Hey mate, I'm not very well-versed in the acoustic genre but I'll try to be helpful. First question, how did you mic the guitar? I think it sounds a bit too boomy/bassy and this often characteristic of placing a microphone at the main hole of the body. Perhaps you should experiment with placing the microphone either at the 12th fret or pointing upward to the bottom of the body. The vibrato effect is not for me personally but the vocals sound fine to me.

Would appreciate it if you could C4C: