Hey guys, I've got two instrumental recordings on my profile.

The first one (riff 1) was recorded badly with a micrphone attached to my pc, nearly complete.

The second one (riff 2) was recorded with a better microphone, but we played much worse.
The second one needs more done one it..but I would appreciate some points of view!

We have just started writing now.

The second I need most points of view, for example there's a clean pre-chorus, and I would like to know, from the outside listener if you think the tonality of the separate things fit etc.

As I said, riff 2 needs more work done (we only started doing yesterday) and it's played quite badly, but any feedback, constructive criticism etc would be nice!
Never imagine yourself not to be otherwise than what it might appear to others that what you were or might have been was not otherwise than what you had been would have appeared to them to be otherwise