Usernames sucks
Tab Contributor
Join date: Jun 2010
12,735 IQ
#1
Hi is there anything like chatroulette for musicians, so jou can jam with random pepole over the internet? Sometimes you are just bored and alone and want a jam, and last but not least you learn alot from it... So is it anything like this?
mattrusso
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2012
615 IQ
#2
I don't think webcams or the internet are that efficient yet. The lag would probably destroy any hope of playing together in time with someone.
mattrusso
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2012
615 IQ
#4
Even if the latency is exactly equal, it still won't work as long as the lag is noticeable. For example, consider a situation where the two of us are doing this together. If I'm playing chords and you're playing melody, you're gonna play so that it's in time with the audio coming from your computer. To me, it's going to sound like you're late, and I'll try to fix the problem. Then to you, it'll sound like I'm speeding up...and so on. See what I mean?

It is a really really cool idea, though, and I hope it's possible someday!
Last edited by mattrusso at Nov 28, 2012,
sickman411
strč prst skrz krk
Join date: Jan 2009
395 IQ
#6
There's a thing called Jam with Chrome by Google where you can jam with friends using your computer keyboard. That's the closest I know of. You have to have a good internet connection though or there will just be an error message.
SomeBlueKind
Banned
Join date: Sep 2009
259 IQ
#7
Why would it even need to be video? Couldn't you just make it an audio stream so that the amount of data having to be transferred would be reduced, thus reducing and maybe even eliminating latency.
AJScott
Registered User
Join date: Nov 2010
1,383 IQ
#8
Quote by Usernames sucks
But isnt the latency equal for both? So if it dosnt happen at the same time in rality, it would seem like it for both of us?


No, it's not.

Internet packet streaming isn't consistent. Go run a speed test first time you might get 10.4mb/s next test you might get 9.8.

It's these inconsistencies that make this a bad idea. Until there is virtually no lag or no lag humans can perceive this won't really be a possibility.

Skype voice lag is around 0.3 seconds I believe (I read somewhere), have you ever tried to do some recording when you have latency issues? It's horrible it's just not possible to do.
WeTheGods
Dbag
Join date: Apr 2009
68 IQ
#9
I did a guitar class online back in high school, and there were two or three occasions that I had to jam with someone using our webcams. It was disastrous.
MrDo0m
Blessed Sisyphus
Join date: Jun 2011
772 IQ
#10
Seems like it'd be the coolest idea in the world, but lag has to ruin it for us. Hey, you could still post a pre-recorded file and have someone else jam to that.
Hail
i'm a mean bully
Join date: Jan 2010
431 IQ
#11
so would they run up and down scales back and forth or literally masturbate

since you said it would be like chatroulette and all
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
KG6_Steven
Eats ponies for breakfast
Join date: Nov 2006
3,130 IQ
#12
With a fast connection, the lag shouldn't be that bad. My nephew also plays guitar and hooks up with other guitar players online to jam together. Not sure what he uses.
Leather Sleeves
Tab Contributor
Join date: Oct 2007
858 IQ
#13
I thought about using skype for this once, apparently the program is equiped with noise-cutting technology which makes instruments inaudible. I've never tried it myself though, I think lag alone would make it impossible.
Slashiepie
Banged
Join date: Apr 2011
492 IQ
#14
Quote by Hail
so would they run up and down scales back and forth or literally masturbate

since you said it would be like chatroulette and all


hhh makes sense, instead of dicks you would see... well dicks, dicks playing scales..

T.S: Concepts like that are being worked on:

http://www.ejamming.com/

EJamming’s technology focuses on the problem of latency. On the standard Internet, it takes a nontrivial amount of time for data to travel from one person to another. And the larger the files, the more travel time it takes, as anyone who has watched video online can attest. EJamming tries to minimize latency on a few different fronts, Glueckman says, although since the technology is proprietary, the company would only provide overviews of its approach.

First, the eJamming software decreases the file sizes sent over the network. To do this, the company’s engineers developed their own compression and decompression algorithms that shrink the file size, yet still maintain an audio quality higher than MP3, a common compression scheme, says Glueckman. Second, each musician is directly connected with the other musicians in a jam session, instead of being routed through a server. This peer-to-peer configuration “results in a lower latency by routing the audio stream directly to your jam mates rather than, on average, doubling that transport latency by directing the audio stream through a remote server,” says Bill Redmann, chief technology officer of eJamming.

I don't know how true that is, and how well or bad it translates to reality but:

If people can friggin hit a flying plasma ball with a laser in the air while dodging rockets and bouncing off the walls, with pings of 200+ on Unreal Tournament, musicians can find a way to circumvent the lag.

I dont know how modern games are tackling this problem, but i a m sure they have specific "unlagged" code to compensate lost packets and instable connections, wont be long before someone nails it for musical purpouses.
Quote by Hail
i'm the internet equivalent of ripping the skin off my face and strangling you with it right now


Quote by Steve Albini
Remixing is for talentless pussies who don't know how to tune a drum or point a microphone.
Last edited by Slashiepie at Nov 29, 2012,
food1010
Bassist
Join date: Jun 2007
1,660 IQ
#15
I think the best way to eliminate the latency issue would be to record loops and send them back and forth. Of course, then you would sacrifice one of the most important aspects of jamming, which is the immediate cause/reaction that you get by playing simultaneously.

The problem is, even a tiny bit of a delay can throw off your timing significantly.
Only play what you hear. If you don’t hear anything, don’t play anything.
-Chick Corea