#1
i play classic rock/alt country. I already have an OD pedal. Really have no interest in playing leads.

What other pedals would you recommend for rhythm guitar?

I play a MIM Tele into Champion 600.
#3
To me, any guitar without at least a hint of reverb sounds quite terrible. I'd also consider getting a chorus and delay like lyonk55 said, especially for clean sounds they can do so much for your tone.
#4
chorus,reverb,delay AND flanger is gd if u wanna add a lil twist to your songs etc.
#5
You should check out the Electro-Harmonix Graphic-Fuzz Pedal. Beutiful fuzz, reverb, and overdrive if you need it. Plus you can mess around and experiment with it forever to get that perfect tone.
#7
I'd get reverb. Reverb, IMO, is the best effect in the world and probably the only one I couldn't play without. A hint of reverb gives your tone a huge amount of depth and sparkle. And I use a tele/fender amp rig too.
#8
So today I went and got a Holy Grail Reverb and that was the ticket. I am havin some fun now.

MIM Tele > Boss BD2 > Holy Grail > Fender Champion 600.

I have found a couple combos that my ears lie. I am a smilin 40yr old.