Great Spinal Tap moment at 2:35! The show must go on! Sound quality could be better, but I know that isn't easy for a live show. Not easy to tell how good the singing is with the sound quality. Guitar player & singer have stage presence (their energy). Guitar player should tune guitar with sound muted (need a tuner with muting capability). Long ago I played in a band where one of the guitar players would tune his guitar at very loud volume: extremely annoying. Good for a first show together. I know from experience that first shows can be a disaster: some people can really choke in front of a crowd. Never hurts to have a girl in the band if she plays well (she did). Drummer did fine. Perhaps you could review my music at this link: