10 Artists Who Hate Their Hit Songs. Part 2

We are our own biggest critics.

logo
Ultimate Guitar
10 Artists Who Hate Their Hit Songs. Part 2
14
These 10 artists created great hit songs and they wish they'd never done this. Check out Part 1 to find out more stories.

R.E.M. 'Shiny Happy People'

The song appeared on R.E.M. 1991 album 'Out of Time' and was released as a single in the same year. It peaked at #10 on the Billboard Hot 100, and at #6 on the UK Singles Chart. Despite the song's success, band members were ambivalent about being known for a pop song that lacked gravitas.

The legend has it that when R.E.M. submitted 'Out of Time' to the Warner Bros., the label said that they needed an extra happy, upbeat song for radio. The band then wrote 'Shiny Happy People,' expecting the label to reject it. But instead, the Warners loved it!

Michael Stipe told the BBC in 2016:

'It's a fruity pop song written for children. It just is what it is, if there was one song that was sent into outer space to represent R.E.M. for the rest of time, I would not want it to be Shiny Happy People.'
YouTube preview picture

Tina Turner 'What’s Love Got to Do with It'

The song was recorded in 1984 and was taken from Tina Turner’s fifth solo album, ‘Private Dancer’. It eventually became Turner's most successful single, topping the U.S. Billboard chart for three weeks in a row. It served as one of the defining songs of her solo career.

According to the rumors, Turner hated the track from the moment she first heard the demo tape. But her manager Roger Davies convinced her to cut her own version. In 2012, the song was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame giving Turner her third Grammy Hall of Fame Award and her eleventh Grammy Award.

Something tells us that Tina's hairstyle in the music video might be another thing that she hates.

YouTube preview picture

Madonna ‘Like a Virgin’

'Like a Virgin' is a song recorded by American singer Madonna for her second studio album Like a Virgin (1984).

In a 2008 interview with New York’s Z100 FM radio station, the singer said:

'I’m not sure I can sing 'Holiday' or 'Like a Virgin' ever again. I just can’t, unless somebody paid me, like, $30 million or something.'
She reiterated her dislike of the track in 2009, telling reporters:
'For some reason, people think that when you go to a restaurant or you are going shopping that you want to hear one of your own songs. It’s usually ‘Like a Virgin’ and that is the one I don’t want to hear.'
Considering what came after it (the 'Sex' book and 'Holy Water') it's only logical that Madonna would almost feel a bit awkward performing this classic hit. It didn't stop her, though, from including it on the setlist for her following two world tours.
YouTube preview picture

Sinéad O’Connor 'Nothing Compares 2 U'

This is a song written and composed by Prince for one of his side projects, The Family, for the eponymous album The Family. It was later made famous by Irish recording artist Sinéad O'Connor. Her version of the song became a worldwide hit in 1990. Its music video received heavy rotation on MTV. Its lyrics explore feelings of longing from an abandoned lover's point of view.

Sinead O'Connor announced in a Facebook post that she'll no longer sing 'Nothing Compares 2 U' because she doesn't emotionally identify with the song. The singer explained:

'I don’t want audiences to be disappointed coming along to a show and then not hearing it, so I am letting you know here that you won’t. If I were to sing it just to please people, I wouldn’t be doing my job right, because my job is to be emotionally available. I’d be lying. You’d be getting a lie. My job is to give you honesty. I’m trained in honesty. I can’t act. It just isn’t in my training. I have ceased singing other songs over the years for the same reason.'
YouTube preview picture

The Smiths ‘What Difference Does It Make?’

Morrissey has stated that 'What Difference Does It Make?' is among his least favorite Smiths songs. However, it became one of the band's first significant chart hits, peaking at #12 in the UK.

