search for: in
 
advanced + submit your tab

+ submit your review

+ submit your article
fresh tabs / 0-9 a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z / top 100 tabs

Dave Mustaine Discusses 'The 100 Greatest Metal Guitarists'

artist: megadeth date: 08/27/2009 category: interviews
rating: 5.5 / votes: 2 
Dave Mustaine Discusses 'The 100 Greatest Metal Guitarists'

Dave Ling of Classic Rock magazine recently conducted an interview with Megadeth mainman Dave Mustaine. A couple of excerpts from the chat follow below.

Classic Rock: How did it feel to bury some past grievances with Slayer by touring together?

Mustaine: [Smiling faintly]: I didn't even talk to Kerry [King, guitarist] yet.

But he did watch Megadeth's show from the side of the stage?

Yeah. I've never had anything against Kerry — he started it all. The many things he said about me hurt my feelings, but I'm still open to being friends with him. Maybe we'll sit down together and have a drink; he'll have Jägermeister and I'll have water. I'm a different person now, I'm 47. I'm happy in my life.

But the olive branch came personally from you?

Yeah. I've done a lot of that. I did it with Pantera. I did it with [estranged former bassist] David Ellefson. I had dinner recently with Dave and he said that [leaving the band] was the dumbest thing he ever did. I said, that's okay — I forgive you. As I sit here talking to you now, thinking about the people I have grievances with, there are zero. I'm really happy with my life. And as my career nears its end, it's finishing at the top.

Can you pinpoint why you are in such a good headspace right now?

My faith [in God] is behind why I'm playing as good, and how I got rid of my demons. That I've been saved is something I don't push it on anybody, but it's helped me. It goes back to what I said about Slayer at the start. I'd said I'd never play with Satanic bands. Though people don't know this, I also said I'd never play with man-whore bands because I didn't want to go out there and struggle with staring at chicks in the audience. But when my life changed I put all that stuff on the side. I realized I could play with bands that attract female audiences; after all, guys like to go to gigs where there will be chicks — even chubby ones, 'cos there are chubby dudes — and I began to lighten up. That's what this whole thing's about. Right now I'm happy, joyous, free… I'm your buddy, the guy you've known forever. You've said mean things about me; you've said great things about me. But we're friends; friendship is about good and bad.

How did it feel to be No. 1 in Joel McIver's recent book, "The 100 Greatest Metal Guitarists"?

It was especially sweet when I found out that Joel has written books on Metallica. I looked at my copy of the book — I wasn't on the cover or the back. I figured I'd be somewhere like No. 69. So I thumbed through it; it's a really comprehensive, good book. I got to No. 50 and I thought, "Am I in here?" I'd been told that I was, but not which position. So I got No. 16 and I saw Hetfield. I thought, "Wow," because I respect James. I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world.

The other two being?

Malcolm Young [of AC/DC] and myself. Malcolm kept it basic but brought a whole new style of rhythm playing to the world. So I got to the Top 10… I still wasn't in there. Every page I turned, I became more excited. I get to No. 5 and it's Kirk [Hammett], and I thought, "Thank you, God." At that point it didn't matter [which position I was]. To be better than both of them [Hetfield and Hammett] meant so much — it's been one of the pet peeves of my career and I've never known how to deal with it. I didn't realize that it has had so much bearing upon my life. Then I got to No. 2 and it was John Petrucci [of Dream Theater] and I froze. I was No. 1. What made it better still is that the guy wrote: "This isn't about Dave as a person because he's been a cock" — [interjects with a bray of laughter] — "These four pages are about his guitar playing, which is the best. There are people who are better at one thing that Mustaine does, and others that are better than another, but no-one who's as good at everything." All I thought was… I win!

In a way did it represent closure?

That's it exactly. I'm not addicted [to anything] anymore. And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica]. That game has ended. Lars [Ulrich] called me up and offered the chance to come to the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame thing and not be inducted, to sit in the audience [instead]. "It's only for people who've been on the records" is what I was told. That would have been awkward. So I didn't go. There are obviously some unresolved issues on Lars' part. But you know what? If God wants me in the Hall Of Fame, I will be there.

Read more of the interview from Classic Rock magazine.

Video footage of Mustaine talking about Metallica in March 2008 on guitarist Dave Navarro's (Jane's Addiction) online TV show on ManiaTV.com called "Spread TV" can be viewed here.

This article is a part of the Metal Thursday campaign, read more here.

POSTED: 08/27/2009 - 08:24 am
print
share
subscribe to
More Megadeth news:
+ Broderick Doesn't Share Mustaine And Ellefson's Christian Beliefs interviews 11/14/2011
+ Megadeth: 'Public Enemy No 1' Video online downloads 11/04/2011
+ Megadeth: 'Th1rt3en' To Sell 40K-45K First Week general music news 11/03/2011
+ Megadeth Hangs Out With Pee-Wee Herman: Photo general music news 11/02/2011
+ Megadeth's Dave Mustaine: 6 Questions About 'Th1rt3en' upcoming releases 10/31/2011
+ view all
comments policy  283  comments posted, 40 removed | this article is 88% spam-free
     
syke5 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:36 am / quote |
HAHA dude hes number 1 thats so awesome definitely buying this book! and Endgame comes out sept 15 goto hot topic to get it and i got first comment!
     
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:41 am / quote |
And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].


if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd
     
Nite` wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:46 am / quote |
I'm Glad Mustaine is happy with life it's always good to see people who been in a bad way find themselves
     
scawti wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:51 am / quote |
if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

There's a difference in taking pride in coming in on top and struggling with demons.
He'll have to deal with the rest of his life with questions about Metallica - and Lars seems to like taking jabs at him. It was gloating, but respectful gloating.
     
enginehead wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:56 am / quote |
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote:

And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd


Like the recent Metal Hammer article on him pointed out, one can sense that there still is that feeling present with Dave, just not in a big way. Doesn't really bother me, it shows that this whole new forgoveness thing going on isn't sort of an act.

btw the metal hammer article was really good if ur a megadeth fan you'll like it
     
Skuzzmo wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:06 am / quote |
That article made me smile....

Nice one Dave.

     
Right-Wing Dick wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:09 am / quote |
Leaves one kind of drug for another (religion).
     
Jet_Black88 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:52 am / quote |
I actually saw that book a couple months ago.

I thumbed through it...when I saw Mustaine at number 1 and Paul Gilbert didn't get a mention at ALL, I was like..."Okay, something's wrong here."
     
scithe37 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:53 am / quote |
I personally wouldn't put him no.1, but he is still a god and at least top 10 deserving.
     
nerv wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:02 am / quote |
[quote]I actually saw that book a couple months ago.

I thumbed through it...when I saw Mustaine at number 1 and Paul Gilbert didn't get a mention at ALL, I was like..."Okay, something's wrong here."/quote]

even though Paul Gilbert is one of my favorite guitarrist I dont consider him a metal guitarrist
     
ST Thrash wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:02 pm / quote |
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote:

And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd

I think the I win was a bit of a joke. And it's not about being better, but about how good it feels to be number 1. and he deserves it. Some say he's overrated but he started the real fast shit. He taught kerry things like chromatics. Look at show no mercy. No chromatic riffs. Then kerry comes out of death and that's the next 20 years. But he can lead rythm sing pretty good.
     
Cafas wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:09 pm / quote |
He definitely has a unique rhythm style, whether we're talking metal or otherwise, but lists like that are bullshit for so many different reasons.

I think the I win was a bit of a joke. And it's not about being better, but about how good it feels to be number 1. and he deserves it. Some say he's overrated but he started the real fast shit. He taught kerry things like chromatics. Look at show no mercy. No chromatic riffs.


Um, without even trying, the main riff in The Antichrist has passing tones. I'm not sure if you actually know what the chromatic scale is or not, but I'd suggest you actually listen to the album before you say stuff like this.
     
sw1ss023 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:13 pm / quote |
Wow, dave seems like a good guy.
     
Rimfrost wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:13 pm / quote |
must be pretty cool to realize that some people consider you a better guitar player than John Petrruci
     
WillzKORN wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:13 pm / quote |
well deserved, he is a cock, but as a guitarist he is great in rhythm, solos and songwriting. personally i prefer john petrucci, but it sounds like a good list.
     
Rimfrost wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:15 pm / quote |
i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top
     
DSchmitty wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:15 pm / quote |
And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.
     
ThunderPX wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:15 pm / quote |
I had dinner recently with Dave and he said that [leaving the band] was the dumbest thing he ever did.


Oh hey, so the next time someone leaves, Ellefson can come back.
     
DSchmitty wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:17 pm / quote |
And another thing, the ONLY thing I can see why mustaine would even be mentioned in a top 100 guitar players list would be for rhythym playing, I mean the man can only play a could different keys in minor pentatonic, it's ****ing terrible and pathetic.

The list is top 100 GUITAR PLAYERS, not musicians, not song writers, which is mustaines only talent, this list is about PURE TECHNICAL SKILL ONLY, and that's something that mustaine lacks greatly.
     
Zangetsu 101 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:25 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.



Remember guys, Dave Mustaine ain't entitled to an opinion...
     
isabiggles wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:26 pm / quote |
Any particular reason he chose no.69? Something tells me that Dave hasn't quite lost all of his demons yet :p
     
 element4433   m   wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:27 pm / quote |
Checked.
     
AmzGuitarist wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:28 pm / quote |
he's good but not better than half of em
     
JuicyJuiceBox wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:29 pm / quote |
I wonder what criteria the author used when compiling this list. That's not a complaint, "best" is such a subjective term that I'd like to hear the reasoning in putting some guitarist before others.
     
Sewe Dae wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:33 pm / quote |
Mustaine really is a great guitarist but g*ddamn he's got a stick up his ass.
     
Sami Philadelph wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:35 pm / quote |
Lol@DCSchmitty...

You're entitled to an opinion,but I'm telling you right now,your opinions wrong.

As for the article,I enjoyed,it,already saw this book and the metallica books awhile back. Good stuff.
     
legato89 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:36 pm / quote |
He is not a better rhythm guitarist than Hetfield. Sorry, but he isn't. He is a better lead/solo guitarist than Hammett and Hetfield, but not rhythm. The fact that Hetfield can sing and play some really catchy and complex riffs without appearing all stiff and still like Mustaine is proof enough. Also, I find it kind of almost sad that because he was rated higher than his former bandmates in some book that is strictly opinion, "closure". I mean, Megadeths entire formation was to get back at Metallica.
     
moto_psycho wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:37 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.


you do realise that is the music that counts, francesco fareri is amazing, but ****ing shit to listen to. metallica aint the most technical band out there, but theres a reason they are the most popular.
     
Ribcage wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:40 pm / quote |
I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world.

The other two being?

Malcolm Young [of AC/DC] and myself.

LOL. Oh god, Mustaine is a egotistical dick. Hell of a player though.
     
BenjaminFields wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:41 pm / quote |
47 year old man child. It takes a pointless list to make him finally come to terms with the past? Who is this writer? Never heard of him, could care less how he sees the history of metal. I really think Mustaine is kinda pathetic.

If he has really come to terms with his Metallica past then why couldn't he show up at the induction ceremony? That would of certainly put it to rest.

I like how the end of the article mentions a link to Navarro's show where Mustaine is yapping about Metallica...again.
     
Sami Philadelph wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:41 pm / quote |
legato89 wrote:

He is not a better rhythm guitarist than Hetfield. Sorry, but he isn't. He is a better lead/solo guitarist than Hammett and Hetfield, but not rhythm. The fact that Hetfield can sing and play some really catchy and complex riffs without appearing all stiff and still like Mustaine is proof enough. Also, I find it kind of almost sad that because he was rated higher than his former bandmates in some book that is strictly opinion, "closure". I mean, Megadeths entire formation was to get back at Metallica.


LOL,Point me to these complex riffs Hetfield plays,I was in BEST BUY the other day and saw an 8 year old playing Battery,GIVE ME A BREAK...

I don't know man,technical ability isn't debatable,its FACT that Mustaine is by far technically more talented than Hetfield,even Hetfield (and Lars) have said this on numerous occasions,but,thats beside the point. Just listening is pretty obvious.

     
moto_psycho wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:41 pm / quote |
also, after reading that, it makes you realise how much of a dick dave really is, i personally think anyone that "finds" god must have something wrong with them. to be born into religion and have it drummed in all your life, fair dues, but to some how convert yourself with the complete lack of evidence available?

plus MAN!!! he speaks highly of his own ass. although id still kiss it
     
Set-Abominae wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:41 pm / quote |
Heminator89 wrote:

Dave Mustaine is better than JOHN PETRUCCI? What a ****ing joke!

