater and for Mike himself. Excited trepidation, I guess.

[camdencarey1]

He better not join fagot ass avenged sevenfold

[mervycowan]

\m/A7X\m/ wrote:
Yeah the well known gays who are all either married or have girlfriends, good one!

didn't say they were gay, merely commented on their sound and appearance. even better one.

[foREVer666]

camdencarey1 wrote:

He better not join fagot ass avenged sevenfold

boo hoo poor baby, theres no point gettin wound up over it its hardly down to you what mike does you moron

[Kilvik]

I cannot explain the pain i felt in my heart when i heard the news about Mike leaving Dream Theater! It's like a Mirror without a reflection. I have been a Bloodfan of Dream Theater since i first heard them many years ago. And they have inspired me in every possible way! Their music has changed my life! And finding out that the guy who put the must effort in the band is leaving is heartbreaking! I trust him and supports him in his choice, but i'm am worried sick of what will happen to Dream Theater now! He made many of their best songs! He wrote The 12 Step Suite because of his war against his alcohol problems, He Wrote A Change of Season for his mother and The Best of Times for his Father! His Father named the band. He is the Dream of Dream Theater and he is irreplaceable.
Dream Theater is the perfect combination of musicians, and are all a part of what makes their music to music! And if you take one of those pieces away it will all collapse!
But still...
If Mike or the rest of Dream Theater reads this i must just say that i'm not disappointed. I'm hurt! But i respect whatever you do, and me and i bet every Dream Theater/Portnoy fan's out there prey to God that it's just a longer break and not over yet. We need Dream Theaters Special and unique music! Because it's the only band that never had disappointed me! You have always made one album better than the other and no one can say for sure what is your best album!

- Love from Norway's biggest Dream Theater fan.

[Jasonbts]

Hungry_Hameds wrote:

Never really heard much of them, but it's clear from the lack of "I dont care" messages that this is the end of an era. May have to educate myself

Not my kind of band, but they're still good. Worth checking out!

[mrrman]

Well this sucks...now the new search for a drummer begins....

[illmental]

Hungry_Hameds wrote:

Never really heard much of them, but it's clear from the lack of "I dont care" messages that this is the end of an era. May have to educate myself

You should start with the song (Pull me under!

[Joshua Garcia]

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.

Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

[Xomar]

if he goes to play for A7x he will go from being my favorite drummer to a sell out in a sh*tty band

[Levi79]

Wow, he quit Dream Theater to be in Avenged? That's ****ing weak. What a fag.

[parkerp38lover]

wow what the f***. This is a damn travesty. DT will never be the same. I think this is a huge mistake on portnoy's part.

[djtraceman]

honestly, i'm trying to get over this as much as the next fan. how am i doing so? just imagining that first Dream Theater album after Portnoy returns.

[MegadethFan18]

Levi79 wrote:

Wow, he quit Dream Theater to be in Avenged? That's ****ing weak. What a fag.

Learn to read.

[GDrock!]

NOOOOO!!!!! I don't think there's anyone who can replace him!!! Hmmm... how bout The Rev??? oh wait he's dead... WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO ALL THE GOOD DRUMMERS??? *shoots self*

[bakaxninja]

Guys, if you look at his facebook page, you'll see a post by him saying NOT to blame Avenged sevenfold...

[MegadethFan18]

Also I have been meaning to get into Dream Theater for ages but have yet to and this is a HUGE shock to me. This headline is equal "James Hetfield leaves Metallica" or "Kerry King leaves Slayer" or "Slash leaves Guns N' Roses"

Just kidding about that last one

[rmp0012002]

He wanted a hiatus, the band didn't. He did everything for the band and burned himself out. He seems to like the idea of just being part of a band instead of running the business all the time. DT doesn't exist without Mike. It was his band.

[WizMystery]

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.

[Deathmethod]

When I read the original post on his FB page I felt like a good friend had died. I'm wearing all my DT gear today in memorial of what they were.

I hope the best for both, but I don't think it will ever be the same.

[shred_wizzard]

truly sad, but if you're not enjoying it...you're not enjoying it...and after 25 years of loyalty and service to the band/fans, he has earned the right to do what he likes

[JBecker=SHREDDA]

Best of luck to him, i say, its his life, and his choice. I'm actually excited to see DT will get to replace him.

[ridinglightning]

I support MP and DT on whatever they do.

[moses132049]

wow, so he quit, and he tried to guilt them into waiting for him, what a... im not gonna say it cause i dont wanna get banned again, but you get what im trying to say. apparently he is a control freak so id like to see how much better dream theater gets without him

[a7xb4d]

Wow..... I'm not sure what to say except that that came out of freakin' nowhere. I'm kinda split on whether it would be cool if he joined sevenfold....it would kinda be like he was cheating on his band

[deathofarev]

can people stop blaming avenged sevenfold please? for **** sake it's not their fault he's left dream theater, it's his choice. ok now an the bitching stop ok? if the rev hadn't died (not his fault) mike would have only gone to another band and you would just bitch about them, so please all **** off

[ferretbassit11]

wow this was a shock and im not the only one who thinks that

[Noremak]

Whoever replaces him better have a REALLY REALLY REALLY big drum set.

[Genghis_khan]

Next album will be the first DT CD I'll be downloading before buying it...

WHAT A FUCKING SHOCK... AND JUST AFTER A GREAT DIVING DAY!!!!!

[edgeyyz]

NOOOOO

[Wolfinator-x]

Good luck to Mike and Dream Theater.

[TheZombieRitual]

But Petrucci, Myung and Portnoy are (were) like the greatest trio (next to Rush of course).

[TheSpatulaOfDoo]

Gonna go ahead and guess he got money hungry with sevenfold. and does anybody else think he sounds like a diva?

[Bxesparty]

Omg this made me shiz my pants. it was so unexpected. :O!!!!!

[slickerthnsleek]

Hope he stays with A7x... he's incredible and I'd hear more of him with them than with DT.

Sucks for DT though... he's a hard act to follow.

[thommoboy]

nooooo

[Vornik]

Can't say I'm overly impressed by his "I bust my ass!" and "I ran this band!" attitude.

