Robert Plant Explains Why He Won't Reunite With Zeppelin

Over the past few months, the mere mention of Led Zeppelin would likely elicit at least one of these responses: "Are they reuniting?" and "Why not?"

While frontman Robert Plant originally sat down with Ben Jones on Absolute Radio to talk about his current work with singer/violinist Alison Krauss, the conversation eventually turned to the Led Zeppelin reunion that could have been.

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years," Plant says. "No matter what you do, you have to really guard the discretion of what you’ve done in the past and make sure that you have all the reasons and the right place to be able to do something with absolute and total conviction."

He adds, "I think the thing about it is really, is that to visit old ground, it's a very incredibly delicate thing to do, and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice."

During the interview, Plant also confirmed that he is already working on new material with Alison Krauss after the success of their 2007 album, "Raising Sand". "Raising Sand" was nominated for five awards at this year’s 51st Grammy Awards, including Album of the Year.

The full interview can be heard here.

Report by David Lowe-Bianco.

Comments

[Paul DB]

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

[Godbe]

Well it's sad, but I think he's right, it's just not the same.

[Pierced Brosnan]

I think he's right, maybe they should just leave their legacy as it is.

[Chevelle454]

it would be sweet to see them, but if they can't perform, leave it as it is

[edbert]

People would go to see them regardless, but I respect Mr. Plant's decision. Even though Jason has done a fantastic job filling in, it's not Led Zeppelin without John Bonham.

I still wouldn't mind seeing the other guys tour under a different name though.

[kjb]

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

[Powerhouse]

As much as I was hoping to see Led Zeppelin this year, I completely understand and respect his decision. Seems so many bands are reuniting these days just for the money and fame, and if Led Zeppelin reunited, they'd definitely get a gigantic dose of both. But he obviously feels that their time has come and gone, and to try to bring back the life of their original legacy would be redundant and distasteful.

I say good on him. That album he did with Alison Krauss was fantastic, by the way.

[bulldog03]

it will never be the same without bonzo. it was great. let it be.

[Guitar Villain]

he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

[Bradexman]

I'm happy to hear that Plant's making a new album with Alison Krauss. I loved the last one and both Krauss and Plant are amazing vocalists. Can't wait for it.

And aren't Page, Jones, and Jason Bonham making a new album with a new singer anyways? They're still making muusic, just not together as Led Zeppelin.

[arcticradiohead]

maybe we can finally stop hearing about this now. i mean i would have loved to see led zeppelin during my lifetime but i appreciate where hes coming from

[rebeltildeth87]

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

[therescue06]

hasnt he explained the same thing enough? stop bothering him, its not gonna happen...people are really ignorant

[Scitzo Frenic]

I wish the media would shut the **** up about this. Led Zeppelin did reunite, at the O2 arena. They played and they left. It's over. End of story. People should enjoy what was, rather than try to constantly replicate it.

[yeoman125]

I think he may also be a bit concerned with the fact that his voice is not what it used to be, and fans may be dissapointed about his performance.

[hendriko]

you know, as much as I'd like for this to happen - I totally understand him.
Led Zeppelin was a band, it's a legend now.

[SlashFan810]

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

Indeed

[Zooropean11]

The reasons given to the public are rather pretentious in my opinion. The truth is: Bonzo's dead, Pagey can't play like he used to, and Plant just can't reach the higher registers, where he was once so powerful. A Led Zep reunion, even if it brough huge amounts of money and fame to the members, would be an artistic debacle, make no mistake. I'm happy that at least Plant understands this.

[The Shadow]

Spot on, Plant! I respect the guy even more now.....plus I love how articulate and well-spoken he is in interviews, the dude's got brains!

[Powerpro]

Robert, why don't you just say the truth. You can't sing the songs like you used to anymore, you dont want to play the songs if you can't do justice to them. It's not an embarrasing thing ...your in your sixties and it's good you know when to hang it up.

[Adam124]

Completely agree with what plant is saying. Let's lay all this "bring back zeppelin" shit to rest.

[jorgeD]

I always thought being at a led zep show was something out of this world, but I saw a couple clips from their show last year(?) and it was pretty shitty.

I'd rather know them as this magical band.

[rebeltildeth87]

jorgeD wrote:

I always thought being at a led zep show was something out of this world, but I saw a couple clips from their show last year(?) and it was pretty shitty.

I'd rather know them as this magical band.

thats exactly what plant is trying to avoid. he doesnt want the legacy tainted in any way. and the truth is if they did another album, or toured with or without him, they would taint that legacy. reguardless of how good they played, it would be impossible for them to match anything they did in their prime.

[thedarkblues06]

SlashFan810 wrote:

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

Indeed

I kind of agree with this, but I have a problem with this:

The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years.

This statement really perturbs me. Because, if they were SO incomplete, why the hell did he stay with the band? And incomplete for 28 years? What does THAT mean? I think if I was Bonham or Page, I would be somewhat taken aback by this. Did he not get along or something?

I think the "going back into the past is delicate" is political fluff to account for his age, as well as his voice...and he pulled out at a good time. But he should just be frank, and not "politically correct."

[[x]Huffy[x]]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

Some things can't be bought. I think its quite obvious he doesn't care about the money involved.

[Axe Samurai]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

are you saying they should get back together because there's money in it for them?.

haha i find that sad if thats the case as people would jump at that opportunity to call them sell outs. The way they have set it out for the future is that the Led Zep will go down in history as one of the greatest bands of all time rather than ruining that image by getting back together just for money or (although unlikely) maybe not being able to perform well together.

[Metallicaloveu]

As much as I would love to see them reunited and tour, I respect his decisions because they aren't the same band they used to be. He's clearly not in it for the money like some bands are.

