Page 2 of 2
wolflen
one note away from satori
Join date: May 2008
11 IQ
#41
somewhere in the book chord chemistry..ted greene does an analysis on a song he arranged..now there is a chord in the progression that "doesn't belong" to the key of the song..ted says .. he experimented and this chord sounded good..ted rarely used the term mode..and for good reason..he stressed creativity/experiment over written theory rules..and found little wrong with chord progression that don't follow rules if they sound good..

ernest toch in his book "the shaping forces in music" says the same thing but in a more classical setting..with examples of the classical masters..

not to say ted didn't follow theory rules...he did indeed..he just knew they are not absolute..

play well

wolf
Last edited by wolflen at Jan 25, 2013,
Arby911
Finding the Pattern
Join date: Jul 2010
830 IQ
#42
Quote by AeolianWolf


an extreme example, perhaps, but the point still stands - anybody can edit wikipedia. if i went there right now and edited out all of the instances of the word "mode mixture", it would go largely unnoticed.


Let's try an experiment. Go do it. See how long it stands.

I'm betting less than 24 hours.

Wikipedia has it's flaws, but by its very nature is continuously self-correcting, contrary to your inference.

As to the OP, damned if I know. I generally come here to lurk, learn and amuse myself by reading the mode arguments...
“Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.”
Charles Darwin
20Tigers
1
Join date: Jun 2008
640 IQ
#44
Quote by wolflen
somewhere in the book chord chemistry..ted greene does an analysis on a song he arranged..now there is a chord in the progression that "doesn't belong" to the key of the song..ted says .. he experimented and this chord sounded good..ted rarely used the term mode..and for good reason..he stressed creativity/experiment over written theory rules..and found little wrong with chord progression that don't follow rules if they sound good..

ernest toch in his book "the shaping forces in music" says the same thing but in a more classical setting..with examples of the classical masters..

not to say ted didn't follow theory rules...he did indeed..he just knew they are not absolute..

play well

wolf

Just curious, what are the theory rules you're talking about?
Si
Angusman60
I think, therefore, I am.
Join date: Aug 2004
987 IQ
#45
Perhaps general counterpoint and general harmonic function rules?
2010 Gibson SG Honeyburst
I'm a musician, a composer, and a theory nut. Pleased to meet you! Check out my websites and drop me a line.

"The essence of all beautiful art, all great art, is gratitude. " ~ Freidrich Nietzche


My Website
白い雲
Registered User
Join date: Apr 2008
174 IQ
#46
wolflen made a mistake, he broke the rule that you're not allowed to say "rules" when talking about theory
wolflen
one note away from satori
Join date: May 2008
11 IQ
#47
Quote by 20Tigers
Just curious, what are the theory rules you're talking about?



the usual suspects...

rule 1: there are no rules

rule 2: forget rule one
mdc
UG's Mr Chord Man
Join date: Feb 2008
722 IQ
#48
Quote by wolflen
somewhere in the book chord chemistry..ted greene does an analysis on a song he arranged..now there is a chord in the progression that "doesn't belong" to the key of the song..ted says .. he experimented and this chord sounded good..ted rarely used the term mode..and for good reason..he stressed creativity/experiment over written theory rules..and found little wrong with chord progression that don't follow rules if they sound good..

ernest toch in his book "the shaping forces in music" says the same thing but in a more classical setting..with examples of the classical masters..

not to say ted didn't follow theory rules...he did indeed..he just knew they are not absolute..

play well

wolf

I've been listening to some Howard Roberts recently, amazing jazz player.

He says that through thematic development, anything will work over anything. Through voice leading any chord will go to any chord.
the usual suspects...

rule 1: there are no rules

rule 2: forget rule one

I love this. Thank you.