Bob Dolan :D
Registered User
Join date: Oct 2012
163 IQ
#1
Hello I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this, but ill take a shot considering its the Jazz/Blues forum..

I'm fairly new to jazz playing, but i have done quite a bit of theory before this, and I thought it would be a good idea to try learn some jazz standards, and went with one of my favourites, Autumn leaves..

I've always played the song in the Key of G, but the other day I came across a video of Stanley Jordan playing it.

[forbidden link] - very cool use of 2 guitars

However, I took the melody as I know it (VI,VII, I, IV - for the first group of notes) up to higher octave like he plays it, but it didn't sound right, and when I tried to transcribe it, it found that it was obviously the same interval of notes, but a half tone higher, in the key of Ab..

So my question is, is he just playing it in a different key to what its usually played in, are am I just missing something?

And also, I have a shaking feeling my ears might be deceiving me, cause I've only recently stopped using tabs, and started using my ears, and I might be wrong about the whole thing..

Thanks in advance
FrauVfromPoB
Registered User
Join date: Jun 2010
662 IQ
#2
People play standards in different keys all the time. It also could be due to Youtube compression, or someone altering the pitch to dodge copyright issues.
mattrusso
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2012
615 IQ
#3
First of all, the key of that tune is E minor, not G major.

FrauVfromPoB is exactly right. It's probably just being played in a different key, but people do sometimes change the pitch on YouTube so as not to get sued.
mattrusso
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2012
615 IQ
#5
Quote by Fallenoath
E minor's relative scale is G Major, so its pretty much the same thing though.

It's not the same at all. E minor is built from the same basic set of notes as G major, but the tonal center is E, not G. That alone is a HUGE difference. Also, minor keys have a different (similar, but not the same) set of "rules" from major keys. One example in this tune would be the fact that many people play E-6 as the tonic chord instead of E- or E-7. If this was G major, this would be a VI-6, which functionally doesn't make any sense.
Fallenoath
My minds playin' tricks
Join date: Feb 2012
985 IQ
#6
Quote by mattrusso
It's not the same at all. E minor is built from the same basic set of notes as G major, but the tonal center is E, not G. That alone is a HUGE difference. Also, minor keys have a different (similar, but not the same) set of "rules" from major keys. One example in this tune would be the fact that many people play E-6 as the tonic chord instead of E- or E-7. If this was G major, this would be a VI-6, which functionally doesn't make any sense.


Oh, I always heard that you can switch between the two and that's why a lot of backtracks have both the major and minor keys attached to them. I'm no master such as yourself but I thought you could. In a way I thought it was like using a mode.

Sorry.
Just another Sheep in the design of the Almighty Machine.


-GEAR-
Gibson 60s Les Paul Tribute (Sunburst)
1999 Ibanez RG470 (TitaniumIce-MIJ)
Jackson RR3 (Trans-Red)
Peavey 6505+
Podx3
smartguyreviews
Kenny G on Ecstacy
Join date: May 2008
863 IQ
#7
its G minor

its always been G minor

the only people who play in E minor are ones who think owning a real book makes them jazz players

call autumn leaves at an actual jazz jam. they will know its G minor or quickly out themselves as nothingness.