West Riding
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2013
80 IQ
#1
Obviously it's just a matter of taste and personal opinion, but who do you think has produced the best bands, England or America?
West Riding
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2013
80 IQ
#3
Both. Also a mixture of the two have been very successful, for example The a Jimmy Hendrix Experience, jimmy obviously bring an American and the drummer/bassist English. Also Fleetwood Mac.
baconblue
Registered User
Join date: Nov 2012
10 IQ
#4
Best is a weird term - what about Most Influential - in modern times this has gotta be the the English bands
IdigClapton99
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2014
10 IQ
#5
I agree that both America and England have brought forth some of the most legendary titles in music history. Yes, the names Chuck Berry, Elvis Presley, Jerry Lee Lewis, Roy Orbison, et cetera have contributed to the roots of the entire Rock genre, but, England's part (in my opinion) has had a greater influence upon the music we music "addicts" (Can we really live without it? Is there any other reason as to why you registered onto this website?) know and love. From Elvis, Chuck Berry, and many others, came (most notably) The Beatles and The Rolling Stones. The members of these bands were some who were directly influenced by the American Rock legends of the 1950s. From these two supergroups came artists like The Who, The Kinks, The Animals, The Velvet Underground, Fleetwood Mac, Black Sabbath (who eventually created the genre of Metal due to their heavy sound) , CREAM, The Yardbirds, who established the careers of Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck, and Jimmy Page (Clapton: Derek and the Dominos, Beck: solo, Page: Led Zeppelin). With these groups and others, this created the LA Rock scene in the late '60s (The Doors, Jefferson Airplane, Fleetwood Mac (Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham), etc.) and heavier artists like Aerosmith and Alice Cooper.
Last edited by IdigClapton99 at Jan 10, 2014,
BooM13
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2014
10 IQ
#6
I believe that this process changes the winner cyclical, it changes over time (20-30 years). The previous stage was for the Americans, the British and now begins.
Although my favorite, regardless of the time - this is America))
gsutke503
Registered User
Join date: May 2011
90 IQ
#7
I agree the scene is in a constant state of evolution. A songwriter borrows little snippets from the past and plays it to his style and that influences everyone else to continue to borrow and when that gets overplayed we move onto the next plane.

But...the American brand is king!
CJGunner7
Registered User
Join date: Mar 2013
30 IQ
#9
I think America has produced more successful bands but for me the UK has produced far more great bands
"Music Without Emotion Is Like Food Without Flavour"
Paul Gilbert
Domguy99
Power/Symphonic Metaller
Join date: Mar 2014
30 IQ
#10
England's had some great bands, they definitely beat America, especially when it comes to classic rock. That's just my opinion.
gsutke503
Registered User
Join date: May 2011
90 IQ
#11
Also - - England (historically) doesn't seem to have had a jam scene in the likes of what the Grateful Dead grandfathered. In fact check out the whole GD Europe 72 collection...the crowds were practically starving for country rock/ psychedelic rock/ folk/ blues/ and all other genres an average dead show threw at ya!
plaidypus
Registered User
Join date: Mar 2014
10 IQ
#13
Probably England. Can't say that any of my top five favourite bands have been from anywhere but there...