[[x]Huffy[x]]

thedarkblues06 wrote:

SlashFan810 wrote:

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

Indeed

I kind of agree with this, but I have a problem with this:

The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years.

This statement really perturbs me. Because, if they were SO incomplete, why the hell did he stay with the band? And incomplete for 28 years? What does THAT mean? I think if I was Bonham or Page, I would be somewhat taken aback by this. Did he not get along or something?

I think the "going back into the past is delicate" is political fluff to account for his age, as well as his voice...and he pulled out at a good time. But he should just be frank, and not "politically correct."

He said incomplete for 28 years because that is when John Bonham died, you fool. The band split up shortly afterwards.

[mrcrono]

thedarkblues06 wrote:

SlashFan810 wrote:

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

Indeed

I kind of agree with this, but I have a problem with this:

The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years.

This statement really perturbs me. Because, if they were SO incomplete, why the hell did he stay with the band? And incomplete for 28 years? What does THAT mean? I think if I was Bonham or Page, I would be somewhat taken aback by this. Did he not get along or something?

I think the "going back into the past is delicate" is political fluff to account for his age, as well as his voice...and he pulled out at a good time. But he should just be frank, and not "politically correct."

"Incomplete" refers to Bonham's death. So if you were Bonham, you wouldn't be taken aback by this message... you'd be dead.

[Iliaz]

Although I really would've loved to see the Zeppelin rise again, I have to admit that Mr. Plant has a point. Better don't do it, if chances are that you **** up...

[thedarkblues06]

"Incomplete" refers to Bonham's death. So if you were Bonham, you wouldn't be taken aback by this message... you'd be dead.

He said incomplete for 28 years because that is when John Bonham died, you fool. The band split up shortly afterwards.

I was talking about JASON Bonham, but okay, that makes sense now. (Apologize to all the LZ fanboys, but never was HUGE on LZ myself, just respected/enjoyed the band).

[FlyingLeukemia]

Led Zeppelin was certainly an amazingly talented band, but they got more and more disappointing over time. They needed to quit while they were ahead and they did.

[Tyler Durden]

Robert Plant is so right, its time to let the Zepp reunion lay to rest

[-LAW-]

Wise words from a true legend.. it's weird. Cuz I see this guy down the local a fair bit!

[Quicksand15]

Kudos to Robert Plant for showing some backbone!

[Lotz222]

Well its offical UG, you have led me to never ever ever ever ever ever never ever ever care about Led Zepplin again. THANKS!

[Soundwash22]

I agree with him, you know there are people out there that would compare Zep from before to now and mock them saying "Thier too old....its not the same....blah blah blah." Better to go out on top I think and Thank You Gentlemen for giving us some of the greatest music ever written....

[Power123]

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

ermm they dont need the money hence why there not reuniting...

also incomplete being with John Bonham it wouldnt be the same with out him
maybe they can get away with the odd show without him eg O2 but not a whole tour tbh..

[riffmasterjosh]

as much as i want a Led Zeppelin reunion tour (and trust me i do!!!) you have to respect Plant for not wanting to continue without bonham. It will not be the same and more bands should do this. Lots of bands get back together without some members and its never the same. they could never recreate the magic they had and he doesn't want to let the fans down. I do feel however that the other members need to find a singer and have their own band.

[xdxana]

Plaint asswhole!
Rock 'n roll is not dead, he is not dead, jimi is not dead, I don't care about perform, he can, all of them.
Like Ozzy Osbourne, like Rolling Stone, Led Zeppellin can do rock too.

[The Frayed End]

I understand that he loves Bonzo and misses him so much, I feel the same way. And I understand that there'd been complications before. But man, for the ones that never saw Zeppelin live(like me. I wasn't even alive then), no reunion can be heartbreaking too. I'll completely get if he doesn't want to sing Stairwat to heavem. I don't care. I just want to see the remaining 3/4 part of LedZep. Like, Please?

[thedarkblues06]

Rock 'n roll is not dead, he is not dead, jimi is not dead, I don't care about perform, he can, all of them.
Like Ozzy Osbourne, like Rolling Stone, Led Zeppellin can do rock too.

Glad you know what's better for Led Zep than a Led Zep member.

[LedZeppelin9345]

of course it's not going to be the same show as the 70s, but a lot of fans, including me, never got to see the real Led Zeppelin live, and i would really love to see Jimmy Page at least.

it wouldn't be the same, but it would still be fucking amazing.

[fetus989]

Paul DB wrote:

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

Yea me neither.

[Strat132]

Basically everyone is saying the same thing yet everyone is complaining that they wont be reuniting. YEah i would pay a hell of a lot of money to them perform but would it be worth it is the question. Everyone knows Plants voice is completely shot and there is no way he could make it sound like the good old days. I agree with Plant on the fact that they have been incomplete cause they havent had a singer. I dont respect him at all for the answer he gave. Just make fans happy and be completely honest

[mmnohmygod]

He's dead right! They were young guys back then and it was a totally different buzz. to try and bring it back would be lame they should just do their own thing or make a different band or something. one of the best bands ever

[RU Experienced?]

Glad I'm finally getting some closure on these damn rumor's. Well said by Plant, everyone seems to make him out as an ******* but he's obviously thought this through.

[MuffinMan]

Strat132 wrote:

Basically everyone is saying the same thing yet everyone is complaining that they wont be reuniting. YEah i would pay a hell of a lot of money to them perform but would it be worth it is the question. Everyone knows Plants voice is completely shot and there is no way he could make it sound like the good old days. I agree with Plant on the fact that they have been incomplete cause they havent had a singer. I dont respect him at all for the answer he gave. Just make fans happy and be completely honest

You people confuse me. "...and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice." That's exactly what he said... Lrn 2 read.

[Ndelle94]

I am so happy their not reuniting. They have achieved perfection at a certain point. Doing anything less would just be disappointing.

