#2
I enjoyed that it had some good subtle atmospheric quality to it, and great rhythmic tone. I really enjoyed the little lick being cycled starting on 1:50 to break things up for a bit. The title of the song is 100% perfectly fitting for the kind of vibe it gives off and being that you describe this as punk. My critique Id give for this is that you have a very solid foundation here for other things to be layered on top of this maybe like some leads Idk if that would be less punk but i could hear it yearning for some instruments voice at times, and you probably already know this but with some decent vocals/lyrics this would be a hit .

C4C= https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1679534
#3
Great, I really like this man. Its upbeat and has a happy vibe to it which I look for in music! I used to listen to a lot of punk and can hear influences in here from loads of punk rocks bands. I really wish there were some vocals to this I can imagine a great melody over this that would be catchy as hell! Please C4C mine here bro https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1679688
#4
I like it, but I think it's a mix of rock and punk, but it is very fun sounding. I think my only suggestion is raise guitar volume a hair, I kept getting distracted by the drums and missing some of the guitar, they sound good together though, I think it's just a volume or eq thing, then again, might be my add lolol. Keep on keeping on!

Chex out my instrumentals if you get time
https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1679019