Page 1 of 2
#1
Now Im creating this thread to help new up-and-coming guitarists, Bassists, Drummers, or in fact any musician alike to ask any questions they have that is just not quite hitting them right. Such as modes, major\minor scales reading manuscript, mastering harmonics, having trouble remembering chords. Anything, just post a comment and me or someone else will help you. Joe
#2
Hi dude, your intentions are good but we have an entire forum for this kind of thing. Additionally I hope your advice is correct, because the regulars here will destroy you for any missteps you make.

Cheers.
And no, Guitar Hero will not help. Even on expert. Really.
Soundcloud
#4
What's a geetar?

What modes are used by Panic at the Dick Show?
Last edited by Jacques-Henri at Jan 3, 2013,
#8
Quote by Rebel Scum
Are modes and scales useless and should we not bother learning them?

F*ck you Xiaoxi
#11
Quote by Rebel Scum
Are modes and scales useless and should we not bother learning them?
YES

...modes and scales are still useless.


Quote by PhoenixGRM
Hey guys could you spare a minute to Vote for my band. Go to the site Search our band Listana with CTRL+F for quick and vote Thank you .
Quote by sam b
Voted for Patron Çıldırdı.

Thanks
Quote by PhoenixGRM
But our Band is Listana
#12
Quote by Elderer
chord consiting of F# A# F# fret B and G string at 11th and E at 14

Name that chord thread. Lol
#13
why do people still play guitar since they invented bass? are they just in denial or?
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#15
Quote by chronowarp
lolbass


my middle finger is banned during foreplay cause vaginal DPS is too high for the server to handle
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#16
Since bass has been brought up: Why do people claim bass is easy to learn/play? I see no logical reason.

I mean, to me it seems both are as easy or as hard as you want them to be (with the guitar you can use power chords and play 3 chord songs all day every day, which is as easy as it gets).
#17
Quote by CryogenicHusk
Since bass has been brought up: Why do people claim bass is easy to learn/play? I see no logical reason.

I mean, to me it seems both are as easy or as hard as you want them to be (with the guitar you can use power chords and play 3 chord songs all day every day, which is as easy as it gets).


Fewer strings = easier to play. Since I don't slap n pop my bass technique is real similar to my guitar technique and by that rationale it's easier to play.
#18
Quote by z4twenny
Fewer strings = easier to play. Since I don't slap n pop my bass technique is real similar to my guitar technique and by that rationale it's easier to play.


But people hardly use all 6 strings at once. I mean there's even a thread where some guy was asking why should anybody play major and minor chords with more than 3 notes.
#19
Quote by CryogenicHusk
But people hardly use all 6 strings at once. I mean there's even a thread where some guy was asking why should anybody play major and minor chords with more than 3 notes.


I remember that thread. Good times, good times.
#20
i may only have 4 strings (for now!) but by god i use every bit of them, and it's not uncommon for me to play extended chords.

there's so much territory where the guitar dominates that you forget that you can use over the first few frets on a bass, but there's just something about the high mids on a bass that makes chords sing as fully as a piano (or a harp if you have some banjo background, yolo)

i just couldn't ever get that on a guitar. the only tuning that satisfied me at all was B F# C# D A E but it just didn't have that deepness and the foundations that a bass innately has. i'd have to be playing an 8 string to hit that level, and that just doesn't reflect how i approach instrumentation or i'd have gone for that instead of selling off all my guitar equipment lol
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
Last edited by Hail at Jan 3, 2013,
#21
Quote by CryogenicHusk
But people hardly use all 6 strings at once. I mean there's even a thread where some guy was asking why should anybody play major and minor chords with more than 3 notes.

At once? That's usually chordal stuff but plenty of guitarists use all 6 strings consistently. I know I do, whether I need to or not
#22
Quote by Hail
i may only have 4 strings (for now!) but by god i use every bit of them, and it's not uncommon for me to play extended chords.

there's so much territory where the guitar dominates that you forget that you can use over the first few frets on a bass, but there's just something about the high mids on a bass that makes chords sing as fully as a piano (or a harp if you have some banjo background, yolo)

i just couldn't ever get that on a guitar. the only tuning that satisfied me at all was B F# C# D A E but it just didn't have that deepness and the foundations that a bass innately has. i'd have to be playing an 8 string to hit that level, and that just doesn't reflect how i approach instrumentation or i'd have gone for that instead of selling off all my guitar equipment lol


How was the transition? Any setbacks? Also, in your (or anybody else's who wishes to jump in on the matter) opinion, who has a better chance to "make it" (whatever that means to you, whether it is getting a gig playing for a relatively famous or really famous band or as a session musician, or whatever), a good bass player or a good guitar player? I'd think the bass player has the advantage, since there are so many more good guitar players out there than there are good bass players, which makes competition for guitar a bit steeper.

