Billwallace89
Go Blackhawks!
Join date: Nov 2010
666 IQ
#1
I have a Samson CO1U USB mic and a Scarlett 2i4.
Is micing the acoustic gonna sound better than DI?
When I record with teh Samson now, it gives me a really dull/flat sound. It's almost muffled sounding. I'm not looking for any crazy sound, I really just want it to sound like my acoustic sounds when I'm playing it.
Gear:
Fender Telecaster w/ Dual Gibson Humbuckers
Ovation Celebrity Acoustic/Electric
Fender Frontman 212R
Band(s):
Old Too Young (Folk/Bluegrass/Punk)
The Orange Line (Stoner Metal/Punk/Alternative)
kyle62
Need a dispenser here!
Join date: May 2007
1,619 IQ
#2
Depends what mics you buy!

The C01U is definitely a bit of a bland mic, but nothing a bit of EQ can't fix. I'd look at your mic placement before I started questioning the mic/preamp.
Billwallace89
Go Blackhawks!
Join date: Nov 2010
666 IQ
#3
I'm considering selling my Samson and my Peavey and trying to get an SM58. Will that be decent for acoustic or is that a vocal/amp only mic?
And I was looking at another recent post about recording acoustic and I saw that it's better to put the mic about "14 inches from the hole". I've been recording directly in front of it. Would that cause that muffled sound?
And I'm still very new at using EQ. Any suggestions on a preset?
Gear:
Fender Telecaster w/ Dual Gibson Humbuckers
Ovation Celebrity Acoustic/Electric
Fender Frontman 212R
Band(s):
Old Too Young (Folk/Bluegrass/Punk)
The Orange Line (Stoner Metal/Punk/Alternative)
kyle62
Need a dispenser here!
Join date: May 2007
1,619 IQ
#4
Quote by Billwallace89
I'm considering selling my Samson and my Peavey and trying to get an SM58. Will that be decent for acoustic or is that a vocal/amp only mic?
And I was looking at another recent post about recording acoustic and I saw that it's better to put the mic about "14 inches from the hole". I've been recording directly in front of it. Would that cause that muffled sound?
And I'm still very new at using EQ. Any suggestions on a preset?

The SM58 is a big step down for both acoustic guitar and vocals. Don't bother.


Recording out of the soundhole will give you a dark, boomy sound, yes.

I suggest you start with the mic aimed squarely at the 12th fret from about 10 inches away. For a bighter sound, angle away from the body/soundhole. If it sounds too thin, aim it towards the body.
Billwallace89
Go Blackhawks!
Join date: Nov 2010
666 IQ
#5
Thanks.
I was prepared to get the SM58. It seems to be highly recomended on these forums.
Would you maybe have another suggestion for a mic? The acoustic recording isn't as important as the vocals, but I'd still like to do acoustic here and there.
Gear:
Fender Telecaster w/ Dual Gibson Humbuckers
Ovation Celebrity Acoustic/Electric
Fender Frontman 212R
Band(s):
Old Too Young (Folk/Bluegrass/Punk)
The Orange Line (Stoner Metal/Punk/Alternative)
kyle62
Need a dispenser here!
Join date: May 2007
1,619 IQ
#7
I can highly recommend the guitarist Jay Graydon's website for some expert recording advice:

It's a very comprehensive set of articles and he's a kick ass guitarist.
None of that is advice, more just information about a guitarist's personal setup




The SM58 is a great mic for live vocals. It can work well in the studio with certain vocalists in specific circumstances.

If you want a dirt-cheap way of getting nice acoustic tone, you can get a pair of Behringer C2s for around £40. They're a surprisingly decent little condenser mic, and you could arrange them in a stereo pair to capture your guitar from two different angles that can then be mixed or panned together.
Sethis
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2011
171 IQ
#9
Quote by Billwallace89
I have a Samson CO1U USB mic and a Scarlett 2i4.
Is micing the acoustic gonna sound better than DI?
When I record with teh Samson now, it gives me a really dull/flat sound. It's almost muffled sounding. I'm not looking for any crazy sound, I really just want it to sound like my acoustic sounds when I'm playing it.


I don't really like an acoustic g recorded from its pickups. Imo an acoustic recorded with almost any mic will sound better.
Sethis
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2011
171 IQ
#10
Quote by kyle62
The SM58 is a big step down for both acoustic guitar and vocals. Don't bother.


I don't really think it's a step down. I haven't heard the SM58 but I've heard what the SM57 can do and they're pretty similar. I think they just have different uses. The condenser will give a fuller sound that will sound great on a song with just one guitar but the SM58 will give a brighter sound that can sit nicely in a dense mix.

But as you said I'd prefer a condenser as a general acoustic/vocal mic for recording since he can get only one.
Last edited by Sethis at Feb 18, 2013,
ChemicalFire
King of Bacon Pancakes
Join date: Oct 2007
5,773 IQ
#11
Quote by Sethis
I don't really think it's a step down. I haven't heard the SM58 but I've heard what the SM57 can do and they're pretty similar. I think they just have different uses. The condenser will give a fuller sound that will sound great on a song with just one guitar but the SM58 will give a brighter sound that can sit nicely in a dense mix.