Some people will never understand.

Michael Romeo > John Petrucci, by the way.
     
Soozy wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:43 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And another thing, the ONLY thing I can see why mustaine would even be mentioned in a top 100 guitar players list would be for rhythym playing, I mean the man can only play a could different keys in minor pentatonic, it's ****ing terrible and pathetic.

The list is top 100 GUITAR PLAYERS, not musicians, not song writers, which is mustaines only talent, this list is about PURE TECHNICAL SKILL ONLY, and that's something that mustaine lacks greatly.


Haven't read the book, but it mentions that there are people better than him in certain areas...I'm assuming one is technical skill. All things incorporated, he's the best all-around. Can't really argue that.

It really seems like his insecurities fueled him to excel in music
     
mtllica wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:47 pm / quote |
Rimfrost wrote:

i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top


I haven't been able to find the book, but I did hear that Chuck was placed at no. 10
     
deadstorm wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:48 pm / quote |
Well after the last couple of interviews he did lately, I definitely would rather meet this Dave than the 80' ******* Dave. Good job to Dave for finally growing at 47 years old!
     
the_hoodster wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:48 pm / quote |
RyanMetalMatthe wrote:

How the **** did Kirk get ahead of James? He shouldn't even be in the damn book.


I think he deserves a place in the book but I think James is better too!
     
Cerelil wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:49 pm / quote |
I actually saw that book a couple months ago.

I thumbed through it...when I saw Mustaine at number 1 and Paul Gilbert didn't get a mention at ALL, I was like..."Okay, something's wrong here."


Paul Gilbert wasn't eligible, it was only people who were focused in metal, So, guitarists like Satch and Vai missed out too. Paul Gilbert is more focused in pop/rock than metal, metal was just Racer X and a few solo things.
     
Im a Rattlehead wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:50 pm / quote |
He's a brilliant guitarist! My favourite infact!

He is the greatest guitarist and the reason is because he is great at every playing style! Sure Eddie Van Halen, Steve Vai, Satriani and Malmsteen are great guitarists, but they only focus on lead playing! Mustaine focuses on everything and gives his other guitarists(Chris Broderick at the moment) a chance to shine (e.g. Marty Friedman's Tornado of Souls solo) while he also focuses on his rhythm patterns!

He invented many great playing styles in which other players have taken on i.e. the spider-riff!

& just listen to his lead solos. Holy Wars, need I say more? An absolute killer of a solo!

I'm really happy that something like this has come out, because people will now research his material instead of thinking "Well he sounds like an arrogant ******* so he must suck!"

Mustaine for President!!!!
     
niel9802 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:50 pm / quote |
well done dave/1 he deserves to be no. 1. he is the father of thrash after all.
     
Waterboy799 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:50 pm / quote |
i didn't know Dave was religious...actually i thought he was quite the opposite.

well good for him i guess, at least he's made the effort in turning his life around for the better.
     
CliffIsAngry wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:51 pm / quote |
isabiggles wrote:

Any particular reason he chose no.69? Something tells me that Dave hasn't quite lost all of his demons yet :p
he's used to being rated as shit by magazines so I guess he just figured oh another list .

I'm glad for dave, he deserves this, imo he is an uncrowned king in metal. He's one of the biggest influences in metal.
     
CliffIsAngry wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:54 pm / quote |
ZeppelinruleZ wrote:

What a d-bag. I disliked him before, and this just solidified my feelings.
how is he a douche?
     
TheBodomBullet wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:56 pm / quote |
Rimfrost wrote:

i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top


He's the father of death metal and one of the best of all time. If he's not at least top 10 I'll be upset.
     
TheBodomBullet wrote on 08/27/2009 - 12:57 pm / quote |
That being said I wonder where Jeff Waters is placed?
     
Trickle7052 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:00 pm / quote |
ZeppelinruleZ wrote:

What a d-bag. I disliked him before, and this just solidified my feelings.

Yeah I agree i hated him to and now i hate him even more. Yes I am a big Metallica fan but both bands are overated. I listened to bands that can play circles around both of them but still Metallica Rules!!
     
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:00 pm / quote |
enginehead wrote:

IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote:

And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd

Like the recent Metal Hammer article on him pointed out, one can sense that there still is that feeling present with Dave, just not in a big way. Doesn't really bother me, it shows that this whole new forgoveness thing going on isn't sort of an act.

btw the metal hammer article was really good if ur a megadeth fan you'll like it


good point , i didnt meant to take away from dave, he is a very good guitarist, i will have to take a look at the interview, thanks for the recomendation.

everyone needs to stop fighting about whose better there is no one list that EVERYONE will agree with.
     
 nightraven   m   wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:00 pm / quote |
checked
     
Limaj_daas wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:02 pm / quote |
I liked the interview, made me laugh, though Dave's tone is still very cocky.

mtllica wrote:

Rimfrost wrote:

i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top

I haven't been able to find the book, but I did hear that Chuck was placed at no. 10


http://www.emptywords.org/JawbonePress01-2009. htm

That's the entry, and a well deserved one. Though honestly, I wouldn't have minded if he was higher, but that's just me.
     
Davyboy420 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:06 pm / quote |
Dave Mustaine is ****in awesome
his interviews are always so funny
     
oncetaken wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:15 pm / quote |
Wow. He comes across as a huge douche.
     
carlos1536 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:16 pm / quote |
i cant believe dave isnt in the rock n roll hall of fame yet... i mean cmon metallica's in there! hes the reason metallica started good with kill em all and ride the lightning! dave shuld b inducted! and good 4 dave 4 not showin up 2 look like a fool while metallica plays there.
     
MetalManic 666 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:19 pm / quote |
"All I thought was... I win!" AWESOME LINE

MEGADAVE FTW
     
OfficialPressSt wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:22 pm / quote |
Megadeth? How about Megadouche? He violated the only rule I can think of when it comes to being a great guitarist: NEVER consider yourself one. You think Hendrix was sitting at home dipping the bong going "I'm the best there ever was!"? Yeah, Dave has great skill, and while I'm not a fan, I respect Megadeth for what they've accomplished. However, it seems after 100 rehab stints, they still haven't fixed his douchiness.
     
Religulous wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:23 pm / quote |
Seems like he's settled down... One thing that might not be corrupt about religion?

Go Dave.
     
jordan93 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:24 pm / quote |
i like megadeth more then metallica so im glad he surpassed them. marty friedman could kick kurts ass!
     
Linchy wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:29 pm / quote |
He is a fantastic guitarist, and its great to see him acknowledge Hetfield's fantastic rhythm playing (IMO Hetfield > Hammett) but really, he shouldn't have been number 1. I think Randy Rhoads should be number 1, and its great to see Petrucci being number 2 also.

Either way, nice to see Dave is trying and actually is moving on, and he has grown up. Props to the man, and I hope the new album is good and I wish him success.
     
TheMartyr559 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:34 pm / quote |
Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...
     
TDAJGuitarist wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:34 pm / quote |
If he is number one and Heitfield is even mentioned then that list is BS
     
TDAJGuitarist wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:35 pm / quote |
TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...


HAHAHAHAHA! Very true
     
hak_hap wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:37 pm / quote |
TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...


hilarious and true, man...Im laughing so bad, thats my sentence of the week...
     
MetalUpYourRear wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:37 pm / quote |
legato89 wrote:

He is not a better rhythm guitarist than Hetfield. Sorry, but he isn't. He is a better lead/solo guitarist than Hammett and Hetfield, but not rhythm. The fact that Hetfield can sing and play some really catchy and complex riffs without appearing all stiff and still like Mustaine is proof enough. Also, I find it kind of almost sad that because he was rated higher than his former bandmates in some book that is strictly opinion, "closure". I mean, Megadeths entire formation was to get back at Metallica.


Dude... No. Go listen to "Take No Prisoners" and come beck to apologize.
     
surgikal wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:37 pm / quote |
TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...


Quite true...this is a complete joke for him to be no 1...every time ive seen him he has played sloppy and ****ed something up...a joke
     
slypoonce wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:40 pm / quote |
Right-Wing Dick wrote:

Leaves one kind of drug for another (religion).


haha, you got it my friend.
     
TDAJGuitarist wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:43 pm / quote |
Jeff Loomis anybody?
Marty Friedman?
John Petrucchi?
Yngwie Malmsteen?
Chris Broderick?
and thousands of others who are about a million times better then Dave Mustane...If you think Heitfield and Mustane deserve to even be in the top 50 then you probably also think Kurt Cobain should be on this list...In other words...Your a poser
     
Jehuty wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:46 pm / quote |
I think he still has a lot to learn. I do think he still has some things he cannot put to rest. I like his music you know, but these lists hold no value at all.
     
Stingray5 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:47 pm / quote |
That book sounds like a joke. Like the author has never even picked up a guitar.
     
jetfuel495 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:48 pm / quote |
TDAJGuitarist wrote:

Jeff Loomis anybody?
Marty Friedman?
John Petrucchi?
Yngwie Malmsteen?
Chris Broderick?
and thousands of others who are about a million times better then Dave Mustane...If you think Heitfield and Mustane deserve to even be in the top 50 then you probably also think Kurt Cobain should be on this list...In other words...Your a poser
lololololol

Better is a relative measure. Sure, those guys could shred circles around DAVE, but I haven't heard any of them write riffs that are as good, and none of them sing while playing either.

And, I LOVE DAVE.

That is all.
     
alternatum wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:50 pm / quote |
I think Dave earned #1 but I saw this book and didn't see Randy Rhoads ANYWHERE, I could've just missed him but he should have been in the top 3
     
deafening wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:53 pm / quote |
Right-Wing Dick wrote:

Leaves one kind of drug for another (religion).


lmao AMEN
     
Limaj_daas wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:53 pm / quote |
alternatum wrote:

I think Dave earned #1 but I saw this book and didn't see Randy Rhoads ANYWHERE, I could've just missed him but he should have been in the top 3


yeah the author considered him a Hard Rock guitarist instead of metal, check out the interview on UG, there was quite a debate in the comments.
     
PcaKes wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:56 pm / quote |
Yeah Iommi should be #1. Also, is it just me or is Dave really preachy in this?
     
Guano23 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 01:59 pm / quote |
I hate these top ten guitarists or what ever. Its all opinions based on the author. The list would be different with any other author. While Dave is a great guitarist there are plenty others out there jsut as good skill wise. Hell there people that arent in bands that would blow helf the people on the list out of the water.
     
Menza_ wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:02 pm / quote |
I read that book.
alternatum wrote:

I think Dave earned #1 but I saw this book and didn't see Randy Rhoads ANYWHERE, I could've just missed him but he should have been in the top 3

If you look in the appendix it shows a list of top Rock guitarists. and outrageous shredders and stuff.
     
ktulu51 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:02 pm / quote |
I am a huge Megadeth fan. I've loved them for years. But I still don't think Dave should have been #1. Top 10 definitely. And ahead of Kirk and James no matter what. Also I want to point out that the fact that Dave isn't in the Hall of Fame is complete bull. He wrote many of the early riffs that made Metallica famous. Without Dave they would not have made it anywhere close to where they have.
     
..NEM.. wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:03 pm / quote |
jetfuel495 wrote:

TDAJGuitarist wrote:

Jeff Loomis anybody?
Marty Friedman?
John Petrucchi?
Yngwie Malmsteen?
Chris Broderick?
and thousands of others who are about a million times better then Dave Mustane...If you think Heitfield and Mustane deserve to even be in the top 50 then you probably also think Kurt Cobain should be on this list...In other words...Your a poser
lololololol

Better is a relative measure. Sure, those guys could shred circles around DAVE, but I haven't heard any of them write riffs that are as good, and none of them sing while playing either.

And, I LOVE DAVE.

That is all.

This is not about who can sing while playing guitar, it's about how good you play guitar. Also good riffs are also subjective, so what's your point?
     
deafening wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:05 pm / quote |
also sorry for the double post, got ahead of myself, but mustaine is not the best guitarist technically or melodically in my opinion.
     
livewire76 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:09 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.


