#1
WHO'S YOUR BEST , UNDER RATED , OVER RATED GUITARIST........


BEST: DARRELL "DIMEBAG" ABBOTT

UNDER RATED: JERRY CANTRELL

OVER RATED: Jeffery Phillip Wiedlandt AKA ZAKK WYLDE
#2
Over rated: Dime, and Kurt


Quote by justinb904
im more of a social godzilla than chameleon

Quote by MetalMessiah665
Alright, I'll give them a try, Japanese Black Speed rarely disappoints.

Quote by azzemojo
Hmm judging from your pic you'd fit in more with a fat busted tribute.
#3
Quote by dime&kurt
WHO'S YOUR BEST , UNDER RATED , OVER RATED GUITARIST........


BEST: DARRELL "DIMEBAG" ABBOTT

UNDER RATED: JERRY CANTRELL

OVER RATED: Jeffery Phillip Wiedlandt AKA ZAKK WYLDE


#4
Chance of anyone coming up with a interesting thread in the metal forum - 0%
101010101010001010101
#7
Best: *Arguable*
Underrated: *Arguable* Christopher Amott.
Overrated: Dimebag, Kurt Cobain, Jerry Cantrell, etc. As for other overrated things: caps lock.
Last edited by Embodiment at Aug 27, 2006,
#9
kirk hammet is definitly not underrated...
id say hes overrated actually
"Music is religion for me. There'll be music in the hereafter, too." - Jimi Hendrix
#10
Quote by las7
Chance of anyone coming up with a interesting thread in the metal forum - 0%


Pfft....


....who eats apples as a healthy snack?
#11
Quote by dime&kurt
WHO'S YOUR BEST , UNDER RATED , OVER RATED GUITARIST........


BEST: John Petrucci

UNDER RATED: JERRY CANTRELL

OVER RATED: Dimebag, Kirk Hammett, Insert dead guitarist who died at 27 or early in career


*Fixed
#12
Best guitarists: SRV (blues/rock), Herman Li (metal), Tom Morello (originality)
Most overrated guitarists: Synester Gates, Kirk Hammet (now), Zakk Wylde
Most underrated guitarts: James Hetfield (incredible songwriter and great riff-writer), Dave Mustaine (my favorite rythym guitarist/songwriter/soloist ever)
#14
Dimebag is not god, but he is really good. Most people haven't actually seen how good he is though, he didn't win all those competitions as a kid by being a Kirk Hammet. He really does possess skill, therefore I'm not going to say he's over rated.

As for this thread, pointless. Rating is in the ears and eyes of the listener and viewer.
-Mike
#15
Quote by dime&kurt
WHO'S YOUR BEST , UNDER RATED , OVER RATED GUITARIST........


BEST: DARRELL "DIMEBAG" ABBOTT

UNDER RATED: JERRY CANTRELL

OVER RATED: Jeffery Phillip Wiedlandt AKA ZAKK WYLDE



Take the caps off n00ber.

Quote by Stiffy Maximus
best: chuck schuldiner
under: chuck schuldiner
over: jimmy page


Page aint metal.

Quote by ninyader
best : herman li
underrated : kirk hammett
overrated : dimebag


Kirk is OVERrated.

Quote by shanerdoo
best-alexi laiho
under-chet atkins
over-kirk hammett


Chet Atkins is country...this is akward.


Quote by SGRocker0791
Pfft....


....who eats apples as a healthy snack?



I do!!!111!!!11
#18
Most of the Bests should be the over rateds :p

Eh it's whatever you like, I think a lot of guitarist can make good music and play with confidence, that's how they got where they are.
-Mike
#19
Quote by HopePoisoned

Eh it's whatever you like, I think a lot of guitarist can make good music and play with confidence, that's how they got where they are.


Agreed
#20
Quote by Mr. President
Best:Me
Under: Me
Over: Everybody Else


I'm over-rated.
#21
Chuck Schuldiner or Andy LaRocque are without a doubt the most underrated.
Member #2 of the "Eggnog > Humanity" club
^^Pm Scourge441 to join

PM MackDaddy or RhinosaurBones to join the Mortal Kombat Klub. That's right, Klub with a K.

Quote by happytimeharry
wow, is that backgammon? Now that's what I call fore play...
#22
Quote by SGRocker0791


That was my joke I haven't used it in awhile, but still.
2006 AND 2007 Ultimate Guitar Best Vocalist

Quote by Magero
Jack - 3:54 AM
I will smoke, and eat and watch Futurama in your honour
#24
It's a chick .... hanging .... in a tree.

Seems self-explanatory to me.
2006 AND 2007 Ultimate Guitar Best Vocalist

Quote by Magero
Jack - 3:54 AM
I will smoke, and eat and watch Futurama in your honour
#27
Best- Muhammed Suicmez
Underrated- Chuck Schuldiner or Jon Nodveidt
Overrated- Zakk Wylde, Kerry King
#29
Best: Petrucci
Underrated: Friedman (or Jason Becker)
Overrated: Definately Kirk Hammet
No fucking images.

Ghey.
#31
Best: John Petrucci
Under: Dimebag.. i hate when people bash him
Over: Kirk Hammett
Ibanez RGA 121
Ibanez RG3EX1
Some sort of Marshall Stack
Ibanez Weeping Demon
Little POD thing



Plagued Paradise
#32
Best- Trey Azagthoth
Under- Matt Sotelo from Decrepit Birth
Over- Herman Li
"In the name of Satan, I condemn this image of God."- Deicide "Trifixion"
#33
Best: Depends on who you ask, but I'm gonna go with Chris Broderick
Under: Jari Maenpaa
Over: Mikael Akerfeldt(sp?)
#34
Best: James Murphy

Underrated: Jeff Hanneman - definitely the better of the two guitarists of Slayer.

Overrated: Chuck Schuldiner - he wrote some kick ass music, but I've heard much better guitar


edit: since when is Petrucci metal? Same goes for Jason Becker. Steve Vai, Joe Satriani...

NOT METAL!!!
"Virtually no one who is taught Relativity continues to read the Bible."

Last edited by Bubonic Chronic at Aug 28, 2006,
#35
underrated - Herman Li
overrated - Mick Thompson
best - Dimebag, Alexi Laiho

It's really dissapointing to see Dime in the "overrated" I found he was really good... R.I.P.
#36
Best - Matt Heafy
Under Rated - Dimebag Darrel
Over Rated - Kirk Hammet

thats my opinion, no need to argue over it...
Gear:

ESP KH II Vintage
Dean Dime Razorback Slime BumbleBee
Fender Stratocaster
Jackson King V
Line 6 Spider III 150w
Marshall MG100HDFX
Roland Cube 30w
Zoom 505 II
Line 6 Floor Pod
Monster Cables
#37
Quote by aluminum.maiden
underrated - Herman Li
best-Alexi Laiho



overrated: herman li, laiho


(even though theyre not bad by any means)
Youtube covers

[url="http://www.youtube.com/user/MrJumboHumbo[/URL"]
#38
Quote by abhimetalhead
Best - Matt Heafy
Under Rated - Dimebag Darrel
Over Rated - Kirk Hammet

thats my opinion, no need to argue over it...


Do I need to cut your balls off?