#1
If you are brand new... I am old and decayed.
Always polar opposites.
I wish you wouldnt pretend that you knew,
it's tiring when you play these games- the thought,
its old.
Be something new. Not yourself, not someone else,
be something you've done before,
because you can't do anything,
that wasn't done before.
I wish you would stop repeating yourself,
and take my commands:
one, two, three.
Just listen already.
This is for every time, you thought you saw a shooting star,
and wasted a wish that will never come true,
this is for being something that you never knew.
#2
"because you can't do anything,
that wasn't done before."

Double negatives can be terribly hard to get your head around, or maybe it's just because I am tired, however, I would recommend altering that somehow.