Well you were right about getting flamed, but wrong about the reason. Malcolm Young and James Hetfiled are over-rated? Reeeeaaaallly! That's a good one. Got any more "insights"? They might be getting old now but they both were pinoeers of guitar in theyre own ways and have influenced millions. Wouldnt surprise me if youre picks would list them as inspiration. Over-rated.. LOL
     
SumFX wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:11 pm / quote |
What has he done to be hated so much?
He seems really cool from what i have read in this interview.
Metal heads stop being douchebags! just cuz you think his lead playing is limited doesn't mean he is terrible! soloing isn't everything! He deserves that spot i would rather listen to Megadeth than most other Thrash Metal bands.
     
metallica4life_ wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:15 pm / quote |
born-again christians... religion sucks... and Mustaine is a great guitar player, but certainly not number 1, and he is a piece of shit as a human being... in one single interview, he talked shit about Kerry King, James Hetfield, Kirk Hammett, Lars Ulrich and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame...
     
Sanitarium91 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:16 pm / quote |
Set-Abominae wrote:

Heminator89 wrote:

Dave Mustaine is better than JOHN PETRUCCI? What a ****ing joke!
Some people will never understand.

Michael Romeo > John Petrucci, by the way.
I know. As a lead player, Dave isn't that great and even though he's a great rhythm player, there's plenty of better ones out there.
     
jetfuel495 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:18 pm / quote |
..NEM.. wrote:
This is not about who can sing while playing guitar, it's about how good you play guitar. Also good riffs are also subjective, so what's your point?
The whole topic is subjective >.>

Personally I don't think he's the greatest guitarist of metal, but hell, I still wish I could riff like that.
     
visiofx wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:20 pm / quote |
mustaine has surpassed hetfield in my opinion...hetfield was the best in the late 80's to the early 90's but mustaine keeps getting better and better as time goes by, he stayed consistent and truly mastered his craft...he truly deserved the greatest metal guitarist...not often you find a great metal rhythm player, vocalist and lead guitarist rolled into one.and Dimebag shouldve been #2! Petrucci? that guys a robot
     
 ZeGuitarist   m   wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:21 pm / quote |
Checked.
     
-LAW- wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:21 pm / quote |
To me it kind of sucks that he ended up turning to religion - but no offence to religious people, because it's a free world right?

But Mustaine really is the best. I'm chuffed for him. Can't help but think about the crap that has lead up to this point in his life without smiling.. retribution huh? Divine perhaps? (I joke! mwah!)
     
LD_Luke D wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:22 pm / quote |
iommi invented metal guitar

as soon as freidman left 'deth, they went downhill.

defineteley underrated, but not number one
     
Carvin-on-Bass wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:22 pm / quote |
Hes not even close to no.1....
     
visiofx wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:23 pm / quote |
cocky but cool

dgard wrote:

**** dave mustaine he's a cocky *****
     
Dynamight wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:23 pm / quote |
Even if the list were about metal riffs and song structures alone, I would agree that Dave Mustaine is one of the most influential metal guitarists. It's hard to include lead guitarists in such a list, because most lead styles used in metal aren't exclusive to it, especially the pentatonic and blues based. However, even if he's not a highly versatile lead guitarist like Marty Friedman or Jason Becker, he certainly holds his own, especially next to Metallica and the rest of the Big Four. Combine all that with his arguably unique vocal style and consider that he directly influenced several highly successful bands, and you have someone who deserves to get a high spot on that list by any unbiased standards.
     
LD_Luke D wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:23 pm / quote |
dimebag > Petrucci

petrucci is fast and accurate, but sacrifices taste
     
protesthehero wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:24 pm / quote |
dave=god
     
protesthehero wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:24 pm / quote |
dimebag shouldve been first or second
     
Vendim wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:28 pm / quote |
hmm, I think there are much better metal guitar players than Dave Mustaine....
But let him be happy.
     
ProgMetalDT wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:29 pm / quote |
Petrucci should be number 1. No doubt about it, he completely owns the crap out of anyone else. That's just my opinion, sorry if you don't agree.
     
Life Is Brutal wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:32 pm / quote |
Set-Abominae wrote:

Heminator89 wrote:

Dave Mustaine is better than JOHN PETRUCCI? What a ****ing joke!

Some people will never understand.

Michael Romeo > John Petrucci, by the way.

Both Great guitarists, But michael Romeo is awesome.

I'm starting to hate lists that involve greatest, or best on a general level. There should be a list for like best Alternate picker, Sweeper, ECT. I've never seen a list like that before.
     
duzit89 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:34 pm / quote |
[quote]BenjaminFields wrote:

If he has really come to terms with his Metallica past then why couldn't he show up at the induction ceremony? That would of certainly put it to rest.
[quote]

he had a show the same night... whut is he guna do... screw his fans just to watch metallica get in the hall of fame? what would YOU rather do?.. i'd rather play a kickass show for my fans instead of watching a few sellouts get celebrated in the hall of fame thats for sure
     
NorCalLos wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:36 pm / quote |
Anyone watch the video? That was funny.
     
SlyDevil13 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:37 pm / quote |
wtf, dave is good, but not better than petrucci. one guys book's opinion doesnt make him right, but neither is my opinion
     
Shinsen88 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:40 pm / quote |
Very cool interview. I've got some new respect for this guy.
     
Lchoke wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:40 pm / quote |
Dave mustaine tho a excelent guitarist is an arrogant guy...not a fan and u sing like a chick
     
NathanWolff wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:47 pm / quote |
Insert witty biased voiced opinion here.
     
shotgunjoe wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:52 pm / quote |
This guy is laughable.
     
FearOfTheDuck wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:53 pm / quote |
He deserves to be number one!

Even if he is ginger and christian, he rules!
     
DeadlyDevil1985 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:54 pm / quote |
Dave #1? What the ****
     
\m/(-_-)\m/ wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:59 pm / quote |
Sewe Dae wrote:

Mustaine really is a great guitarist but g*ddamn he's got a stick up his ass.


I'm pretty sure he's just joking around. Like, he's being arrogant on purpose, and he knows it.
     
\m/(-_-)\m/ wrote on 08/27/2009 - 02:59 pm / quote |
FearOfTheDuck wrote:

He deserves to be number one!

Even if he is ginger and christian, he rules!


Urm... He has blonde hair, not red.
     
Jøhnny wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:09 pm / quote |
I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world.

The other two being?

Malcolm Young [of AC/DC] and myself.

I lol'd here

And btw...
he'll have Jägermeister and I'll have water.

Dave isn't drinking any alcohol anymore?
     
mrcool2288 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:10 pm / quote |
Paul Waggoner anyone?
     
Black Ox wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:14 pm / quote |
I like Megadeth,but I think Mustaine makes too much of a deal about getting rated over James and Kirk. I mean,he's still not over Metallica even after creating an excellent band.
     
Death 0tter wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:22 pm / quote |
Dave Mustaine is my hero
     
TheMysticBard wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:31 pm / quote |
Mustain is kine of.... cocky.
     
Archieisted wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:37 pm / quote |
god sake dave is such a ****, megadeth are great but come on.
winning against metallica? all that shows is he still wishes he was with them.
Have u guys never noticed? Slayers fault he did nothing
metallica's fault he did nothing

****ing dave its never your fault
megadeth and metallica rule but dave is a shit
     
bass-man9712 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:38 pm / quote |
omg hes STILL not over Metallica? im not denying that he's a good guitarist but forget about it already, you have your own band now. and to Johnny no he doesnt because he was a serious alcoholic before which is what got him kicked out of Metallica
     
DonJulio wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:40 pm / quote |
i dont know he sounds arrogant in this... all that "i'm the best" talk and all. and that row with kirk and james... i mean he says hes 47, a different person and happy with his life and all, so why can't he get over that kindergarten stuff for gods sake?!
     
blommen wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:43 pm / quote |
dave deserved this one IMO, if not him then dime. read the book and while it has some flaws (Kirk hammet, Matt Heafy, and Tom Morello) i think its a really good and well thought list. you can of course never please everyone with these kind of things but mciver does a great job of implementing different guitarists from different parts of the metal genres, and offers some pretty good insight on most of them. when people say that dave isn't the greatest guitarist because of his lack of technicality, they are missing a point, in the way that this is not a shred list, its a metal list. about who has been the most revolutionising, consistent, and influential guitarist, and combines it with technical skill, both in the department of lead and of rythm, and that is what Dave does in McIvers oppinion.
     
lostprophet20 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:44 pm / quote |
DAVE MUSTAINE IS THA BEST
     
Lrn2play wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:45 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.


Good job not taking in any information. He got no1 because of the variety in his talents, not to be compared to an individual lead or rhythm guitarist.
Malcolm Young is the most UNDERrated guitarist probably of all time. He came up with all the memorable riffs ACDC is known for, but Angus Y. gets all the guitar attention. But I do agree about Friedman, otherwise everything else you said is complete bullshit.
     
johnnybj wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:46 pm / quote |
lists don't mean shit. i find it amusing that he took it so seriously.
     
homair wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:54 pm / quote |
scawti wrote:

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?
There's a difference in taking pride in coming in on top and struggling with demons.
He'll have to deal with the rest of his life with questions about Metallica - and Lars seems to like taking jabs at him. It was gloating, but respectful gloating.


Yeah cause Dave has never enjoyed taking jabs at Lars. Yeah I've seen Lars make the occasional jab at Dave but more often than not he's always had good things to say. Dave has always been the one making jabs and he always contradicts himself. One moment he's like ''I forgive everyone'' then he's like ''I banged Kirk's girlfriend oh yeah!'' then ''I'm such a forgiving person now''
     
Lrn2play wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:54 pm / quote |
Every comment on this page shows why metal is dumb genre.

Ready...set...
AND FLAME!
     
lopezmetalmunky wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:56 pm / quote |
Mehhhh. I'm not sure about Mustaine. He contradicted himself quite a bit, especially on the Metallica things. I think he still has some hard, unresolved issues with the band that he needs to sort out.
     
BenjaminFields wrote on 08/27/2009 - 03:56 pm / quote |
duzit89 wrote:

[quote]BenjaminFields wrote:

If he has really come to terms with his Metallica past then why couldn't he show up at the induction ceremony? That would of certainly put it to rest.
[quote]

he had a show the same night... whut is he guna do... screw his fans just to watch metallica get in the hall of fame? what would YOU rather do?.. i'd rather play a kickass show for my fans instead of watching a few sellouts get celebrated in the hall of fame thats for sure


He obviously thought it over. It's stated in the interview.

MUSTAINE=FAIL=duzit89
     
BaseballFury wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:04 pm / quote |
You know, I'm so glad to hear Dave Mustaine has finally "released the demons" he had once endured. There was a whole lot of animosity among Metallica and himself...we all know how it went...but he's really understood that at his age and frame-of-mind there is no time to waist on bullshit childish skiffs of the past. Overall, he deserves to be recognized and put in the spot light, I mean the man is so influential!
     
sXe170 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:13 pm / quote |
Dave Mustaine is sooo overrated. He is not the father/king/creator of Thrash. He played speed metal for the majority of his career. Gary Hohlt of Exodus should be ahead of him, he can write alot better riffs and solo all over Mustaine. Listen to ANY Exodus record and you'll see how much of a god Hohlt is.
     
Ninjabunnies wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:16 pm / quote |
I read this book. The section describing the Number 1 as the man from Megadeth was a bit funny. The author wrote about how much people would slam him down for putting him as #1, but he wanted to put him here because of how he changed the face of metal.