Quote by z4twenny
At once? That's usually chordal stuff but plenty of guitarists use all 6 strings consistently. I know I do, whether I need to or not


Well, at once, I guess. Otherwise, I would think there's no real difference and if it's something that is in range, in terms of frets, for the bass you can imitate anything on it that you could play on the guitar (albeit an octave lower) and doing something like that with just 4 strings and larger frets/thicker strings could be arguably trickier than with those extra 2 strings and smaller frets/thinner strings.

There are those dudes who strum away at open chords and do hardly anything else, and that isn't exactly next-level stuff either.

edit: Lately I've been considering trading the electric guitar for a bass. I'd still keep my classical guitar and keep learning it, but I wonder if I would do better as a bass player than I do as an electric guitar player.
Last edited by CryogenicHusk at Jan 3, 2013,
#23
Quote by CryogenicHusk
Since bass has been brought up: Why do people claim bass is easy to learn/play? I see no logical reason.

I mean, to me it seems both are as easy or as hard as you want them to be (with the guitar you can use power chords and play 3 chord songs all day every day, which is as easy as it gets).

Think about the roles that each primarily play in contemporary music, and then ask yourself that question again.
#24
Quote by chronowarp
Think about the roles that each primarily play in contemporary music, and then ask yourself that question again.


So there's no logical reason, just ignorance.
#25
Quote by CryogenicHusk
So there's no logical reason, just ignorance.

Of course there's a logical reason. The role of the bass in a modern rock ensemble is really simplistic, almost exclusively monophonic, and rarely abundant in any extreme technical challenges.

What is crucial in a mix? Focused low end. Kick and Bass. If youre bass is kapoodlingdoodling all the time then where the **** is your focused low end.
#26
Quote by CryogenicHusk
So there's no logical reason, just ignorance.

Bass is typically used as a support instrument. If you look at a lot of rock bands with bass players hammering on the root note while the guitar player is more harmonically active, its easy to see why some may consider bass an easier instrument. And in a case like that I would agree, but of course that is not always going to be the case.
As you said before, either can be as easy or as difficult as the player wants to make them
#27
I think it's harder to solo on bass. You can't just play guitar solo on bass, it will sound terrible. Bass solo has to have more groove and usually landing on the root note sounds the best. On guitar it doesn't matter which chord tone you land on when you solo (if you even play chord tones all the time). You can sustain notes in a guitar solo but on bass it will not sound good. You need to play guitar and bass differently. They are as easy/hard to play but the playing style is different.
Quote by AlanHB
Just remember that there are no boring scales, just boring players.

Gear

Bach Stradivarius 37G
Charvel So Cal
Hartke HyDrive 210c
Ibanez BL70
Laney VC30
Tokai TB48
Yamaha FG720S-12
Yamaha P115
#28
Quote by MaggaraMarine
I think it's harder to solo on bass. You can't just play guitar solo on bass, it will sound terrible.

Yeah you can, and no it won't.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KjVGJ3YFDc8
#29
Quote by CryogenicHusk
How was the transition? Any setbacks? Also, in your (or anybody else's who wishes to jump in on the matter) opinion, who has a better chance to "make it" (whatever that means to you, whether it is getting a gig playing for a relatively famous or really famous band or as a session musician, or whatever), a good bass player or a good guitar player? I'd think the bass player has the advantage, since there are so many more good guitar players out there than there are good bass players, which makes competition for guitar a bit steeper.


it's definitely easier to be unique, but it's all about doing whatever you might find your niche in. i wouldn't switch to bass just cause it's easier to be flashy - it's a logistical nightmare, because outside of the big names like hamm, pastorius, wooten and that ilk there's very little exploration in that realm, which means whatever you do needs to involve you absolutely owning it.

