search for: in
 
advanced + submit your tab

+ submit your review

+ submit your article
fresh tabs / 0-9 a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z / top 100 tabs

How To Destroy Angels EP Review

artist: how to destroy angels date: 07/09/2010 category: compact discs
How To Destroy Angels EP
Released: Jun 1, 2010
Genre: Post-industrial, experimental, art rock, dark ambient
Label: The Null Corporation
Number Of Tracks: 6
This EP sounds nothing like anything Renzor did for Nine Inch Nails - the sound is less angry and more frustrated.
 Sound: 8
 Lyrics: 8
 Impression: 8
 Overall rating:
 8.1 
 Reviewer rating:
 8 
 Users rating:
 8.2 
 Votes:
 20 
 1 review 37 commentsvote for this cd: 
overall: 8
How To Destroy Angels EP Reviewed by: Gerard Way Jr, on july 09, 2010
3 of 6 people found this review helpful

Sound: Ah, Trent Reznor does it again. Along with his wife, Mariqueen Maandig, and some guy no one cares about called Atticus Ross (who has produced for Nine Inch Nails as well as Jane's Addiction), Reznor has created an interesting post-indistrial group called How to Destroy Angels, and, in June of 2010 released their eponymous EP.

The name actually comes from the debut EP by band Coil, so you can imagine that, whilst musical creativity is all over this record, the name is a blatant and inexplicable ripoff. Really, Trent?

This being from the same guy who pulls off Nine Inch Nails, I'm sure you can imagine the sound; ominous and experimental. Whilst lighter in tone than most Nine Inch Nails stuff, there is a definite Reznor presence here. It's his child, after all.

In many ways, however, this EP sounds nothing like anything he did for Nine Inch Nails - the sound is less angry and more frustrated. Less screaming and more shouting. In other words, the musical emotions are present, but muted; less raw than anything NIN presents. I would almost say there's more of a Shiny Toy Guns vibe if I weren't afraid of people who take music seriously shouting at me in the comments. Eh, people are still annoyed at my lukewarm review of 'Thriller,' so I'll live.

This being said, it's all great stuff, opening with "The Space in Between"'s haunting ambiance, continuing with the grittier "Parasite," which incorporates more angry guitar; this is followed by "Fur Lined," one of the better tracks, which is one place where I'll think Shiny Toy Guns or - God forbid - Lady Gaga. Granted, I highly doubt the genius Reznor took ANY leafs out of Gaga's - er - book, but this fits right in with some of the bouncier techno/pop songs of the age.

"BBB" is one of my personal favorites, and I can't really figure out why. It might be the sexy vocals or alluring lyrics. Yeah, that'll be it. "The Believers" is decent as well, with some pretty deep and very natural-feeling experimental instrumentation to open. Bringing up the rear is "A Drowning," which can best be described as the easiest track on the record, if the longest.

Throughout this list, we're met with a solid sound quite distinct from the other records Reznor has worked on, which is always nice; I'd hate to tell you "This is a bad excuse for a NIN sellout." Thankfully, no such warnings are necessary. I can tell you confidently that 'How to Destroy Angels' sounds great, has tight production, and a nice break from the more emotionally direct works Trent has released. // 8

Lyrics and Singing: Despite distinct musical style, the biggest difference between Nine Inch Nails and How to Destroy Angels may just be the vocals. Instead of listening to Trent confess his emotional issues, we get to hear Mrs Reznor's pipes.

Her voice is a softer coo, more akin to Enya or other vocalists of the sort, if less Irish. This blends perfectly with the softer vibe of this EP. Quite honestly, if we had to hear Trent ranting darkly about how "I get everything I want when I get part of you" and whatnot, it would just be out of place..

Lyrics are exceptional for a side-project, and just what you'd expect from something Reznor put his hands on. Sure, he's not singing, but I highly doubt he had nothing to do with the lyrical composition and various other aspects of this EP.

This being said, I'm giving 'HTDA' an 8/10 for good lyrics, vocals which mesh perfectly and are half of what makes this record so enjoyable, and overall decent singer skills. // 8

Impression: Obviously, I can't draw comparisons to other How to Destroy Angels records, as they don't exist. I'm not even going to whip out Coil references or hold it next to 'The Downward Spiral,' because this is nothing like either.

Whereas Trent Reznor has everything to do with this record, it's as innovative as Nine Inch Nails and in different ways. Comparisons to other artists are certainly up for grabs, but for every "I've heard this before" moment, there were "Oh yeah, this is my groove; this is the new thing!" moments.

EPs are great because you can produce a few really great songs and stick them all on one CD, and that's exactly what 'How to Copy Other Artists' EP Titles' does. From beginning to end, this EP delivers the goods, though the standout moments are in "BBB," "Fur Lined," and "A Drowning."

