#1
I have been learning to play guitar on Jackson with a 16" Radius. Today I played a friends Schecter with a 14" Radius. I felt way more comfortable on the Schecter.

Does this make sense, or is it just my imagination?
#2
What makes sense? That you have a preference? That you can feel a difference in radius?

None of this is crazy. Preferences like this will start to show up once you get comfortable playing and start to develop an ear. It will be amps next - careful, they're expensive.
#3
Quote by Malazan66
I have been learning to play guitar on Jackson with a 16" Radius. Today I played a friends Schecter with a 14" Radius. I felt way more comfortable on the Schecter.

Does this make sense, or is it just my imagination?


The radius is just the curve of the fretboard.

The shape of the back of the neck is, for me anyway, the more determinant part of comfort. Flatter radius lend themselves better to chord work, tighter radius will be "faster" by feel.

Mileage may vary of course.


Plus if that Jackson is a bolt on you can buy a neck with a tighter radius.
Last edited by Zoomyrs1 at Nov 14, 2012,
#4
It seemed like like my hand did not fatigue as much with the Schecter. I'd like to try a 12 or a 10 inch Radius now.

My Jackson is a bolt-on, Didn't even think about the neck change scenario
Last edited by Malazan66 at Nov 14, 2012,
#5
If your Jackson has a compound radius, then it will graduate from 12" to 16" as you move up the fretboard.

Also, there are other factors at work, like the size and profile of the neck.
#6
Hand fatigue is more often caused by using a neck that's too thin for you, rather than anything to do with the fretboard radius. Schecters have an average-thickness neck while Jacksons have a fairly thin neck, so it's not surprising that you may find the Schecter more comfortable.

The difference between a 14" radius and a 16" one is, by the way, virtually nothing. Really anything more than 11" is flat enough that bends will never choke out and once you go beyond 12" you're playing on a practically flat surface.
Yes, I know everything. No, I can't play worth a damn.
A child is trafficked and sold for sex slavery every 30 seconds. Support Love146.
#7
Quote by Roc8995
What makes sense? That you have a preference? That you can feel a difference in radius?

None of this is crazy. Preferences like this will start to show up once you get comfortable playing and start to develop an ear. It will be amps next - careful, they're expensive.


This all day long. Amps are a b*tch!
#8
Why does a thinner neck, fatigue my wrist more? I would have thought a thicker one would be harder on your Hand/Wrist.

Thanks for the replies
#9
Quote by Malazan66
Why does a thinner neck, fatigue my wrist more? I would have thought a thicker one would be harder on your Hand/Wrist.

Thanks for the replies

Depends on your posture. Many people that use the baseball bat posture find a thicker neck to be more comfortable. And many people that use classical posture prefer a thinner neck.
#10
I also agree that the thickness is more the reason why!

For example, the difference in the radius of an ibanez standard vs. prestige is about 400mm vs. 430mm wich is basically nothing. But the neck of a prestige is 1 to 2 mm thinner than a regular line and it makes for a massive difference.
#11
Quote by MrFlibble
Hand fatigue is more often caused by using a neck that's too thin for you, rather than anything to do with the fretboard radius. Schecters have an average-thickness neck while Jacksons have a fairly thin neck, so it's not surprising that you may find the Schecter more comfortable.

The difference between a 14" radius and a 16" one is, by the way, virtually nothing. Really anything more than 11" is flat enough that bends will never choke out and once you go beyond 12" you're playing on a practically flat surface.


honestly i call BS. you cannot generalize the conditions of hand fatigue, everybody has different hands and preferences.

i am not disagreeing about anything else, just the conditions of hand fatigue.
WTLT 2014 GG&A

Quote by andersondb7
alright "king of the guitar forum"


Quote by trashedlostfdup
nope i am "GOD of the guitar forum" i think that fits me better.


Quote by andersondb7
youre just being a jerk man.


***9V BATTERIES ARE FROM HELL!*** (updated 2016-11-27)
Resentments and Rambling from a Guitar Junkie
---> http://trashedengineering.blogspot.com/
#12
I couldn't stand schecters because chords were so much harder for me with that style of neck. A flatter neck feels better to me all around. To each their own.
#13
Which Jackson and which Schecter? You could also have just played a better quality guitar.

Quote by EyeNon15
Thats too bad, I was under the impression I was arguing something profound


1 3 5 R
2 4 6
#14
Quote by JustRooster
Which Jackson and which Schecter? You could also have just played a better quality guitar.



Or just better set up.

A guitar with a proper set up and extra-lights is ALWAYS going to be easier to play then a guitar with the strings 3 gauges to heavy for its tuss rod setting.

There are a shit load of variables.

I don't remember ever playing a Jackson that was hard to play, I got the impression that the Schecter necks were relatively similar.
#15
Quote by JustRooster
Which Jackson and which Schecter? You could also have just played a better quality guitar.



It was a Hellraiser Special C-1

and my Jackson is a 96' PS-4
#16
Quote by Malazan66
It was a Hellraiser Special C-1

and my Jackson is a 96' PS-4

Your guitar has a compound radius neck, with a different profile. Consider other guitars if you aren't happy with yours. Try out some LTDs and Schecters, but also try everything else you can get your hands on. You obviously don't know what you need from a guitar, so think about that as well. Make a list of things you want in a guitar, and a list of things that don't matter. A list including these things:

Scale Length
Fret number
Fret size(regular, jumbo, ect)
High fret access
Fretboard radius
Neck thickness
Neck shape/profile
Neck heel/joint
Bridge
Pickup configuration
Shape/style
Wood types
#17
Honestly, owning various guitars is the best Ive found (obviously not economical). How many times have you tried a guitar at a store, it felt good, you loved it. You get it home and then you love deminishes the more time you spend with it. That initial infatuation can be a bitch.

For me, trying only eliminates guitars that I REALLY dont like, but then theres still a huge list of possibles and some those dont pan out months down the road.
#18
Quote by Axe Murderer
Honestly, owning various guitars is the best Ive found (obviously not economical). How many times have you tried a guitar at a store, it felt good, you loved it. You get it home and then you love deminishes the more time you spend with it. That initial infatuation can be a bitch.

For me, trying only eliminates guitars that I REALLY dont like, but then theres still a huge list of possibles and some those dont pan out months down the road.

This has been my experience as well.