Page 16 of 16
scroungemonkeys
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2003
66 IQ
#602
I can look at it and tell you it is wrong....

it is minor.....

Am7b9/Bb
or would you call it Am7/Bb (since you are stating the flatted 9th in the bass?)
Quote by bananajammin
wow

we need more of these givers of correct, thorough advice on UG
scroungemonkeys
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2003
66 IQ
#604
can I just post now since I was right....I use that chord like every other day hehe.....
Quote by bananajammin
wow

we need more of these givers of correct, thorough advice on UG
scroungemonkeys
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2003
66 IQ
#606
ok you will have trouble with this chord

7
0
4
0
5
0

it leads to
4
5
4
0
x
x
if that helps
Quote by bananajammin
wow

we need more of these givers of correct, thorough advice on UG
Punkarse
UG's Sarcastic Vigilante
Join date: Jul 2004
25 IQ
#608
I would call that first chord an E7, it's just missing the third, which is introduced with the next chord.
The above user has physical deformities, which make any crude, sarcastic or offensive comments actually the fault of the threadstarter. Honest.
JmP's Evil Picnic (you know you want to...)
scroungemonkeys
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2003
66 IQ
#609
I will accept that it functions that way as well...
I would have also accepted E7 with the third omitted just changing the voicing....

EDIT: Seth got it first.....
Quote by bananajammin
wow

we need more of these givers of correct, thorough advice on UG
Punkarse
UG's Sarcastic Vigilante
Join date: Jul 2004
25 IQ
#611
No, no, you got it. I'm feeling lazy today.
The above user has physical deformities, which make any crude, sarcastic or offensive comments actually the fault of the threadstarter. Honest.
JmP's Evil Picnic (you know you want to...)
scroungemonkeys
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2003
66 IQ
#613
nope I am leaving for skewl...go for it punk
Quote by bananajammin
wow

we need more of these givers of correct, thorough advice on UG
Punkarse
UG's Sarcastic Vigilante
Join date: Jul 2004
25 IQ
#614
OK, a quickie=


e--2------------
B--0------------
D--2--------------
G--1-----------
A--2-------------
E--0---------
The above user has physical deformities, which make any crude, sarcastic or offensive comments actually the fault of the threadstarter. Honest.
JmP's Evil Picnic (you know you want to...)
casualty01
Here all along
Join date: Apr 2002
2,622 IQ
#615
Originally posted by Punkarse
OK, a quickie=


e--2------------
B--0------------
D--2--------------
G--1-----------
A--2-------------
E--0---------



Emaj (9)


Originally posted by The_Strat_Man
Did I get the chord, or not?

Sounds good to me ^


no, you didn't

Originally posted by scroungemonkeys
I can look at it and tell you it is wrong....

it is minor.....

Am7b9/Bb
or would you call it Am7/Bb (since you are stating the flatted 9th in the bass?)


oh lord... not you again.

anyways neither did you....


seriously, does function count for anything anymore?

it's a STOCK fucking C7 inversion. it just so happens to have the 13 in the melody. ergo C7(13)

look at JUST a dom7 voicing on the upper strings


--6--
--5--
--5--
--5--
-----
-----


^^ now, if you look at that and call it an Amin7b9 you're retarted. yes, it COULD be called that out of technicality. but it's like calling this chord


-----
-----
--0--
--2--
--3--
-----


an Emin#5/C

could that be a name? yeah, sure. does it work? yeah, sure. is it what it is? no, not at all.

same with the chord slash posted. it's nothing more than a C7 3rd inversion with the 13th in the melody.

so... the answer is indeed C7(13)/Bb


NOT Am7b9/Bb

don't believe me? ok resolve it... resolve it to what a C7 resolves to, and then resolve it to what an Amin7b9 would resolve to... oh, thats right. that has name has no place or function other then in a modal setting.

for christ sake ... function lol. use your ears as well.... they DO help.

Cas-
Punkarse
UG's Sarcastic Vigilante
Join date: Jul 2004
25 IQ
#617
We must all repent [flaggelation flaggelation] Woe, woe...

Ok, having now purged myself, it's Cas' go. Or this might even be a good point to start a new thread.
The above user has physical deformities, which make any crude, sarcastic or offensive comments actually the fault of the threadstarter. Honest.
JmP's Evil Picnic (you know you want to...)
Punkarse
UG's Sarcastic Vigilante
Join date: Jul 2004
25 IQ
#619
OK, got it.
The above user has physical deformities, which make any crude, sarcastic or offensive comments actually the fault of the threadstarter. Honest.
JmP's Evil Picnic (you know you want to...)
The_Strat_Man
I'm back!
Join date: Jun 2004
1,574 IQ
#622
Originally posted by casualty01
silly bastards lol. everything was directed towards mr. Am7b9/Bb up there.. no one else.

Cas-


Meh, I called it A7b9/Bb.

EDIT:
PMin' Cas to archive this. Peace people. 32 pages of Name That goodness and it's being locked up...
casualty01
Here all along
Join date: Apr 2002
2,622 IQ
#623
Originally posted by The_Strat_Man
Meh, I called it A7b9/Bb.



you also "asked" if it was right and didn't go on to tell someone else they were wrong and then state with authority that you were correct. big difference.

I was addressing him on that whole thing. sorry if it sounded like I was thrashing you or the general NTT participants or anything

Cas-
The_Strat_Man
I'm back!
Join date: Jun 2004
1,574 IQ
#624
Nah, it's cool. I respect your musical theory a lot. Whether mod or not, you still help me and have my upmost respect (like Corwinoid).