#3
They all all the same. That's all the G Blues scale (the inclusion of the Tritone means it's blues, not pentatonic).

Repeat this after me:

Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
#4
Terrible site. They don't even label the notes as Bb and Db.

Perfect example of the amount of shit on the internet.
#5
Quote by mdc
Terrible site. They don't even label the notes as Bb and Db.

Perfect example of the amount of shit on the internet.


this guitar player i'm working with uses it to write songs. he'll put the tuning as drop C and hit "c minor scale" and will use the bottom 3 strings for power chords and play pentatonic crap over it

so TS, if this is you, stop it, because i'm gonna have a hernia
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#6
Quote by Hail
this guitar player i'm working with uses it to write songs. he'll put the tuning as drop C and hit "c minor scale" and will use the bottom 3 strings for power chords and play pentatonic crap over it

so TS, if this is you, stop it, because i'm gonna have a hernia

#8
You're confusing scale positions with modes.

A lot of shit sites on the internet will break up major scale fingers into 4 fret groupings. That's great. The problem begins when they label these different positions/fingerings as "modes".

They're all just ****in' G major. They have the same notes as the modes of the major scale, but the distinction is in the tonality of the piece you're playing - not the lowest note of whatever position you start playing in.
#12
Quote by HotspurJr

Repeat this after me:

Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.

Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Last edited by mdc at Sep 29, 2012,
#13
eek

Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
But boys will be boys and girls have those eyes
that'll cut you to ribbons, sometimes
and all you can do is just wait by the moon
and bleed if it's what she says you ought to do
#14
Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
#16
Quote by 123mac123
But to Clarify, In Major you'd call this scale

http://www.all-guitar-chords.com/guitar_scales.php?qqq=3&scch=G&scchnam=Major&get2=Get&t=0&choice=1

G Ionian?

http://www.all-guitar-chords.com/guitar_scales.php?qqq=5&scch=G&scchnam=Major&get2=Get&t=0&choice=1

And this Scale A Dorian?

If you can identify my confusion please explain to me what Im thinking wrong thanks


Nope. THose are both different positions of the G major scale.

Some people use mode names to refer to different positions, but this tends to be confusing more than it's helpful.

Life isn't made easier because there is no consistent naming. I would call those positions positions 4 and 5 of the G major scale, but some people would call them positions 1 and 2. Ultimately, it doesn't really matter - except that mode names are misleading and confusing.

However, a song being modal "means something" and talking about a song being in "A Dorian" means something (although on UG we can argue for hours and hours about what exactly it means!). What it doesn't mean is that it was composed or is played in the second position you listed, rather than the first position you listed.

(My quick and dirty approach would be that A Dorian is a song with those notes and a forced resolution to A, rather than G. This definition is too broad for some people, however).

Worth pointing out that people who do use modal scales because they're applying chord-scale theory (don't ask) can only really do so effectively if they can play all of them in one position, so the idea of modes corresponding to different places on the neck isn't useful for them, either.
#18
Yeah, the names of the scale positions are the same as names of modes. They are the same scale but just different position. I think it kind of sucks when the teachers use modes as scale position names. I mean, it's OK if you understand that it's different than really playing modal music. And you aren't playing modes if you play different scale positions. It would be easier if they were just "first position" and "second position" etc.

Playing the same notes in a different position on the fretboard is playing the same scale.
Quote by AlanHB
Just remember that there are no boring scales, just boring players.

Gear

Bach Stradivarius 37G
Charvel So Cal
Hartke HyDrive 210c
Ibanez BL70
Laney VC30
Tokai TB48
Yamaha FG720S-12
Yamaha P115
#22
I think you have the answer you're looking for, and the locals are getting restless. I'm going to close this thread before it gets real ugly.
And no, Guitar Hero will not help. Even on expert. Really.
Soundcloud