What he wrote. not me
     
 Scourge441   m   wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:19 pm / quote |
Checked.
     
shreddykrueger wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:31 pm / quote |
I was THE biggest Megadeth fan for years. I was lucky enough to meet them on The World Needs A Hero tour. Them and Metallica were tied at my personal favorites, regardless of their hatred for each other, I loved them equally. Then I gravitated more towards 'Deth after awhile because they just struck a chord with me and I connected with them a lot more than any other band. However, I'm not exactly certain why, I personally don't have the same feeling I used to. I believe in 'to each their own' so I don't care if he found "God" or whatever, but he really does seem somewhat preachy here, and I certainly feel the Metallica/Megadeth feud is just boring, redundant and childish at this point. It's old news to be quite frank. I always thought Mustaine was my favorite guitarist, but in the past year, to year and a half, I gravitated towards more death metal, such as Death, Cynic, Disincarnate, Obituary, Atheist, and a lot of other bands like those and in recent months I find myself liking James Murphy or Paul Masvidal over Dave and any of the other guitarists that was in the band, as well as Chuck Schuldiner for sure. I think people like those guys deserve more credibility and recognition than Dave and his religious views and ongoing spite for Metallica. I don't agree that those 3 guitarists are the best rhythm guitarists in the world, albeit they are incredible, there are people who dominate what they do. Get any one of those guys to play some Death or something...I can't see them doing it. Chuck played rhythm, lead, and sand while having a great side guitarist at the same time, give credit where it's due. Sorry Dave, used to worship you, but suddenly I can't relate with your view on things anymore. Best of luck to you though, once a musician is "satisfied" or "happy" I find that their inspiration and creativity lags tremendously.
     
cukd7x-a2- wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:40 pm / quote |
^people progress and grow out of things, its perfectly understandable

and its good to see Dave finally got some proper recognition, i\even if it may be a bit more than it would seem it should be, but hey hes finally got something of his own
     
metalonastrat wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:54 pm / quote |
where the bloody hell is jeff loomis? loomis > mustaine. a lot >.
     
cpopken wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:55 pm / quote |
jordan93 wrote:

i like megadeth more then metallica so im glad he surpassed them. marty friedman could kick kurts ass!


Kurt who? Cobain? I don't think he is a metal guitarist.
     
chucknorris69 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 04:59 pm / quote |
Everyone is so bitter about this, its hilarious. "dave is shitty." well how many million albums have you sold?
"If I made the list it would be better" because your opinion is now conclusive fact. lulz
     
FretboardToAsh wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:00 pm / quote |
Well at least he's a happy person, I couldn't give a damn about any list.
     
str84ever wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:03 pm / quote |
TDAJGuitarist wrote:

Jeff Loomis anybody?
Marty Friedman?
John Petrucchi?
Yngwie Malmsteen?
Chris Broderick?
and thousands of others who are about a million times better then Dave Mustane...If you think Heitfield and Mustane deserve to even be in the top 50 then you probably also think Kurt Cobain should be on this list...In other words...Your a poser


Welcome to the mass media. The industry that caters to what you want to hear.

You honestly think they are gonna name some guitarist no one knows or gives a shit about?

That doesn't sell. Also why are people slagging Mustaine about this? He didn't ask to be made number 1.

/facepalm at you people.
     
Megadethfan123 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:08 pm / quote |
im getting my lithograph pic of endgame signed by all four members :O and the endgame album as well! soo good to hear from Dave. Wish the best for him
     
haz_uk wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:10 pm / quote |
he's a good player, but you can still feel the bitter undertones in his words. he tries to come across as the more intelligent one, taking the moral high ground and embracing his inner-child.

get a grip of yourself mate, you're still a bitter, petty (and ginger) 23 year old crying inside because you got kicked out of a better band.
     
Megadethfan123 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:13 pm / quote |
nz_sam wrote:

Dimebag Darrell anyone?


Agree; but a lot of people think otherwise as of him being overrated and all :s
     
espChris93 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:15 pm / quote |
Wow as much as i adore Dave's playing he is not even close to being number 1 in the world, i mean marty freidman? Muhammed Suicmez? Jeff Loomis? Paul Gilbert? Guthrie Govan? Shawn Lane? anyone????
     
blindfatkid23 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:15 pm / quote |
I'm happy for him, but he's gotta work on that huge ego.
     
Waff wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:18 pm / quote |
Dave! Good for you!!!!
     
AtomicPunk7 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:23 pm / quote |
Who else but Dave?
     
Vypor wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:26 pm / quote |
Yeah.. lame.. Mustaines better than I am but not good enough to deserve number 1.....

Sorry, i agree with him on this - he should of been like, #69
     
sucubus wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:41 pm / quote |
Mr Petrucci will not be happy, and will go in2 bear mode and destroy mustaine, and rape his soul in the process....
tht said, im not complaining, fed up of seeing dimebag at the top of the list all the time (not tht i have anything against him), so well done mustaine
     
Shabalaba wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:45 pm / quote |
He still has issues with everything he said, he came across as bitter about it all still. For the main it's understandable why he is but why he denies it is beyond me.
     
the_burning_one wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:48 pm / quote |
eh... well i like megadeth, but all in all, tastewise and in technical ability, id say hes somewhere in the high twenties.

and secondly, im sorry to anyone who has heard me bash dime once and a while. i listened to a load of pantera over the weekend and he delivered the tastiest solos ive almost ever heard.
     
2mins2midnite wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:53 pm / quote |
And as my career nears its end, it's finishing at the top.


I don't want dave's career to end :'(
     
Myke. wrote on 08/27/2009 - 05:57 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.


Oh that's TOTALLY the logic.
Because scales make a guitarist good??
NO.
Anyone can heartlessly play the same stupid scales over and over.
*COUGH* DRAGONFORCE *COUGH*
     
MetallicaPwn3dU wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:10 pm / quote |
All I thought was… I win!

HAHAHA I LOL'D
but yes...he's right he does win above every guitarist lol : )
     
TheJCLK83 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:10 pm / quote |
Sami Philadelph said: LOL,Point me to these complex riffs Hetfield plays,I was in BEST BUY the other day and saw an 8 year old playing Battery,GIVE ME A BREAK...

I don't know man,technical ability isn't debatable,its FACT that Mustaine is by far technically more talented than Hetfield,even Hetfield (and Lars) have said this on numerous occasions,but,thats beside the point. Just listening is pretty obvious.

I don't know who you are but considering you just said you saw someone at Best Buy playing guitar add to that an 8 y/o playing Battery I doubt that it was a real guitar and more along the lines of Guitar Hero. If you have to go to Best Buy to justify the technicality of a guitarist you obviously don't know what you're talking about.

Anyway I enjoyed the article I love Megadeth as well as Metallica but i do hate all the fights that show up everywhere b/t them like really get a life even Dave has said its all behind him. Be glad we got two amazing bands out of it with some amazing contributions to something we all love. Best of luck to Mustaine I'm glad he is feeling well and can't wait for the "Endgame".
     
shwilly wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:15 pm / quote |
He deserves more recognition than he's getting but GOD Dave, why do you even give a f*ck about these lameass lists, even if they are comprehensive and all that.

If you want to dissect or even compare all that guitar badassery, that's great, good for you, but assigning a number to those people makes these lists so unnecesarily lame because you know it'll make people focus on stuff like "Kirk being to high" or "whatever happened to (...George Lynch?)"
     
Tapping_Ninja wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:16 pm / quote |
mrcool2288 wrote:

Paul Waggoner anyone?


He's aweosme, but I wouldn't put him infront of Dave either... Because when he started there were not players like him.... I mean sure you had players who played fast like that, but non where quite like Dave... Paul owes a lot to Dave, Marty, and Chris Poland (come to think of it Paul reminds me of Chris a lot... any ways just a side note... Second to the guy who called Dave and Hammett ****ing terrible should be ashemed to call himself a guitar player... All though I'll amitt some of metallicas later stuff did suck (but not every song can be a winner).

But it's nice to hear someone in #1 who isn't Vai, Satch, Pertucci, and Yngwie... Because they are all overrated... well At least Pertucci and Yngwie...
     
Drift king77 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:27 pm / quote |
I think the fact that Dave is a christian is a very admirable thing, this still doesn't win me over because i still think he's a dick. He contradicts himself so much in the article its not funny. Then he goes on to point out that he is a better guitarist than Petrucci? What the **** dave, i mean your a great guitarist, yeh, but very few people can measure up the the likes of Dream Theater. One last thing, James Hetfeild is and will always be a better rythym guitarist than Mustaine, no matter what anyone says.
     
David_Bowie=GOD wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:31 pm / quote |
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote:

And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd


They probably don't bother him now than he's beaten them.
     
jrcsgtpeppers wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:31 pm / quote |
wow he isn't even that great of a guitarist. Buckethead should be number 1.
     
snakesson wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:34 pm / quote |

1 Dave Mustaine (Megadeth, MD.45)
2 John Petrucci (Dream Theater)
3 Jeff Waters (Annihilator)
4 Zakk Wylde (Black Label Society, Ozzy Osbourne)
5 Dimebag (Pantera)
6 Tony Iomi (Black Sabbath)
7 Trey Azagthoth (Morbid Angel)
8 James Hetfield (Metallica)
9 Mikael Akerfeldt (Opeth)
10 Chuck Schuldiner (Death, Voodoocult)
11 Fredrik Thordendal (Meshuggah)
12 Pat Obrien (Cannibal Corpse)
13 Alex Skolnick (Testament)
14 Ralph Santolla (Deicide, Eyewitness, Death, Millennium, Iced Earth)
15 Kirk Hammett (Metallica)
16 Tom Morello (Rage Against The Machine, Audioslave)
17 Ihsahn ( Vegard Sverre Tveitan) (Emperor, Embryonic, Thou Shalt Suffer)
18 Kerry King (Slayer)
19 Mick Thomson (Slipknot)
20 Herman Li (Dragonforce)
21 Alex Laiho (Children Of Bodom)
22 Jeff Hanneman (Slayer)
23 Phil Demmel (Machine Head)
24 Samoth (Tomas Haugen) (Emperor, Zyklon)
25 Glen Tipton (Judas Priest)
26 Marty Friedman (Solo, Megadeth)
27 James Murphy (Death, Testament)
28 Michael Amott (Arch Enemy, Spiritual Beggers)
29 K.K Downing (Judas Priest)
30 Marten Hagstrom (Meshuggah)
31 Alex Auburn (Cryptopsy)
32 Ron Jarzombek (Watchtower, Spastic Ink)
33 Christopher Amott (Arch Enemy, Armageddon)
34 Bjorn Gelotte (In Flames)
35 Erik Rutan (Morbid Angel, Ripping Corpse)
36 Eric Peterson (Testament)
37 Rudolf Schenker (The Scorpions)
38 Jeff Loomis (Nevermore
39 Fredrik Akesson (Opeth, Krux)
40 Andres Bjorler (The Haunted)
41 Adrian Smith (Iron Maiden)
42 Michael Schenker (Scorpions, UFO, Michael Schenker group)
43 Dino Cazares (Fear Factory, Divine Heresy)
44 Waclaw 'Vogg' Kieltyka (Decapitated, Lux Occulta)
45 Jensen (Patrik Jensen) (The Haunted)
46 Rob Barrett (Cannibal Corpse, Malevolent Creation)
47 Dave Murray (Iron Maiden)
48 Kai Hansen (Helloween, Gamma Ray)
49 Andreas Kisser (Sepultura)
50 Devin Townsend (Strapping Young Lad)
51 James Root (Slipknot, Stone Sour)
52 Karl Sanders (Nile)
53 Corey Beaulieu (Trivium)
54 Matt Bachand (Shadows Fall)
55 Gary Holt (Exodus)
56 Rand Burkey (Atheist)
57 Mille Petrozza (Kreator)
58 Scott Ian (Anthrax)
59 Timo Tolkki (Stratovarius)
60 Andy La Rocque (King Diamond)
61 Martin Larsson (House Of Usher, At The Gates)
62 Chris Degarmo (Queensryche)
63 Niklas Sundin (Dark Tranquility)
64 Andre Olbrich (Blind Guardian)
65 Jon Schaffer (Iced Earth)
66 Synyster Gates ( Brian Haner JR.) (Avenged Sevenfold)
67 Matt Heafy (Trivium)
68 Piotr Wiwczarek (Vader)
69 Dallas Toler-Wade (Nile)
70 Jason Mendonca (Akercocke)
71 Jesse Pintado (Terrorizer, Morbid Angel)
72 Marc Rizzo (Soulfly, Ill Nino)
73 Zacky Vengeance (Zachary Baker) (Avenged Sevenfold)
74 Jack Owen (Cannibal Corpse, Adrift)
75 Sam Totman (Dragonforce)
76 Matt Tuck (Bullet For My Valentine)
77 Matthias Jabs (Scorpions)
78 Kirk Windstein (Crowbar, Down, Kingdom Of Sorrow)
79 Thomas Fischer (Hellhammer)
80 Janick Gers (Iron Maiden)
81 Dan Spitz (Anthrax)
82 Chris Poland (Megadeth, Damn the Machine)
83 Dave Suzuki (Vital Remains, Deicide)
84 Michael Weikath (Helloween)
85 Max Cavalera (Sepultura, Soulfly)
86 'Fast' Eddie Clarke (Fastway, Motorhead)
87 Michael Denner (Mercyful Fate, King Diamond)
88 Stefan Elmgren (Hammerfall)
89 Galder (Thomas Rune Andersen) (Old Man's Child, Dimmu Borgir)
90 Paul Allender (Cradle Of Filth)
91 Paul Masvidal (Cynic)
92 Mantas (Jeff Dunn) (Venom)
93 Robb Flynn (Machine Head)
94 Dan Swano (Solo, Various Artists)
95 Joe Duplantier (Gojira)
96 Michael Romeo (Symphony X)
97 Jim Martin (EZ Street, Faith No More)
98 Matt Wilcock (Akercocke, The Berzerker)
99 Peter Lindgren (Opeth)
100 Euronymous (Oystein Arseth) (Mayhem)

here is the complete list, but the thing about the list is very disturbing, there are no guitar gods such as: Muhammed Suicmez (Necrophagist), Nergal (Behemoth), any of Suffocation's guitarists, etc, well at least those I can name off the top of my head, enjoy ^^
     