[SteveVaiFreak]

my god .. it was shocking to see the new ...

good luck to both ....

Now i'd like to see Mike in Opeth ... it would be quite awsome

[shredder3386]

Worst....news.....EVER!!!!! Im a guitarist but Portnoy is one of my favorite musicians of all time, this ****ing sucks

[Nutman69]

im surprised the whole band didnt just go on hiatus since hes one of the most important members. hopefully DT just takes a break for a few years & they can rejoin as better people.

[agm_ultimatex]

Kilvik wrote:

I cannot explain the pain i felt in my heart when i heard the news about Mike leaving Dream Theater! It's like a Mirror without a reflection. I have been a Bloodfan of Dream Theater since i first heard them many years ago. And they have inspired me in every possible way! Their music has changed my life! And finding out that the guy who put the must effort in the band is leaving is heartbreaking! I trust him and supports him in his choice, but i'm am worried sick of what will happen to Dream Theater now! He made many of their best songs! He wrote The 12 Step Suite because of his war against his alcohol problems, He Wrote A Change of Season for his mother and The Best of Times for his Father! His Father named the band. He is the Dream of Dream Theater and he is irreplaceable.
Dream Theater is the perfect combination of musicians, and are all a part of what makes their music to music! And if you take one of those pieces away it will all collapse!
But still...
If Mike or the rest of Dream Theater reads this i must just say that i'm not disappointed. I'm hurt! But i respect whatever you do, and me and i bet every Dream Theater/Portnoy fan's out there prey to God that it's just a longer break and not over yet. We need Dream Theaters Special and unique music! Because it's the only band that never had disappointed me! You have always made one album better than the other and no one can say for sure what is your best album!

- Love from Norway's biggest Dream Theater fan.

I dont think anyone can say it better. Very well put

[pwrmax]

DT will do a tour and maybe an album, then he will return

[Megadeth2011]

If he wants to, that's fine. He's worked very hard, and even if it hasn't been quite the best quality lately... well, he still worked on it, didn't he? Let's give him a break. I think eventually he'll want to come back. And when he does, I'm sure the new album will be sweet!!!

[Avedas]

He sounds so pissed off it's hilarious. Too bad DT is likely done now. It doesn't matter what they do, it just won't be the same. Unless they pull something mindblowingly amazing, they're over.

[Chaingarden]

Right on. He was the only member of Dream Theater I really liked anyway.

[perilio]

This is my f***ing nightmare, enough said.

[Watermelonlulz]

Just from the way he seems to word the statement to kind of imply that he IS DT, kind of makes me not care at all. And as far as him being the "victim", you should definitely hold up commitments to your own band before you run off and work yourself out with a different one, then cry about not being able to take a break while everyone else is ready to go. Plus, he was too METUL

[Megalomaniac46]

Just another reason for me to hate Avenged Sevenfold. Stealing one of my fave band's drummer.

[squareimage]

bignuts20 wrote:

crazysam23_Atax wrote:

I blame AX7. Their new album, except for MP's drums, sucked anyway.

This just proves that you're hating on them for no good reason. The drum parts on Nightmare weren't even written by Portnoy.

+1

[!Mike!]

crazysam23_Atax wrote:

I blame AX7. Their new album, except for MP's drums, sucked anyway.

You're just an MP ass kisser, if you knew the Rev actually wrote all the drums before he died you wouldn't have said that the drums don't suck.

[bradtastic222]

i reckon he will go to a7x on a near full time basis now :S

[rob_guitar]

Without Portnoy there is no Dream Theatre. Now Petrucci will have to hold it down. A7X's new album sucked balls, nightmare is a cool song with a cool vid, but the rest of the album doesn't hold up to it. Also, although Portnoy didn't write the drum parts for the album he did add his own touch and embellishments to the already written parts.

[clay005]

Sad.....

[Joshua Garcia]

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.

The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

[ippystratman]

wow that was unexpected! what are dream theater gonna do now i wonder,itll be hard to replace him...thats if its even possible. honestly, i hope he doesnt go on to join a7x full time, dont get me wrong, i love a7x way more than dream theater and i think what he did on their new album was a brilliant thing to do, something about it just wouldnt be right to me, know what i mean?

[DaBoXBabY]

NightEmbers wrote:

i hope you all had a chance to see Dream Theater at least once in your life, its one hell of an experience

Thankfully I did this summer while they were with maiden. Makes me a sad panda it wasn't a full set.

[Austyn6661]

rob_guitar wrote:

Without Portnoy there is no Dream Theatre. Now Petrucci will have to hold it down. A7X's new album sucked balls, nightmare is a cool song with a cool vid, but the rest of the album doesn't hold up to it. Also, although Portnoy didn't write the drum parts for the album he did add his own touch and embellishments to the already written parts.

all he did in nightmare (the song) was a couple octoban fills and some ride stuff in the chorus. he actually took out some double bass during the solo, and I would bet that if the rev were still living, it would have sounded damn similar.

nightmare is also the worst song off the album, compared to Save Me and the rest of the tracks, its generic as f**k.

[ztmusic09]

Ok, people learn to read and listen to interviews...He chose to play with A7X, out of respect and honor for The Rev. And yea..the drum parts weren't written by MP because he said in another interview that he got a demo of all the songs with The Rev's drum parts and he just wanted to bring The Rev's parts to life...not his own. MP is and always will be one of the greatest..if not the greatest drummer of all time. And honestly it's kind of shitty that the other guys of DT couldn't just take a little break till the new work on the album in January. With all the things MP does, he deserves a break. I am tho, a very big DT fan. There music is some amazing stuff and it will be very, very hard finding someone with the same force that MP has. I will always love DT, but it will be hard to get into it since MP has left. Btw, I think the new A7X album is frackin' amazing!

[Austyn6661]

but I don't want to talk about a7x on a DT article. they have NOTHING to do with it.

sucks that mike left, he really was the soul of the band, and an amazing drummer to boot.

[Guitar Skater]

I love how this article confirms his departure from Dream Theater and Arrival into A7X

everyones so quick to point the finger but just a little reading can increase your knowledge substantially.