*facepalm*
All I want is for everyone to go to hell...
...It's the last place I was seen before I lost myself



Quote by DisarmGoliath
You can be the deputy llamma of the recordings forum!
Billwallace89
Go Blackhawks!
Join date: Nov 2010
666 IQ
#12
I've heard the C2's are only good for vox if you have an EQ preset. Is there any other mic that'll give me a good dry recording in that price range?
Gear:
Fender Telecaster w/ Dual Gibson Humbuckers
Ovation Celebrity Acoustic/Electric
Fender Frontman 212R
Band(s):
Old Too Young (Folk/Bluegrass/Punk)
The Orange Line (Stoner Metal/Punk/Alternative)
DickinsonSound
Recording Engineer
Join date: Feb 2013
10 IQ
#13
Recording an acoustic guitar depends entirely on where it is going to sit in the mix, the genre and the room.

I'm going to guess from your set up you don't have any other mics - and that is okay. What has been suggested so far is the best way - with one mic I would go for about 6-10inches (depending on your playing style) from 12th fret. The higher up the neck you go you'll get more string sound and a less transient recording - closer to the sound hole you will get move booming body noise.

Re: the shure 57/58 debate...
SM57 and an SM58 are the same mic. As in..the same apart from one having a pop shield (58) the other having a grill. These will sound muffled on an acoustic guitar and if you are purchasing a mic for acoustic only - there are plenty of other options on the market. (If you are after something multi-purpose - can't go wrong with them or a beyerdynamic 201. The 201 is more a go-to mic for me than a shure. But as with anything in recording...it depends on everything!)

Another point to note - you say you like the way it sounds to you, so try putting the mic by your head. That's where your ears are - and that is mic placement 101, if unsure stick your head in and find out =D.

Let us know how you get on, and post samples on soundcloud for us to hear!

JD
Billwallace89
Go Blackhawks!
Join date: Nov 2010
666 IQ
#14
Thanks. I'll try sticking the mic by my head and see what I can get with that. I'll definately post something for you guy when I do.
Gear:
Fender Telecaster w/ Dual Gibson Humbuckers
Ovation Celebrity Acoustic/Electric
Fender Frontman 212R
Band(s):
Old Too Young (Folk/Bluegrass/Punk)
The Orange Line (Stoner Metal/Punk/Alternative)
axemanchris
Awwww.... NOW what?!
Join date: Aug 2006
2,471 IQ
#15
Quote by DickinsonSound
Recording an acoustic guitar depends entirely on where it is going to sit in the mix, the genre and the room. ...
Let us know how you get on, and post samples on soundcloud for us to hear!

JD


This... ^

CT
Could I get some more talent in the monitors, please?

I know it sounds crazy, but try to learn to inhale your voice. www.thebelcantotechnique.com

Chris is the king of relating music things to other objects in real life.
roaraudio
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2012
289 IQ
#16
Hey TS.
You really should, if your capable, have someone else play the guitar whilst you walk around the room to find the three spots where the guitar sounds best. Mark those spots and then determine which is the best. Get the guitarist to sit there.

Microphone choice is only half the battle.
That said you can't go wrong with a figure 8 pattern in front and a omni pattern next to the head, headstock side.
roaraudio
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2012
289 IQ
#17
p.s. My mic choice and placement will get you full bodied lower frequencies and crisp highs.
Brilliant sound for acoustic music.
DisarmGoliath
Disarms Goliaths
Join date: Dec 2008
1,411 IQ
#18
So many random snippets of poor advice/assumption here (if I don't quote you in this post, I'm not talking about you, though you probably know this anyway based on what you said ). In reverse chronological order...


Quote by Billwallace89
I've heard the C2's are only good for vox if you have an EQ preset. Is there any other mic that'll give me a good dry recording in that price range?

Whoever told you this was talking out of their arse - EQ should never be used with presets because every project/mix/audio signal is different and no one EQ preset will work best in any situation other than (potentially) the one it was created for.

Quote by Sethis
I don't really think it's a step down. I haven't heard the SM58 but I've heard what the SM57 can do and they're pretty similar. I think they just have different uses. The condenser will give a fuller sound that will sound great on a song with just one guitar but the SM58 will give a brighter sound that can sit nicely in a dense mix.

But as you said I'd prefer a condenser as a general acoustic/vocal mic for recording since he can get only one.

Actually, if anything condenser mics are brighter than dynamics as they have an extended high frequency response up to, and usually exceeding, 20KHz whereas most dynamics roll off around 15KHz or lower, quite significantly.

Quote by Sethis
I don't really like an acoustic g recorded from its pickups. Imo an acoustic recorded with almost any mic will sound better.

Depends on the situation - if you want a bright, up-front acoustic sound that doesn't need to sit wide/in stereo in the mix, then it is often better to DI it... especially if the preamps on the guitar are good (which is often the case in more expensive electro-acoustics).

Quote by StuartBahn
I can highly recommend the guitarist Jay Graydon's website for some expert recording advice: http://www.jaygraydon.com/guitatxt.htm#Recording

It's a very comprehensive set of articles and he's a kick ass guitarist.

Well, that's a lovely advert but it's not particularly helpful here...

Quote by Billwallace89
Thanks.
I was prepared to get the SM58. It seems to be highly recomended on these forums.

Don't worry, we're doing our best to rectify that
Hey, look. Sigs are back.