#2
not bad. both of you guitarists need a lot of work on your vibrato. it's more than just wiggling your hand. i will say, though, that the poor vibrato was brought out more by the tone. you kept the rhythm pretty well, but the lead playing was very boring. again, though, that was more of a technical issue -- vibrato, legato, etc. it sounded almost more like an exercise. and some of the bends in the slower section weren't in tune.

your drummer is pretty good - he can keep the rhythms very tight and clean.

your bassist plays a 6-string, so he must therefore be awesome. seriously, i felt that he didn't really do the bass solo justice. but again, that could just be a tone issue. that aside, it was pretty good. he's got some decent chops -- it was better than i could do, that's for sure.
Anfangen ist leicht, Beharren eine Kunst.