[paun]

Legend.but shit happens

[AidanTDR]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

maybe, just maybe he wasn't thinking about the money?! that is a possibilty with musicians you know

[This1GoesTo11]

Well put, Robert. I respect what you're saying.

[51VH50]

thats the Zeppelin mantra.

[Gh.]

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

Despite the fact, that his f***** rich owning almost a quarter of Led Zeppelin catalog, he never was(and is) a materialist. Read more about that fantasic dude.

[Orion999]

all I have to say is that I have a tremendous amount of respect for his integrity, because they could make baller dough off any kind of reunion. I admire the respect he has for John Bonham's memory and for the special and unique nature of what they did in their youth. It's a really difficult thing to look at something you yourself did and be able to say "even I'm not there anymore...and if I can't be there, no one can." I'm not saying I totally agree with his decision, but I definately respect it.

[blaghostbla]

The defeat of the Royalist insurrection extinguished the threat to the Convention and earned Bonaparte sudden fame, wealth, and the patronage of the new Directory...

[guitarlad89]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

because they don't do it for the money. They love what they do, and they do it for themselves and the fans. When they play, they play from the heart, and emotion pours out. I respect them all immensely.

[MangeRamone]

mrcrono wrote:
...So if you were Bonham, you wouldn't be taken aback by this message... you'd be dead.

lol'd so friggin hard

[JPScralatchtica]

I highly doubt that Plant or Page, Jones, and Bonham are concerned about the money in this situation. They've all made enough for the rest of their lives. It's just a difference in interest. Plant has moved on to the more mellow side of his music and the other guys want to bring back some old fashioned rock and roll. I don't feel that a reunion would at all be a let down; it would be another great album of new music, but people need to realize that it won't sound the same as led zeppelin from 30 years ago and that's fine. I'm just excited to hear that Plant will be making new music and hopefully Page, Jones, and Bonham will be making some new music as well; don't give up just because Plant isn't in the band.

[Levi79]

i think they should possibly do a reunion tour and just call Led Zepplin done, never to re-unite again.

[TheEscapist]

Great band, but belongs to the 70's. Let it there.

[Strat132]

MuffinMan wrote:

Strat132 wrote:

Basically everyone is saying the same thing yet everyone is complaining that they wont be reuniting. YEah i would pay a hell of a lot of money to them perform but would it be worth it is the question. Everyone knows Plants voice is completely shot and there is no way he could make it sound like the good old days. I agree with Plant on the fact that they have been incomplete cause they havent had a singer. I dont respect him at all for the answer he gave. Just make fans happy and be completely honest

You people confuse me. "...and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice." That's exactly what he said... Lrn 2 read.

my bad sorry lol

[darkcheef]

jimmy,john,and jason (3 J's haha) should just tour under a diff name and just find a good singer

[spiff389]

i really like Robert's explanation of this whole situation. it's the best i've read yet. and i like that he just wants to leave the legacy of led zeppelin as what it already is.

[RampagingAcorn]

wow.. what a prick

[David_Bowie=GOD]

Paul DB wrote:

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

same

[Tulkas]

This blows, and is very disrespectful to all of his fans!

[Tulkas]

It's always the singers that have to be the screw ups!

[Rajah]

Guitar Villain wrote:

he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

Exactly! Imagine him singing the Immigrant Song? Instead of being in F# they'd have to tune down and play it in D, or there abouts.

[Kapalen]

Guitar Villain wrote:

he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

He practically says this is why he won't do it he's using Bonham's death as an excuse that's not honoring him that's belittling him.

Fuck Plant.

[nmcollins05]

I really have gained some repect for Robert Plant. He is willing to leave Led Zeppelin in the past. Its cool he has the integrity to leave his work the way it was. I don't know why everyone is so mad. Why do we need more Zeppelin? I only wish he could convince some of his peers to do the same. Bands from the past have all been trying to resurrect their careers of late. The problem is none of their new stuff compares to the old...so why do it?

[!@#$]

I wish he'd go back to his Strange Sensation band, I liked the last album they did.

[ValoRhoads]

I'm all for Jimmy and John Paul just making a new band. I love Led Zep, but Plant is right, revisiting your youth as a middle aged man is just something you just shouldn't do.

[tonedeafidiot]

I am sick and tired of the blatant narcissism revolving around Led Zeppelin. "We can't put our albums up for download cause they're too good," "We can't license a single song to anyone under any circumstance cause they're too good," and now "We can't continue our tour because it might make us look bad." Just STFU and play for your fans.

[Dingoman]

at least this isnt another article about Axl Rose

[AllenRothenberg]

i think if everyone compares the way they think of zeppelin now to how they would if zeppelin chucked out one or two more okay to bad albums they'd get why it might be a good idea to not risk it. Plus, no matter how legendary they were, Zeppelin is Plant's old band and is probably tired of being asked about it all the time

[mjones1992]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

Wow. You killed that. You have no idea what Robert Plant stands for at all. Go read up on all of the charity work he's done, and how much money doesn't matter to him.

And just to add, the O2 show and the Live Aid show were charity events.

[Luppi]

kjb wrote:

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

The thing is; it IS enough. And thus this decision.
Not very bright maybe no?

[FlyingPirahna]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

No, nothing short of one of his closest friends' resurrection will do. Go away.

[Mobes52]

How would it be disappointing? Weren't they kick ass in London last year?

[rickguitarguy86]

I used to be excited about hearing there might be a reunion but robert plant is straight up dick and i could care less now.

[QBAG]

I think they should do one more tour, for people like me who were born too god damn late in life and didnt get to live in one of the greatest decades ever where these guys ruled. They proved with that show in London they can still do it, so do it one more time, for me and countless others.