Morrissey told Following The Mozziah that he was not at all fond of this song's lyrics:

'What Difference Does It Make' is musically interesting but lyrically it is very...Simon Le Bon [Duran Duran]. I find the lyrics facile and mildly embarrassing. Otherwise, it's a majestic pop melody by Johnny and, ironically, had the lyrics indeed been penned by Simon Le Bon, I would probably cover it! As it is I'd feel too ashamed.'
YouTube preview picture

Coldplay ‘Speed of Sound’

'Speed of Sound' is a song written by British rock band Coldplay for their third studio album, 'X&Y' (2005). The band has admitted that they were trying to rip off Kate Bush's 'Running Up That Hill' but didn't quite get it right on this.

Chris Martin has said that it's one of his least favorite songs. To this day, Coldplay does not perform it in any of their concerts.

After being asked if any Coldplay songs had ever become hits that he personally thought were terrible, Martin explained that, while he thinks 'Speed of Sound' isn’t necessarily a bad song, it pains him to think that they never got it right on the record. He cannot bear to listen to the current recording or play the song live.

When asked why Martin’s reasoning was that the lack of enthusiasm would detract from the overall experience:

Chris Martin: 'It pains me.'
Howard Stern: 'Now, you have to play this in concert.'
Chris Martin: 'No, we don’t. We don’t play it.'
Howard Stern: 'Because of your feelings about the song?'
Chris Martin: 'Yeah, because, like I said, an audience can pick up real fast if you’re not convinced by something…'
YouTube preview picture

Kings of Leon 'Sex on Fire'

For Kings of Leon, fan insistence is probably the only thing keeping the song on their set list.

Nathan Followill, the drummer, reconfirmed in an interview for UK newspaper, The Sun:

'I would be pretty damn happy if my sex was never ever on fire again. Fans want it and you have to do it, and after so many albums together I can tell you, there’s a lot of debate about what records make it onto a set list. Everyone has their favorites.'

YouTube preview picture

MGMT 'Kids,' 'Time to Pretend'

NME named it a number-one song on its list of the Best Singles of 2008.

Andrew VanWyngarden said in his 2010 interview:

'It’s not exactly hatred here, but there’s not a huge amount of love either. ‘I’m not saying that ‘Kids’ and ‘Time to Pretend’ are stupid songs, but I think there’s at least partial irony and sarcasm. Now we’re 27. It’s hard to keep that naive-19-year-old-at-college philosophy going when you’re writing a second album.'
MGMT is less than thrilled to revive any of their songs from the record that made them famous in favor of composting material that is entirely non-reminiscent of their earliest and most popular work.
YouTube preview picture
YouTube preview picture

Radiohead 'High and Dry'

While his dislike of Creep is well-known, he also disliked another iconic song from their early period. It was originally written for Pablo Honey, but put aside as the band thought it sounded like a Rod Stewart song. However, while The Bends was being made, it was rediscovered and the original demo mixed and put on the album.

In a 2007 interview with Pitchfork Media, Yorke stated that he did not like the song, saying:

'It's not bad... it's very bad.'
He also stated that he had been pressured into including the song on The Bends.
YouTube preview picture

The Beatles 'When I'm Sixty-Four'

This was one of countless Beatles songs, written by Paul, that John Lennon hated. He referred to this track as 'granny music.' He also said that the song was 'Paul's, completely. I would never dream of writing a song like that.'
YouTube preview picture

