which pedal would be better to achieve a punk rock (green day) sound?

ibanez ts9 tube screamer
BBE green screamer

my amp is a traynor ycv40t and my guitar is a gibson sg

The Green Screamer has a somewhat "punky" tone to it if dialed in the right way. Can't say much for the others though.

Martin DSR
Taylor 214e
Fender Strat
Epiphone 335 Dot
Carlo Robelli Acoustic

1978 Fender Pro Reverb
Boss Blues Driver
Boss Super Overdrive
EHX Holy Grail
Boss DD-20 Giga Delay
i used to use an mxr 10 band EQ to get the green day sounds from American Idiot - the dirty but not really distorted tone. the 10 band has a gain control that a turned up and the rest was pretty flat, just a slight treble and bass boost.