Page 1 of 2
#1
Ok so I'm 13 started playing guitar a year ago, I'm making my christmas list and I'm considering if i should just ask for a electric guitar and an amp. I got a fender CD-60CE last year. I want one but im not sure. I would like some reasons on why too ask for one or not too.
#3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nY-XDF_Ask
Because with an electric you have the ability to shred peoples faces off seriously though i started with an acoustic and moved onto electric and it certainly helped further my playing. I play both but for some songs obviously an electric is needed so it expands the musical capabilities of the instrument. Sticking to acoustic is limiting what you can accomplish, i would recommend taking the next step into electric
#4
You either want one or you don't, it's not up to anyone else.
#5
I'm not going to convince you of anything. You decide what you want.

I play acoustic 99% of the time. I prefer the tone and I can do anything on it that I can do on electric.
#6
Actually, you know you really shouldn't play the guitar. There are too many guitarists in the world already. Start playing drums, the world seems to have a drummer shortage.
#7
1) you enjoy music that uses an electric guitar

2) you enjoy playing guitar

If you answered no to either of the above questions, then don't get an electric.
⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸⫷⫸
Airline 3P Deluxe
Gibson SG Special w/ SD 59's
Victoria MIJ 60's Electric Guitar
Martin DCX1E
Hughes & Kettner Tubemeister 18
Bunch of Pedals
Squier Vintage Modified Jaguar
#8
Quote by J_W
Actually, you know you really shouldn't play the guitar. There are too many guitarists in the world already. Start playing drums, the world seems to have a drummer shortage.



SO. MUCH. THIS.
Legion!
Original 1969 Fender Jazzmaster
Jackson JS32R Dinky "Curry"
ESP/LTD SN-1000
Jackson Stars Kelly "Aiko"
Ormsby SX6 prototype
Dingwall NG-2 "Kimmy"
MiM Fender Jazz Bass "Pancho"
EVH 5153
#9
Quote by J_W
Actually, you know you really shouldn't play the guitar. There are too many guitarists in the world already. Start playing drums, the world seems to have a drummer shortage.


Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.
#10
For a beginner I think an electric guitar is actually preferable to an acoustic
1. you can play both clean and distorted
2. electric guitars are easier on the hand to play, and easier to learn on, this is why most people who play primarily electric guitars as beginners tend not to have the problems with barre chords that acoustic beginners tend toward
3. expanded range give you more things techniques you can learn, and will likely speed up progress, and be less boring
#11
1) Electric (at least 99% of the time) is easier to play/learn on for beginners; since you've already learned chords etc. on an acoustic it will be easier.

2) You can shred on electric...mainly strum on acoustic.

3) Chicks dig it.

4) More versatile tones, distortion etc.

5) Don't be a one trick pony, I own an acoustic and electric bass, and play punk/alt and bluegrass, it's fun the expand.

If those don't convince you buy a bass or a drum kit.
#12
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.


I play rhythm guitar...
#13
Don't bother asking for an electric unless you can get a good amp with it. A crappy amp (like any Line 6 Spider or Marshall MG...most solid states, come to think of it) will take all the fun out of it.

So unless there's a $350 - $2,000 budget for a good amp to go with the guitar, then you're better off with sticking to acoustic if you can stand it (I played acoustic for a couple of months, bought an electic because they sound cooler, and will never go back--electrics are so much more versatile and ergonomic). Most good amps are tube. You're probably looking more like $600 for a good tube amp, but a Fender Champ could be an OK starter.

I'd like to see KG6_Steven whammy dive with his acoustic
Last edited by jetwash69 at Nov 19, 2012,
#14
If you play electric with a bunch of whammys and shit, girls will suck your dick. If you play acoustic you have to smoke weed and sing like John Mayer. Girls will still suck your dick but then you actually have to start being good and can't cover everything up with effects.
#15
If you need us to convince you, then you don't really want one.
Just stalked your profile. Keep the acoustic and just play Mumford and sons. Do it
LOOK ANOTHER GENERIC SIGNATURE ABOUT MY GEAR AND STUFF
Ibanez P.O.S (modded RG)
ESP Horizon FR-II
ESP LTD H-308 (Ironing board with strings)

"A great man once said; "a great man once said""

Extend your range....7s 8s and more
#16
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.[/QUOTE
I play rhythm guitar...

ARE WE THE LAST OF OUR KIND?!

OT: I second the drum notion. Or become a really awesome bassist, I don't know a lot of those either. Or get an electric guitar, or don't.

Basically, this should have been /thread:

Quote by JoeFlips
1) you enjoy music that uses an electric guitar 2) you enjoy playing guitar If you answered no to either of the above questions, then don't get an electric.
#17
Quote by jetwash69
Don't bother asking for an electric unless you can get a good amp with it. A crappy amp (like any Line 6 Spider or Marshall MG...most solid states, come to think of it) will take all the fun out of it.