plus, after a point, unless you plan on being subserviant to other (read: not necessarily better) musicians, you're quite limited. i'm heavily interested in electronic ensembles because it's just impossible to get the bass to "meld" outside of the rhythm section unless you're approaching it carefully. that's why i'm stuck on the issue of having my music recording ahead of time and having an audio engineer and/or DJ perform with me so the burden isn't completely mine and so the audience has something to watch rather than me hitting buttons for 30 minutes while i'm trying to play my part and be entertaining.

like i said, though, it just fell into my preferences and went together flawlessly. on guitar, i'd have to work my ass off to get something up to speed, clean, to learn a new technique, but on bass it's all very simple and comes incredibly naturally. i enjoy the fact that my fingers are the tone producers and it's very easy to hear what i want the note to sound like and just change my finger approach, articulation, which finger i'm using, whatever and find something that works. with guitar i didn't have fun with that kind of exploration - it was just more of a burden rather than an interesting thing to me. that's all you need - to love innovation and enjoy what you're doing enough to not even realize how much time and effort and obsession you're putting into it.

@magg: listen to jaco. all the secrets of the universe can be found in his playing.
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#30
^^ Yeah... Well, I was talking about more typical guitar solos (try to play a solo by Slash and I think it sounds awful on bass). My band's guitarist sucks on bass. He plays it too much like guitar and that's what makes it sound bad. You need to play them differently, they are different instruments.
Quote by AlanHB
Just remember that there are no boring scales, just boring players.

Gear

Bach Stradivarius 37G
Charvel So Cal
Hartke HyDrive 210c
Ibanez BL70
Laney VC30
Tokai TB48
Yamaha FG720S-12
Yamaha P115
#31
Quote by MaggaraMarine
. You need to play them differently, they are different instruments.


i disagree i'm by no means the best bass player but i can keep up generally and it's only because i've got decent guitar chops and decent ears. the only way i really play differently is in the purely physical aspect of hand/arm movement to compensate for the neck and string distance.
#32
Quote by z4twenny
Fewer strings = easier to play. Since I don't slap n pop my bass technique is real similar to my guitar technique and by that rationale it's easier to play.
The funny thing is, fewer strings actually makes it a lot ****ing harder. You can only move across an octave + a fourth/fifth in the same position, whereas on guitar you can span two octaves + a third without shifting at all. Plus, working out chord voicings on guitar is a lot easier because of the wider range of notes within the same area of the fretboard.
Only play what you hear. If you don’t hear anything, don’t play anything.
-Chick Corea
#33
to be fair a solo by slash sounds awful on guitar, too
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#35
Quote by z4twenny
i disagree i'm by no means the best bass player but i can keep up generally and it's only because i've got decent guitar chops and decent ears. the only way i really play differently is in the purely physical aspect of hand/arm movement to compensate for the neck and string distance.

Yes, I can also play bass because I can play guitar but they have a different role in a band. The technique is the same but the way you play it is different. You need to play certain things in certain parts to sound good. As I said, our band's guitarist is a terrible bassist. He can play it technically pretty well but when he plays, he doesn't play the right things in the right time and plays solos all the time. It just sounds terrible.
Quote by AlanHB
Just remember that there are no boring scales, just boring players.

Gear

Bach Stradivarius 37G
Charvel So Cal
Hartke HyDrive 210c
Ibanez BL70
Laney VC30
Tokai TB48
Yamaha FG720S-12
Yamaha P115
#36
Quote by Matt.Guitar
When you start trying to claim one instrument is easier to play than another, you really do open a can of worms.
Why does everything always have to be a contest? Good bass players know their place.


good guitarists keep their amps off

that's when they know we give them the treatses, yes we do, that's a good boy, ruff ruff, metal up your ass, how cute of you, you think you can think
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
#37
Quote by chronowarp
Of course there's a logical reason. The role of the bass in a modern rock ensemble is really simplistic, almost exclusively monophonic, and rarely abundant in any extreme technical challenges.

What is crucial in a mix? Focused low end. Kick and Bass. If youre bass is kapoodlingdoodling all the time then where the **** is your focused low end.


