What would be a good pedal for Weezer's Pinkerton style distortion, like from Getchoo?
Greatest. Weezer. Album. Ever. Yes, it's better than the Blue Album.

But anyway, I was watching a demo on proguitarshop.com just tonight for a Tortuga Yeti Fuzz-Stortion pedal and he started playing The Good Life, and it sounded exactly like it. However, I highly doubt that that pedal is in your budget, unless you have $300 to spare. But I think that a decent Fuzz/Distortion type of pedal would work just fine.

Just look through the demos for the fuzz pedals on their website and I'm sure you'll find one.

Quote by dullsilver_mike
The resonant frequency of the clitoris is too low for the guitar players to take care of.

Quote by jackers1234
you sir, have just won for this statement. =D

Young Knees