[bearsfan092]

Portnoy is overrated, but he's still really really damn good. Considering how huge DT is in prog music, this is huge news.

[Renegade_Elite]

well this sucks... these guys are honestly what got me into playing guitar... it just won't be the same

[WizMystery]

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.


The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

You seemed to be aiming it at the wrong sentiment, when you said that I got the idea you were calling DT a fake band. He listens to DT apparently so I still don't know why you said that o.o

[niejel]

he's NOT quitting.

he's taking a break geez people . . .

UG, this is the first time I'll be criticizing your title. He is NOT quitting. He is simply taking a break. Imagine playing for 25 years with three or four different bands. For some, it's a dream come true, but after a while, you'll want a vacation.

[xicetraex]

Crazy.

[sewoo55]

he is NOT taking a break ecause of avenged sevenfold!!!!!

why don't you go and see his facebook profile? he explains everything there.

and looks like most Ugers can't read. this will only be a temporary break; he's not quitting

[cbusch08]

****...this ruins everything ever!

[trashbeast]

from what im reading, he said he WANTED a break, but felt guilty about putting the other band members dreams on hold, so he decided to quit and let them go on however they choose. thats how i interpreted this anyway.

[niejel]

sewoo55 wrote:

he is NOT taking a break ecause of avenged sevenfold!!!!!

why don't you go and see his facebook profile? he explains everything there.

and looks like most Ugers can't read. this will only be a temporary break; he's not quitting

exactly. look for his facebook, then you'll see the note that confirms everything.

trashbeast wrote:

from what im reading, he said he WANTED a break, but felt guilty about putting the other band members dreams on hold, so he decided to quit and let them go on however they choose. thats how i interpreted this anyway.

I think they had their dreams come true, they still want more, if that's what you mean.

[SilverSpurs616]

Not a fan of any band he's been in, but I agree with what he's saying. He should do what's best for himself, and others should respect that.

[IbanezDudeCK]

Well this is just the worst thing ever. All my favorite drummers are quitting my favorite bands culminating with this... my favorite drummer of all time quitting after one of my favorite bands best albums. The only people that could possibly fill in are Thomas Lang, Travis Smith, and the guy from Mutiny Within. I was hoping for a new album soon but its not looking good. Why not just take a break from the 20 'projects' he has going on and stick with his main band?

[IRONDEATH123]

Well, I am not a Dream Theater fan anymore! Was never really a huge fan anyways.... UP THE IRONS!

[Juanitoson]

What a self-righteous dick...

[domdomdrums92]

hope he stays with a7x... it would be the best for him

[Joshua Garcia]

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.


The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

You seemed to be aiming it at the wrong sentiment, when you said that I got the idea you were calling DT a fake band. He listens to DT apparently so I still don't know why you said that o.o

Why? Because any dick comparing A7X to the Jonas Brothers doesn't know what music is that's why!

[Second Rate]

Simon Phillips. Those are the only two words the Dream Theater guys need to know, Simon Phillips. Seriously, the dude eats Mike alive. Not to take anything away from mike, he's one of my favorites, but his technical skills are.. shall we say... wanting (he even readily admits it). Simon would be a perfect fit with Dream Theater, he's done an awful lot of prog and fusion work. Mike's music and lyrics were the weakest part of Dream Theater as well.

[Fendergod666]

Ehh don't worry Portnoy wasn't the talent in the band.
DT will live on with just a shitty drummer.

[Fendergod666]

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.


The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

You seemed to be aiming it at the wrong sentiment, when you said that I got the idea you were calling DT a fake band. He listens to DT apparently so I still don't know why you said that o.o

Why? Because any dick comparing A7X to the Jonas Brothers doesn't know what music is that's why!

I would take The Jonas Brothers any day over A7X.

[satch_magic]

man, I was so crushed when I heard this

[pinkdolphin]

its quite a shock, but in all honesty i'd be more upset if Petrucci left. Portnoy is the worlds greates drummer, but his songwriting and lyrics kinda suck. Let LaBrie, Myung, and Petrucci write the music like old times. Hell let Rudess have a say too. Hopefully they return to a more proggy sound and steer away from trying to be all heavy. Black CLouds and Silver Linings had the worst lyrics of any DT album

[Non-Fiction]

Wow, didn't see that coming.

[SoulSyphon]

damn, biggest shock of the day, right above me kicking my cousin's ass on Dragon Ball Z Budokai 3 xD

[schirripar]

Him and John Frusciante should start a band lol

[SoulSyphon]

also, i love Avenged Sevenfold, and while they may be rumors, i think Mike joining A7X would be a waste of his skill, unless they take on a new musical direction that truly puts Brian's and Zacky's guitar skills to better use and make their songs actually hard to learn to play.

[Fendergod666]

pinkdolphin wrote:

its quite a shock, but in all honesty i'd be more upset if Petrucci left. Portnoy is the worlds greates drummer, but his songwriting and lyrics kinda suck. Let LaBrie, Myung, and Petrucci write the music like old times. Hell let Rudess have a say too. Hopefully they return to a more proggy sound and steer away from trying to be all heavy. Black CLouds and Silver Linings had the worst lyrics of any DT album

I agree.
The only reason the lyrics sucked is because Portnoy wrote a bunch of them

[FootSwitch]

wwwwwooooowwwww didnt see this coming at all

[dbshred92]

if he joins AX7 then the joke'll be on him...

[MetalBirdBassis]

i had a feeling this was coming i saw him with DT when they toured with Maiden and he looked like he was just going through the motions but then i swap him with A7X and he just had that fire he killed it that night and as much as i love him in DT i want him in A7X more

[Leonhart231]

Well, that sucks... He definitely deserves a break though. But he always argued for heavy songs which I loved. You'll be missed Portnoy!

[RAGman22ReborN]

MP needed this break.

Hey Petrucci! How about giving us another cool solo instrumental album? It was pretty cool to see what you can pull without the rest of DT.

[marcelaguiar]

Dream Theater has never caught my attention...all I know is that they have a talented drummer. And they have long-ass songs.