Yeah, but I was thinking that, not only are there other styles besides rock and in many of those Bass gets a good amount of spotlight, but also that even in rock there's bands like Iron Maiden and Rush that are extremely popular (and not overly technical like tech death metal or a lot of prog metal bands) and have bass players that contribute just as much as the lead instruments. Do people trashing bass simply choose to pretend bands like those even exist? Yeah, I agree that the role of the bass player is usually different, but it is not necessarily easier. The role of the drums is different from the role of the guitar too, yet you don't see people claiming it is an easier instrument because it is more of a rhythm instrument. There's no real justifiable logic to it when it's so easy to provide counter-examples.

Quote by TV-Casualty
Bass is typically used as a support instrument. If you look at a lot of rock bands with bass players hammering on the root note while the guitar player is more harmonically active, its easy to see why some may consider bass an easier instrument. And in a case like that I would agree, but of course that is not always going to be the case.
As you said before, either can be as easy or as difficult as the player wants to make them


Exactly my point. What is typical isn't necessarily the rule. And I agree with the poster above that people need to stop comparing instruments and just play whatever they want to play on the instrument they are most comfortable with, whether it is guitar, bass, piano, sax, banjo, etc.

I immediately think of Bela Fleck playing those Bach violin partitas on the banjo... I'm glad he didn't see himself forcibly confined to country and bluegrass (nothing wrong with those styles, but the more the merrier) just because his instrument of choice is the banjo.

Quote by Hail
it's definitely easier to be unique, but it's all about doing whatever you might find your niche in. i wouldn't switch to bass just cause it's easier to be flashy - it's a logistical nightmare, because outside of the big names like hamm, pastorius, wooten and that ilk there's very little exploration in that realm, which means whatever you do needs to involve you absolutely owning it.

plus, after a point, unless you plan on being subserviant to other (read: not necessarily better) musicians, you're quite limited. i'm heavily interested in electronic ensembles because it's just impossible to get the bass to "meld" outside of the rhythm section unless you're approaching it carefully. that's why i'm stuck on the issue of having my music recording ahead of time and having an audio engineer and/or DJ perform with me so the burden isn't completely mine and so the audience has something to watch rather than me hitting buttons for 30 minutes while i'm trying to play my part and be entertaining.

like i said, though, it just fell into my preferences and went together flawlessly. on guitar, i'd have to work my ass off to get something up to speed, clean, to learn a new technique, but on bass it's all very simple and comes incredibly naturally. i enjoy the fact that my fingers are the tone producers and it's very easy to hear what i want the note to sound like and just change my finger approach, articulation, which finger i'm using, whatever and find something that works. with guitar i didn't have fun with that kind of exploration - it was just more of a burden rather than an interesting thing to me. that's all you need - to love innovation and enjoy what you're doing enough to not even realize how much time and effort and obsession you're putting into it.


Yeah, I wouldn't switch based on logistics alone. Like I said, I'd give it a try first before making decision. Classical guitar just takes up most of my free time already, and I'm wondering, since I am getting used to using my fingers as tone producers, like you said, if maybe Bass would come to me more naturally at this point than electric guitar does or ever did.

I wasn't thinking about just being flashy and having the spotlight, I was thinking more about which one is easier to have a niche with... Everybody and their little brother plays electric guitar, it seems. So Bass just seems to be something where finding something not everybody can offer might be less difficult. I might be wrong, though. Like you said, if it involves absolutely owning it, then maybe it is just about as difficult, if not more, than it is with the guitar.

I'll see if I can borrow somebody's bass and give it a shot and see if it's more comfortable for me.
#38
So he starts the thread and ditches when he sees the angry villagers with burning torches damn
#39
My two cents on bass being easier;

I feel that it's easier to pick up as a complete n00b and get productive with more quickly. As was already mentioned, someone with no clue can pick up a bass and play root-note rock pretty easily. And since there is plenty of music where that's all you need, you can contribute to a band just by learning the notes on the neck and off you go.

With a guitar, you'll need to know some chords, at least, and butt-simple solos aren't gonna cut it. So, you'll need to learn more to be able to contribute guitar to a band.

Now, of course, once you get beyond the basics (or is that bassics?), each instrument has its own school of virtuosity that requires a different set of skills to master. Some skills transfer, some don't.
#40
cryo: get a hold of a conklin 7 string. best of both worlds, tune it BEADGCD and have a ball
Quote by theogonia777
Hail killed MT

Quote by jongtr
I want to be Hail when I grow up.
Page 1 of 2