So unless there's a $350 - $2,000 budget for a good amp to go with the guitar, then you're better off with sticking to acoustic if you can stand it (I played acoustic for a couple of months, bought an electic because they sound cooler, and will never go back--electrics are so much more versatile and ergonomic). Most good amps are tube. You're probably looking more like $600 for a good tube amp, but a Fender Champ could be an OK starter.

I'd like to see KG6_Steven whammy dive with his acoustic

this is just plain not true, a cheap amp, or a cheap amp and a few effects is just fine for practice and are great for beginners
#19
You can shred on electric...mainly strum on acoustic.


You can definitely shred on an acoustic.

(I can't, but I can't shred on an electric, either.)
Sturgeon's 2nd Law, a.k.a. Sturgeon's Revelation: “Ninety percent of everything is crap.”

Why, yes, I am a lawyer- thanks for asking!


alhaq369
It is very impotent to success a business.
#20
Quote by jetwash69
Don't bother asking for an electric unless you can get a good amp with it. A crappy amp (like any Line 6 Spider or Marshall MG...most solid states, come to think of it) will take all the fun out of it.

So unless there's a $350 - $2,000 budget for a good amp to go with the guitar, then you're better off with sticking to acoustic if you can stand it (I played acoustic for a couple of months, bought an electic because they sound cooler, and will never go back--electrics are so much more versatile and ergonomic). Most good amps are tube. You're probably looking more like $600 for a good tube amp, but a Fender Champ could be an OK starter.

I'd like to see KG6_Steven whammy dive with his acoustic


Do not listen to this TS, I started playing with a Vox pathfinder solid state practice amp, It was a fine practice amp, and while I now have tube amps I still use that amp for home practice. You can find perfectly acceptable beginner amps below $350.
I SEE A BAD MOON RISING
I SEE TROUBLE ON THE WAY
#21
Quote by DylanHendrix
Do not listen to this TS, I started playing with a Vox pathfinder solid state practice amp, It was a fine practice amp, and while I now have tube amps I still use that amp for home practice. You can find perfectly acceptable beginner amps below $350.


Agreed, you don't need $2k worth of gear when you are first starting out! I'd just avoid starter kits you see at Wal-Mart, Best Buy etc. Those will frustrate you for sure.
#22
Quote by DylanHendrix
Do not listen to this TS, I started playing with a Vox pathfinder solid state practice amp, It was a fine practice amp, and while I now have tube amps I still use that amp for home practice. You can find perfectly acceptable beginner amps below $350.


Quote by Huge Guy
Agreed, you don't need $2k worth of gear when you are first starting out! I'd just avoid starter kits you see at Wal-Mart, Best Buy etc. Those will frustrate you for sure.


Well, I did say a $350 Fender Champ would be OK.

But you can also spend almost $600 and get garbage: http://www.zzounds.com/item--MSHMGCFSTACK. Many here would argue that even $1000+ tube hybrid amps suck.

Not all solid states are garbage. VOX is probably the best for lower-end amps. Most of the time I play thru a $150 5 watt Solid State VOX DA5, but I'm playing that thru a $200 Digitech RP355...it doesn't sound as good without something like that. Plus the DA5 is discontinued and the replacement product sounds like a tin can.

So yeah, my Marshall tube amp doesn't see much action at home, but my Marshall MG (first amp) was a pure waste of money, and if I hadn't picked up an MFX pedal and a keyboard amp to play it thru, I probably would have given up long before I got the gigging tube rig or the current practice rig.

The point is stay away from all "Starter amps", from the ones that come with guitars, to anything that says MG or Spider, and almost anything 15watts or less unless it's all tube.
Last edited by jetwash69 at Nov 19, 2012,
#23
Quote by jetwash69
Don't bother asking for an electric unless you can get a good amp with it. A crappy amp (like any Line 6 Spider or Marshall MG...most solid states, come to think of it) will take all the fun out of it.

So unless there's a $350 - $2,000 budget for a good amp to go with the guitar, then you're better off with sticking to acoustic if you can stand it (I played acoustic for a couple of months, bought an electic because they sound cooler, and will never go back--electrics are so much more versatile and ergonomic). Most good amps are tube. You're probably looking more like $600 for a good tube amp, but a Fender Champ could be an OK starter.

I'd like to see KG6_Steven whammy dive with his acoustic


This is one of those things where everyone is unique. $2000 is a good budget for an amp, but I can tell you that, even with the amps I have here, I still prefer to play acoustic. I have four amps in this room - two of them were $2000 each, the other was $3000 and the last is a cheapie Peavey Valveking 112, which has been retubed. When I do play the amps, the el cheapo Peavey sees just as much use as the expensive hand-wired, hand-built amps.

