Well, I'm retrieving a Stereo Electric Mistress from my brother, which I know sounds decent enough in front of my amp. I'm considering bringing my MXR CC and Boss BF-2 and asking for a trade for a new delay pedal.

I'm looking at the TC Electronic Flashback and the Malekko 616. I guess my question is how decent are the "Analog" and "Tape" modes on the Flashback?

I know it's not gonna be a perfect representation of the analog sound, but a lot of the newer delays I'm seeing are digital emulators of analog delay or hybrid circuits which seem to sound pretty decent IMHO.

Also, what's the likelihood of them doing a straight trade between my 2 pedals for one of the ones I listed?
Maximum volume yields maximum goats.