ZOSO <(")
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2011
758 IQ
#1
im thinking about getting a guitar made from Warmoth.com ans was wondering what is the best wood to use for the body?
W4RP1G
Please, call me Pig.
Join date: May 2010
2,847 IQ
#2
Quote by ZOSO <(
im thinking about getting a guitar made from Warmoth.com ans was wondering what is the best wood to use for the body?

There should be an accurate descriptions of the woods on the warmoth website. Also, there is no "best wood", only different woods. If you want to sound like a strat(for example), then you'd probably want to look into alder, for a Les Paul, look into mahogany, ect.. Durability, weight, and looks are other factors to consider as well.
browns82jk
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2011
275 IQ
#4
I prefer basswood its fairly cheap and light and has good sound to it but it is very soft so if you are abusive on bodys don't use basswood.
Beauty/Broken
Aural Shogun
Join date: May 2011
300 IQ
#5
I would avoid basswood if you're wanting to go for quality. It's one of the cheaper tonewoods that you often find on very cheap or budget guitars.

I'd say if you want bright go Alder. If you want warm go Mahogany.
Guitars
ESP Eclipse I CTM FR
LTD EC1000 FR
LTD H1007 FR

Bass
ESP Surveyor

Line 6 Pod HD500

Wanted: ESP XJ-6, ESP Classic 400 Strat/Tele or ESP Traditional Series Strat/Tele

Dig Symphonic Metal or Visual Kei < Click.
Carl6661
UG Freak
Join date: Oct 2007
2,096 IQ
#6
Quote by Beauty/Broken
I would avoid basswood if you're wanting to go for quality. It's one of the cheaper tonewoods that you often find on very cheap or budget guitars


I'm not an expert by any means, but like all woods, you can get good quality, as well as bad. You can't just say it's all bad and should be avoided because it's it's used of a lot of cheaper guitars. It just so happens to be readily available and cheap. There are also a lot of very cheap guitars make from alder and mahogany.

From what I know, the basswood Warmoth uses is generally very good. Assuming you like the sound of it, I would only say avoid it if you have a tendancy to beat your bodies up a bit, as it's very soft. If not, it's worth bearing in mind.
I deeply regret the 6661 in my username. Siiiigh. Damn you, 14 year old me, you edgy little bastard.
Sakke
Chaser of 'Tone'
Join date: Jul 2009
909 IQ
#7
Quote by Beauty/Broken
I would avoid basswood if you're wanting to go for quality. It's one of the cheaper tonewoods that you often find on very cheap or budget guitars.

I'd say if you want bright go Alder. If you want warm go Mahogany.


So Ibanez JEM has a cheap wood? I don't think so...

Quote by Carl6661
I'm not an expert by any means, but like all woods, you can get good quality, as well as bad. You can't just say it's all bad and should be avoided because it's it's used of a lot of cheaper guitars. It just so happens to be readily available and cheap. There are also a lot of very cheap guitars make from alder and mahogany.

From what I know, the basswood Warmoth uses is generally very good. Assuming you like the sound of it, I would only say avoid it if you have a tendancy to beat your bodies up a bit, as it's very soft. If not, it's worth bearing in mind.


I'm not an expert either, but you're right. There is cheap alder, cheap mahogany (like nato) and cheap basswood. Then there's expensive out of each. I don't exactly know how the pricing goes and why it goes like that, maybe rarity and then the amount of work needed to be done for the blank. Some woods are easier to work on than others. That's what I know.
Gear pics

Quote by Cathbard
Bugera cloning Blackstar is a scandal cloaked in a tragedy making love to a nightmare.

Last edited by Sakke at Sep 20, 2012,
logicbdj
Tab Contributor
Join date: Sep 2010
4,558 IQ
#8
My Ibanez Satriani JS2400 also is made of basswood... it has a darkish, rich sound and is not 'cheap' if that's the sound you want.
von Layzonfon
UG's Grammar Stickler
Join date: Dec 2010
1,214 IQ
#9
*Takes deep breath*

Pickups + Electronics + Processing + Amplification > Wood

If you're talking about sound. If you want bright, go single coil. If you want warm, go humbucker. Fine tune with EQ.

Wood type is more of a concern when considering workability, finish and durability.

This is my opinion, formed through experience, although I know many people find it controversial.
deathbycontrol
*insert awesome here*
Join date: Jul 2008
600 IQ
#10
Quote by von Layzonfon
*Takes deep breath*

Pickups + Electronics + Processing + Amplification > Wood

If you're talking about sound. If you want bright, go single coil. If you want warm, go humbucker. Fine tune with EQ.

Wood type is more of a concern when considering workability, finish and durability.

This is my opinion, formed through experience, although I know many people find it controversial.

I kind of agree with this, but wood type also has a lot to do with sustain, weight, and how well certain frequencies sound.

Like I've noticed that heavier wood usually has better sounding lows, and lighter has better highs.