Personally, I think acoustic sounds better - the tone is warmer and richer. To me, electric guitars are thin sounding - especially when doing rhythm work. I still occasionally pull down one of my electrics and warm up the tubes - no SS amps here. I can't stand the sound of a SS amp - and I don't want to get into a debate about tubes vs. SS. It's a personal choice and that's my choice. Something to think about is I have some nice, high-end guitars and amps, and I still prefer the tone of an acoustic over electric.

So, what does all this mean? Decide for yourself what you like. The fact is, you've only been playing a short while and your "ears" still haven't developed. If you decide to buy an electric for Christmas, chances are pretty good you won't know what to ask for. The guitar you end up receiving won't be the one you want and in a few years, you'll realize it was a bad choice and end up trading it for the one that really has the tone you love. Go to your local guitar store and try some on for size.

You're right... no whammy dive with any of my acoustics. However, I can always pull down one of my electrics and use them.
#24
Quote by jetwash69
Well, I did say a $350 Fender Champ would be OK.

But you can also spend almost $600 and get garbage: http://www.zzounds.com/item--MSHMGCFSTACK. Many here would argue that even $1000+ tube hybrid amps suck.

Not all solid states are garbage. VOX is probably the best for lower-end amps. Most of the time I play thru a $150 5 watt Solid State VOX DA5, but I'm playing that thru a $200 Digitech RP355...it doesn't sound as good without something like that. Plus the DA5 is discontinued and the replacement product sounds like a tin can.

So yeah, my Marshall tube amp doesn't see much action at home, but my Marshall MG (first amp) was a pure waste of money, and if I hadn't picked up an MFX pedal and a keyboard amp to play it thru, I probably would have given up long before I got the gigging tube rig or the current practice rig.

The point is stay away from all "Starter amps", from the ones that come with guitars, to anything that says MG or Spider, and almost anything 15watts or less unless it's all tube.


My point is like the person above says, when you are first starting out you have to develop your ears and it's not so important, really, what your first gear is.

I don't think the OP's mom is planning on spending more than a couple of hundred bucks on a gift.

My first guitar and amp was a high school graduation present, I got a Lyon by Washburn guitar (HSH, haven't seen one like it since) and a 60w Crate solid state amp which was about $200 at the time. I used these all through college, didn't upgrade anything till I had a job after I graduated.

It was definitely the amp that made the difference with the sound, though. I had friend with Squiers and cruddy little amps that sounded so tinny.
Last edited by Huge Guy at Nov 20, 2012,
#25
Quote by Huge Guy
It was definitely the amp that made the difference with the sound, though. I had friend with Squiers and cruddy little amps that sounded so tinny.


And that's my point, too. I think the TS might even be OK with a Fender Mustang II or III amp. But I know too many people who likely quit because their amp pack amps, Frontman, Spiders, Bandits, MGs, Behringers, etc. sucked so bad.

BTW, a Squier guitar might not be bad to start with, if it means buying a better amp. My second guitar was a Squier Affinity (first was an MIA Strat). After a pro setup (including shimming the neck), and replacing the [broken] tuning pegs with locking tuners like they use in the MIA Deluxe Strats, it now plays just as well as the MIA Strat. And with aftermarket HH pickups and Deluxe S-1 electronics, is sounds a lot meaner, too--much better tone out of the Squier with half the investment. Just wish it had 22 frets and a 2-point trem. I got the Squier as a cheap travel guitar, but now after heavy modding, it's my favorite stage guitar over some other very nice guitars.

MIM Fenders have come a long way in the last 6 years, but when I bought the [made in China] Squier, it had much better build quality (but a worse setup) than the Mexican Strats. The frets were perfect--no overhang, unlike the sharp frets on the MIM Strats of the day. The bad neck angle was fixed easily enough with the pro-setup.

Thread-Starter: if you do get an electric guitar that costs less than $1,000, be prepared to spend $50 - $100 on a pro setup. Even most music stores don't do a good job setting up the guitars. Plus everything changes if you want to use thicker strings. You should find a reputable luthier or guitar tech to do the setup. A bad setup can make the guitar a lot harder to play.
#26
Quote by jacobtheimpaler

ARE WE THE LAST OF OUR KIND?!

OT: I second the drum notion. Or become a really awesome bassist, I don't know a lot of those either. Or get an electric guitar, or don't.

Basically, this should have been /thread:


I think we are man, its terrible but somebody has to do something to hold up songs amirite?
#27
pickup a used mexican strat for $250 and a 30 watt peavey vypyr and you should be fine (30 watt because it has a 12" speaker) ~$150? you would be fine for a while unless you are a gear wh0re like me.
WTLT 2014 GG&A

Quote by andersondb7
alright "king of the guitar forum"


Quote by trashedlostfdup
nope i am "GOD of the guitar forum" i think that fits me better.


