Black coffin case for $25 or Gator Deluxe GC-Electric-A for $40. Both in good condition. For my ESP LTD H-302

As of now I'm planning on just getting the coffin since it is cheaper, unless someone has a reason I should spring for the gator.
i'd get the gator just because it doesn't look as cheesey/stupid, but that's me. i would suggest SKB, but that's a lot more than your budget.
Gear :

Gibson Les Paul Special
Fender Koa Stratocaster
Korg Pitchblack
Dunlop 535Q Crybaby Wah
BBE Boosta Grande
Fulltone OCD v4
EHX Russian Big Muff Pi
Vox Night Train
Egnater Rebel 112x Cab
Marshall Class 5