#1
Hey guys.

Now i was looking at the tension between a set normal tension d'ddadario classical strings and a set of 8 guage electric guitar strings..

and the tension was around the same.

Setting tone issues aside.


would this damage the guitar if i was to put a set of electric guitar strings on a classical guitar?

say a set of guage 9 or 8.


I understand the tone won't be the most pleasant.

But I would like too know if this would cause damage to the guitar?


thanks again.

cheers.
98% of teens have been around or have had alcohol. Put this in your sig if you like bagels.

Originally Posted by Sol9989:
I cum blood
never gonna give you up,
all fap together
to 2 girls 1 cup?
#3
if they're the same gauge, probably not, but the strings won't fit the nut, tuners or saddle, intonation will probably be off, and the guitar will sound pretty bad. btw, the strings will cut into the saddle as it's not the kind made for wire. my husband says he's seen people break the tie block using steel strings and might wear out the frets very quickly.

btw, d'addario electric lights:
PL010 E 0.010 0.25 16.2 7.35
PL013 B 0.013 0.33 15.4 6.98
PL017 G 0.017 0.43 16.6 7.53
PNG025 D 0.025 0.64 20.3 9.21
PNG035 A 0.035 0.89 21.4 9.71
PNG045 E 0.045 1.14 19.2 8.71

139.1 pounds of pressure


and their hardest tension classicals, not normal tension
J4401 E 0.029 0.737 16.4 7.44
J4402 B 0.0333 0.846 12.5 5.67
J4403 G 0.0416 1.057 12.9 5.85
J4404 D 0.030 0.76 16.3 7.39
J4405 A 0.036 0.91 15.9 7.21
J4406 E 0.045 1.14 15.7 7.12

89.7 pounds of pressure

that would be 50 pounds less for the classicals, and you don't mention what guitar it is, cheap classicals don't always withstand hard nylon strings so well, either.
Quote by Skeet UK
I just looked in my Oxford English Dictionary and under "Acoustic Guitar", there was your Avatar and an email address!
Last edited by patticake at Jun 17, 2011,
#5
DO NOT DO IT, anything those strings touch - frets, nut bridge saddle, will wear down so fast
#6
It will broke, TRUST ME, I did it when i was a kid to my first guitar, intonation went crazy after a time, it couldn't stand the tension, and right now my guitar is hang'd on the wall of my studio, with more than 10 years without playing a single note. DON'T!
Since 2002 using UG. This page teached me how to play guitar and help'd me to embrace the passion of my life: Music.
#7
lol I had a kids classical guitar as a kid (go figure), a friend of the family who played bass ws asked to string it and he used steel strings. It didn't break, not sure if he ever put all 6 on it but even the 3 that were on it when I later on started playing had pulled the neck so much you needed some serious power to fret a note. A badly intonated one

Don't do it
I'm dancing in the moonlight
It's caught me in its spotlight
Dancing in the moonlight
On this long hot summer night


Martin D-28
Last edited by Chips- at Jun 17, 2011,
#8
It's like putting wheels on a cat - unnecessary and cruel. Your guitar will not appreciate the added tension and it will either break outright or be warped beyond belief, so do it only at your own risk of having your guitar licence revoked.
Last edited by beab at Jun 17, 2011,
#9
If the tension is indeed the same, it won't do any harm, regardless of the naysayers here.

But what's the purpose?
#10
I agree with Arby to a degree. IF the tension is the same, then it's unlikely you'll do any severe structural damage to the instrument. As Patti notes, the nut slots will be way too big, and you might get some rattle and buzz there.
If the saddle and nut are not of bone or something similar, you will experience rapid wear.

Waaay back when, in the 70s, my wife-to-be left "her" guitar (a nice Martin!) with her ex and was without a guitar. (I didn't play at the time)
She really wanted a guitar, and so I went out and bought her a used Suzuki classical at a music store. It had been strung with steel strings. We were both quite ignorant of guitars at the time....
Nonetheless, she played that little guitar for a couple of years till I started playing and we upgraded...
Now, the Suzuki was a sturdy little plywood thing and probably stronger than many "good" guitars.
So... If you want to experiment, go ahead. Might be a learning experience.
#11
do it! then post pictures of the guitar after it sits for a day. even if it does not snap or some other way destroy the guitar, the long term effects will be extremely poor.
#12
those of you that have done this, how would you tie them at the bridge securely?
Check out "thelastplaceyoulook" on YouTube, iTunes and [url="http://facebook.com/thelastplaceyoulook
"]Facebook
#13
I havn't done it, but if i were to try, I'd just tie it the same way you would normally tie classical strings. I don't see why it would not work.
#14
Quote by adambauman31
but why?


+1

No reason you couldn't just seems silly IMHO
Gear
Jackson DK2
Ibanez RGR320EX
Guild X82 Nova
Godin Seagull S6

Vox V847
Vox VT40+ / VFS5 VT


Quote by FatalGear41

Right now, there are six and a half billion people on earth who don't care what kind of tubes you have in your amplifier
#15
Yes the nut slot would be extra wide as the nylons are much wider guage.

and i can see the part would wear down. good point.

BUT!

for those of you who said the tension would damage it.

I CLEARLY said that the strings would be the same tension.

not a set of tens.

but 8's or 9's,

most likely 8's

haha.


mm yes sounds very much an un easy task.

thanks for your input very impressed haha.

sounds like it's a shit idea haha.


and the calsssical guitar is this old old japanese classical guitar.

defo not something i'd like to mess around with.
just being hypithetical.

haha.

gosh spelling fail.

but thank you all.


defo won't be donig this hahaha

and they could jsut be put in the bridger as you would with say.. nylon ball end strings.


yep.

but i guessi t would be more of an issue of wearing parts out and intonation and and rattling, not so much tension destroying guitar.. hmm.


anotehr idea..


i couldnt just use really thick strings eitther.. because the G string is roughly close to the size of the low E.


unless i got a new nut cut.. it wouldn't be possible.


nah so not worth it. haha. cheers.
98% of teens have been around or have had alcohol. Put this in your sig if you like bagels.

Originally Posted by Sol9989:
I cum blood
never gonna give you up,
all fap together
to 2 girls 1 cup?