dwally89
dwally89
Join date: Dec 2005
1,559 IQ
#1
I was thinking about how larger musical instruments tend to produce deeper notes (e.g. a double bass), and how smaller instruments produce higher notes (e.g. violin).

Does anyone know if this is the same with humans?
i.e. does your height affect how high/low you can sing?

Can anyone think of any counter examples to this?

Thanks
Adam Black 12 String
Alesis X Guitar
Epiphone DR-200ce
Italia Maranello Standard
Fender American Deluxe Strat

Digitech Whammy
Vox Crybaby
Behringer UD100
Boss RC-2

Roland Cube 15
Marshall DSL-401
Sound City 20 Watt Valve
adodin
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2009
134 IQ
#2
It doesn't. Length affects wind instruments because thats how long the air collumn is. (which is why uncovering holes higher up on the tube gives a higher pitch. Pitch in vocals is dependent on the frequency of oscillation of the vocal chords not the length of any tubes.
stevoreno
u punks can drive me nuts
Join date: Jul 2006
23 IQ
#3
There is some corolation between height and vocal pitch, however not as much as you are thinking. Tension is the main key here, just like in guitar strings. The vocal chords work the same way. Tighten the string, the higher the pitch. Loosen the string, the lower the pitch.
All my guitars are old enough to buy beer, are You?
metalmetalhead
Panterica
Join date: May 2007
517 IQ
#4
I dont really remember all the details. But the longer the vocal chords the lower. shorter the higher, then theres the quality thin vs thickness. But I dont really remember. Iv seen big people with tinny voices and vise versa. Like stevo said im sure theres some corolation But its not always true.
Cowless
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2010
307 IQ
#5
Vocal range has more to do with genetics, environment, and practice than it does size. For example, Mike Tyson. You'd expect him to have this great big voice, but he sounds like Mickey Mouse.
Blind In 1 Ear
Git-Man
Join date: Jun 2006
2,962 IQ
#6
Quote by Cowless
Vocal range has more to do with genetics, environment, and practice than it does size. For example, Mike Tyson. You'd expect him to have this great big voice, but he sounds like Mickey Mouse.

mike tyson is only 5'10'' though. thats pretty much average height.
Cowless
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2010
307 IQ
#7
Quote by Blind In 1 Ear
mike tyson is only 5'10'' though. thats pretty much average height.


Wow, I thought he was bigger than that! But - the point still stands. He has a higher than average voice, when by this height=voice theory he should be a baritone of some sort. I know plenty of short dudes with deep voices and tall dudes with high voices and vice versa.
wasp2020
Registered User
Join date: Jun 2005
919 IQ
#8
Quote by Cowless
Wow, I thought he was bigger than that! But - the point still stands. He has a higher than average voice, when by this height=voice theory he should be a baritone of some sort. I know plenty of short dudes with deep voices and tall dudes with high voices and vice versa.


Exceptions don't disprove trends.
dwally89
dwally89
Join date: Dec 2005
1,559 IQ
#9
Quote by wasp2020
Exceptions don't disprove trends.

+1
Adam Black 12 String
Alesis X Guitar
Epiphone DR-200ce
Italia Maranello Standard
Fender American Deluxe Strat

Digitech Whammy
Vox Crybaby
Behringer UD100
Boss RC-2

Roland Cube 15
Marshall DSL-401
Sound City 20 Watt Valve
Cowless
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2010
307 IQ
#10
Quote by wasp2020
Exceptions don't disprove trends.


What I'm saying is that there doesn't seem to be a trend. If exceptions to a trend occur just as if not more often than the "norm", then there is no norm. Not that any of us have the resources to even attempt a scientific study on this, it's all just conjecture. I'd be willing to shut up if somebody had a study that put this to rest.
curlyhead_P
?
Join date: Aug 2006
343 IQ
#11
Okay, talk to everyone you know and listen to their voice. If all the tall people have deep voices, and the short people high voices, then your theory is correct. Case closed.

Or better yet, let me save some trouble. Try just THINKING about all your friends' voices. You don't actually have to talk with them. Is there a correlation between height and vocal range?

Ya know what? Let me save you some more trouble. The answer is no.
_________________________
https://amateurchemist.bandcamp.com/

https://verbosa.bandcamp.com/
Cowless
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2010
307 IQ
#12
Quote by curlyhead_P
Okay, talk to everyone you know and listen to their voice. If all the tall people have deep voices, and the short people high voices, then your theory is correct. Case closed.

Or better yet, let me save some trouble. Try just THINKING about all your friends' voices. You don't actually have to talk with them. Is there a correlation between height and vocal range?

Ya know what? Let me save you some more trouble. The answer is no.


This guy. This guy right here.
GuitarMunky
I play guitar n stuff
Join date: May 2007
115 IQ
#13
Quote by dwally89
I was thinking about how larger musical instruments tend to produce deeper notes (e.g. a double bass), and how smaller instruments produce higher notes (e.g. violin).

Does anyone know if this is the same with humans?
i.e. does your height affect how high/low you can sing?

Can anyone think of any counter examples to this?

Thanks


Does it matter? you're born with what you got. work with it.

It's not like you can change your body to match your desired vocal style.

Worry about shit that you can do something about.
shred is gaudy music
dwally89
dwally89
Join date: Dec 2005
1,559 IQ
#14
Quote by GuitarMunky
Does it matter? you're born with what you got. work with it.

It's not like you can change your body to match your desired vocal style.

Worry about shit that you can do something about.


Who said that I was referring to myself?
Adam Black 12 String
Alesis X Guitar
Epiphone DR-200ce
Italia Maranello Standard
Fender American Deluxe Strat

Digitech Whammy
Vox Crybaby
Behringer UD100
Boss RC-2

Roland Cube 15
Marshall DSL-401
Sound City 20 Watt Valve
gavk
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2011
57 IQ
#15
i don't think there's much of a correlation, i know a lot of people (including me) who are small but have very deep voices. in the choir in my college, in general the tenors were a lot taller than the basses.
GuitarMunky
I play guitar n stuff
Join date: May 2007
115 IQ
#16
Quote by dwally89
Who said that I was referring to myself?


it doesn't matter. you can't change other peoples size either. (or vocal range).
shred is gaudy music