CoreysMonster wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:36 pm / quote |
*facepalm* god I hate all these people sucking mustaines dick. for crying out loud, the guy is 47 and STILL pissed about being kicked out of a band and crying about how so many people hate him. He said in the Some Kind of Monster DVD to Lars "people hate me because of you", and for a while I believed it, but the more I hear about this guy the more I think people hate him because he's a douche.
For god's sake, move on, dude! You're 47 and STILL MAD about something that happened in the 80's.
For him to be all "yeah, I'm better than them! woohoo!" in the interview shows how insecure he still is about himself and his status. If Petrucci sees the list and sees "oh hey, some dude thought I was the second best guitarist in the world" I doubt he'd give a crap, tbh.
God I hate when musicians get so full of themselves. It's MUSIC, it's supposed to be fun, theraputic or whatever, but not this hate war I always read about as soon as Mustaine comes in the picture.
     
Chris_09 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:36 pm / quote |
[quote]LOL,Point me to these complex riffs Hetfield plays,I was in BEST BUY the other day and saw an 8 year old playing Battery,GIVE ME A BREAK...

I don't know man,technical ability isn't debatable,its FACT that Mustaine is by far [quote]

Guitar hero doesnt count. number 1 and 2 i've seen some kids that are animals with a guitar. kids are crazy these days we just need to guide them to the dark side \m/
     
CoreysMonster wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:38 pm / quote |
Oh, but the guy who made the list gets credit for listing the dudes from Meshuggah, they're waaay underrated. but seriously, Zakk Wylde up that high? He so terrible even Ozzy doesn't want him anymore.
     
WheredMyRockGo? wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:41 pm / quote |
moto_psycho wrote:

also, after reading that, it makes you realise how much of a dick dave really is, i personally think anyone that "finds" god must have something wrong with them. to be born into religion and have it drummed in all your life, fair dues, but to some how convert yourself with the complete lack of evidence available?

plus MAN!!! he speaks highly of his own ass. although id still kiss it


Yeah i agree, you never see any normal people suddenly find religion. And i always hate when athletes or people that win awards for something continually thank god for the opportunity. Keep it to yourself.
     
TatarSalad2 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:45 pm / quote |
This made him seem really irrogant in my opinion.

I can't believe Zakk is number four. He should be like, number 69. But it's good to see that Bjorn Gelotte is on here. It makes me mad as well to see Herman Lee's name above Alexi Laiho's.
     
TatarSalad2 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:46 pm / quote |
Also, is Paul Gilbert even on here?!
     
wookiefoot wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:52 pm / quote |
i like how people mention dave can sing and play at the same time, doesn't he just talk like 80% of the time?

...and petrucci is better
     
trashbeast wrote on 08/27/2009 - 06:53 pm / quote |
Synester gates? Higher then chris poland?
     
jimishred wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:01 pm / quote |
alexi is lower that herman li WTF! anyway great to see dave up thier as well as angus he bloody awesome but hey weres dime?
     
SumFX wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:03 pm / quote |
wtf is Matt Tuck & that twat from Avenged Sevenfold Doing On There?
Mustaine is cool, i would rather listen to Megadeth than Metallica.
And why are you saying he's still bitter about Metallica? he has moved on can't any of you understand that!
     
jimishred wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:05 pm / quote |
WHAT nergal is up thier he should be a least in the top 10!!
     
Ead wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:09 pm / quote |
I don't know why someone as experienced as Dave would really put much faith in a list. lists are always garbage. I'm sure it'd be hard not to let being named number one go to your head a little bit, but come on, its just another list. I would shrug it off.
     
kerguitar08 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:10 pm / quote |
Lol Joel McIver should be arrested for giving Dave Mustaine an unnecessary ego boost. And Dave Mustaine should seriously be banned from mentioning Metallica in any interview he does from now on because it's getting very very old...
     
Ead wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:12 pm / quote |
and why the hell is Chuck Schuldiner listed only as Death and Voodoo Cult?? far as I know, he only recorded one song with Voodoo Cult or something like that. these guys never heard of Control Denied?
     
kud666 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:13 pm / quote |
i disagree with quite a lot of that top 100 ( prob the same as many of you lot) but im sorry how the hell is herman li better that marty friedman,alexi laiho,all the iron maiden guitarists, both judas priest guitarists, the schenker brothers and about 30 others?
     
Talonwolf wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:14 pm / quote |
That list is ****ed. I guess it's hard making a list of the 100 best metal guitarists, but... still. It's ****ed.

And typical Dave to mention Metallica in this interview. I don't think I've ever watched or read an interview where he doesn't mention Metallica.

He might have a giant ego, might have found God, might have got to number 1 in this list, but he still gets pissed off over something that happened almost 3 decades ago. Still a pussy in my eyes.

And that's coming from a huge Megadeth fan. Still, cool seeing Trey Azagthoth in the list, except I didn't expect him to be so high...
     
javier323 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:22 pm / quote |
"That's it exactly. I'm not addicted [to anything] anymore. And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica]. That game has ended. Lars [Ulrich] called me up and offered the chance to come to the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame thing and not be inducted, to sit in the audience [instead]. "It's only for people who've been on the records" is what I was told. That would have been awkward. So I didn't go. There are obviously some unresolved issues on Lars' part. But you know what? If God wants me in the Hall Of Fame, I will be there."

read this http://www.metalunderground.com/news/details.cfm?newsid=4767 1
     
Neurie wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:27 pm / quote |
for a guy who lost complete control of his arm and took him years of rehab to get back to playing again it is one hell of an achivement
     
CKYIbanezParker wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:31 pm / quote |
just because a book says that, doesn't mean thats the opinion of 3 billion people.

i'm glad hes off of drugs and drinking.

i think deron miller should be on that list.
     
Crazy Rob wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:31 pm / quote |
im a lil confuzzled why they picked dave over JP but im not rly bothered as this book cant meen much if kirk hammett got No.5
     
Distortion360 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:32 pm / quote |
Rimfrost wrote:

i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top


Hell ****ing yes.
     
BlaqIc3 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:46 pm / quote |
luckily chuck norris isnt a guitar player....or else he would be #1 imo :P
     
Viking_Swede666 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 07:49 pm / quote |
It's nice that Dave has found inner peace and some sort of closure within himself, he seems like a much happier person now.
     
zyprox wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:00 pm / quote |
What an *****. Neither James nor Kirk have have bad things to say about Dave. Still even after all these years he feels the need to be a douchebag about everything.


I hope you're joking. Both of them make fun of Dave all the time. Regardless, I'm not positive on the criteria, but I doubt the author was going for a strictly literal list of who has the best training, who plays without making any mistakes, who dances the polka with a monkey while playing guitar, etc. I get the sense that there were other indirect impacts on the author's ranking. Honestly, I don't disagree.

I'll admit I have the biggest hard-on for Dave and whatnot, but I find it hard pressed to find legitimate reasons the author was invalidated for putting him at #1. He created a distinct guitar sound, playing style and attitude. He constantly surrounded himself by some of the most talented musicians in the business at the time and all of those musicians walked away having learned something from Dave. His rhythm playing, his lead playing, his vocals, his stage persona, his lyrical output; these are all things that created the very foundation for metal, as we know it, to be born. So many other of his contemporaries have admitted to his massive reach over the formation of the modern metal movement.

All of these guitarists people are listing off as though it means something; half of them aren't there because they weren't considered metal by the author. Deal with it. Paul Gilbert isn't metal. Too bad. The other half were either heavily influenced by Mustaine and therefore playing into his ranking or just weren't as ground-breaking to the author. Jeff Loomis, as many have cited, for example actually auditioned for Megadeth after Jeff Young's departure. Guess what, he didn't make it. If someone auditioned, it doesn't matter what they say, if they didn't make it, they weren't good enough. Marty Friedman was obviously the best that both Daves found and even then, Marty admits that Dave Mustaine taught him about rhythm and song structure. Sure, Marty could (at the time) play lead circles around Dave, but they didn't go any where or mean anything until Dave showed him how to use them. Honestly, to me, Marty's leads are pretty boring compared to Dave's. I think Dave's lead playing is some of the most exciting, aggressive and honest I've ever heard.

As for his Metallica grudge, it isn't really too big of a concern for me where he stands on it. He might have been a violent alcoholic and they may have been right to throw him out, but Dave has said many times consistently that he told them not to use his material. Well, we see how that turned out. Again, many thrash metal founding acts admit that it was Dave's material on Metallica's first record that even got them going on that band. I would definitely hold a grudge if I was in Dave's position.

To deny that Dave Mustaine is at all, not a founding figure at the very basis of modern metal as we know it is just pure ignorance. Period.

I've loved Dave at times and I've hated Dave at times.. but I'm not going to spew bullshit because I'm butt hurt that he finally gets the credit he was so wholeheartedly due since day one.
     
matx33 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:02 pm / quote |
He's happy, good for him. And he's put out some good recordings, certainly helped the face of metal. Kudos for that.

It doesn't change the fact that he has been, and continues to be on occasion (read this article closely), a flaming ****.
     
matx33 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:04 pm / quote |

matx33 wrote:

He's happy, good for him. And he's put out some good recordings, certainly helped the face of metal. Kudos for that.

It doesn't change the fact that he has been, and continues to be on occasion (read this article closely), a flaming ****.


That is to say, a flaming and hypocritical ****.
(Though to be fair, nobody's free from hypocrisy)
     
Theeman0000 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:07 pm / quote |
Dave Mustaine is my personal guitar hero, but this article is a bit dickish. Personally, though, I'd like to bring up the existence of such awesome dicks as Lou Reed, Mick Jagger, Jim Morrison, and Ozzy Osbourne. Being a dickwad doesn't necessarily take anything away from you in the rock world, and Mustaine is a sick guitarist no matter which way you look at it.

If Chuck Schuldiner isn't in the top five of that book, then it's a piece of shit and should not be trusted.
     
98Timberwolf wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:20 pm / quote |
Well good for Dave to be happy now. I'm not sure what to think of these top *insert number* lists though. Music shouldn't be a competition in my opinion, but it's nice to see people get recognition for what they accomplish. If the people on the list don't treat it as a competition, i can't see any harm in it. As far as the whole "I won!" thing goes, I think he was kind of saying that jokingly.
     
hanselrocks1 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:29 pm / quote |
GJ Dave youve cleaned up and got something you deserve
     
indiebass21 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:31 pm / quote |
"he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world."
"The other two being?"
"Malcolm Young [of AC/DC] and myself"
I laughed for a good 30 seconds, I wonder if he realizes how cocky he sounds. I love Megadeth but this dialogue sounds like something straight out of spinal tap.
     
headbanger703 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:37 pm / quote |
CliffIsAngry wrote:

isabiggles wrote:

Any particular reason he chose no.69? Something tells me that Dave hasn't quite lost all of his demons yet :p he's used to being rated as shit by magazines so I guess he just figured oh another list .

I'm glad for dave, he deserves this, imo he is an uncrowned king in metal. He's one of the biggest influences in metal.


..... you clearly missed his little joke..
     
und3ad_s4int wrote on 08/27/2009 - 08:53 pm / quote |
OfficialPressSt wrote:

Megadeth? How about Megadouche? He violated the only rule I can think of when it comes to being a great guitarist: NEVER consider yourself one. You think Hendrix was sitting at home dipping the bong going "I'm the best there ever was!"? Yeah, Dave has great skill, and while I'm not a fan, I respect Megadeth for what they've accomplished. However, it seems after 100 rehab stints, they still haven't fixed his douchiness.
     
