Wednesday Question: Covers That Sound Better Than Originals

Votes and nominations inside...

logo
Ultimate Guitar
Wednesday Question: Covers That Sound Better Than Originals
28

For this week's traditional Wednesday Question, we'd like to kindly ask you folks to think about all the cover songs out there and answer this thing right here:

Which cover song sounds better than its original version?

THE RULES - post only one suggestion per comment after checking that your favorite wasn't already nominated (Ctrl+F and all).

Multiple nominations of one song create heavy confusion, since on one hand it's unfair to the given track to take into consideration only the most upvoted nomination, but seeing that multiple nominations allow one user to give two or more votes to the same tune, it's also unfair to other nominees not to discard it.

Finally, vote up the ideas you support and vote down the ones you dislike. We'll sum up your votes by Friday and bring you another classic UG top list. Show us what you got now!

796 comments sorted by best / new / date

    vulgardisplay19
    Obvious answer: All Along The Watchtower - Hendrix
    dewitt
    Sorry to throw this here, but since UG didn't say it in the article, I'd like to encourage people to sort by "New comments" (Yes, that's a thing now!) so that nominations that weren't posted so early have a chance at getting attention.
    Touchingcloth
    Totally agree! I'm looking at all of the latest posts and although there are some great suggestions, they're not getting a chance
    Touchingcloth
    Totally agree! I'm looking at all of the latest posts and although there are some great suggestions, they're not getting a Chance; maybe a token vote here or there
    ElPanda
    I read recently that when Dylan does that song now he does the Hendrix rendition. Not many people can out-Dylan Dylan.
    dial-a-death
    Or any cover of a Bob Dylan song really.
    estranged_2003
    dont talk pish
    dial-a-death
    I'm not. He's a decent song writer, but personally, I can't stand his voice. I would rather listen to Hendrix doing Watchtower, The Byrds playing Mr Tambourine man, and (although far from my favourite) Guns 'n' Roses playing Knockin' on Heaven's Door. It's just opinion.
    estranged_2003
    A decent song writer? come on, thats a bit understatement. I notice you mention 3 acoustic songs, albums like H61,bringing it all back home, blonde on blonde, blood on the tracks,desire,slow train coming,shot of love, as good as ive been to you, world gone wrong, oh mercy etc with a whole band behind him are very different. Although I may be a die hard fan i can understand people saying they are not a fan of his voice to say he cant sing is totally incorrect. Very few singers could have held 200,000+ in their hand at blackbushe or on the 1974 tour for example the way he done.
    kmitchell74
    a decent song writer. a DECENT song writer. Yeah, and Michael Jordan was pretty good at basketball.
    Hero_1985
    Yeah. I'm not even a Hendrix or Dylan fan, yet this cover is one of my favorite songs ever.
    bobafettacheese
    Gary Jules- Mad World, such a haunting song, in a good way.
    UmbraMachina
    I have to disagree. While it's a good cover, the mood almost feels forced as sad, while the original Tears for Fears version presents a much more complex soundscape that simply sounds more "mad".
    ElPanda
    True. The Gary Jules version is pretty good, but the original was more fitting. Even that trippy solo was cool.
    N-D
    Fantômas - Rosemary's Baby (Christopher Komeda cover) I can't decide what I like more - this or the cover of Nino Rota's "The Godfather" - the whole "The Director's Cut" album is just fantastically great! And yes, Mike Patton is just an insane genius!..
    cooper9934
    Not going to win but I totally agree. The directors cut is one of my favorite albums ever.
    Lensver
    Metallica - Am I Evil?
    13phogue
    Lets make it easy and say a majority of Garage Inc
    Hero_1985
    I would have gone with Turn the Page, personally. It does a better job of taking something and making it their own.
    dewitt
    Not any of the classic rock covers, though.
    dewitt
    Lol y'all actually like their Tuesday's Gone?
    momo_512
    I like it but as a tribute. But -to me- they butchered astronomy and whiskey in the jar...
    vikingman369
    lol, says the person who probably only knows "Don't Fear the Reaper" and "The Boys are Back in Town"
    momo_512
    Metallica fanboy much? I've got all discographies from both bands (and metallica too), is it a crime to have an opinion? I prefer these songs from thin lizzy and blue öyster cult, I dont understand why that would made me an incult... Don't insult people because their opinions diverge from yours But I'll add to my previous comment : I still like the covers metallica did, but it's far from being as good as the one I mentionned (to me)
    imbatman1312
    I always felt that song didn't translate from British to American so well, but I'm probably in a minority here as everyone seems to love the Metallica version
    Bronix32
    Hurt - Johnny Cash
    JJ1990
    One thing I love is that although both versions share the same lyrics, both have such a different tone and meaning. With the NIN version it tells a story of somebody who is lost and desperate in a world of drugs, reliving his hurts through addiction. With Johnny Cash's version it shows an old man who has had a great long life, filled with pain, love and regret. I wouldn't necessarily say one is better than the other, because both renditions are so excellent in their own way.
    primus182
    are you KIDDING ? the original is flawless with so much emotion from Trent
    yankmaddog
    Thank you for your sensible answer!!
    munkysquid
    The question is about covers that sound better than the original. Nothing wrong with the NIN version whatsoever, but I reckon the man in black felt it, channeled it and did it better. Love both versions regardless.