That being said, thses guys are amazing regardless of what happens and they will still live on forever

[Jastul]

The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years

Axl could learn a thing or two about this man...

anyhow, I fully agree with Mr. Plant, and respect his decision to not go on without Bonzo and respect him a hell of a lot more for knowing and admitting to himself and the world that the time of Led Zeppelin has come and gone and it would be disrespectful to Bonzo and their legacy to try to force the issue and relieve something that isn't there anymore

Thank you Mr. Plant, Mr. Bonham, Mr. Jones and Mr. Page for all the great music and good memories, hopefully your legacy can rest in peace now, we who are about to rock salute you

Checked.

[latkingz781]

tearjerker

[etniesmuzikskat]

I honestly dont give a shit about a reunion. Leave the legacy where it belongs and move on.

[mxzach98]

im going to ball up and admit it, if i were in his shoes i would reunite. But it takes balls to say no, ROBERT knows that if led zep reunited it would be to different and it would be a complete sell out

[Cobra Strike]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"

So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

Thats a stupid remark. No matter how much money you have, it wont change anything. Robert is rich anyway. He cant perform like he used to. Phisically impossible. There isn't enough money in the world to change life.

[IamGod 666]

its because he cant sing! Plant is full of shit. not that they should reunite

[Serial Rocker]

I'm completely right with whatever he says.

[acoustielectric]

You know what, alchohol killed freaking music! Jimi hendrix had too much to drink and had an overdose, DIED! That's over. John bonham got drunk and died like jimi, and he was taken along with the legacy of led zeppelin. How about even black sabbath, who kicked ozzy out for drinking too much and started to suck! One of the best rock n roll singers Bon Scott, died from drinking too much!! I'm MAD!!!!

[RockUAway]

Just tour
john bonham was great, but atleast a FAMILY member is filling in and not some random guy

Plant even said the the reunion at o2 arena was amazing and was talkin about future plans. Guns N' Roses (or better yet, Axl and friends) are selling out arenas every time they go on tour so I dont think this should be an issue.

[Phoenix_24Leas]

acoustielectric wrote:

You know what, alchohol killed freaking music! Jimi hendrix had too much to drink and had an overdose, DIED! That's over. John bonham got drunk and died like jimi, and he was taken along with the legacy of led zeppelin. How about even black sabbath, who kicked ozzy out for drinking too much and started to suck! One of the best rock n roll singers Bon Scott, died from drinking too much!! I'm MAD!!!!

the way I heard it he took some drug and tried to counteract it which lead to jimi choking on his own vomit. I could be wrong tho

[tremeloud]

TO ALL THE PEOPLE BITCHING ABOUT HIS VOCALS:
no shit
Plant knows his voice isn't the same, and he mentioned how reuniting is a delicate thing and it can bring disappointment. He doesn't want to disappoint. He isn't full of shit he knows that Zeppelin wouldn't be the same on many levels, and the fact that he can't perform the same is definitely one of them.

[tremeloud]

acoustielectric wrote:

You know what, alchohol killed freaking music! Jimi hendrix had too much to drink and had an overdose, DIED! That's over. John bonham got drunk and died like jimi, and he was taken along with the legacy of led zeppelin. How about even black sabbath, who kicked ozzy out for drinking too much and started to suck! One of the best rock n roll singers Bon Scott, died from drinking too much!! I'm MAD!!!!

Alcohol and aircraft.
Helis, plane crashes...

[YoHendrix]

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

Plant should do it for Charity!

[acoustielectric]

Lol no offense to anyone 'cause I'm a lz fan, but wouldn't it be funny if they did go on tour at that age, old people rocking out?

[acoustielectric]

Phoenix_24Leas wrote:

acoustielectric wrote:

You know what, alchohol killed freaking music! Jimi hendrix had too much to drink and had an overdose, DIED! That's over. John bonham got drunk and died like jimi, and he was taken along with the legacy of led zeppelin. How about even black sabbath, who kicked ozzy out for drinking too much and started to suck! One of the best rock n roll singers Bon Scott, died from drinking too much!! I'm MAD!!!!

the way I heard it he took some drug and tried to counteract it which lead to jimi choking on his own vomit. I could be wrong tho

Yeah, he choked on his vomit, but thats because of his drinking...

[ihavenoname93]

rebeltildeth87 wrote:

i agree with robert 110%. he knows whats best for the legacy of zeppelin, and hes not thinking of the truck loads of money he would get.

or the truckloads of money isnt high enough for him

acoustielectric wrote:

Lol no offense to anyone 'cause I'm a lz fan, but wouldn't it be funny if they did go on tour at that age, old people rocking out?

unless they werent old 2 years ago, they already have

[-tempest-]

acoustielectric wrote:

Lol no offense to anyone 'cause I'm a lz fan, but wouldn't it be funny if they did go on tour at that age, old people rocking out?

i think that would call from more than a couple ambulances at said show, my friend

[FuZzY(aus)]

good to see him standing by his opinion despite pressure
awesome awesome man

[Veritas69]

older bands are still going on tour like stones and AC/DC. but if you think that you haven't got it anymore thats understandable

[TwistedLogic]

Plant wants to protect the integrity and aura that Zep had in the past and that is fine with me. Somethings are special because of the people and time in which these people got together; be it make a great movie, a great album, or be exceptional at sports like the San Fran 49's of the 80's. Some things need to be left as they were and preserved for thier greatness, not resurrected for profit or vanity or fan pressure. Zep was an astonishing band in the day and we need to realize that that can and will never be replicated. Kudas to Plant for saying no.

[Zeppman918]

yea it would be cool to see them all together again. but it wouldnt be the same without Plant, and that enough could kind of ruin the whole plan. i mean the worst that could happen is they go on tour and suck...and then what. i dont think people would start disliking them, but the press would probably in someway downplay the whole thing, and who needs that. Led Zeppelin rocked and they'll forever be known for rocking, they should just leave it at that. Or if the rest of the band members get together and start collaborating, change the name or something so it gives it a whole new meaning.