[BillR87]

We'll I can only hope that DT will continiue on with there musical endevour they've never let members quitting hold them back before but this is a very sad day in metal indeed who knows maybe portnoy will one day rejoin the band a rekindle what they had but what does this mean for the new album in progress?

[CaptainDan748]

ShiningEntity wrote:

Are people ****ing stupid? He HASN'T LEFT DREAM THEATER FOR A7X. The ignorance and presumption of some people is actually painful.

Thank you.

[Sox0690]

I laugh at the people saying he's selling out if he joins A7X. Sure they are a mainstream band, but if he enjoys it more power to him. He doesn't have any obligation to anyone but himself. Do you let other people control what you do with your career? Didn't think so

[CaptainDan748]

IbanezDudeCK wrote:

Well this is just the worst thing ever. All my favorite drummers are quitting my favorite bands culminating with this... my favorite drummer of all time quitting after one of my favorite bands best albums. The only people that could possibly fill in are Thomas Lang, Travis Smith, and the guy from Mutiny Within. I was hoping for a new album soon but its not looking good. Why not just take a break from the 20 'projects' he has going on and stick with his main band?

My thoughts as well. He kind of seems to put himself in the position of tired out guy by pursuing so much outside of Dream Theater work.

[darth awsome]

At least he wont be writing anymore shitty lyrics.
i wanna see who they replace him with. I hear Thomas Pridgen is looking for a gig...

[the_unforgiven6]

I can't say that I'm the biggest Dream Theater fan but I do enjoy their work. Good thing I'm a big Mike Portnoy fan and I can still enjoy his drumming regardless of what he does with it. Kinda sad though to see him let DT go.

[gareno]

Although the drummer that replaces him will probably be very talented, he will never replace Mike Portnoy in my heart.

[InfernalFender]

A really, really big loss for Dream Theater. I love the band, but I have utmost respect for Mike in the way he went about this. It's a shame the rest didn't feel the same way.

I wish both Mike and DT all the best for the future.

[Ima_Rockaholic!]

It's okay Portnoy, whatever you choose to do I'm sure it'll be fantastic.

['Leviathan']

I'm actually really interested in seeing which direction Dream Theater will take with their music now. Without the presence and influence of Mike, they just might - and I'm not saying this disrespectfully - become 'great' like they were pre-SDoIT era. While I'm deeply saddened by the news, I'm equally fascinated with thoughts of the input others may finally have. (I hope to **** they let Myung write lyrics again, his were seriously the best out of all 5 of them.)

[emphaticleech]

"Wah, I'm so tired. Wah. I quit."

[OtakuXXI]

No way... DT without Portnoy is NOT DT.
Good luck to MP and good luck to the new DT.

[rechris06]

crazysam23_Atax wrote:

I blame AX7. Their new album, except for MP's drums, sucked anyway.

You do realize that the rev wrote most of if not everything for that album right? jerkoff

[rechris06]

Fendergod666 wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.


The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

You seemed to be aiming it at the wrong sentiment, when you said that I got the idea you were calling DT a fake band. He listens to DT apparently so I still don't know why you said that o.o

Why? Because any dick comparing A7X to the Jonas Brothers doesn't know what music is that's why!
I would take The Jonas Brothers any day over A7X.

HAHAHAHAHA dude that is funny XD

[bigtimmy]

truly regret not seeing dream theater in concert now

[thadjrdn123]

Everyone needs to realize, Dream Theater is not dead. In fact, they're far from it. From what I've heard, most of the actual musical (and lyrical) writing was Petrucci, with Portnoy just pushing everyone in a metal direction (especially when he took over the task of producer). Now, Myung Labrie and Rudess can step forward. Everyone remember Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence? Rudess wrote the Overture to that which spawned the whole 42 minute long orgasm that is that song. They are capable of working without Mike. It'll probably be for the best though; for DT to start becoming more proggy and amazing (I'm hoping they'll put out their best album since SDOIT next year); and for Mike to get the metal beat out of him so that he realizes that he needs to return to his baby (Dream Theater) in the years to come

And for all of you A7X haters, grow up. Respect them for what they do, which is bring metal elements to pop culture. They're shitloads more successful than you/I ever will be in a band. I don't love them, but I do like some of their stuff and will listen to them once in a while.

But, DT is my favorite band, and this made me tear up when I first saw it on facebook. Hell, I'm still in denial about it.

[dream_theater24]

I will stab myself if Mike joint A7X

[yasman88]

They should change the name to Majesty now.

Dream Theater has too much of a Portnoy stamp on it.

[Schnecko]

It is a shock for all DT fans around the world, including me. Portnoy never can be replaced. Before DT is dissolving he will return because it was the biggest project for him so far. Sad greetings from Austria.

[devilex121]

man... that just sucks

[EpsilonJSTC]

Only Buddy Rich would be a suitable replacement. Fat chance of that happening.

[Ali-b912]

I think it's impossible to replace him. Nobody plays quite the same way he does. His balance of technicality and power is unique. Many technical drummers play with almost no power, while others play with loads of weight, but they lack the technical ability to play fast fills and unusual times and tempo changes. Portnoy is one of few who balances both really well.

And he's such an integral part of Dream Theater; to me most of their songs go too long and get boring (especially some of JP's solos), but Mike's drumming makes alot of the extended sections worth listening to.

If he joins Avenged Sevenfold I'll be very, very unhappy and in a way disappointed. Obviously, if it's what he wants then he should do it, but I think they're really not worth the time. I remember reading an interview where he laughed at the idea of someone suggesting he leave DT and join Poison, and to me all those -core bands are the current equivalent to that whole glam scene.

[Kivarenn82]

Given how the last album (systematic) i heard from them sounded.. I'd agree that a break is in order.

[starfire666]

Well, I for one think this is good... DT is by far my favourite band but when I saw them live last year I was really bored, no spark there... Maybe without Mike there they would stop ripping off other bands and finally write some original music themselves!!!

[gilbertn923]

This really is a horrible year for the metal community. Witht eh death of Dio, The Rev, and Paul Gray you also have the break up of Despised Icon and now Portnoy is leaving Dream Theater. What more is there to come for us for the rest of this year?

