#1
Seriously, ever since people starting saying how hardcore needs a makeover, it got me thinking. Most music has very little intensity, and too much heaviness. Anyone can make Heavy sounding songs, because there is a rough formula to it (Tune down, chug certain patterns, scream). On the other hand, it's hard to write songs where you can pull of emotions through instrumentation, and singing style. Bands are to afraid to sound light, so they bring on the chug, while they miss out on the intensity.
These aren't the same thing.

Ex. Emmure, Winds of Plague is heavy. No doubt.
Strike Anywhere, Title Fight is intense. They don't get as heavy, but they are not "lighter" or "less-hardcore"

See?
Thoughts?
#2
what about bands that are intense and heavy?
"If the good die young, we'll fucking live forever"

Quote by zezimathehero
Genital Warts > What Separates Me From You


Quote by zezimathehero
Genital warts, what separates me from you
#3
A lot of bands i would call intense belong more in the pop punk/emo forum... brand new can be very intense without being overly heavy for example.
#5
Botch and Converge are both, but I see what you're saying
Quote by emoboy027
Is fingering an emo chick that likes yoy and that has fallen in love with you is it wrong to you to finger her during lunch outside in front of everyone at the high school? would you not care or lol even wish it was you?

Youztoobz
MIDI Magicalness!
#6
this thread doesn't even make sense
good job rac
Quote by alm0st a skat3r
yeah i remember when i had a good conscience. now i dont give a ****

xxx
smoke weed, drink 40's, **** titties
#7
Quote by StonaLemons
A lot of bands i would call intense belong more in the pop punk/emo forum... brand new can be very intense without being overly heavy for example.

+1

They are my guilty pleasure.

And I agree with TS, but it depends whether you are judging from a studio recording point of view, or from a live performance point of view.
#8
you shouldn't feel guilty about listening to brand new
"If the good die young, we'll fucking live forever"

Quote by zezimathehero
Genital Warts > What Separates Me From You


Quote by zezimathehero
Genital warts, what separates me from you
#9
Forget where, but we've discussed this before... and, forgive me if I'm wrong, I thought this hardcore makeover was more to do with chord structure as opposed to heaviness? I also wouldn't exactly say that hardcore is the best place to be putting emotion through instrumentation. While it is possible, I'm just saying that's more a metal thing what with the solos and what not.
#11
Quote by waldorphPRS41
This. Best band ever.

this
"If the good die young, we'll fucking live forever"

Quote by zezimathehero
Genital Warts > What Separates Me From You


Quote by zezimathehero
Genital warts, what separates me from you
#12
Quote by Valderama
+1

They are my guilty pleasure.

And I agree with TS, but it depends whether you are judging from a studio recording point of view, or from a live performance point of view.


Out of all the bands you could decide to have a guilty pleasure of it's Brand New?
#13
Blood Brothers are pretty intense, but I wouldn't consider them heavy.
#14
Quote by Thebiz
Blood Brothers are pretty intense, but I wouldn't consider them heavy.

agreed. theres a 1000 bands that meet that criteria though.
"If the good die young, we'll fucking live forever"

Quote by zezimathehero
Genital Warts > What Separates Me From You


Quote by zezimathehero
Genital warts, what separates me from you
#17
Quote by MustangMan311
Emmure and Winds of Plague are poor examples of heavy.

Emmure and Winds of Plague are poor examples of music...
Quote by emoboy027
Is fingering an emo chick that likes yoy and that has fallen in love with you is it wrong to you to finger her during lunch outside in front of everyone at the high school? would you not care or lol even wish it was you?

Youztoobz
MIDI Magicalness!
#18
winds of plague is my guilty pleasure
"If the good die young, we'll fucking live forever"

Quote by zezimathehero
Genital Warts > What Separates Me From You


Quote by zezimathehero
Genital warts, what separates me from you
#19
Quote by Okeefe Is Legit
Especially since WoP plays in E standard.



Mother of Mercy plays in E standard and i'd say they are somewhat heavy
Quote by alm0st a skat3r
yeah i remember when i had a good conscience. now i dont give a ****

xxx
smoke weed, drink 40's, **** titties
#21
Quote by MustangMan311
...Dillinger plays in E standard, and they're one of the heavier bands out there right now. That has nothing to do with it.



+1
even better example.
Quote by alm0st a skat3r
yeah i remember when i had a good conscience. now i dont give a ****

xxx
smoke weed, drink 40's, **** titties
#22
When I think intensity, I think Infest (and bands influenced by them). When I think heaviness, I think Integrity (and bands influenced by them).