[HeavyMetalHokie]

i think its very respectful for him to say this. hes basically saying they cant compete with old zeppelin and he doesnt want to dissapoint himself or the fans. its better than charging 600$ a seat and seeing a crappy burnt out version of zeppelin, thats what he wants to avoid

[chimcrew]

as much as i love zep, i don't think a reunion would be a great idea because it would totally ruin the image that we all have of them... it's like bringing back a retired athlete and expecting him to perform as if he were in his prime...

[cueva101]

i realy think thell sound good they sounded real good in 07 seven

[Les Paul57]

i agree with most of you guys, led zeppelin was one of the greatest band ever and lets remember them that way. they're done and don't want to push it.

[GibsonMonroe547]

i respect what robert says and they should leave Led as it is. they were great, but i honestly think the three of them should keep going under a new name with the band Kingdom Come's singer should be their singer

[ClassicGuitar77]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

i cant believe you said that man. its not the money, screw that. its the feeling of the music and everything it represented and stood for. money doesnt mean anything in this situation, its about the music. im as sad as everyone else that Plant decided not to, but to say something like that, wow... think about it. its about the music man, not the money. i wish they would tour too, i would love to, but if even ONE of them doesnt feel the music, then its not worth it and its not right.

[ClassicGuitar77]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

i cant believe you said that man. its not the money, screw that. its the feeling of the music and everything it represented and stood for. money doesnt mean anything in this situation, its about the music. im as sad as everyone else that Plant decided not to, but to say something like that, wow... think about it. its about the music man, not the money. i wish they would tour too, i would love to, but if even ONE of them doesnt feel the music, then its not worth it and its not right.

[Dymencion]

a lot of people in his position would see dollar signs, so we have to respect him for that

[ultimatedaver]

IMO it's cause they don't do drugs like they did back in the day.

[drummz11]

"it was an april morning when they told us we should go, as i turned to you, you smiled at me, how could we say no? With all the fun to have, to live the dreams we always had, oh the songs to sing, when at last we return again"-Achilles Last Stand

Maybe its not their time to return yet.
(yes i know this song is probably about Lord of the Rings)

[poopdedoop]

Mr. Plant is right, I'm afraid. No matter how bad we want it, Bonzo is gone and you can't have Led Zeppelin unless it's the real Led Zeppelin. It wouldn't be right for them to reunite without Jimmy Page. It wouldn't be right for them to reunite without John Paul Jones. It wouldn't be right for them to reunite without Robert Plant. Why would it make sense for them to reunite without John Bonham? The music they've made is great enough to stand the test of time for all time...I mean sometimes they're blown out of proportion and overrated...but for the most part they're one of the greatest bands that has ever existed, and their musical legacy doesn't need to be messed with.

[zasmith]

the song he did with Alison Krauss was actually written with jimmy page which i think that would have sounded a bit better along with a good guitar solo could have sounded a bit better

[BohemianRoy]

i like plant and i agree with him

[cubspackers4]

everyone i know who saw them live said it sucked, they were hoping for more zeppelin tunes

[piginacanoe212]

if they got together again it would be cool yeah, but they wouldnt be as good as they were and it would tarnish their title as "the best band ever"

[Guitar_tischler]

Surprised how many agree with Plant,and so do I. A reunion might the destroy their almost mythical reputation. R.I.P

[andregomes]

He's completely right. They broke up because Bonham died, and it would be inconsistent to reunite 28 years later. Zeppelin is about the symbols and if one symbol is missing, that wouldn't be them. I'm happy Plant has discernment to refuse a reunion. We don't want more like "Sex Pistols" without Sid Vicious. But I'd still see them if they reunited

[RicheyVOX]

Like we all didn't know what this was gonna say. What an epic waste of time. A new Zeppelin album would only solidify their reputation as possibly the best ever

[Fuzzbox91]

I really respect him for making this decision and not selling out, in fact my respect for him has gone way up, hes right unfortunatly, its not zep without bonzo

[voidSkipper]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

I thoroughly doubt he's talking about money.

[JHante]

F*****K THIS!!!!! Led Zeppelin has to reunion!!!! i dont care if its not as good as their old stuff. Led Zeppelin used to be my reason for living. of course now its metallica but still! Led Zeppelin is what made me finally decide that i wanted to play guitar the rest of life! im not saying get back together and make an album! im saying tour the world and make our final wish come true!!!! thats all im saying. yes it would be wrong to get the band back together without bonzo but jason bonham is a great drummer..... definately good enough for a tour! btw..... come to San Diego!!!!!11

[shadowsoldier08]

never liked him in the first placed, but hes got a point. going on now would be silly when they are not who they used to be. look at indiana jones4, sounded like a good idea, but nothing beats the original.

[mithra_trinity]

they cant reunite anyway,without the drummer there cant be a led zeppelin

[Led-Zeppelin71]

I just wanna see page busting out a ****ing solo!!!!
even if he did a solo career I would be so excited and buzzing with anticipation of seeing my god preform on a stage!!!

[Co&Ca11]

i am glad they arent getting back together, as much as i like zeppelin and would have loved to see them back in the day, it just wouldnt be the same now

[Filter]

I think he's right..
Let me use an analogy.
Would Pantera be the same without Dimebag? No..

[Hungry_Hameds]

"I think the thing about it is really, is that to visit old ground, it's a very incredibly delicate thing to do, and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice."

Guitar Villain wrote:

he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

he said that, the above shows he recognises that, read it properly!

Bonzo is the greatest rock drummer ever, no doubt. I dont know of any people 60 plus who can still sing like when they were young, you cant play sports like u did when u were young at 60, so why is voice any different? It's not his fault, we will all be old one day! He knows he cant replicate his youth, he also knows the zep lineup was one of a kind. They are the best rock band of all time.