Megadeth Mani4c wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:00 pm / quote |
dave mustaine owns!!!
     
CliffIsAngry wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:07 pm / quote |
98Timberwolf wrote:

Well good for Dave to be happy now. I'm not sure what to think of these top *insert number* lists though. Music shouldn't be a competition in my opinion, but it's nice to see people get recognition for what they accomplish. If the people on the list don't treat it as a competition, i can't see any harm in it. As far as the whole "I won!" thing goes, I think he was kind of saying that jokingly.
yes when I read his replies in the interview I also sense alot of sarcasm and joking. I think it's great for dave to finally get some recognition, he deserves it. he's a rock solid rhythm guitarist and song writer.
     
adamlovesbcrich wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:10 pm / quote |
Does anyone know what the Kerry/Mustaine fight was about? I'm uninformed.
     
redcthulhu wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:21 pm / quote |
Well, he sounds like kind of a douche, but otherwise he's pretty cool.
     
MeGaDeth2314 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:24 pm / quote |
hahaha I love how Dave calls himself one of the top 3 greatest rhythm guitarist of all time. I love Megadeth, but Dave Mustaine just needs to let this shit go and stop popping up all over the headlines saying how much better of a person he is than Slayer or Metallica. We get it, you don't like Metallica, but Hetfield doesn't have a weekly interview on UG reminding everyone all the time. Dave's a good guy, just getting a little too used to the "spotlight" imo.
     
MeGaDeth2314 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:25 pm / quote |
wow, that was really ironic considering my username. and when is BTBAM gonna get the credit they deserve on these lists?
     
Deep*Kick wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:51 pm / quote |
Lots of comments. Congrats Dave, but "top lists" are always a waste of time anyway and aren't really a huge achievement.
     
ti-on_suxandrox wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:52 pm / quote |
you know what's funny, i recently found a band called 'evil cancer' on youtube. I liked em and had a chat with them with youtube pm's.

We had a great conversation, and i found out that they were great guys. The guitarist said that dave was a big influence on him, and his whole life he wanted to be like dave.

Then he joined cancer, and although he has great rhythm chops, nobody can hear his guitar under the screams of the two vocalists.

You guys should check out this band, they are very.....unique.
     
Fireballz 1077 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:54 pm / quote |
Nice lol...Dave brags a little too much sometimes, but he deserves some recognition.
     
overkill127 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 09:55 pm / quote |
this list is comprehensive but i do have a few issues...

first-i like how he included newer bands, but I don't like how he pretty much only focuses on European bands. There are amazing new american metal guitarists (Oli Herbert, Mark Morton to name just two) who deserve credit.

Secondly-Mustaine is a great guitarist, but he does not deserve the top slot. I like metallica and megadeth equally for different reasons and i think mustaine does deserve a high placement but certainly not the first

Thirdly-neither herman li nor sam totman sould not even be on the list. I went to see dragonforce live at the last mayhem and was throughly unimpressed. For me, one of the tenants of being a great metal guitarist is a great live performance.
     
herman ri2 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:16 pm / quote |
TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...


When Chris Brodrick, Marty Friedman, and Chris Poland write classic riffs like hanger 18, Take No prisoners, and many more then come back to be. Anyone can practice for hours and sweep like a mobster but it takes a special guitarist to write creative and classic albums and change styles of playing.
     
herman ri2 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:18 pm / quote |
I would rather have a guitarist who can write mind blowing riffs/songs than a guitarist who can mimic a few guitar solos and write good solos anyday.
     
IbanezDudeCK wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:28 pm / quote |
Dave's a little off on his numbering. Tom Morello is 16. Kirk Hammett is 15. James Hetfield is 8. Dimebag is 5.
I was pretty pleased with the book, but I thought Rusty Cooley of Outworld and Kiko Loureiro of Angra should've been up there a ways, or atleast in it.
     
Set-Abominae wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:39 pm / quote |
The people up above misunderstood my comment about the guy saying Petrucci being second to Mustaine is a joke. I meant that some people will never learn that insanely fast and complex shred solos do not necessarily make you a great guitarist. Yes, you are skilled and technical, but there is a huge difference between being skilled and being great. This list was not ranked on sheer lead/rhythm prowess alone, but also on songwriting skills, musicianship, the impact the guitarist in question has made on the industry, their staying power as songwriters, and the overall quality of their music.

It clearly states in the article (and the book) that there are plenty of guitarists who are better than Mustaine in many of those areas, but he is sufficiently skilled enough in all the areas to be named number one.

This is why Petrucci is not number one. Yes, he is an amazing guitarist (albeit an extremely boring one, in my opinion), but Dream Theater did not help to launch metal from the underground into the public eye as the Big Four did (of which Megadeth comprises one quarter). The sheer fact that they're part of such a group (and that Mustaine is the main songwriter/lyricist for his band), and the fact that they're still writing balls-out thrash metal should be evidence enough that Mustaine deserves the top spot.

Plus, these lists are entirely subjective and is this one jerkoff's opinion, so naturally people will disagree. //End rant//
     
hagalwadi007 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:41 pm / quote |
METAL GUITARIST PEOPLE!
Dream Theater...i ****ing love them,but they arent 100% metal all the time
     
dann_blood wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:42 pm / quote |
Jesus Christ he's a dick. Almost everything he says in that interview reeks of him believing he's better than everyone despite not being willing to admit it.
     
Set-Abominae wrote on 08/27/2009 - 10:43 pm / quote |
I'm also really miffed to see Jon Schaffer beat out by guitarists from Shadows Fall, Slipknot, Trivium and the like. Schaffer has churned out some damn fine albums (read: Burnt Offerings, Night of Stormrider, Something Wicked This Way Comes, etc), and I think he deserves a little more credit than that.
     
troyponce wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:02 pm / quote |
herman ri2 wrote:

TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...

When Chris Brodrick, Marty Friedman, and Chris Poland write classic riffs like hanger 18, Take No prisoners, and many more then come back to be. Anyone can practice for hours and sweep like a mobster but it takes a special guitarist to write creative and classic albums and change styles of playing.

Chris Poland is a very accomplished jazz/fusion guitarist now, and calling his creativity into question is silly.

Marty Friedman has inspired countless contemporaries through his time with Jason Becker in Cacophony and changed the way metal guitar would be played, even before Megadeth. Not to mention his solo albums with blisteringly unique phrasing and note choice.

Chris Broderick hasn't had many opportunities to shine creatively. Jag Panzer had a specific thing they wanted and he filled the spot admirably.

The guy you were responding to was clearly ignorant, but you are not helping.
     
Ain_Elohim wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:05 pm / quote |
This book, I read it, and it makes me want to make a list that makes more sense.
     
IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:15 pm / quote |
David_Bowie=GOD wrote:

IRONMAIDENTLICA wrote:

And I'm no longer struggling with past demons from another band [Metallica].

if hes no longer struggling why did he say he won when he was ahead of james and kirk?

Anyways dave is a very good guitarist, cant wait for the new cd

They probably don't bother him now than he's beaten them.


Mmm....matter of opinion i guess...
     
fadetoblack84 wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:34 pm / quote |
I find it hard to believe that Kirk Hammett is 5th and Hetfield is 16th. Hetfield just seems like a better guitarist to me. He is superb at rhythm guitar and he can solo nearly a well as Kirk. Thats just my opinion. Mustaine definately tops my list or is near the top of my list. Top 3 definately. With Hetfield and Petrucci.
     
JJJOEY wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:35 pm / quote |
Then I got to No. 2 and it was John Petrucci [of Dream Theater] and I froze. I was No. 1.

Dream Theater is the best and if Dave beat Petrucci then awesome. Gotta respect the legends and Dave is certainly one of if not the greatest guitarists of all time.
Rock on Megadeth \m/
     
GenerationKILL wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:36 pm / quote |
I hope michael ammott is on that list!
     
Hellish_Wolf wrote on 08/27/2009 - 11:40 pm / quote |
Hmm, better than Petrucci? I like Dave, but I think that is a stretch. (Not saying that Petrucci is the best guitarist but imo Dave isn't nearly as good.)
     
bloodletter55 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:01 am / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And another thing, the ONLY thing I can see why mustaine would even be mentioned in a top 100 guitar players list would be for rhythym playing, I mean the man can only play a could different keys in minor pentatonic, it's ****ing terrible and pathetic.

The list is top 100 GUITAR PLAYERS, not musicians, not song writers, which is mustaines only talent, this list is about PURE TECHNICAL SKILL ONLY, and that's something that mustaine lacks greatly.


Your opinion is blindly stated. Look at the solos on peace sells. I don't see pentatonics, DO YOU? How about the first solo to Dread and the Fugitive Mind? Yes yes, quite pentatonic(sarcasm). Let's not forget about HANGAR 18.
     
edgeyyz wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:02 am / quote |
I'd have to say that Hetfield is better at rhythm, but Dave is better than Kirk. BUT, I still think Petrucci is much better than Dave at soloing. Someone else should have been #1 IMO.
     
edgeyyz wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:04 am / quote |
fadetoblack84 wrote:

I find it hard to believe that Kirk Hammett is 5th and Hetfield is 16th. Hetfield just seems like a better guitarist to me. He is superb at rhythm guitar and he can solo nearly a well as Kirk. Thats just my opinion. Mustaine definately tops my list or is near the top of my list. Top 3 definately. With Hetfield and Petrucci.

I agree 100%. Plus, James wouldn't wah the hell out of his solos. And Petrucci and Mustaine are great. Kirk, eh, not too much.
     
ruker wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:06 am / quote |
31 Alex Auburn (Cryptopsy)


Yet no Jon... the list creator deserves to be shot. Much like TIME's top 10, this list is just a popularity contest. If it were based on skill alone, 75% of the guys on this list wouldn't even come close to making it.
     
Ponomar wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:10 am / quote |
fadetoblack84 wrote:

I find it hard to believe that Kirk Hammett is 5th and Hetfield is 16th. Hetfield just seems like a better guitarist to me. He is superb at rhythm guitar and he can solo nearly a well as Kirk. Thats just my opinion. Mustaine definately tops my list or is near the top of my list. Top 3 definately. With Hetfield and Petrucci.


Actually, in a Guitar World magazine James admitted that he'll never be as good of a guitarist as Kirk.
Metallica ftw, Megadeath is good but Dave is a dick.
     
the_burning_one wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:19 am / quote |
whoever says james hetfield shouldnt be up there is wrong imo. he says top metal guitarists, not top ten fastest, not top ten soloists, he says top metal GUITARISTS. and id say james is up there.
     
ThatWouldBeJon wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:19 am / quote |
(the dead of rock hall of fame)
Sorry Mr. Mustaine but you cannot be in the hall of fame because you did not appear on any of metallicas reords, but you only wrote nearly all of the lead parts to the entire Kill 'Em All album and the majority of the parts to Ride The Lightning which sparked the one of the most popular thrash metal band in the world but no you cannot be inducted into the hall of fame because you yousrelf did not appear on a single album...

can you blame dave for being pissed off for so long i mean come on any win over metallica he gets he prides over but i would too if i were him
     
punk&metal wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:34 am / quote |
dave is the coolest living guy in metal

rip cliff
     
TC1223 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:50 am / quote |
Dont worry Dave, you'll be there whether God wants you there or not
     
RicoTheBeast wrote on 08/28/2009 - 01:16 am / quote |
[quote=SumFX]What has he done to be hated so much?
He seems really cool from what i have read in this interview.[/quote]

Lol...you've got about 25 years of interviews to catch up on buddy...

I definitely don't think that Mustaine deserves to be #1 anywhere but his own head (where he clearly stated he is...), but whatever, that's been debated enough. My only beef is this: how does Tom Morello get ranked at #16, and Randy Rhoads is nowhere to be found? Don't get me wrong, Morello is amazing and definitely one of the all-time greats, but there is no frickin way he can be considered more 'metal' than Sir Rhoads...
     
maj.pain wrote on 08/28/2009 - 01:25 am / quote |
DAVE MUSTAINE NUMBER 1!!!!! HELL YEA.
best guitarist in the world
     
Shrexter wrote on 08/28/2009 - 02:24 am / quote |
Its funny how you guys are all talking about how he won because hes good at rhythm and lead, and you all argue Metallica vs. Mustaine.

