i saw you at the
rock gym and i thought you were
pretty cool
you yelled and didn't give a fuck

you had hair in your face and
you listened to sleighbells
i thought i might fall over
you asked me if i was gonna
go to the climbing movie later i said no

later we matched on tinder but
before that i saw you on
your bike and i didn't
say hi

you looked like a total badass
crossing two lanes
of traffic
I really like this. You've found something very clever and/or honest, captures how people present themselves right now.

I'd cut out one "later", or both, just wasted words, and you wouldn't give the game away for "before".