    N-D
    Sepultura - War (Bob Marley & The Wailers cover) Just raw and great...
    owen556
    Catamaran - Kyuss I really hope this doesn't get lost in this sea of comments, because this really is a tremendous cover and one of my favorite songs of all time. Pretty shocked to see this hasn't earned a single vote, it transforms the song into something more beautiful and sheer production and talent makes this cover so uniquely better than the original.
    N-D
    311 - Love Song (The Cure cover) The Cure's original is really great, but 311's version is much more soulful and deep in my opinion - just check it:
    metaldalz
    AMAZING cover, it's just sooooo good!! It took the song to a whole new level...
    Lateralus91
    Hallelujah - Jeff Buckley
    pariskoloveas
    Buckley did a great job, but it's nowhere near Cohen's original version.. The question is about covers that are better than the original, not "good covers".
    ElPanda
    Well technically Jeff's was a cover of John Cale's version of Hallelujah. Even Cohen said no one cared about that song until Jeff made it popular.
    toateridax2010
    *John Cale I have a lot of respect for Cohen as a songwriter, but I honestly prefer John Cale's version.
    erikhanz
    I'd say that John Cale's version is as good as either Buckley's and Cohen's versions. Maybe better?
    DrRockter
    Quiet Riot Cum on Feel the Noize
    dewitt
    I wouldn't say they did it better. Theirs is just far more popular today. They didn't even really change anything about it.
    cmvideo
    Easy - Faith No More. The original is good but they killed it with that cover
    dewitt
    How can it be better when the keyboard sounds like a simplified MIDI version, they cut one of the two verses out, and changed nothing else but "ooh" to "eww".
    Parthan
    FNM's version is basically a completely straight cover but with the piano parts simplified and one less verse. The cover is good, but only because the original song is great and there's nothing added to it by FNM.
    richriverkaraok
    This is my #1 cover of all time, the perfect balance of being true to the original yet making it your own.
    grim1
    Ugly Kid Joe- Cats in the Cradle, gives me goosebumps everytime i hear it. Plus, i hate the original
    kratos379
    Santana - Black Magic Woman It was actually originally released by Fleetwood Mac, which really surprised me when I found out. Both versions are great though.
    poopdog18
    The man who sold the world -nirvana
    starlessband
    Yea they do a great job with this, but IMHO the Bowie version is better. Especially the live one from SNL.
    JimBell
    Turn the Page - Metallica.
    yankmaddog
    Seager's is sooooo much better.
    dewitt
    I'm with you, man. I like it better than their Whiskey in the Jar or Tuesday's Gone, but it's not better than Bob Seger.
    Phaneron
    Metallica - Breadfan
    Waren
    Is everyone going to post all of Metallica's Garage Inc? Because most of their versions suck ass! Budgie's breadfan is so much better than Metallica's... it also applies to the Blue Öyster Cult covers (they sound horrid to me, and I listened to BOC's versions first).
    Phaneron
    Metallica is one of the most popular bands of all time. Of course there's going to be several songs from that album chosen for this poll.
    shanetvogel
    Whiskey In The Jar - Metallica. Originally by I think The Dubliners, then Thin Lizzy. Always been one of my favorite Metallica tunes.
    The-MathMog
    Isn't it an old folk-song too? If so, it's hard to say it's "better" than the original, when it has tons of forms.
    Caladryus
    Metallica's cover is good, but nowhere near the original
    steventhomas198
    I hate the Metallica cover. It's almost note for note the thin lizzy song so what's the point? Thin lizzy should have been the nominations here
    xwf
    Manfred Mann-Blinded by the Light
    The_Wilrus
    No No no no no. Sorry. I respect its your opinion but Manfred Mann butchered this song. Greeting from Asbury Park was rough and poorly mastered but the original is better. Check out a live version if the recording is to poor.
    MrPoopyButthole
    Muse - Feeling Good
    woody182
    I Ike it. But it ain't nowhere near better
    N7Crazy
    It's two very different versions - Personally, I prefer Simone's original, but Muse's is also great
    DMRIOT
    Ha. When I heard that on the radio when it came out I honestly thought it was a joke version in the style of Thom Yorke. I was howling with laughter and other people were saying it was incredible.
    dewitt
    I've always thought that Matt Bellamy sounds like a Thom Yorke knockoff (vocally), but people here call me crazy for thinking that.
    arcanom
    What makes you think that Matt sounds like knock off? I keep hearing this but never understand the logic behind it beyond similar vocal range and use of falsetto.. I think their delivery/tone is very different in style. Matt is more in your face while Thom sounds much more calm/soothing. Yes they get into each others territories time to time (For example Blackout-Muse verses sound like Thom) but their "distinctive" voices are similar at all. Especially Showbiz album sounds nothing like early Radiohead...
    dewitt
    I don't mean it in a bad way. I just don't know another word for it.
    GhostHost13
    Knockin' on Heavens Door - Guns 'n Roses
    jimmycourage
    I may be the only one but Guns n Roses' cover is my LEAST favorite cover of this song. Eric Clapton, Warren Zevon, even Bon Jovi do it better. I don't think GNR's version has any of the emotion that the song's lyrics would imply.
    jerome snail
    Anthrax - Antisocial
    jevticsava
    Limp Bizkit - Faith
    vertexjuggler
    I was going to suggest this but though I may get down voted into oblivion due to the LB hate
    Phaneron
    I think you'll find that quite a few people on UG have respect for Limp Bizkit but think Fred Durst is a douche.