Am i the only one here who thinks that Dimebag was better overall than both Hetfield and Mustaine?

It may seem cliche or whatever but it's cliche because he really was one of the greatest overall metal guitarists ever. But theres really no point in arguing its all opinion haha.
     
metallica-#1 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:05 am / quote |
sXe170 :
Dave Mustaine is sooo overrated. He is not the father/king/creator of Thrash. He played speed metal for the majority of his career. Gary Hohlt of Exodus should be ahead of him, he can write alot better riffs and solo all over Mustaine. Listen to ANY Exodus record and you'll see how much of a god Hohlt is.


well if thats the case... shouldnt Kirk Hammett be considered the Father of Thrash Metal? i mean.. Exodus WAS Kirk's band, he started it and they were playin thrash while Mustaine was still playin ordinary metal

as for Dave Mustaine finding closure on a list thats based completely on opinion... this is bullshit, he's just fishin for reasons to call himself better than the best metal band in the world (i think we all know who that is, its been said enough in this article... [Metallica]) and now that some guy rated him #1 he thinks hes better, just because the author says he's better in HIS oppinion

grow up Mustaine, opinionated lists dont make you the best guitarist, but if we were going by over-all skill from a musical stand-point, id give the award to Hetfield. he's inspired more fans with his riffs and early vocal style more than Mustaine and he is in a more influencial band. plus Hetfield's solos are much better, they may not be more technical.. but thats not what music or solos is about.

just cuz you know a fajillion scales doesnt mean you gotta show em off. Hetfield's solos are very well thought out and melodic and very emotional at times, i truely consider him one of the best for those reasons above
     
bassthunder wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:11 am / quote |
Okay, Mustaine is good, but number one? Hardly. His riffs are great, but there are plenty of other guitarists out there who play both rhythm and lead better (Robert Flynn jumps to mind).

Though really, I'm not sure why I'm arguing about this. Ultimately, this is just another bullshit list like the hundreds of others that have come before it. The only difference is this one got published.
     
 ZeGuitarist   m   wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:19 am / quote |
Checked...
     
Colgate Total wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:32 am / quote |
Lol.

Interviews like that make me like Dave even more. He writes great music, and he plays it great. He has never ****ed up live (as far as I've seen) and his riffs are the most memorable thing about Megadeth. I have no problem with Dave being first, but I have to wonder how the hell Kirk placed higher than James.

I'm wondering where Schuldiner, Azagthoth, and Iommi placed though.
     
SOADriff wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:41 am / quote |
excellent.
     
starfire666 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 03:45 am / quote |
IMHO there never will be a better guitar player than Mr. Petrucci, but I am happy for Dave to make the top of the list because of his songwriting abilities.
     
cobainAnselmo wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:05 am / quote |
"So I got No. 16 and I saw Hetfield. I thought, "Wow," because I respect James. I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world."

goddamn, he is still ****in arrogant...

otherwise, mustaine is pretty cool, but he is number one???

oh, come on...
     
ihavenoname93 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:13 am / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.


i think youre missing the point of music
     
ihavenoname93 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:16 am / quote |
cobainAnselmo wrote:

"So I got No. 16 and I saw Hetfield. I thought, "Wow," because I respect James. I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world."

goddamn, he is still ****in arrogant...

otherwise, mustaine is pretty cool, but he is number one???

oh, come on...


well considering james has had about 3 solos ever, its not too arrogant i guess. i think its worse that he put himself in the top 3 rhythm guitarists of all time.

hes no number one, even most of his lead guitarists have been better than him, but he deffinitely deserves to be on the list
     
nick_b wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:18 am / quote |
"one of the top three" then goes to name himself as one of them. toss-off.
     
ihavenoname93 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:22 am / quote |
Ponomar wrote:
Actually, in a Guitar World magazine James admitted that he'll never be as good of a guitarist as Kirk.
Metallica ftw, Megadeath is good but Dave is a dick.


thats just sucking up. in interviews ive heard mustaine say chris broderick is better than friedman, which is what he said about glen drover, which is bullshit.
     
KingSquall802 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:40 am / quote |
James Hetfield is a better songwriter than Dave all the way. For me technicality in guitar is greeat but it is somewhat crazy. Sometimes It is just something to show off that u got da skills.

Whatever u say guys but James Hetfield is the "Badass King Of Riffs"!!!!!
     
metal-murnanes wrote on 08/28/2009 - 04:41 am / quote |
These lists really should be more specfic. Such as "top 20 Thrash guitarists" or "top 10 most technical guitarists (for a specific genre)". Metal as a whole is to varied to put into one list, such as this one because most are throwing toys out the pram and aruging opinions. dont get me wrong, it should be done but it does get tedious =p. Nonetheless, A very good read!
     
MetalManic 666 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 05:05 am / quote |
*coughs* Dave wins
     
john_bird_o wrote on 08/28/2009 - 05:37 am / quote |
So I got No. 16 and I saw Hetfield. I thought, "Wow," because I respect James. I'm a better lead player than he is. To be better than both of them [Hetfield and Hammett] meant so much
. Man this guy has such a big ego, seriously. Who gives a shit that you placed number one on ONE list of 100 great Metal guitarists. Yes Dave you are amazing, but the fact that you believe you are amazing is ridiculous. If the truth be told, your not that amazing. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love Megadeth and have seen them live so many times. But lets be honest; ok you 'KEEP IT METAL' in comparison to Metallica who have had albums of different sounds, but you can't write songs that are anywhere near as good as Metallica at the top of their game. Everyone talks about how Mustaine wrote most parts for Kill 'em all and ride the lighting, but that is one element of writing an album. Megadeth have never had an album which is more significant than any Metallica album. Mustaine cannot even try to write anything meaningful and melodic, which is why it's just Thrash all the time. Mustaine lets face it, you will never write songs as good as Metallica so get over yourself. We all know that yes your are 'technically' better than Hetfield, but you are not a better songwriter. Music is about writing songs that people can relate to, and tbh theres only so far you can go with listening to thrash. At least when you listen to Metallica you get some great melodic value from their music, listen to songs like 'The Unforgiven' and 'Nothing Else Matters' for an example. You wonder why Metallica play stadiums and Megadeth don't? Metallica reach out to more people with the balance in their music, which is why Hetfield will always be better than Mustaine. Also, hands down a band has to be good live as well. Ive seen Metallica and Megadeth lots of times, and Megadeth are ****ing boring live. Metallica are so much better live. Im sorry Musaine, but METALLICA ALL THE WAY! When you get thousands of people in a stadium singing 'Enter Sandman', Master Of Puppets', singing the solo guitar to 'one' at the beginning of the song, then maybe you might be able to talk about being in the same league as Hetfield.....METALLICA FOR THE WIN
     
apu99992 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 06:03 am / quote |
respectfully, though Mustaines comments are, in the light of hindsight, self-reproving I believe he is still very much an interesting character with his own opinions, along with a tendency to express through numerous forms of media, as many of you no doubt are aware of, himself, his judgments, and his daily predicaments which, even when read briefly, reveal an astonishing amount of personal perceptions that, though possibly possibly odd for someone his age, represente his complete disregard for others comments on his opnionions as well as a personal triump over his glaring insecurities that have been attempting to destroy him for most of the past 20 years.

Hows that for a stick up someone's ass?

No seriously this should in no way descend into a quite monotheistic Mustaine-Hetfield battle. The truth is that Dave is speed metal. Today most of the bands are quite laid back (Dave represents this with his attitude) but they are still taking shit from everybody because of old prejudices and perceptions (you people).
Dave realy did invent the rhythm style, and when I mean that I'm in now way referring to the actual chord progressions or beat. It is the large amount of energy he put into develop this playing style and showcasing it to the world. In a way hes like the Yngwie of speedmetal. He employed a variety of techniques that, although they may not have been new, were never used in that manner before. IUnfortunately everyone stole them from him and he became addicted (in the same way Yngwie started downing those cheesecakes).l Eventually he relapsed, picking up his career right where it left off happy to find that the fans that had supported him all along were still there. Of course the people that hated him were also still there.
     
steevo92 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 06:08 am / quote |
I agree with taking Mustaine to No. 1. He is really deserved it now... I Love Metallica and Megadeth, Dream Theater and Pantera too and know all the songs from these bands
Mustaine has more skills than Hammett,Hetfield,Petrucci or Dimebag i think
     
jacksparrow4986 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 06:36 am / quote |
"To be better than both of them [Hetfield and Hammett] meant so much"

Right, so when someone writes a book and says "hey your better than all these guys", do you take it that seriously? Mustaine is a ****in arrogant moron. He's got some skills sure, but how the **** do you rate players at that level? He was RATED the best in one man's OPINION out all the guitarists he KNOWS. Seriously, only a moron would get satisfaction about reading yourself as number one in that context. I'm willing to bet most of the guitarists on that list didn't even read that book.
     
MetalManic 666 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 06:47 am / quote |
john_bird_o wrote:

So I got No. 16 and I saw Hetfield. I thought, "Wow," because I respect James. I'm a better lead player than he is. To be better than both of them [Hetfield and Hammett] meant so much . Man this guy has such a big ego, seriously. Who gives a shit that you placed number one on ONE list of 100 great Metal guitarists. Yes Dave you are amazing, but the fact that you believe you are amazing is ridiculous. If the truth be told, your not that amazing. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love Megadeth and have seen them live so many times. But lets be honest; ok you 'KEEP IT METAL' in comparison to Metallica who have had albums of different sounds, but you can't write songs that are anywhere near as good as Metallica at the top of their game. Everyone talks about how Mustaine wrote most parts for Kill 'em all and ride the lighting, but that is one element of writing an album. Megadeth have never had an album which is more significant than any Metallica album. Mustaine cannot even try to write anything meaningful and melodic, which is why it's just Thrash all the time. Mustaine lets face it, you will never write songs as good as Metallica so get over yourself. We all know that yes your are 'technically' better than Hetfield, but you are not a better songwriter. Music is about writing songs that people can relate to, and tbh theres only so far you can go with listening to thrash. At least when you listen to Metallica you get some great melodic value from their music, listen to songs like 'The Unforgiven' and 'Nothing Else Matters' for an example. You wonder why Metallica play stadiums and Megadeth don't? Metallica reach out to more people with the balance in their music, which is why Hetfield will always be better than Mustaine. Also, hands down a band has to be good live as well. Ive seen Metallica and Megadeth lots of times, and Megadeth are ****ing boring live. Metallica are so much better live. Im sorry Musaine, but METALLICA ALL THE WAY! When you get thousands of people in a stadium singing 'Enter Sandman', Master Of Puppets', singing the solo guitar to 'one' at the beginning of the song, then maybe you might be able to talk about being in the same league as Hetfield.....METALLICA FOR THE WIN
umm wow just wow...
so metallica are better than megadeth because megadeth are thrash all the time and metallica arent... ok just checking. also i agree with u that dave is amazing coz he is but whats wrong with him knowing that?
     
Destihado wrote on 08/28/2009 - 06:57 am / quote |
To hell with god Dave! What the hell has god to do with metal???
     
Shreddaboi12 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 07:12 am / quote |
wtf he wasnt even right bout the book

i have the book and kirk isnt no.5 hes no.15
and james is no.8

     
john_bird_o wrote on 08/28/2009 - 07:17 am / quote |
so metallica are better than megadeth because megadeth are thrash all the time and metallica arent...

No of course not, it's because Metallica are better songwriters. Yes ok, songs like 'Symphony Of Destruction' have awesome riffs throughout, theres no denying. But, Metallica write riffs that are far more epic, like 'Enter Sandman' for example. Just my opinion, but my opinion makes sense.
     
slayaplaya wrote on 08/28/2009 - 07:47 am / quote |
TheMartyr559 wrote:

Dave Mustaine isn't even the best guitarist in his own band...


Funny cuz' it's true
     
Sober_god wrote on 08/28/2009 - 07:52 am / quote |
I never thought that megadeth would be so popular that people who dont listen to their music would comment. As for dave he was with out a doubt the best musician of the big four trash bands but i always see that British guitarist are not appreciated in america
     
Astyan wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:04 am / quote |
Rofl at the everlasting habit of refusing to acknowledge certain guitarists' talent because they use shredding in their compositions. People claiming Petrucci is "fast but lacks soul/taste" or any variation on this theme have obviously no ****ing clue. The guy conveys emotion all over the place when necessary, through his amazing skills but also through his simple and unique way of enjoying what he plays.