Quote by andersondb7
youre just being a jerk man.


***9V BATTERIES ARE FROM HELL!*** (updated 2016-11-27)
Resentments and Rambling from a Guitar Junkie
---> http://trashedengineering.blogspot.com/
#28
Quote by jetwash69
Don't bother asking for an electric unless you can get a good amp with it. A crappy amp (like any Line 6 Spider or Marshall MG...most solid states, come to think of it) will take all the fun out of it.

So unless there's a $350 - $2,000 budget for a good amp to go with the guitar, then you're better off with sticking to acoustic if you can stand it (I played acoustic for a couple of months, bought an electic because they sound cooler, and will never go back--electrics are so much more versatile and ergonomic). Most good amps are tube. You're probably looking more like $600 for a good tube amp, but a Fender Champ could be an OK starter.

I'd like to see KG6_Steven whammy dive with his acoustic

Definatly disagree. I started on acoustic as well and played for a year before I got my first electric for christmas. It was one of the happiest days of my life. it was $100 and it came with a 10 watt amp with only gain and tone controls. Started getting money at 13 just to be able to buy better equipment. Got legit jobs starting at 15 with the main focus on just getting better gear. 9 years later i've got professional grade equipment (although I'll probably always collect new goodies). Getting low quality stuff and making you work for better stuff makes you more responsible and mature. Plus when you get better equipment and see how your hard work has payed off because the new stuff is so much better you get so inspired to become even better.

But why you should get an electric, do it just cause. Buy a $100 peice of crap and if it doesn't inspire you to practice its only $100. But if you like blues, jazz, rock, or metal I can almost ensure you you'll want to practice. And you knows, tastes change, you may and probably will get into other kinds of music when youre older and want to try to play stuff like it.

Also if you ever stop feeling inspired you can switch to electric which is such a different pony. then if you ever stop feeling it playing electric just go back to playing acoustically for awhile.
#29
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.


So true. There aren't many Izzy Stradlin wannabies out there. Fantastic guitarist.
#30
Quote by jacobtheimpaler
I play rhythm guitar...


May Tom Cruise bless you for it. I'm leaning that way as well.
#31
FWIW, I prefer rhythm m'self.
Sturgeon's 2nd Law, a.k.a. Sturgeon's Revelation: “Ninety percent of everything is crap.”

Why, yes, I am a lawyer- thanks for asking!


alhaq369
It is very impotent to success a business.
#32
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.


I dont understand this. How can you play guitar and not play rhythm to some degree?
#35
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.

I am a Rythm guitarist. By choice.
Hufschmid
Blackat
Washburn USA Custom Shop
PRS
Mayones
Orange
Diezel
Engl
#37
Quote by JAHellraiser
Amen brotha. Wish he wasn't such a...i dont even know how to describe it. just how low key he is. Wish he would've stayed in Velvet Revolver when they were forming.


He never really made it far with them. He was part of the formation but not much before that. But yeah, in G N'R he was such an amazing guitarist who was in a band with another amazing guitarist. I keep meaning to check his solo stuff out.
#38
Why do you even have to ask us? Just get one already!
G͔͓̅e͎͉̟̽ͬ͐̎̃͐ͨͅå͈͖͕̹̤̟̐̏͋ͅr̩͕̫̰̗s̹̳̼ͥ̒̍̄̅ͥ̚:


ESP Standard Eclipse I CTM VW
ESP LTD Deluxe H-1001
ESP LTD Deluxe Viper-1000 STBC
ESP Edwards E-EX-100STD
Warmoth Paulcaster "Tiger"
Tanglewood TW170 AS
Vox Tonelab ST
Blackstar HT-1R


#39
Quote by Axe Murderer
I dont understand this. How can you play guitar and not play rhythm to some degree?


That is very true, but a rhythm guitar player is kind of like a bass player in a sense, we're happy laying down the song's structure and we prefer to play chords and riffs than shredded leads.

Personally, I love playing rhythm because I have more fun doing it.
#40
Quote by Soccerguy
Or become a rhythm guitarist, I think they've gone extinct.



Thats what I am practicing to be one day. Dont personally give a rats arse about finger blistering solos and running the fretboard back and forth like a maniac.

May be an odd comment about a person whos favourite guitarists contain Buckethead, but hey the above doesnt mean I dont like hearing a good a solo...

ESP LTD F-50 + Tonezone
Cort EVL-Z4 + X2N
Cort EVL-K47B

Marshall Valvestate 8100
Randall RG1503
Bugera 333
Peavey Rockmaster preamp

Line6 Pod X3
Page 1 of 2