Overall, quite a good EP, and they're offering it to you for free - you heard me - on their website. I highly recommend giving the album a spin and seeing what you think. It's not for everyone, like any record, but for fans of the genre and perhaps those wanting a look into the experimental side, this is an excellent choice. // 8

Vote Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No
Comment Post your comment
comments policy  37  comments posted
     
Iaroslav wrote on 07/09/2010 - 04:57 am / quote |
Great record, not a big fan of Reznor, but i actually liked this one a lot
     
EpiExplorer wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:02 am / quote |
Mariqueen Maandig.

I'm just gonna like, laugh for a minute then slap myself.

Anyway, I dont see why he has to do a side-project of industrial rock, when his main band was already a project of industrial rock.. Even if it is with his wife. But oh well, some musicians I just dont understand.
     
DualReaver wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:50 am / quote |
pretty disappointing only a few good tracks
     
Jyrgen wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:55 am / quote |
It's a decent EP. Looking forward to the upcoming full length album.
     
Offworld92 wrote on 07/09/2010 - 07:45 am / quote |
*sigh* I miss Nine Inch Nails so much...

When I listened to one of the songs on this EP (The Space in Between, I think), it sounded exactly - exactly like Nine Inch Nails, just with a different vocalist.

I don't like it... It just makes me miss Trent a lot.
     
willem93 wrote on 07/09/2010 - 08:00 am / quote |
Ah, Trent Renzor does it again

Who's Trent Renzor? I only know a Trent Reznor...
     
acefecoo wrote on 07/09/2010 - 08:59 am / quote |
pretty bad review
     
FearOfTheDuck wrote on 07/09/2010 - 09:45 am / quote |
willem93 wrote:

Ah, Trent Renzor does it again

Who's Trent Renzor? I only know a Trent Reznor...


Its a typo you egg
     
satyphan wrote on 07/09/2010 - 10:12 am / quote |
how is it a type if it's wriitten all over the review?
     
satyphan wrote on 07/09/2010 - 10:12 am / quote |
typo*
     
dottedeighth wrote on 07/09/2010 - 11:08 am / quote |
"...and some guy no one cares about called Atticus Ross."

Ignorance.
     
hak_hap wrote on 07/09/2010 - 12:39 pm / quote |
willem93 wrote:

Ah, Trent Renzor does it again

Who's Trent Renzor? I only know a Trent Reznor...


you're a pathetic teenager...yet your comment might be older than yourself....
     
Rockinguitar wrote on 07/09/2010 - 01:04 pm / quote |
His names is "Gerard Way Junior"...What you people expecting? Shakespeare?
     
JazzNick67 wrote on 07/09/2010 - 01:30 pm / quote |
I really liked the EP; it still felt very Nine Inch Nails-ish but with a much lighter vibe through the whole thing.

As for the review, it was pretty bad. I mean, come on, he spelt Reznor wrong through the whole thing! If you're gonna write a review or something for a website, you might as well use spell check. Also, no one cares about Atticus Ross? Really? Also, refrencing another band is not a bad thing, nor is it "ripping another band off".

Reviewer needs to learn a thing or two before anyone can take his opinion seriously.
     
Mythmaster30 wrote on 07/09/2010 - 02:53 pm / quote |
This is a very humorous and great review. i really like it. I also like the EP. Keep up the good work.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:40 pm / quote |
dottedeighth wrote:

"...and some guy no one cares about called Atticus Ross."

Ignorance.


It was sarcasm.

Rockinguitar wrote:

His names is "Gerard Way Junior"...What you people expecting? Shakespeare?


That's an outdated name, actually; I used to be a big MCR fan.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:41 pm / quote |
JazzNick67 wrote:

I really liked the EP; it still felt very Nine Inch Nails-ish but with a much lighter vibe through the whole thing.

As for the review, it was pretty bad. I mean, come on, he spelt Reznor wrong through the whole thing! If you're gonna write a review or something for a website, you might as well use spell check. Also, no one cares about Atticus Ross? Really? Also, refrencing another band is not a bad thing, nor is it "ripping another band off".

Reviewer needs to learn a thing or two before anyone can take his opinion seriously.


I did miss the typo; I'll go ahead and fix that. The thing about Atticus Ross was a joke. Lighten up.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/09/2010 - 06:43 pm / quote |
I've just sent a request for the typo's to be fixed. Thanks for all the feedback.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/09/2010 - 07:01 pm / quote |
Also, for those of you discriminating my name, I recommend you check out my lukewarm review of "The Black Parade." I would recommend my reviews for the other two records, but as old as those are, they don't apply anymore. I need to rewrite them.

Keep in mind that I joined this site several years ago and can't change my username.
     
Like I Is wrote on 07/09/2010 - 07:38 pm / quote |
There are so many pretentious jackasses on this site.

It's a fine review. Not a fan of the music, though.
     
anorexorcist15 wrote on 07/09/2010 - 07:45 pm / quote |
JazzNick67 wrote:

I really liked the EP; it still felt very Nine Inch Nails-ish but with a much lighter vibe through the whole thing.