But I'd say that 60% of the tone comes from the electronics.
---------------------------
Here have a waffle!
(>^_^)>#
logicbdj
Tab Contributor
Join date: Sep 2010
4,558 IQ
#11
I have the same pickups in an swamp ash body as I do in a basswood body... a brighter and sharper attack in the swamp ash (a harder and brighter wood).
von Layzonfon
UG's Grammar Stickler
Join date: Dec 2010
1,214 IQ
#12
Quote by logicbdj
I have the same pickups in an swamp ash body as I do in a basswood body... a brighter and sharper attack in the swamp ash (a harder and brighter wood).
Just out of curiosity; are they the same body style, thickness, neck construction, scale length, nut, bridge, string gauge, wiring configuration, pots, capacitors? As any scientist will tell you, if you want to measure the effect of changing a single variable you have to keep everything else constant.
logicbdj
Tab Contributor
Join date: Sep 2010
4,558 IQ
#13
The Swamp ash is more of a EVH style guitar (MusicMan), whereas the Basswood is the Satriani model. Certainly there are other variables. I'll give you that. How many guitars do you have that are exactly the same specs, but different wood bodies, and there is no difference in tone?
MegadethFan18
Judge Shredd
Join date: Dec 2008
1,387 IQ
#14
You really just need to figure out what exactly you are looking for, no one can tell you what that is. For my build I just wanted the hardest piece I could in in the fewest pieces (for structural integrity). After looking at a hardness chart I bought a 1 piece American Ash body for £50 ($80).
W4RP1G
Please, call me Pig.
Join date: May 2010
2,847 IQ
#15
Quote by Beauty/Broken
I would avoid basswood if you're wanting to go for quality. It's one of the cheaper tonewoods that you often find on very cheap or budget guitars.

Yes, basswood is "cheaper" in cost, but it's not a bad tone-wood by any means. It sounds as good as any other tone-wood and it's light. The only downsides are that the color and grain pattern are bland, and it's soft. Both of those things mean little if it's painted and clear coated with poly.
browns82jk
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2011
275 IQ
#16
Quote by W4RP1G
Yes, basswood is "cheaper" in cost, but it's not a bad tone-wood by any means. It sounds as good as any other tone-wood and it's light. The only downsides are that the color and grain pattern are bland, and it's soft. Both of those things mean little if it's painted and clear coated with poly.


Thank you for agree'ing haha.

2 out of my 3 guitars are basswood and the third is mahogany. and i actually prefer the basswood sound over the mahogany. The leads are brighter and sharper but of course if you're going for a warm bluesy sound then mahogany would work. But I like basswood because for the sound and the price of it you can't beat it.
von Layzonfon
UG's Grammar Stickler
Join date: Dec 2010
1,214 IQ
#17
Quote by logicbdj
The Swamp ash is more of a EVH style guitar (MusicMan), whereas the Basswood is the Satriani model. Certainly there are other variables. I'll give you that. How many guitars do you have that are exactly the same specs, but different wood bodies, and there is no difference in tone?
That's sort of my point. There are so many different things that contribute to the sound of a guitar it's almost impossible to compare any two and reach a satisfactory conclusion. I'm not for one minute suggesting that the wood makes no difference at all, I just think that it's often given much more credit than it may be due, given everything else that's going on to generate the sound that's coming out of the speakers.

In fact, I own several guitars with similar, but notably different specs and I did comparative recordings which you can listen to here if you so choose. Which one sounds the brightest to me? The one made of mahogany. But you'd be hard pressed to tell most of them apart. Go figure.

For another excellent example of the conundrum, take a look at this. Two ostensibly identical guitars except for the finish and yet they sound slightly different. Is the finish responsible for that? Given that he clearly states that he's blocked the trem on one, de-tuned it and changed the string gauge, is it not more likely that those are the cause of the different tone? There's a similar debate raging in the comments under the video.

Anyway, this is one of those things that everyone has opinions on and everyone finds their own "truth". At the end of the day we find what we are happy with. I'm not saying anyone is right or wrong, just hopefully encouraging people to ignore comments like, "Plywood!? It's junk!". Try it. You might be surprised. I mean, who doesn't want an excuse to acquire lots of different guitars, right?

ZOSO, sorry for hijacking your thread. All the advice here is good but don't sweat your choice too much. And enjoy your new guitar - when it arrives.

Peace to all.
Maineguitarist
Go to Mainer
Join date: Jun 2012
887 IQ
#18
Oak FTW
My Name is Cameron.
Quote by Cathbard
For me, bedroom levels is a cranked plexi half stack.

Now get off my ****ing lawn.


Shinozoku
UG Nerd
Join date: Aug 2006
1,227 IQ
#19
Quote by Beauty/Broken
I would avoid basswood if you're wanting to go for quality. It's one of the cheaper tonewoods that you often find on very cheap or budget guitars.

I'd say if you want bright go Alder. If you want warm go Mahogany.

Ahh, hahaha.... The "basswood is a cheap guitar wood" argument.

http://www.ibanez.com/ElectricGuitars/model-JS2400

That is but one example. Search more for your own purposes and education.
Then there's this band called Slice The Cake...

Bunch of faggots putting random riffs together and calling it "progressive" deathcore.
Stupid name.
Probably picked "for teh lulz"

Mod in UG's Official Gain Whores