Not bad. You guys can play.

I like Sarah Sees best. The guitar parts in the other songs are a bit repetitive. I'd like to hear a bit more melody, espacially in the solos. The synth in Sarah Sees gives the song more body. And I love the acceleration at the end. Hope? Anticipation? Very nice.

The second voice/backing vocal is a bit off in When we were Nocturnal and To Reconstruct. A bit too high. Not much, but enough to bother me.

The recordings are top notch. Especially for live. Impressive.
The drummer is your best trump. I like rock with varried drum patterns.
Also the lyrics are very good, and generally brought very well.

I like,

Lol, dude were from Pa, and have the same exact band name. Diffrent Country Band name dificulties.
Edit- nice music though.
pretty good sound i'd say. i agree with the above comment that it's kind of death cab-esque. particularly the vocals. it's pretty cool man, i don't know how hard it is to get support with that genre up in your part of the world, but it's cool man. seems like college kids would be into it.

anyway.. check ours out https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1154639