More on topic, I like Mustaine. But although he's a legend, he's not Number One material, sorry. But it's all subjective anyway.
     
playfielder wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:04 am / quote |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE2jmZq-eck
now skip to 4:50.
Petrucci owns mustaine in the solo.
JP's tone is A LOT better too
     
fishcrumble wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:10 am / quote |
I laughed so hard when he said:
I'm a better lead player than he is, but he's one of the three best rhythm players in the world.

The other two being?

Malcolm Young [of AC/DC] and myself.
I love Dave, but he's such a self assured twat.
     
m0o wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:21 am / quote |
sorry but he sounds like a ****ing arrogant prick. no respect here. i dont care how good he may be.
     
Vinura wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:25 am / quote |
dave deserves the no1, nobody else does the amount of stuff he does, still i cant beleive they didnt have Paul Gilbert in this list, what a sham
     
say5ss2 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:35 am / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And now people see why so many people think Mustaine is a cocky piece of shit.

He just called himself, and 2 EXTREMELY mainstream and arguably overrated players the best rhythm guitar players in the world.

WAKE UP Mustaine, this isn't the 80s where people would touch their guitar an hour a day and then write some cliche progression and pentatonic solo and become gods, people actually WORK REALLY HARD everyday to perfect their creative skills and technique as a talent, there are SOOO many guitarists out there that could literally run circles around you, rhythm players as well who could hold down/alt picking riffs for hours, honestly there could be a whole new top 100 list with NONE of them up there and it would be more accurate.

I'm not a metallica fan btw, as I will probably get flamed to be, both bands are overrated, and both lead guitarists are FUCKING TERRIBLE (Hammett, and Mustaine), Friedman on the other hand is a virtuoso who could rip any mode up any scale and improvise over any progression, because he worked to get where he is musician/skill-wise.

TWO thumbs up to this guy!!!
     
musicforpeace wrote on 08/28/2009 - 08:43 am / quote |
Wonder where Dimebag would be on that list? I reckon top 20.
     
 nightraven   m   wrote on 08/28/2009 - 09:28 am / quote |
checkeddd
     
Froboarder wrote on 08/28/2009 - 09:38 am / quote |
Yay. I love Megadeth. Can't wait 'till the 15th. =)
Dave, you cocky *******, you rule.
     
mr_metal121 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 09:48 am / quote |
hmm i don't know what the full list is, but i personally would of constructed it differently, if you're looking at shredders id have Joe Satriani, Steve Vai, Yngwie Malmsteen, maybe Jeff Loomis, John Petrucci, there are some great full time guitarists (rhythm and leads) like Dimebag, Chuck Schuldiner, of course Dave is kick ass, Chris Broderick is a really good player, I'm not sure what exactly this guy based his choices on, i'll just say I would of had a much different list
     
legato89 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:07 am / quote |
18 Kerry King (Slayer)
19 Mick Thomson (Slipknot)
20 Herman Li (Dragonforce)


This list is a COMPLETE joke.
     
Duffman123 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:22 am / quote |
He's always in the news atm
     
Mariner wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:27 am / quote |
K. Hammet sucks, even compared to James... They should have kept Dave from the start..
     
Pingis_Or_Death wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:28 am / quote |
The book chould be called "100 greatest MAINSTREAM metal guitarists".
     
Gexzilla wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:41 am / quote |
Funny thing - the best guitarist and the worst singer in metal is the same person

I wouldn't call him #1 alone though, but one of the best for sure.

     
Robert Gray wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:43 am / quote |
Pingis_Or_Death wrote:

The book chould be called "100 greatest MAINSTREAM metal guitarists".

I like how you class the likes of Chuck Schuldiner as "mainstream metal guitarists".
     
Biohazard wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:51 am / quote |
what a puss.
     
emkaybee wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:58 am / quote |
LD_Luke D wrote:

dimebag > Petrucci

petrucci is fast and accurate, but sacrifices taste


He sacrifices 'taste'? You, sir, make an underwhelming argument.

Also, Michael Romeo at 96? Why so lowww?
     
AngryGoldfish wrote on 08/28/2009 - 12:31 pm / quote |
Wow. Great article.
     
Metal Head 101 wrote on 08/28/2009 - 10:35 pm / quote |
Here we, Mustaine rocks, Hammet is good but very repetitive and I personally think Marty Friedman should be in the top 10
     
Ponyexpress wrote on 08/29/2009 - 05:32 pm / quote |
WAIT JUST A MINUTE...
MUSTAINE IS A CHRISTIAN NOW?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
cool
     
Shaharz wrote on 08/31/2009 - 01:52 am / quote |
Ponyexpress wrote:

WAIT JUST A MINUTE...
MUSTAINE IS A CHRISTIAN NOW?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
cool


lol. I was surprised too.
He completely deserves being number 1
Can't wait for Endgame
     
IRONMETADETH wrote on 08/31/2009 - 09:44 pm / quote |
DAVE IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE IN THE #1 SPOT
     
Ozzmars wrote on 09/01/2009 - 10:09 am / quote |
Hell, I thought he wasn't going to be in there at all. The world is a strange place and Dave seems to rarely get the recognition he deserves. Probably 'cause there are too many Metallica fans out there. Great to hear he got to #1. He deserves it. Megadeth's been my favorite band since I was 16 (29 now) and always will be. There is no other band or guitarist that comes close! and Dave is a fascinating and inspiring person! Megadeth for ever!
     
Jmoarguitar wrote on 09/07/2009 - 12:52 pm / quote |
DSchmitty wrote:

And another thing, the ONLY thing I can see why mustaine would even be mentioned in a top 100 guitar players list would be for rhythym playing, I mean the man can only play a could different keys in minor pentatonic, it's ****ing terrible and pathetic.

The list is top 100 GUITAR PLAYERS, not musicians, not song writers, which is mustaines only talent, this list is about PURE TECHNICAL SKILL ONLY, and that's something that mustaine lacks greatly.
Song writing is the only skill he has. DUDE, thats all you ****ing need! The guitar was invented for SONGS and WRITING SONGS. screw pure technical skill, it's so damn boring when listening to guys wank on the guitar with no damn emotion and people think they're the best, i pick angus young and his sloppy ass guitar playing and put him as my 3rd favourite guitarist and all those pure technical shredders all sit at the back of my book. thats my thought.
     
AceDauntless wrote on 09/10/2009 - 07:04 pm / quote |
FUCK YEAH!
     
DanielBenitez wrote on 09/10/2009 - 11:22 pm / quote |
Kirks way bettter
wat he talking about he being better than james
James better too
look at them sold heck lot more albums than megadeth BOOO!!!
     
rgt42dx wrote on 09/11/2009 - 08:55 am / quote |
appreciate his works on met and other bios, but this list is a ****ing abomination. one can argue that dime's songwriting isn't as good as dave's but that difference can't compare to what darrell can do as an axeman in pretty much every aspect above mustaine but i guess the rhythm part is arguable but still. watch mustaine's solo in the cemetery gates cover, four spots above dime really? guitar-wise, mustaine is in between james and kirk but him alone can't surpass both of them combined imo, talking about peaks here. if only met lived on with dave and cliff churning out for material...
     
JakoSnako wrote on 09/11/2009 - 09:20 am / quote |
lol, never read that book, but i really dont think dave mustaine i the best guitarist of all time. and the comment on rythm players? he sees himself as the best rhythm player? wow.
     
JakoSnako wrote on 09/11/2009 - 09:23 am / quote |
[b]rgt42dx[b\] wrote:
if only met lived on with dave and cliff churning out for material...


if only... that would be amazing

RIP Cliff
     
KillTimer wrote on 12/29/2009 - 09:05 am / quote |
For sure, any opinion is kind of subjective. But it seems to me there's always a limit of subjectivism. For me it is evident that the author of this rating never playd guitar) That's a pity.

From the other side I have my own subjective view on this point, let me share it with you.
First some general conclusions about the leaders and the rating itself and then - my podium.

Guitarist. I think guys who play guitar will agree that the best guitarist should be best in solo playing too. Otherwise there could be found a better one) Technique is not enough but necessary. Not for shredding itself but as an ability to express everything you want to. So the only magic cocktail of extraordinary musical mind and perfect technique lets the guitar player book the place in best division.

Mustain. I love Megadeth music. I used to play more then a half riffs and solos from Rust in Peace, Countdown 2 Extinction and Youthanasia albums. Undoubtedly Dave's talents for songwriting, performing, lyrics creating and singing make him a musician of genius. But... who can argue that Dave lack soloing? It's a pity but his solos are primitive and inexpressive. So claiming him the best guitarist why don't we do it for Dio, Ozzy or King Diamond as guitar composers and arrangers too?)

Petrucci. Dream Theater is my favorite band. The music they made seems to me the best for the moment, since their first album until the last one. And not less then 50% of this is impact of J.P. Moreover, John is hypertechnical - he plays classical, legatos, tapping and alternate picking great alike and his speed is really terrific. Not only technique - John can do emotional solos that provocates crying like he do it in Lines in the Sand, Best of Times, Scarred, As I Am and of cause in live Hollow Years version. He absolutely deserves the... 2d place. Not the first, because the best guitarist should do all mentioned above in EVERY solo, in every moment we hear his lead guitar.

Few other notes.
What's up with Satriani and Vai? Is it special heavy metal chart? But Tony Iomy is here... Ok, lets agree to keep them away (why?!)
Iron Maiden. Janick Gers is for sure much better guitar player than Dave Murrey and technically better then Adrian Smith but Adrian compensate it with his brain, he's the one who use it in IM))
Jeff Waters is a very good guitarist. Just a good guitarist. Not the 3d, of cause.

So, the 4-steps podium, like I see it:

4. Victor Smolski / Nuno Bittencourt / Ritchie Kotzen
3. Chuck Schuldiner / Buckethead
2. John Petrucci / Steve Morse / Randy Roads (and Randy used to be able for more, I'm sure).

and the man who's every phrase picked is a miracle...

1. Marty Friedman

Thanx everybody)

     
gnrfloyd87 wrote on 01/30/2010 - 10:55 pm / quote |
Hammett and Petrucci both sh*t on Mustaine, he shouldnt even be in the top 10 nor Hetfield in the top 25
     
Imsmexyftw wrote on 02/09/2010 - 09:51 pm / quote |
Becker > Govan > God > Petrucci > Vai > Satriani > Malmsteen
     
pkweon wrote on 06/03/2010 - 09:25 am / quote |
TheBodomBullet wrote:

That being said I wonder where Jeff Waters is placed?
TheBodomBullet wrote:

3

Rimfrost wrote:

i wonder where Chuck Schuldiner is placed on that list, personally i would defineately put him somewhere in the top

He's the father of death metal and one of the best of all time. If he's not at least top 10 I'll be upset.

10

Mikael Akerfeldt was no.9 though
     
Bobosalah wrote on 07/01/2010 - 05:36 pm / quote |
Wow i just read all the comments xD
Seriously Gratz Dave! idk what these douche bags think of you, youre awesome ^^
im pissed that Paul "God" Gilbert isnt on the list tho >:X
     
coryhickmon09 wrote on 08/09/2011 - 02:30 am / quote |
That is absolutely RIDICULOUS!!!! He's NOT that good! He hits random notes as fast as he can and it sounds like crap! This is an insult to guitarists everywhere. If ANYONE deserved to be number one, it's Zakk Wylde. A guitarist that DOESN'T hit random notes as fast as he can. He slows it down. Plays acoustic. He plays fast pace solos, and slows it down too. I have NEVER heard something that dave played slow. Btw, if there IS something out there where he doesn't hit random note and such, I haven't heard it because megadeth sucks balls and I can't stand to hear that garbage.
     
coryhickmon09 wrote on 08/09/2011 - 02:43 am / quote |
& just listen to his lead solos. Holy Wars, need I say more? An absolute killer of a solo!


Are you kidding me?! IT'S JUST A BUNCH OF RANDOM NOTES THAT SOUND ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE!!!!!
Comment tools:    Post your comment (please login or register and read comments policy first):
biu
   quote
smilies =)
  

About

Help/FAQ

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

RSS Feeds  

Site Map

Link To Us

Tell A Friend

Advertising Info

Job Opportunities

Contact Us

Ultimate-Guitar.Com © 2012