Poll: Whos a better lyrical and musical writer?
Poll Options
View poll results: Whos a better lyrical and musical writer?
Neil Young both lyrics and music
4 13%
Neil Young lyrics
0 0%
Neil Young music
10 33%
Bob Dylan both lyrics and music
16 53%
Bob Dylan lyrics
11 37%
Bob Dylan music
0 0%
Voters: 30.
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#1
Well these two men are both highly idolized by me in both musical talent as well as lyrical talent.

Tell me who you think is better at writing lyrics and the music. Bob Dylan or Neil Young


I personally think Dylan has a slight advantage on young lyrically, but Young is better at composing his music.


You can vote for one or more options, you can vote for multiple ones. For like Ex. Dylan as lyrics, Young as music.
Its how you look and how you feel
Last edited by Hauf at Jun 13, 2006,
imburningstar4
Registered User
Join date: Mar 2006
73 IQ
#2
I like neil young more
but that doesn't mean he writes better songs than dylan
i just like his more
Quote by sonixon
I'll say.
They were originally going make Claudio a part of Mount Rushmore, but the material was not tough enough to sculpt his hair out of.

Quote by thefinalcut
"St. Anger" was done in Drop Z tuning, they were trying to "out heavy" Slipknot.
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#3
Ya, I take Young over Dylan too, but I love them both
Its how you look and how you feel
skydogzoso1986
Registered User
Join date: May 2005
430 IQ
#6
dylan is the best! neal young gets boring after a while imo. i can listen to dylan all day without getting bored, he can be very energetic and can do many things with his simple voice and accoustic guitar/harmonica
Fender Classic Series '50s Telecaster
Fender Hot Rod Deluxe
Mi Audio Crunch Box
Atreideslegend
UG Fanatic
Join date: Apr 2003
820 IQ
#7
dylan is much better for lyrics but neil pwns him for musical creativity without a doubt, also neil is better at the harmonica.

However, i prefer dylan in general to Neil Young.
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#8
Ah, atreideslegend, I thought I met someone who agrees with me, but you took dylan voer young :0

lol, yes I agree Neil is better at harmonica. It's a little easier to listen to then Dylans harmonica playing. I like how they both play it, but Dylan will sometimes play a high note for like 10 seconds and it just hurts my ears.
Its how you look and how you feel
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#10
I know there are other greats, but I was asking between Dylan and Young.
Its how you look and how you feel
SomeEvilDude
Government Conspiracy
Join date: Aug 2004
627 IQ
#11
I put Neil Young for music; Needle & The Damage Done and Crime In The City are brilliant songs. Plus Neil Young's a better guitarist and harmonicist.

That said, I voted Dylan for lyrics; it's very very close though, although I think Dylan is marginally better. Definately the two best lyricists alive though, and two of the best of all time definately.

Quote by Inahrima
Dylan, but there are other great lyricists too, james hetfield for example.


James Hetfield firstly isn't classic rock, and secondly his lyrics are terrible.
stonegolem13
What's the Rush?
Join date: Apr 2006
262 IQ
#12
Dylan all the way man!!!
Co-founder of the UG Pink Floyd Fan club PM me or nick dixon
Winner of the CR Best Avatar Award

Quote by bodyheatseeker
ohhh burrrrn!
That's how we roll in the CR forum.
Irritate us, and we'll sic our 14 year old on you!
BlueOyster23
Welcome To My Nightmare
Join date: Apr 2005
860 IQ
#13
Bob Dylan for both, but Neil Young is one of my favorite singers.
"...And I'm pretty sure what you did to my children's snowman is illegal, if not, sodomy."
-Stephen Colbert: 'The Colbert Report'
slinks
Bastard in a Basket
Join date: May 2005
443 IQ
#14
Both are tied for composition, but I think Dylan slightly edges out Young in songwriting.
Black Star
UG Fanatic
Join date: Dec 2005
376 IQ
#15
Neil Young for music.

For lyrics, I chose Bob Dylan, but he didn't beat Neil Young by much. They are very close.
My guitar modification blog.
Quote by MuffinMan
Jesus was all like "To those about to rock, I salute you." then he grabbed his mighty axe and rocked the Romans out really hard. Of course they were strict classical music so....
Guitaraphone06
Registered User
Join date: Feb 2006
509 IQ
#17
Dylan for both, I like Neil Young but Bob Dylan definitley deserves the better credit for both music and lyrics
Member #5 of the I <3 Schecter's Club-PM Schecter-06 to join
"Member of the Guitarists that wished they could sing because they would make fantastic frontmen club"-Pm Davidian to join
freewheelinbird
UG Addict
Join date: Apr 2005
2,222 IQ
#19
personally, stuff that is highly praised as his best stuff, like some stuff off blonde on blonde, MUSICALLY is great, but lyrically...over analyzed nonsense

from sad eyed lady of the low lands (one of my favorite cuts hahah)
"My warehouse eyes, my Arabian drums,
Should I leave them by your gate,
Or, sad-eyed lady, should I wait?"

people call it genius ?? personally i think his best lyrics lie in his work prior to him going electric.

and "visions of johanna" a GREAT song, but here's an excerpt

"hear the jelly-faced women all sneeze
hear the mustached one say 'jeeze
i can't find my knees'"

great stuff, but lyrics are just random
Quote by JimmyPageSlash
nice i like how rocker clothes are cheap. im gonna be dressing completely rocker soon


TOOL ALERT
Last edited by freewheelinbird at Jun 13, 2006,
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#21
Ya, Dylan does get a bit random at times. Like in Ballad of a Thin Man.

Now you see this one-eyed midget
Shouting the word "NOW"
And you say, "For what reason?"
And he says, "How?"
And you say, "What does this mean?"
And he screams back, "You're a cow
Give me some milk
Or else go home"
Its how you look and how you feel
slinks
Bastard in a Basket
Join date: May 2005
443 IQ
#22
"Ballad of a Thin Man" is one of my favorites, though.
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#23
Oh yeh, def. It's one of my favorites too, infact I was playing it today on my piano
Its how you look and how you feel
Gabuydachk
Registered User
Join date: Oct 2005
443 IQ
#24
they're both very different musicians, lyricists, and people
imo, I like them both

'tis life
Hauf
On the Human Highway
Join date: Apr 2005
878 IQ
#25
Hmm, I disagree Gabuydachk.

I think they are pretty similar musicans in many aspects, mostly their folk stuff. Neil gets a bit more rockish then Dylan does but I still think they are similar.
Its how you look and how you feel
Jesse Mrau
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2005
148 IQ
#27
^Same.

Dylan is completely above everyone else for lyrics. But Young can compose one hell of a song!
sirpsycho85
selfstyled voice o reason
Join date: Feb 2004
858 IQ
#28
bobby for both. i love neil young, but i'll take bob in every category anytime. the thing i can say is that i like neil youngs voice more than bob's now that the'yre both old, but in their prime i prefer bob in every category.
"I see my light come shining from the west down to the east
Any day now, any day now I shall be released"

Know any good teachers in NY, especially skilled in teaching ear training? Tell me
jono034
I'm Your Huckleberry
Join date: Nov 2001
724 IQ
#29
no "vs." threads!



***CLOSED***
UG NMA Member #2

Gil Grissom PWNS YOU!