49 comments sorted by best / new / date

    GR84
    Quite surprised about "High and Dry".... I really like that song actually, I don't need my music to be overly pretentious or over complex all the time, the simplistic of that song is nice, in my opinion there is not a dull moment on The Bends album. Oh well, to each their own. 
    Jazzmandtk
    Agreed.  The Bends gets my vote for best album of the 90s, and that's coming from a massive Oasis fan. High and Dry is a beautiful, simple song.
    milesak
    I used to hate that song so much. In fact, it was my only knowledge of Radiohead, and it took me a very long time for me to give them a chance just because of that song. It's just... Underwhelming.
    N7Crazy
    Same, I can respect Yorke's opinion, but personally I feel it helps create a cohesive vibe on the album, and it's a rather good song on its own
    AusMakka
    Yeah I was really surprised by this. We play it in our acoustic duo and love it!
    SlowJoe
    John Lennon was a bit of a cunt, by all accounts. He was write on that song though.
    MrPsych
    It's a bit sad how John disregarded many of the songs he'd written as "throwaways" when many of them are very nice. Another one of the songs John didn't like (and had absolutely no contribution to) is "Yesterday" 
    Downfault
    Well fortunately for Madonna, she is getting paid 30 million to sing those songs.
    Guns N' Chains
    Pretty sure Jani Lane of Warrant hated "Cherry Pie"
    Eifler121
    Yeah, but can you blame him? Plus, he never struck me as the loving kind.
    SlipOfTheLip
    He was one of the sweetest, nicest people you could ever meet. The label made him write the song. The CBS president at the time wanted a cheesy hit like 'Love in an Elevator'. So Jani wrote Cherry Pie in 15 minutes and next thing the album is Cherry Pie, along with everything else.
    sgtpepp3r1
     Bobby Mcferrin, hated his hit song Don't Worry Be Happy, he wrote it just to prove how easy it was to write a hit song using a formula, of course he regretted it, kinda funny.
    Anjohl
    Why would Madonna care which of her professionally written songs she lip syncs over on stage?
    Eifler121
    I like Speed of Sound. It was the first Coldplay song I heard. Didn't really like much after that.
    HardAttack
    Coldplay's 'Speed of Sound' is amazing. I'd love to hear Chris Martin explain to me what's wrong with it. It has a wonderful melody and it builds on itself as if it's getting bigger and bigger. I even like the acoustic performance of it.
    CoconutBackward
    " 'I’m not sure I can sing 'Holiday' or 'Like a Virgin' ever again. I just can’t, unless somebody paid me, like, $30 million or something.'  Like there weren't enough reasons to hate Madonna (I love "Holiday" and "Like a Virgin").
    MurphySanders7
    [deleted]
    MurphySanders7 · Aug 08, 2017 07:54 PM
    Anjohl
    He never really could do it justice live, even before the booze and food destroyed his voice.
    Eifler121
    Shiny Happy People is about the only R.E.M song I can stand.
    Glass_Ceiling
    It's a shame cause they have so much great and diverse material to choose from. Monster, New adventures in Hi-fi, Collapse into now, just to name a few remarkable albums.
    Eifler121
    I just could never stand them. I don't mean this in a rude way, but they're among my least favorite bands.
    Parthan
    I'm with you on this. Listening to REM has, for me, been the musical equivalent of having a conversation with someone who speaks just a bit too softly for you to clearly make out what they're saying.
    thetonto
    Monster is an awesome album, Bang and Blame is one of my faves, along with Orange Crush and Whats the Frequency Kenneth. Not very deep cuts, but they are excellent imo
    Pucky87
    I saw Coldplay live in Atlanta back in 2012. They definitely played Speed of Sound. They did change the arrangement and do it accoustic... and standing in a the middle of one part of the audience, which is a large part of why I remember it. Great show, though.
    The9
    Is it true Motörhead wouldn't play ace of spades?
    dmorseav
    No.
    slapsymcdougal
    Weeeeell.... Brian Robertson hated it, and didn't want to play it, which contributed to him leaving the bad. Lemmy certainly got sick of it, but he figured that he couldn't not play it, since he'd be pissed if he went to see his favourite band and they didn't play their biggest hit.
    19_skip_90
    Mr Bungle - 'Girls of Porn' should've been on the list too. Great song but they stopped playing it live.
    tomwebbsayshi
    I was actually very surprised by some of these, especially Speed of Sound/Coldplay and Time to Pretend/MGMT. Those are some of their best music IMO.
    Parthan
    It makes sense that Coldplay doesn't like Speed of Sound. It's the only one of their songs that isn't insipid junk. But Tina Turner hating What's Love Got to do with it... That makes me sad.
    paride.casale
    I actually knew that radiohead hated "Creep" EDIT:For fuck's sake I just found out that Creep was included in the first part of this article