Godzilla1969
UG's Pretentious Asshole
Join date: Dec 2005
546 IQ
#1
Obviously, a band's independent label is what truly makes them indie, but since "indie" has transformed into a whole genre in itself, what do you think makes a band "indie" as opposed to rock or electronic? It's a tough question for me to answer; I know one when I hear one, I just can't put my finger on what sets them apart from other genres besides their independent labels. Mellow rock, sometimes folk, and often synth/keyboard definately contribute to it for me.
Last edited by Godzilla1969 at Dec 7, 2006,
Bristlehead
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2003
752 IQ
#2
Yeah that's it for me too. Why the hell are they called indie? Becuase only indie labels would sign them?
devandivine
Registered User
Join date: Jun 2006
32 IQ
#4
i did a project on this in school and i didnt ge tthat good of a mark because of the contrasting definitions of indie i used lol
1. Indie is described as a band with an independant record label/none at all
2. A genre of music for bands that have made it mainstream through college radio and such
Epiphone Les Paul Special 2
Samick Corsair (custom evh paint job)
Bever Creek Acoustic
Boss DS-1
Behringer Bx108
Behringer Kx1200
starsnostars
gloommonger
Join date: Nov 2005
1,035 IQ
#5
i can see this getting locked fast, but yeah, indie to me means bands that are truly independent and self release things. or at the very most, bands that are on small labels and receive little backing. meaning, i do no consider bands like death cab, modest mouse, or the decemberists indie.
Godzilla1969
UG's Pretentious Asshole
Join date: Dec 2005
546 IQ
#6
^But if they're mainstream, they aren't indie anymore.

EDIT: To Devandivine
Kartman
Samuel in da tub.
Join date: May 2005
2,406 IQ
#7
Indie is a status, not a genre. I think when bands label themselves Indie, they're trying get the image of the low budget raw band.
WHY IS EVERYONE IN THE PIT A FUCKING METALCORE KID
Last edited by Kartman at Dec 7, 2006,
Godzilla1969
UG's Pretentious Asshole
Join date: Dec 2005
546 IQ
#8
To me it is more of a status, but I wanted to know why it is now widely considered a genre.
pumpkins_rule
UG's Rap crusader
Join date: Aug 2004
1,404 IQ
#9
Eh, most of the time it's bands with pop sensibilities but without commercial appeal. Of Montreal, Wolf parade, BSS, Metric etc.
Ain't Nuthin' But a UG Thang: Generic member of the UG Hip Hop/Guitar Music Equality Illuminati

Quote by mydarkesthour

It seems like UG is full of those Caveman Metalheads

Quote by mydarkesthour
I meant caveman as in long haired....


astonmartin
Registered User
Join date: Nov 2004
422 IQ
#10
I think of it as catchy but instrumentaly interesting or unique
Quote by Mad Marius
Bush is a good president.

And yes, you HAVE to be drunk to say that with a straight face. And I sure am.



Quote by Garci
Damn, 1.2 billion dollers? Wonder how much that's in dollars
Godzilla1969
UG's Pretentious Asshole
Join date: Dec 2005
546 IQ
#11
Actually, I think these last two posts summed it up quite well.
Blue Motion
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2005
131 IQ
#12
i think the only requirement for a band to sound indie is that they are unique. indie just means their independant and don't compromise their music for commercial appeal. i also think it means they don't jump start their career on mtv or vh1 right from the beginning. i don't know why people keep saying bands like the fray and franz ferdinand are indie. i mean i like franz ferdinand (can't say the same for the fray) but their first single was all over the tv, its just not very indie. whereas if someone like modest mouse has been around for almost ten years and then plays a couple tv shows and has a music video on mtv they still have indie cred i think.
soadlp02
UG's Pissed Biscuit
Join date: Oct 2003
306 IQ
#13
I think that a lot of the stereotypical "indie" sound comes from the producer of the record and the equipment used. Once bands get popular and in turn rich enough to afford expensive equipment, it adds a sort of gloss to their sounds. To me, that's why you can have 2 bands that have completely different sounds but still be in the indie genre.
Member #23 of the Opeth Fan Club

God is dead.
"Tele" Steve
Registered User
Join date: May 2006
276 IQ
#14
I personally don't like the term "indie" because it's used wrong by most people. Many of the bands that are called "indie" are on major labels. To me, "indie" should mean "indie," i.e. artists on independent labels obviously.