rocknroll blues
<3 teh fuzz
Join date: Aug 2005
253 IQ
#1
So the two concert albums that I have of the Who during the period when they performed Tommy in either its entirety (or almost its entirety) are Live at the Isle of Wight and Live at Leeds. On both of these are almost complete renditions of Tommy.

Personally, I think on Wight, the first half (the R&B-fueled mod freak-outs, as it were) is better than the Tommy half, whereas on Leeds I believe it's the other way around (though, A Quick One... at Leeds is pretty sploogetastic).

Anyway, I was wondering how everyone felt about this: do you prefer the rock n roll / R&B halves or the Tommy halves?
Peace, peace, and that's my piece.

Just another pale, skinny, noiserawkin' indie boy with tousled hair

Last.fm
VoodooChild15
Day-Man
Join date: Jan 2004
1,673 IQ
#2
Live, definately the non-Tommy stuff. There's more room for exploration outside the rock opera format. They're about even if we're talking about albums though.
Listen to mah discs.



And coming soon, THE CLEVER DEVILS VS. THE BLONDES.

Vote for me in the
Jesse Mrau
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2005
148 IQ
#3
Although I do enjoy Tommy, alot. I feel they preformed the Rock N Roll R&B stuff better live. And the DVD for Isle Of Wight is amazing.
Sgt. Pepper19
Registered User
Join date: May 2004
55 IQ
#4
Good thread idea. I enjoy the non-Tommy material on Live at Leeds compared to the opposed. I perfer the Tommy second half on the Isle of Wight compared to the opposed. Why? I have no idea.
DieN
I like music
Join date: Dec 2005
121 IQ
#5
I love Tommy but live it is the RnB stuff I enjoy more.
btw...I think on Live At Leeds they where better than on Isle Of Wight. They seemed so tired at the festival performance.
Substitute
Banned
Join date: Mar 2006
10 IQ
#6
Amazing Journey(Sparks) live at Leeds dazzled me. Sparks is my favorite song, it was pretty amazing. But Young Man Blues, Magic Bus, Heaven And Hell, and Happy Jack are my other favorites for the Leeds section. For the Wight album, I found Tommy a little sloppy.. Then again, it was like 4 AM or something. Plus they had less time to practice Tommy in general. Does anyone know if Tommy was played in full in 1969 at Woodstock? Thanks.
ZoSoII_13
The music elitest
Join date: Jan 2006
347 IQ
#7
I think the coolest thing about both albums, especially leeds is just the power of the entire show.
Long Live Rock

Be it dead or alive..



Founding Member of the Capital Punishment to people posting about Guns N Roses in the Classic Rock Forum Club. PM me to join.

a proudly scarred member of the Windmiller's Club
jayr123guitar
YOU NEED MORE GUITAR
Join date: Oct 2005
1,807 IQ
#8
I actually prefer seeing the Tommy section on video as opposed to hearing it on disc. Overall I do prefer the R&B stuff myself, but Tommy is brilliant, no doubt about it. Keith Moon is the shiznit..........
Iruleeverything
UG Newbie
Join date: Jan 2005
120 IQ
#9
I think that Live at leeds, is a much better live version of tommy, isle of wight seems sorta off to me. Of course I love both so much I can't chose between either.
MySpace
Quote by syyz1
You're right, I mean, I can imagine eating children, but listening to good music seems a little too much. You, Iruleeverything, are the master of torture.