Both are good, but when combined in the right way they can be amazing.
#23
IMO, hardcore should be fast and passionate. Ceremony is one of the most intense bands out, and they do it but playing heaps slow with sick vox and the rest, where newer deathcore bands and metalcore bands have to tune to drop G and can't reach that point.
#24
Quote by Internal Chaos
IMO, hardcore should be fast and passionate. Ceremony is one of the most intense bands out, and they do it but playing heaps slow with sick vox and the rest, where newer deathcore bands and metalcore bands have to tune to drop G and can't reach that point.



+1
Yeah i'm pretty sure ceremony plays in standard, a half step down
Quote by alm0st a skat3r
yeah i remember when i had a good conscience. now i dont give a ****

xxx
smoke weed, drink 40's, **** titties
#26
Quote by Internal Chaos
IMO, hardcore should be fast and passionate. Ceremony is one of the most intense bands out, and they do it but playing heaps slow with sick vox and the rest, where newer deathcore bands and metalcore bands have to tune to drop G and can't reach that point.

**** THE GOVERNMENT WIIIIIIIIITH YOOOOOOOUR FIST!


So intense, love that band.
#27
Quote by Bignose
I also wouldn't exactly say that hardcore is the best place to be putting emotion through instrumentation. While it is possible, I'm just saying that's more a metal thing what with the solos and what not.

metalsolos =/= emotion
#28
^depends which ones you listen to.

i think if they're heavy through riffing, not chugging, it's good. i don't know of any examples in hardcore, but stuff like electric wizard, early sabbath. really heavy stuff, with rarely any palm muting and no overuse of open notes.
Quote by B4Dkarma
When you look at a guy and immediately go, "wow, what a douchebag"

that is what girls find attractive.
#29
Quote by Internal Chaos
IMO, hardcore should be fast and passionate. Ceremony is one of the most intense bands out, and they do it but playing heaps slow with sick vox and the rest, where newer deathcore bands and metalcore bands have to tune to drop G and can't reach that point.

That's pretty much what I was trying to say, but couldn't explain. You don't have to be slow or anything, but they have the whole intensity (better word:passionate) thing without chugging. They aren't the hardest band, but they put some of the most emotion in their music, something Drop-B bands can't do.
#30
Quote by MustangMan311
...Dillinger plays in E standard, and they're one of the heavier bands out there right now. That has nothing to do with it.

Judging by the definitions the TS gave, Dillinger would be intense but not heavy. At least for the purposes of this thread. I'm obviously far from an expert on them though.

EDIT: Never mind, I would think the terms "intense" and "passionate" would apply to entirely different aspect of music but apparently in this thread they mean the same thing, so I don't even know what we're talking about now.
My band, Escher
My progressive rock project, Mosaic

Quote by Lappo
clearly, the goal is to convert every thread into a discussion about BTBAM

BTBAM IS ALWAYS RELEVANT
Last edited by GodofCheesecake at Oct 9, 2009,
#31
Quote by GodofCheesecake
Judging by the definitions the TS gave, Dillinger would be intense but not heavy. At least for the purposes of this thread. I'm obviously far from an expert on them though.

EDIT: Never mind, I would think the terms "intense" and "passionate" would apply to entirely different aspect of music but apparently in this thread they mean the same thing, so I don't even know what we're talking about now.

Haha, you must have not listened to 43% Burnt enough, man.
#32
I can't really deny that.
My band, Escher
My progressive rock project, Mosaic

Quote by Lappo
clearly, the goal is to convert every thread into a discussion about BTBAM

BTBAM IS ALWAYS RELEVANT
#33
Interesting thread.
I think both are open to interpretation as well, but basic ideas are present to confirm RentACar's argument.

PERSONALLY
I find bands like The Carrier, Verse and Have Heart intense. They're not as fast, heavy, down tuned or even "evil" (no gore lyrics, or whatever people think is IN lately) but they're easily more intense than Suicide Silence or The Red Shore.
ON THE FLIP SIDE
I find The Acacia Strain to be both intense and heavy. A heavy band will make me want to mosh. An intense band will make me want to DO SOMETHING. Whether that "something" is punch a wall, scream, write a song, whatever, intense bands evoke emotional reaction (in my experience) where as heavy bands are just "empty" enjoyment.

If anyone understands what I'm saying, then rad.