#1
So...in light of the enormous amount of people claiming that Ian Mckaye isn't straightedge, I have a question. Is anyone in/from a straightedge band still edge? I don't really think that Ian broke edge, seeing as it's his mantra and he never said "never have a beer." but anyway, if there's anyone you know or you yourself are still edge, that's okay too. post!


Personally, I bet that the dudes from XfilesX are still...they were pretty damn pissed off.
Everything I say is a lie. Is this true or false? Ha! I made that up!
#2
I dont think Lyle is anymore but honestly Im not sure.

But I know Afi are and pretty sure Gorilla Biscuits are.
#3
I think Ian MacKaye was the only person who was actively "straight edge" in the band. And again, Straight Edge was mostly about moderation, not abstinence.
#4
I know...I'm pretty sure Larm are..cuz those guys are in seein' red. Very few people, it seems, break edge and continue to be in hardcore bands...just a guess though, they very well might not be.
Everything I say is a lie. Is this true or false? Ha! I made that up!
#6
Quote by Iliemyfaceoff
I dont think Lyle is anymore but honestly Im not sure.

But I know Afi are and pretty sure Gorilla Biscuits are.

I'm almost sure only Jade and Davey are straight edge, but hunter and adam are vegans just like jade and davey...