#2
Nice sound quality, good job on that Not a huge fan of your tone though, but that's just my opinion.

There's some really nice stuff there, the main riff is nice, but overall there is a lot of repetition in the first few minutes, but that is a common problem with instrumentals. I really like the part that begins just before the two minute mark, from that point on to 2:30 it's great in my opinion. The following solo is nice, but not my thing really. The powerful riff after that is a nice break, after that there is a really, really nice melodic thrash riff. And at 4:00 there is that riff that really reminds me of the start of the song, but with a twist, so there's nice progression going on. Outro of the song was maybe a bit weak compared to the rest o f the song, but it was still a nice part. The ending was maybe a bit abrupt.

So that's my two cents, I hope that you take something out of it. Overall impression: I really liked it. Great job imo
#3
It's pretty good, but the tone needs some work. I'm not hearing bass (maybe you didn't record bass yet), but the guitar needs to fill out the low end a bit. Otherwise, it's pretty tight.

Care to check out my song? It's a heavy proggy instrumental. More info hereA Lumberjack Enraged thread