Wednesday Question: Greatest Singing Drummer of All Time

Who's the best drummer/vocalist out there?

logo
Ultimate Guitar
Wednesday Question: Greatest Singing Drummer of All Time
10

For this week's traditional Wednesday Question, we'd like to kindly ask you lovely people to think about all the drummers who also sing lead vocals in their respective bands, and answer this:

Who's the best singing drummer of all time?

THE RULES:

  • Post only one suggestion per comment after checking that your favorite wasn't already nominated (Ctrl+F and all).
  • Multiple nominations of one song create heavy confusion, since on one hand it's unfair to the given track to take into consideration only the most upvoted nomination, but seeing that multiple nominations allow one user to give two or more votes to the same tune, it's also unfair to other nominees not to discard it.
  • Vote up the ideas you support and vote down the ones you dislike.

We'll sum up your votes by Friday and bring you another traditional UG top list. Show us what you got now!

177 comments sorted by best / new / date

    starfire666
    Phil Collins
    rodrigo.mij1990
    I can't believe that Phil has a higher vocal range than Peter's It was hilarious when I read that.
    ErnestoFidel
    Has to be the winner. Actually, most people would probably think of him as a drumming singer, not the other way around.
    rodrigo.mij1990
    You're actually WRONG. Phil is great as both a drummer, singer and songwriter. Even if he went far from his jazz drumming to a more motown sound
    ErnestoFidel
    I agree, that's not what I was trying to say. It's just that so many more people know him as a singer. So maybe he is mainly acknowledged for that. I myself enjoy his drumming way more than his singing.
    fieryfenderz
    I don't think there's a better answer. Amazing soaring tenor with complex proggy drumlines that also exceeds at pop and synthpop? Yes please. 
    Sebnam
    Roger Taylor
     
    ACartonOfEggs
    What's the standard for a gold comment award? By my count there are three other comments with much higher votes than this one.
    Candlewolf
    I am totally guessing but that the gold comment is awarded by a person, not automatically, so as the votes change, the comment should be updated. But it's not always. Nothing to lose any sleep over.
    FateDenied
    Brann Dailor of course.
    Krieger91
    *comes in to write Brann Dailor* *Sees Brann Dailor is the first comment* Well done! Seriously, he's amazing, not only in his ability to play like an incredibly good nutcase and sing pretty high simultaneously - "The Motherload" - But also his ear for excellent melodies (Word To The Fucking Wise)
    peppersghost08
    Lord knows Brann isn't flawless live, his voice goes flat, he's out of breath etc But he deserves to be here because god damn, he refuses to compromise and never half arses it. I don't know of another drummer that plays as complex while singing and pulls it off as well as Brann. The man is basically doing a marathon every night and then singing on top of it, so even if his voice isn't the best, he deserves to be here purely for the guts and commitment it takes to do that!
    FateDenied
    Im going to see Mastodon live first time this weekend so beside youtube videos i honestly have no idea how good/bad it's gonna be live. I have seen live videos were Troy takes his vocal duties on certain songs though. Still doesn't make Brann less of a madman.
    Pretelethal
    Brann performs all his parts live usually - at the start of the Emperor of Sand tour he got quite sick so Troy took over his more difficult vocal parts for a few nights. And then the whole band got sick so for a couple of days they sounded meh. But I assure you they're an incredible live band these days (even Brent sings kinda well live now)
    sweenster
    You will not be disappointed...I saw them on this tour and they were incredible. There was no bullshit and they just rocked you song after song and sounded damn good doing it.  Youtube videos rarely do bands justice and Mastodon is a serious example of that.  Have a great show!
    nickdipalo
    Don Henley
    David_Edick
    He's a dick
    GR84
    That doesn't exactly mean he's not a good singing drummer though ...
    dewitt
    Well, that's not what the question is about.  P.S. The "Post a comment" button doesn't work on mobile. Just refreshes the page. 
    Theo1967
    Levon Helm of The Band 
    lefty_138
    Let's see if this reply will post. He grew up about 2 hours from where I live. See, Arkansas ain't all that bad.
    gbaddeley
    Karen Carpenter
    flexiblemile
    Why did I have to scroll so far to see this! She's not rock and she's not a fantastic drummer but those were not requirements in this contest. No one sings like Karen Carpenter. That being said, I don't like the Carpenters
    inspiring
    Taylor Hawkins
    minkbs
    Came in here to nominate him; first one that came to my mind, I freaking LOVE his vocals on Have A Cigar!
    N-D
    Gil Moore (Triumph)
    Walldude63
    He may not be getting the votes but Gil Moore is easily the best singer on this list. Triumph was a vocal powerhouse between Gil and Rik Emmet... The Allied Forces tour was one of the best shows I have ever seen and their performance at the Us Festival just killed.. 
    starfire666
    Dave Grohl
    henrihell
    He is not the drummer in the band he sings lead vocals in.
    kraiga135
    He recorded all the instruments on the Foo Fighters first album, and he has some vocal work on the Them Crooked Vultures album
    Pickn_BlueGrass
    Buddy Miles
    TMoreau15
    It would be a serious oversight if Buddy Miles isn't on the list. He's fucking fantastic. I had never heard much music of that style before. I was in Toronto one day and was told I had to check out Kop's Record Store. I go in and it's a god damn vinyl library. I spent hours picking out records. I go to walk back downstairs and check out, and I hear some amazing music that happened to be Grand Funk Railroad's "On Time." I thought it was super groovy, I was pretty captivated, so I put back some records to get it. Then I go downstairs and Buddy Miles "Live" is playing and I was just awestruck. He was an exceptional talent and his music was so emotional. Whether it was meant to make you move or cry, it evoked a strong response. 
    Challenger440
    Anderson .Paak
    Shaico
    Oh shit, I didn't know he drummed. His drumming and singing is tight as fuck. 
    jamstation
    This guy is unreal for his dynamics, pocket and flow while he sings. Incredible independence. Phil Collins might be the greatest so far but Anderson .Paak may be the best in terms of technique.
    jeremy_allen
    Aaron Gillespie - Underoath
    LittleMartin549
    He is so good, because he is not just a backup singer like a lot of the other nominations, he is the lead singer. 
    irotinmyskin
    Sebastien Grainger - Death From Above 1979
    Anduinfeilds
    This was going to be my addition. His combination of melodic gritty vocals over groovy drum beats are heard nowhere else in the history of music. First thoughts were Collins, Dailor, Grainger, Henley.. wtf Henley's not nominated yet?! I'm taking him. 
    N-D
    Jen Ledger (Skillet) Not a fan but I think she should be mentioned
    Lgndkllr777
    Jen is a terrific drummer. She hits hard, has a ton of energy up on stage every night, and always keeps a smile on her face while performing. It's been a while since they've used it, but for a while she was doing all that playing and singing all while the platform the drumset was on rotated around on stage.
    conarmenti
    EASILY Levon Helm of the Band. Such a unique voice that dude can sing me the phone book any day.
    6.s8dashes
    Sebastian Granger - death from Above 1979
    SFosterS
    Came here looking for kickass Sebas... Death From Above was by far the most energetic live show Iv been too... and Iv see a few... 
    N-D
    Fred LeBlanc (Cowboy Mouth)
    wwstewart
    Without a doubt. Anyone who says otherwise hasn't ever been to their show...and should remedy that at the first opportunity.
    vivec1
     Léo Margarit is a killer singer when given the opportunity
    zack2k
    Singing drummer? He might not be known as drummer before he was popular but I got my vote for Marvin Gaye.