[boris6491]

How unexpected is this.. All the best though to Mike Portnoy and the other guys. I don't think they can call themselves "Dream Theater" any longer without Portnoy in the band. It just wouldn't be right. Replacing him will be a tough task, one I really don't think will be done justice.

[Pingis_Or_Death]

I don't really mind, as long as it makes them progressive again... They've put out some REALLY lame songs these last few years.

[pinkdolphin]

gilbertn923 wrote:

This really is a horrible year for the metal community. Witht eh death of Dio, The Rev, and Paul Gray you also have the break up of Despised Icon and now Portnoy is leaving Dream Theater. What more is there to come for us for the rest of this year?

Kamelot cancelling their North American Tour (to which i had tickets >

[SkinnyWhiteBoy]

Can anyone say midlife crisis?

I think this is more about Mike Portnoy's boyhood crushes on cute guys with tattoos than anything else.

All jokes aside, I honestly think this is Mike Portnoy working his ass off for 25 years in a very serious band, and now he has the opportunity to play bigger shows with a younger, more party-oriented group of musicians like A7X. But, then again he might not even be a permanent member, so I'm pretty much just talking out of my ass, but good thing I fit in with everyone else commenting this article.

Come on guys, get Portnoy's nuts out of your mouths! To say that Portnoy was EVERYTHING about Dream Theater is stupid. Sure, he was one of the more vital pieces, but I honestly think that the band would be ten times more ****ed if John Petrucci left.

While Portnoy was the workhorse of the band who can drum 12409823 beats per second, Petrucci can do the some shit on guitar but actually be creative about it.

But really, Portnoy's great, I get it.

However, Petrucci and the gang are great musicians as well. They'll get through it, and I bet you all now that they're new drummer if anything will push their creativity, and if anything Dream Theater now has something to prove to all of you foolish *******s who have already written them off because as it just so happens they want to continue writing music with each other.

And just as a quick FYI, I've never really listened to Dream Theater, I'm a BTBAM fan myself, and while I'd hate for any of the current BTBAM members to leave, I'd respect the hell out of all of them for the decision knowing that it was what was best for the band and the fans. Especially if they were 25 years deep versus 10. For ****'s sake people, if anything you should give them a round of applause for putting up with each other for that long, most marriages don't even last that long.

[Sum1sDrowningMe]

so does this mean the bands broken up

[NightwishAngel]

I just read this hours ago and I'm still stunned and hurt hearing about Mike's departure. My best wishes are with both Mike and DT.

[hriday_hazarika]

What about the AA suite?

[bartdevil_metal]

Sum1sDrowningMe wrote:

so does this mean the bands broken up

ffs, read the article.

[drawnacrol]

From the sounds of it he is just going on a break, i'd say they all need a break, Petrucci could go on an instrumental tour during the break

[orsgl1]

NOOOO!!!!!
why god why!?!?
such a sad day and such a bad news!
well, at least i can be happy with the music they made all these years, anything mike and the rest of DT do, we will support!! =)

[Key Master]

nOoOoOooOOoOOoO!!!!!

[yasman88]

pinkdolphin wrote:

gilbertn923 wrote:

This really is a horrible year for the metal community. Witht eh death of Dio, The Rev, and Paul Gray you also have the break up of Despised Icon and now Portnoy is leaving Dream Theater. What more is there to come for us for the rest of this year?

Kamelot cancelling their North American Tour (to which i had tickets >

Behemoth singer diagnosed with Leukemia....

yeah this year sucks..

[sven_svensk]

starfire666 wrote:

Well, I for one think this is good... DT is by far my favourite band but when I saw them live last year I was really bored, no spark there... Maybe without Mike there they would stop ripping off other bands and finally write some original music themselves!!!

I agree, to me petrucci has always been the center of the band, and the real talent. I didn't like the cheesy metal direction on the last albums, with portnoy singing.. hopegfully the next album will be different because of this..

[yasman88]

yasman88 wrote:

pinkdolphin wrote:

gilbertn923 wrote:

This really is a horrible year for the metal community. Witht eh death of Dio, The Rev, and Paul Gray you also have the break up of Despised Icon and now Portnoy is leaving Dream Theater. What more is there to come for us for the rest of this year?

Kamelot cancelling their North American Tour (to which i had tickets >

Behemoth singer diagnosed with Leukemia....

yeah this year sucks..

Oh also, Travis Smith quitting Trivium.

.....yup..this year sucks....

[whaitschnoik]

Oh no, what a shit news...

I wonder if he now has the time to do the project with Åkerfeldt...

[False_God]

cant see him leaving affecting DT in a big way. He's a great drummer, but theirs planty more and it wont chnge the sound as much as Petrucci leaving for example. Upwards and forward!

[Vacuity]

Guess he got tired of playing boring music


to be honest that seems to be what happened
this guy practically wanted to transform his band into muse

[Offworld92]

yasman88 wrote:

Oh also, Travis Smith quitting Trivium.

.....yup..this year sucks....

That's a bad thing? Sorry, but Travis was a bit too whiny, and besides, Nick Augusto shits all over him playing-wise. Have you heard Shattering? Good god!

[adj209]

yasman88 wrote:

yasman88 wrote:

pinkdolphin wrote:

gilbertn923 wrote:

This really is a horrible year for the metal community. Witht eh death of Dio, The Rev, and Paul Gray you also have the break up of Despised Icon and now Portnoy is leaving Dream Theater. What more is there to come for us for the rest of this year?

Kamelot cancelling their North American Tour (to which i had tickets >

Behemoth singer diagnosed with Leukemia....

yeah this year sucks..

Oh also, Travis Smith quitting Trivium.

.....yup..this year sucks....

dont forget peter steele

[b101]

SkinnyWhiteBoy wrote:

To say that Portnoy was EVERYTHING about Dream Theater is stupid. Sure, he was one of the more vital pieces, but I honestly think that the band would be ten times more ****ed if John Petrucci left.

Agreed. Admittedly at first I thought this was a September-time April Fools', but, whilst I rate Portnoy so highly, he's never been the most creative of drummers in a progressive sense. If they were to somehow get Gavin Harrison in I'd actually be happier than if Portnoy had stayed, and I never thought I'd be saying that.