[Hungry_Hameds]

"I think the thing about it is really, is that to visit old ground, it's a very incredibly delicate thing to do, and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice."

Guitar Villain wrote:

he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

He does say that if you care to read. He knows he isnt what e used to be power-wise, but can you say Pele is the same amazing footballer he was 40-50 years ago? No, because age changes us, why should voice be any different to physicality?

Bonzo is the greatest rock drummer, so cant be replaced, Jason did well as a one off.

The old lineup is of the greatest rock band ever, why try and pine for the glory days, just be glad younger generations have had a chance to hear why they are so revered.

[Dacons13]

the only people who want them back are old people and the posers who just like the music because their mommies and daddies do.

[Anvil pants]

i think he's just a big pussy and doesn't want to do it because of his relationship with whatever her name is.

[bassmanjoe08]

Fuck this bullshit about "legacy". Call me greedy, but I want to see these guys play.

[deknisely]

I love Planty, but he sounded extremely self-righteous. If you make music, you should want to play it regardless of, well, anything really. He has TONS of fans that would KILL to see him play just ONE last time. If he can't do it for himself, then he should do it for the fans.
All IMO.

[Megadethfan123]

I would like to hear some material of Led Zeppelin with/without Plant, doesnt really matter. why cant Zep get another singer? Queen did it and they have turned out great!

[greendayrocksu]

Man

[greendayrocksu]

I don't want them to leave a bad taste in everyone's mouth, like Van Halen...

[greendayrocksu]

Megadethfan123 wrote:

I would like to hear some material of Led Zeppelin with/without Plant, doesnt really matter. why cant Zep get another singer? Queen did it and they have turned out great!

I agree!

[lopezmetalmunky]

Paul DB wrote:

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

+1

[Craig01]

led zeppelin = every lame preteen's wet dream

[chuckjitsu]

Sorry Percy, I gotta call bullshit here. Using his own logic, they never should have reunited ever. Not for Live Aid, not for the Atlantic 40th anniversary show, not for Unledded, etc. The fact that these are one offs vs full tours is irrelevant. Jimmy and John Paul (and Jason for that matter)do not want to tarnish the Zep legacy any more than Bob does, meaning they wouldn't tour if they didn't think they had the chops for it. Page and Jones are fully aware that it ain't the 70s anymore. If there was a Zep tour in 2009 (or whenever), fans would not expect it to be like seeing Zeppelin circa '75 and if they did they're morons.

The only one lacking conviction about a Zep tour is Percy. The reasons he lays out here are garbage, but only he knows (or maybe he doesn't) the real reason(s) why.

[chuckjitsu]

Yes, they did tour behind Unledded, but not as Led Zeppelin.

[Clunis]

Why do all these singers feel the need to cover up for the fact that they just can't pull off their old stuff anymore? Adapt the songs to a new voice that works...

[TheSilverBeatle]

This is a prime example of how people are retarded. Nearly every band that does get back together gets nothing but "they'll never top their old stuff" "they should have quit while they were ahead" but if they refuse to get together it's "why won't they get back together!"

And to Clunis...here's an alternate solution...do new music that you can and stop living in the past. Wait...that's what Plant is doing.

If he joins the band he's an old geezer longing for his glory days, if he doesn't he's a fan hating guy who can't sing anymore.

There is no pleasing everyone. Unfortunately only the people who aren't pleased speak up.

[Andragon]

Good call. They were great, but I wouldn't pay tons of money to go see em anyway. RIP Bonham.

[Deep*Kick]

Pierced Brosnan wrote:

I think he's right, maybe they should just leave their legacy as it is.

+`100000

[airliner]

ClassicGuitar77 wrote:

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

i cant believe you said that man. its not the money, screw that. its the feeling of the music and everything it represented and stood for. money doesnt mean anything in this situation, its about the music. im as sad as everyone else that Plant decided not to, but to say something like that, wow... think about it. its about the music man, not the money. i wish they would tour too, i would love to, but if even ONE of them doesnt feel the music, then its not worth it and its not right.

beating a dead horse much? and lets not use all those "its not money, its the feeling" cliches. cheers percy.

[41plus182]

tremeloud wrote:

acoustielectric wrote:

You know what, alchohol killed freaking music! Jimi hendrix had too much to drink and had an overdose, DIED! That's over. John bonham got drunk and died like jimi, and he was taken along with the legacy of led zeppelin. How about even black sabbath, who kicked ozzy out for drinking too much and started to suck! One of the best rock n roll singers Bon Scott, died from drinking too much!! I'm MAD!!!!

Alcohol and aircraft.
Helis, plane crashes...

Don't forget suicide either, sadly...

[Dionietzsche]

That almost brought a tear to my eye. Its good to see a living legend that isn't willing to sell a piece of the golden era of rock [cough]Pink Floyd[/cough]. Robert Plant, I've a new found, profound respect for you.

[-xCaMRocKx-]

It's sad, but I guess it's the best decision. I wouldn't have been able to see them anyway, they wouldn't have come to Australia.

I wish they'd release an O2 DVD though, no it's not the same as their glory days, but I still would love to see it.

[-xCaMRocKx-]

Sorry for double post, but does anyone else want to see a Page/JPJ collaboration? I bet it'd be brilliant.

[srvkicks@$$]

this isnt fair most of led zeppelin is still intact and there are about 40 decades of people that havent been to a led zeppelin concert

think about the children
the poor rock'n'roll starved children
the children who have been wishing for the chance to have their ears curessed with good music played live

they should do it for the children

it would be like a save the world tour but instead of saving the world from global warming it would be saving the world from people that are introduced as singing pop sensation or sining sensation

plz led zeppelin save the world

[D3athM4gnetic19]

LZ should do an album with or without plant. Seems like Plant is really committed to his work with Krauss which is kinda sad, I really hoped he would get back together with LZ for a reunion. But as for LZ, I really hope one day they can make another album, that would just be awesome!

