So I had a couple of stickers on my white guitar and decided to take them off only to find that where the stickers were are now white as a sheet and the rest of the guitar is kind of...gross looking off-white almost yellow.

So, obvious question is obvious at this point. How do I get the rest of my guitar to become as clean as where my stickers were?
Adhesive remover, then some polish and buffing and the normal cleanup jazz.
Where's Waldo?
By wood polish do you mean the stuff that you'd put on your coffee table?
Don't use it on a guitar.
..I was watching my death.
Use a carnuba wax. Megulars auto polish works great for taking nicotine, beer, margarita's,blood,etc. off a guitar, and won't leave a film on it like furnitue polish.
"Life's too short for bad tone"-Rev. Billy Gibbons
naptha. in our shop this seems to work to take off ANYTHING adhesive and doesnt damage wood. it evaporates IMMETDIATELY off a hard surface.. im not too sure how youd feel about it and your finnish.
Being a Bass player is pretty LOW i.m.o...
My Gear:
squier strat HSS
(coming soon) hand built superstrat style.
(coming soon) hand built mahogany spruce top acoustic.
Fender Mustang I 20w
Line 6 FLoor POD (standard)