As for the review, it was pretty bad. I mean, come on, he spelt Reznor wrong through the whole thing! If you're gonna write a review or something for a website, you might as well use spell check. Also, no one cares about Atticus Ross? Really? Also, refrencing another band is not a bad thing, nor is it "ripping another band off".

Reviewer needs to learn a thing or two before anyone can take his opinion seriously.

i dont reznor is in the dictionary so spell check wouldnt pick it up lol
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/09/2010 - 07:56 pm / quote |
anorexorcist15 wrote:

JazzNick67 wrote:

I really liked the EP; it still felt very Nine Inch Nails-ish but with a much lighter vibe through the whole thing.

As for the review, it was pretty bad. I mean, come on, he spelt Reznor wrong through the whole thing! If you're gonna write a review or something for a website, you might as well use spell check. Also, no one cares about Atticus Ross? Really? Also, refrencing another band is not a bad thing, nor is it "ripping another band off".

Reviewer needs to learn a thing or two before anyone can take his opinion seriously.
i dont reznor is in the dictionary so spell check wouldnt pick it up lol


No, no, JazzNick was right; it was a mistake I made repeatedly...in all honesty, I didn't know the guy's name until the last couple of weeks, and for some reason read as "Renzor." I've filed a request that the error be fixed.
     
bolezhinkov wrote on 07/10/2010 - 02:36 pm / quote |
its kind of refreshing to hear someone who isn't a die-hard NIN fan reviewing some trent reznor related stuff . . . I wouldn't have trusted this review as much if it was deemed to be a perfect record, actually.
     
Covin wrote on 07/10/2010 - 03:02 pm / quote |
NIN with female vocals
     
crazysam23_Atax wrote on 07/10/2010 - 04:56 pm / quote |
dottedeighth wrote:

"...and some guy no one cares about called Atticus Ross."

Ignorance.
It's called sarcasm, kid.
     
crazysam23_Atax wrote on 07/10/2010 - 04:58 pm / quote |
Like I Is wrote:

It's a fine review. Not a fan of the music, though.
It was one of the more professional reviews I've seen really. It didn't end being a bashfest or a all-out gushfest. It was neutral. That's how music reviews are supposed to be. So, I give Mr. Way a thumbs up.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/10/2010 - 06:07 pm / quote |
crazysam23_Atax wrote:

Like I Is wrote:

It's a fine review. Not a fan of the music, though.It was one of the more professional reviews I've seen really. It didn't end being a bashfest or a all-out gushfest. It was neutral. That's how music reviews are supposed to be. So, I give Mr. Way a thumbs up.


Hey, thanks. ^_^ That's what I strive for.
     
TheAbsentOne wrote on 07/11/2010 - 12:22 am / quote |
I like the direction this is going, hopefully their album with be better than the EP.
To me, it has a lot of low points where I'm kind of going "eh.." and I want to skip the song. It also makes me miss Trent's vocals..

Just got my ThisOneIsOnUs Another Version of the Truth DVD in the mail today too. Now I need to buy the physical copy of this EP, and I'll be set. *Happy*
     
iH8CarAccidents wrote on 07/11/2010 - 01:05 am / quote |
satyphan wrote:

how is it a type if it's wriitten all over the review?


Haha. You had a typo on the word "typo." How ironic.
     
Soundservant wrote on 07/11/2010 - 10:53 am / quote |
DualReaver wrote:

pretty disappointing only a few good tracks


"Few" good tracks?
So, like most of the EP?
     
kgesme21 wrote on 07/11/2010 - 01:12 pm / quote |
trent renzor and dave gorhl should join forces.
     
TheDissident wrote on 07/11/2010 - 09:37 pm / quote |
kgesme21 wrote:

trent renzor and dave gorhl should join forces.


no man that would su.... icwhatudidthar
     
alaub1491 wrote on 07/12/2010 - 04:47 am / quote |
kgesme21 wrote:

trent renzor and dave gorhl should join forces.


It already happened. Grohl is the drummer on many songs off of With Teeth.
     
benx3000 wrote on 07/12/2010 - 02:14 pm / quote |
It's free on their website. So it's worth the proce I guess. Nothing amazing.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/19/2010 - 12:49 pm / quote |
Reznor issue fixed.
     
Gerard Way Jr wrote on 07/19/2010 - 12:50 pm / quote |
alaub1491 wrote:

kgesme21 wrote:

trent renzor and dave gorhl should join forces.

It already happened. Grohl is the drummer on many songs off of With Teeth.


I believe that was the point. xD
     
Dogm@n wrote on 01/18/2011 - 09:57 pm / quote |
I think it is a decent record that shows promise for a full-length follow up. The first two tracks do sound exactly like NIN songs, but then it kind of takes on its own life. "A Drowning" is ****ing amazing. Reznor will never make terrible music.
Comment tools:    Post your comment (please login or register first):
biu
   quote
smilies =)
  

About

Help/FAQ

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

RSS Feeds  

Site Map

Link To Us

Tell A Friend

Advertising Info

Job Opportunities

Contact Us

Ultimate-Guitar.Com © 2012