[DanteLord]

srvkicks@$$ wrote:

this isnt fair most of led zeppelin is still intact and there are about 40 decades of people that havent been to a led zeppelin concert

think about the children
the poor rock'n'roll starved children
the children who have been wishing for the chance to have their ears curessed with good music played live

they should do it for the children

it would be like a save the world tour but instead of saving the world from global warming it would be saving the world from people that are introduced as singing pop sensation or sining sensation

plz led zeppelin save the world

agreed.

[blackmamba68]

bull puckey! Give the man a viagra and let him ROCK again. He hasn't ROCKED in years. Allison Kraus my foot. THAT is what's wrong.

[BobTheBlob]

Paul DB wrote:

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

[DouglasDisaster]

Bravo! My hat's off to Plant for his wisdom and reasoning. Anyone questioning his vocal ability should go see him live. His voice is as good as it was with Zep. It seems to me that he is far from "hanging it up". This new chapter he's writing with Krauss is just that. A whole new chapter to the book he's been reading to us since 1969.

[duke2446]

okay this interview was to put plant in the spotlight again after it became obvious the zep is not re-uniting rail, hail, tornado, armaggedeon whatever.

[deadlights]

Finally. Keep something sacred.

[NaivexLi]

DouglasDisaster wrote:

Bravo! My hat's off to Plant for his wisdom and reasoning. Anyone questioning his vocal ability should go see him live. His voice is as good as it was with Zep. It seems to me that he is far from "hanging it up". This new chapter he's writing with Krauss is just that. A whole new chapter to the book he's been reading to us since 1969.

so well said, and I could nto agree more.

The man is a legend and he knows how to keep it that way.

He doesnt want to be laughed at like many other bands who never try to change.
He's still doing music, he's still being himself completely
but he's not pretending he's in his prime, he's not trying to ruin such a legacy that is Led Zeppelin.

[ænimic]

Robert Plant is staying true. Most rockstars try to drag their legacy way beyond what they can do and what they usually have are "The Best of" concerts.

[Shamanic Rhythm]

Alright, the man has spoken, and I think we should all be able to respect his reasons, after all, he cares as much about the legend of Zeppelin as we do, probably more. Can it rest now? Please?

[brentondig]

I heard this on the radio the other day. He's right, it'll never be the same without Bonzo. Let what was be.

[Wiegraf]

I think Plant's doing the right thing. No sense touring now just to risk imprinting a really bad first impression on a generation that's unfamiliar with them. Better for them to hear them at their best on the records.

[Vinzafy]

Good for you Robert. Way to not be greedy and know the true extent of what could happen if they do. Kudos to him for his decision. Great show of his character.

[Rtard_GWARRIOR]

Tbh, I've never really liked Led Zeppelin, I like Jimmy's playing though. I have one of his solo albums, its not bad at all

[Melkord]

I went with my mom to one of the shows with him and Krauss(I personally can't stand her, but I love zeppelin, so I was there just to see him), and as they were walking out on the stage someone yelled,"Where's Jimmy"? I laughed pretty hard...then died a little.

[Tommy Walker]

Plant's voice is dead. Page's guitar playing was deteriorating with heroin use in the late seventies. Bonzo is obviously dead. While I'm sure JPJ skill has never changed but the rest of the band has fallen apart muscially. Why should Plant try to rehash some performances he no longer has the talent for and taint his art when he can still do something unique musically with Krauss?

[fmansfield444]

hes got a point but i was really hoping for a tour. if they went without plant they should use the singer for Great White. he sounds really close to plant. watch on youtube.

[SeannyBHimself]

I am really disappointed with Robert's decision. When people say that they shouldn't tour so they could keep their legacy strong, I say look at what they did a in 2007. They obviously have still got the talent and the people are willing to pay thousands to see them, so why not go. I think that if they did it, that would create a legacy that no other band could compare to.

[nileflows]

what they did in the past isnt possible to do it at this. some things are better if left untouched. i totally agree with Plant.

[pyritmann]

Good for him, he refuses to sell out even despite the media pressure, he knows if zeppelin reunited they would make a ton of money, but he cares enough about his fans to milk them of every dollar they are willing to spend on a cd simply because of the name... the other classic rock bands wanting to reunite should be as considerate, and besides that... he was nominated for 5 grammys? why would he want to leave that:P every one would hate a new zeppelin album once it came out because it wouldnt be "the same" good boy.

[hendrixguitarx]

as much as i would love to see Led Zeppelin, I think they shouldn't reunite. It just wouldn't be the same without John Bonham, and they're pretty old. they definately couldn't preform like they used to. and SeannyBhimself, Zeppelin already did create a legacy that no other band could compare to.

[asmeister]

Good choice, then. Guess he's not needing the money, and there's nothing more pathetic than seeing reunions made to keep someone liquored up a few years from now.

[mr.happyman]

what he said can be summed up in three words "i suck now"

[FiveStarMotel]

Good for him, all good things gotta come to an end and Zep is one of those things. Plus, he's doing great with Alison Krauss, and that's working out for him. He's still a great musician and Led Zeppelin is a great band but I think it's better that they aren't getting back together.

[Ali-b912]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

Maybe you could consider that not everyone in music is a Lars or Gene Simmons. Everyone has a price, but Plant obviously values his artistic integrity alot more then anybody is willing to pay for.

Also, he seems to be hinting to the idea that if they do reunite, everyone will complain that they aren't as good as they used to be.

