As the title suggests, a few weeks back one of the tuning pegs (D string) chipped off so now I have to tune with some needle nose pliers on that string. Hardly rock n roll during a gig.

I thought it was a Les Paul Standard but it's from 2001 and the tuners are plastic rather than chrome; I've attached a picture.

I don't know if I should replace them all since I never have or if I should just get one via this link: http://www.ebay.com/itm/like/111057642814?lpid=82

Would that work with my guitar or is the sizing different? They don't really expound much in that listing.

Anyway it has been having some tuning issues so I figure replacing them all might help. In that case maybe I should go with these: http://www.guitarcenter.com/Gibson-Vintage-Nickel-Machine-Heads-with-Pearloid-Buttons-100308475-i1128020.gc

Would those fit? I'd hate to spend that kind of money and have them not match what I have.

I've seen super cheap ones for $10 from China but I haven't heard good things about those.

Any help here would be most appreciated.
tuning peg.jpg