[yasman88]

Offworld92 wrote:

yasman88 wrote:

Oh also, Travis Smith quitting Trivium.

.....yup..this year sucks....

That's a bad thing? Sorry, but Travis was a bit too whiny, and besides, Nick Augusto shits all over him playing-wise. Have you heard Shattering? Good god!

Shattering was good and Augusto is definitely a very good replacement, however it was still sad when Smith left the band..

[AdamDK]

I'm disappointed he's left DT, but he's given them 25 years of service, been one of the key people in getting the band where it is now, so I've got nothing but respect for him.

Plus, I'd rather see Dream Theater get a new drummer and then write another really good album than Portnoy choose to stay, but the album be a bit shittier than it could be due to the lack of motivation, etc.

[Tokai09]

Maybe they should get The Rev.....oh wait!....

[Fingerboy18]

HardRock369 wrote:

why avenged sevenfold, that's all i want to know.

why. mike alone comes in with twice the talent the entire band has overall, and you will never be able to convince me they will write songs to fulfill the potential they have with him.

all i know is that avenged's new cd better be the greatest thing to have ever been spawned on this earth.

Mike didn't really write anything for the new album. He said he listened to demos and tried to play in a way that would represent the rev. Mike was the rev's favorite drummer.

[zorba_the_cat]

No, no, no!! What the...!!
How can Dream Theater be without Mike???

Hope that in a couple of months he's gonna change his mind...

HE CAN'T STOP DT, and I CAN'T imagine DT without him!!!!

[aidanagain995]

This is REALLY SHOCKING AND DEVASTATING NEWS. ( I've always loved Dream Theater and all their works (including LTE). But since the decision has been made, we have no their choice than to accept it and respect it.

I wish Dream Theater good luck in their new music career without Mr. Portnoy. I wish that they would still do great. And I wish MP all the best wherever he may be lead. If it will be A7X, then I will respect it. I've listened to A7X's Nightmare with Mike Portnoy and I really found it to be great.

I WISH THEM ALL THE BEST.

[Skwisgaar S]

Too bad it wasn't their singer who left. That guy's really bad and kinda gay.

[loganpwns]

MegadethFan18 wrote:

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.


Can you count? less than half the album is slow songs. Plus it's not like Avenged said "Mike join our band or we will kill you" he said it was an "honour" to play with them so STFU donnie.

Um..no. Most of that album was slow songs. Can you count?

[uninsane_guitar]

Ughhhhh!!!!! Why do all these great bands keep disintegrating before I can ever see them live?!?!?!! First Botch, then IKTPQ, then Fall of Troy, then TN12LLY, then Slipknot, now Dream Theater?!?!!?! WTF!

[lefthandedkid]

This is a COMPLETE shock, wow...I don't even know what to say

[benblakeway14]

This must suck for Dream Theater fans, but I do hope he stays with Avenged Sevenfold now.

[Doonan]

uninsane_guitar wrote:

Ughhhhh!!!!! Why do all these great bands keep disintegrating before I can ever see them live?!?!?!! First Botch, then IKTPQ, then Fall of Troy, then TN12LLY, then Slipknot, now Dream Theater?!?!!?! WTF!

lol obviously its all your fault.

[eetfuk58]

Most people get a motorcycle, or a hooker, or a giant ass tv to help with their midlife crisis,
not quit one of the best bands ever.
Idiot. Hes incredible, but being incredibly stupid.

[izhar]

2012 came early.

[blacksickened]

you people need to shut up and do better in your life than he has. hes still a better musician then every single one of you trash talking loser. play your instrument and stop bickering about what one guy does. hes a drummer and is replacable. he means nothing to this world just like all of you clowns

[Kilvik]

agm_ultimatex wrote:

Kilvik wrote:

I cannot explain the pain i felt in my heart when i heard the news about Mike leaving Dream Theater! It's like a Mirror without a reflection. I have been a Bloodfan of Dream Theater since i first heard them many years ago. And they have inspired me in every possible way! Their music has changed my life! And finding out that the guy who put the must effort in the band is leaving is heartbreaking! I trust him and supports him in his choice, but i'm am worried sick of what will happen to Dream Theater now! He made many of their best songs! He wrote The 12 Step Suite because of his war against his alcohol problems, He Wrote A Change of Season for his mother and The Best of Times for his Father! His Father named the band. He is the Dream of Dream Theater and he is irreplaceable.
Dream Theater is the perfect combination of musicians, and are all a part of what makes their music to music! And if you take one of those pieces away it will all collapse!
But still...
If Mike or the rest of Dream Theater reads this i must just say that i'm not disappointed. I'm hurt! But i respect whatever you do, and me and i bet every Dream Theater/Portnoy fan's out there prey to God that it's just a longer break and not over yet. We need Dream Theaters Special and unique music! Because it's the only band that never had disappointed me! You have always made one album better than the other and no one can say for sure what is your best album!

- Love from Norway's biggest Dream Theater fan.

I dont think anyone can say it better. Very well put

It came straight from the heart. Thanks man, it means a lot to me!
- Love from Norway's biggest Dream Theater fan!

[JephStiph]

Q101 radio in Chicago reported on this story this morning and stated that in addition to leaving DT , he is now offically becoming a permanent member of A7X.
Has this been reported anywhere else ?

[Rautio]

I hope this means they'll start using a drum machine and writing some black metal material.

Wait, what?

[Kilvik]

loganpwns wrote:

MegadethFan18 wrote:

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.


Can you count? less than half the album is slow songs. Plus it's not like Avenged said "Mike join our band or we will kill you" he said it was an "honour" to play with them so STFU donnie.

Um..no. Most of that album was slow songs. Can you count?

To Loganpwns:
Are you a ****ing idiot?! First of all, The Nightmare album was a huge success, and try listening to it more than once before you criticize it!
And seconds of all, It was not A7X fault that Mike quit Dream Theater, and it will never be!
Get your head screwed on straight and shut up!
What you are saying is idiotic facts right from the mouth of a slaughtered pig!

[RDSElite]

I have mixed feelings about this. On one hand I think he's an arse, because he's quitting the best fcking job in the world. I also came back from my holidays today, way to ruin a good mood.