[metal-head666]

they should just do a tour but not make more music. it wont be zeppelin

[Hungry_Hameds]

"I think the thing about it is really, is that to visit old ground, it's a very incredibly delicate thing to do, and the disappointment that could be there once you commit to that and the comparisons to something that was basically fired by youth and a different kind of exuberance to now, its very hard to go back and meet that head on and do it justice."

Guitar Villain wrote:
he should tell the truth and say his vocals can't hold up. I love some of their songs just not tuned down 2 1/2 steps.

He did say it if you bother to read.

Is Pele the same incredible footballer he was 40-50 years ago? No.Because he got old. Why do ppl keep slating Plants voice? Yes it isnt what it used to be, but for 60 its still miles better than a lot of current young ''good singers''.

Why is it ok to be physically poorer when you get old but nno vocally?????

Leave him to do his next album!

Besides you cant replace rock's greatest ever drummer, or alter rock's greatest ever band!!

[srg-slash]

they need to leave it how it is otherwise they will end up wiv a shity cum back album like metallica an it will be shockingly bad, this is how they need 2 leave it

[b-rock34]

I told my friend months ago that Plant wouldn't do it because he's scared he can't pull it off. As far as I'm concerned, he admitted it right there. So, until he grows a pair, it ain't gonna happen.

[tom1thomas1]

has anyone ever listened to allison kraus and robert?

[b-rock34]

tom1thomas1 wrote:

has anyone ever listened to allison kraus and robert?

Yes, I have. And my opinion is that it's good, but nothing special.

[Gasa]

he can at least try... that would be nice

[poona]

Respect to Robert Plant, he knows how to leave the past behind him. The Led Zep reunion concert didn't sound so good anyway, if they did a tour it would just be a black spot on their legacy.

[Vinura]

he's right, it wont be the same

[farhan_zul]

allison krauss??
never heard of her..

[Led_Hed]

I think Zeppelin should have a reunion just because some of the younger fans who weren't around when Zep was still together can come and watch them live.

[Nilpferdkoenig]

He can't sing anymore anyhow, it's horrible.
The entire "No Quarter" DVD is so full of effects and obvious overdubs, it's atrocious.

[Led_Hed]

I think Zeppelin should come back with one more tour so that some of the younger fans who weren't around when Zep was together, can come and see them play.

[lukas1324]

did anyone see jimmy paige play with the foo fighters?

[jatmega]

I think its right of them to not reunite if plant thinks it really wont be Led Zeppelin they ill be playing.

[Quik Axe Player]

It'd be cool to see another Plant and Page project, just the two of them.

[xitlight]

Good to see some musical integrity here. Screw the money.

[PendulousThread]

Paul DB wrote:

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

This.

[Ibanezmansam]

I don't know about everybody else but...I really don't care about this anymore.

yes.

[Gui_Tar_God]

It's a pity. Led Zeppelin forever!

[Raffistyle]

Right or wrong, after 4 cassettes, all 10 EPs on CD, the 4 and 2 disc box sets, the Egyptian bore, t- shirts, posters, solo albums etc. (And I'm only one in the 3 generations of N.American Led fans)
Would it be to much,for a hand full of Western performances. Why only the U.K. Is it not the States that made them living legend, gave them Blues and Rock n Roll. I dont know didley about reasons and convictions,really dont give a fork. Justice would be playing a thank you note in front of the fans, that got you and kept you there, even after 28 years of "incompletion". Don't get me wrong, I will allways love Led and Plant, unconditionally.

[dannydmangillz]

i luv led zeppelin so much, its a dam shame :'(

[xxmoshoutxx]

well at least its finally come from him, rather than speculation and comments from jimmy page and all them!

[Melkord]

tom1thomas1 wrote:

has anyone ever listened to allison kraus and robert?

Yes, went to a show, was ready to stab myself by the time it was over, can't stand kraus.

[Apocalypse4162]

I totally understand his decision and why he chose, and it makes a lot of sense. He's a smart man, but if Zeppelin wants to go on tour still, have they even considered David Coverdale? I listen to him and Page on their album together and it really resembles Robert Plant to the best extent I have heard from someone who sounds somewhat like him. He would be a great vocalist for the tour...

[oiiopo]

Well the legacy is really what's important isn't it? In fifty years, people will listen to Zeppelin and say "that's one of the best bands in a century", not "that's the band that lost it".

[Hellboy griffin]

Let it be

[Aguamento]

kjb wrote:

"The reason that it stopped was because we were incomplete and we've been incomplete now for 28 years,"
So a million gajillion billion dollars wasn't enough no?

...He's talking incomplete in the fact that 1/4 of Led Zeppelin is dead

[metalheadblues]

they made there muzik and there legacy is left

[FearOfTheDuck]

Verbal diarrahea!! Do a tour with Zeppelin, who wouldn't want that? I'd pay good money to see them. They should've done a farewell tour, for the fans. Not just one date at the o2. Oh well i suppose age got the better of him, but look at Brian Johnson from AC/DC, i've seen them twice this year and he still sounds good amd he's running about and stuff! And Brian is older and they're doing a MASSIVE tour!

[thirteenburn]

I thought Plant didn't want to do the reunion because he's "too old" bulls**t? Now it's because "it's too delicate a situation to revisit without the exuberance of youth."

Uh, what?

[Melvin7727]

thedarkblues06 wrote:

"Incomplete" refers to Bonham's death. So if you were Bonham, you wouldn't be taken aback by this message... you'd be dead.

He said incomplete for 28 years because that is when John Bonham died, you fool. The band split up shortly afterwards.

I was talking about JASON Bonham, but okay, that makes sense now. (Apologize to all the LZ fanboys, but never was HUGE on LZ myself, just respected/enjoyed the band).

There are no such thing as "Led Zeppelin fanboys," only those that have the musical tastes and understanding to recognize Led Zeppelin as the greatest rock band of all time.