[jpgilbert701]

*pulls out gun and shoots himself in the head.*

I never got to see DT with him...
FML.

[rgt42dx]

I'm sorry but the rest of DT will have to continue as something else other than "Dream Theater" for Mike Portnoy is truly the heart of the band. It's one thing to have to replace Cliff and Jason in Metallica, But without James Hetfield, it just isn't Metallica. In my opinion, I believe Portnoy's presence is THAT crucial to the existence of the band for everything it stands for. All the best to everyone... I really love DT

[themetalpig]

I wonder if he will improve A7X as a band overall if given the chance to be a permanent member and contribute to a recording process? My guess is yes.

[Nor'Easterbass]

this is the kind of thing i'd expect to see on here on April Fool's Day...wtf. Not even a Dream Theater fan, but this kinda saddened me, knowing what a big deal it is. But now he's gonna go from being the best thing in DT to the best part of A7X. Maybe they wont suck as bad now xD

[Quoteman]

Am I the only one excited at the possibility of Mike Portnoy replacing the Rev? Though i honestly feel the Rev would stretch and pull together the meter in a way that was much more organic, as opposed to his much more metronomic playing, he's one of the only ones I would consider for the job. Not to mention that they kicked hella ass last sunday!

[Quoteman]

I feel that Petrucci is overrated anyway.

[lbounds27]

I didn't read through all the other comments so I may have missed it, but...

am I the only one who hates when people refer to themselves in the third-person...twice...in a written letter?

[blackbird51]

Fendergod666 wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

WizMystery wrote:

Joshua Garcia wrote:

Rebel_Onslaught wrote:

Wow...why mike would want to join The Jonas Brothers..err i mean avenge sevenfold is beyond me, bunch of Chris Angel look alikes, they suck balls. I hope mike fails at everything else he does and has no choice but to rejoin Dream Theater.


Awww, did someone get their period? Well, sorry Mike refused to be in your Justin Bieber cover band, he was probably too busy listening to REAL music, something you wouldn't know about.

Did you just quote the wrong person?

I think Avenged will actually become way better with Mike if he ends up going in that direction (he never said he would or wouldn't, why are you people putting words in his mouth?). A progressive influence could do something for the band, unless that's what Mike's trying to escape.


The hell are you talking about?

Rebel_Onslaught = Justin Bieber cover band
Justin Bieber cover band = Gay

Also I'll support the idea of Mike joining the A7X lineup, but geez people, give it some time. They just released an album a month or so ago, and they're on tour, it's waaay too early to be throwing around rumors.

You seemed to be aiming it at the wrong sentiment, when you said that I got the idea you were calling DT a fake band. He listens to DT apparently so I still don't know why you said that o.o

Why? Because any dick comparing A7X to the Jonas Brothers doesn't know what music is that's why!
I would take The Jonas Brothers any day over A7X.

You sir are officially gay.

[Ravitt]

I have been a dream theater fan for many years and if mike portnoy wants to leave its his lose i think dream theater will be better for it they won't be pushed in that doochebag metal poser sound thats not dt anymore. I'm really sadden that mike is leaving he is almost the heart and soul of this band i don't get it but at least we don't have to put up with those octaban and arena rock over indulgent fills anymore

[Kilvik]

That Portnoy is replacing The Rev is a good thing, because he is the only one who can do the job right!
But who the hell is going to replace him?! No one can do the things he does!
I believe that this will be the darkest period of the Dream Theater history. The Kevin Moore, Derek Shrinian and Charlie Dominici periods was hard for them because they had been in their band for a time, but Purtnoy has been there for 25 years! He is one of the original 5 and no one can play drums like he does! I just can't see a good future for Dream Theater anymore...

[Ravitt]

Kilvik wrote:

That Portnoy is replacing The Rev is a good thing, because he is the only one who can do the job right!
But who the hell is going to replace him?! No one can do the things he does!
I believe that this will be the darkest period of the Dream Theater history. The Kevin Moore, Derek Shrinian and Charlie Dominici periods was hard for them because they had been in their band for a time, but Purtnoy has been there for 25 years! He is one of the original 5 and no one can play drums like he does! I just can't see a good future for Dream Theater anymore...

There is a lot of people who can play drums better than him hes probably the worst member of dt in terms of skill

[blackbird51]

loganpwns wrote:

MegadethFan18 wrote:

loganpwns wrote:

Blame Avenged Sevenfold.

After all, they ruined their own career with their S/t and then Nightmare. So, why not ruin Mike's, too?

Although, Nightmare had about two good songs. It sucked because the majority was slow songs. Yeah, yeah, I understand The Rev died, but you write upsetting lyrics, not terrible slow songs.


Can you count? less than half the album is slow songs. Plus it's not like Avenged said "Mike join our band or we will kill you" he said it was an "honour" to play with them so STFU donnie.

Um..no. Most of that album was slow songs. Can you count?

are you that stupid? stop making shit up. 11 songs on the album, 4 out of 11 songs are in your tiny brain "slow" ..more like some of the songs, not most. we get it, you don't like a7x, but if you are going to attempt to bash them, at least know what your talking about first..

that being said, this article has absolutely nothing to do with a7x.

[dtj88]

This was my holy s*** moment...woke me up.

And a couple of people need to get a handle...it doesn't say he's guaranteed to join A7X...it's just speculation and unconfirmed.

[RDSElite]

Ravitt wrote:

Kilvik wrote:

That Portnoy is replacing The Rev is a good thing, because he is the only one who can do the job right!
But who the hell is going to replace him?! No one can do the things he does!
I believe that this will be the darkest period of the Dream Theater history. The Kevin Moore, Derek Shrinian and Charlie Dominici periods was hard for them because they had been in their band for a time, but Purtnoy has been there for 25 years! He is one of the original 5 and no one can play drums like he does! I just can't see a good future for Dream Theater anymore...


There is a lot of people who can play drums better than him hes probably the worst member of dt in terms of skill

So true

[Banti]

Meh...

[styck11]

maybe not suck a bad thing i mean hes been touring with advenged sevenfold and have u herd there new cd? o_o its awesome! i hope he stays with them

[Ebeli]

UnaLaguna wrote:

Sounds like the best for both parties. Portnoy was pushing the band into a more generic metal direction, which didn't suit them.

Jordan Rudess has said that, when he was in the producer chair, Portnoy has tried to get the band to write songs which emulate other bands. Rudess has indicated that he's much rather write genuinely new, innovative music rather than ripping off other bands.

Hopefully Rudess will get a bigger voice in DT (he's been seriously underused on their last few albums), the band will once again start featuring keyboards prominently, and - as others have said - they will return to a more progressive sound.

+1

[Muck27]

lol @ the fanboys saying "the only good part about nightmare was MP's drumming... Atleast you guys give the rev credit since hes the one who wrote the shit MP played. MP was brought in because he was the rev's musical hero and he was honored to play rev's parts on the album. MP didnt write shit but its cute to hate on a7x while complimenting them at the same time. kudos to you guys

[Quoteman]

Muck27 wrote:

lol @ the fanboys saying "the only good part about nightmare was MP's drumming... Atleast you guys give the rev credit since hes the one who wrote the shit MP played. MP was brought in because he was the rev's musical hero and he was honored to play rev's parts on the album. MP didnt write shit but its cute to hate on a7x while complimenting them at the same time. kudos to you guys

Haha, actually, after listening to nightmare I felt that it was greatly missing something without the Rev's signature drumming and occasional vocal . But Mr. Portnoy still did an excellent job.

[SynesterSeX]

dream_theater24 wrote:

I will stab myself if Mike joint A7X

Do it. It will do the rest of us a favor (those who dont kiss ass)

Lets hope MP joins a7x. All these ass kissers and haters will shoot themselves

[emphaticleech]

SynesterSeX wrote:

dream_theater24 wrote:

I will stab myself if Mike joint A7X


Do it. It will do the rest of us a favor (those who dont kiss ass)

Lets hope MP joins a7x. All these ass kissers and haters will shoot themselves

Agreed. And then A7x can go off and do whatever it is they do, and DT will be down one pissant drummer.

[emphaticleech]

Muck27 wrote:

lol @ the fanboys saying "the only good part about nightmare was MP's drumming... Atleast you guys give the rev credit since hes the one who wrote the shit MP played. MP was brought in because he was the rev's musical hero and he was honored to play rev's parts on the album. MP didnt write shit but its cute to hate on a7x while complimenting them at the same time. kudos to you guys

If it makes you feel any better, I always thought The Rev was a boring drummer and Nightmare was the worst thing they ever did, and one reason is because the even more boring MP came in and played drums. Maybe the Rev could've killed himself sooner and spared us more nasally whining from whatshis**** singer of a7x.

[TheZombieRitual]

slickerthnsleek wrote:

Hope he stays with A7x... he's incredible and I'd hear more of him with them than with DT.

Sucks for DT though... he's a hard act to follow.

You would rather see him drum for Avenged Sevenfold rather than Dream Thearter? You have to be kidding. Dream Theater is far more superior in every way, shape and form than Avenged Sevenfold. If he did that, that decision would be pure retardery in my opinion. Hopefully Mike will come back, he did just say he wanted a break.

[ticklemeemo]

After 20 years, Dream Theater was going to change at some point. They can't make the same exact music for that long and still be popular. I guess that's what Portnoy's problem is, playing the same songs over and over will get to you. Playing something fresh and exciting with another band must have seemed like a great opportunity as opposed to playing for Dream Theater, so I really won't be surprised if he joins Sevenfold. Who, by the way, are extremely talented. If they aren't your cup of tea, that's fine, just don't deny that they have talent.
PS. To the moron that said the new album sucks because it has slow songs: GTFO. Who says a song sucks because it's slow? That is honestly the dumbest thing I've heard in a long time, thanks for making me laugh.

[emphaticleech]

ticklemeemo wrote:

After 20 years, Dream Theater was going to change at some point. They can't make the same exact music for that long and still be popular. I guess that's what Portnoy's problem is, playing the same songs over and over will get to you. Playing something fresh and exciting with another band must have seemed like a great opportunity as opposed to playing for Dream Theater, so I really won't be surprised if he joins Sevenfold. Who, by the way, are extremely talented. If they aren't your cup of tea, that's fine, just don't deny that they have talent.
PS. To the moron that said the new album sucks because it has slow songs: GTFO. Who says a song sucks because it's slow? That is honestly the dumbest thing I've heard in a long time, thanks for making me laugh.

No...

Portnoy's problem is the past few albums DT has put out were rubbish because he wants to emulate other metal bands. The rest of the band stopped letting him have so much creative control, so he wanted a break. They didn't. They can find a drummer to replace him in this day and age, easily. Damon Che of Don Caballero can play circles around Portnoy AND he's not as boring to listen to.

[Air_Stryker]

wezoweez wrote:

if mike joins avenged sevenfold it'll be the biggest waste of talent the world has ever seen. ever.

I think the biggest waste of talent the world has ever seen was Dimebag Darrell getting shot by a schizo (Nathan Gale).

[zernyms]

**** this!! FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK

[kinsenas]

SH*T!!! how could this happen?? i'm a big DT fan since i was 10! i played music because of them! i think im gonna cry T_T

[RockurSocks132]

TheZombieRitual wrote:

slickerthnsleek wrote:

Hope he stays with A7x... he's incredible and I'd hear more of him with them than with DT.

Sucks for DT though... he's a hard act to follow.

You would rather see him drum for Avenged Sevenfold rather than Dream Thearter? You have to be kidding. Dream Theater is far more superior in every way, shape and form than Avenged Sevenfold. If he did that, that decision would be pure retardery in my opinion. Hopefully Mike will come back, he did just say he wanted a break.

people will hear more of mike in A7X because they are more mainstream metal than DT

this totally sucks though :/

[taveshala]

I won't be missing Mike Portnoy as much as I missed Kevin Moore. To my taste, Mike often overdoes his drumming. I love Images & Words and Awake album, 1 to 2 songs from the next 4 albums, and practically nothing from their last 3 ones...so, I hope Mike's leaving will bring a new life to DT.