watchingmefall
Government is hell
Join date: May 2006
1,458 IQ
#1
*Foreword*
This thread is not about discussing whether Mr. Harris plays with 2 or 3 fingers, we've been discussed that forever. /foreword

That out of the way, my bass teacher said that when you play the notes should be defined and consistent (I agree) and he then said that Steve Harris has a bad right hand technique because of the clank we can all hear, never the less he makes great music.

What do you say? bad technique or his own style?
musicology
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2006
48 IQ
#2
That argument will probably go on forever. I believe that the way you play is the way you play, and unless it interferes with how the music sounds, then it's all good. However, there are certain habits that hamper your ability and will end up hurting your muscles and eventually lead to surgery and the like, so that's probably not the best either. But, whatever works for Steve Harris makes him who he is.
My Gear:
Godin BG V and BG IV
GK 1001RB w/ 4x10 RBH
Palatino Upright
Ibanez Talman Artcore
Godin LG
Washburn Acoustic
Godin Classical
Traynor YCV80

DaliLama
Piss Mop
Join date: Apr 2006
152 IQ
#3
I was always impressed with Harris' note definition, a little finger noise never kept me from hearing a full, clear note from him. It's like pick noise on a guitar, and you can't get rid of that no matter how good you are. Would you say that Steve Morse has poor definition because of the sound of his picking, which is quite audible? In my experience as a young teacher at a music store, most older teachers are bitter bastards that don't like a god damned thing anymore.
Quote by zackk
seriously though, listen to DaliLama.
Quote by Arthur Curry
My spidey sense tells me some mothafuckas are gonna be BANNED.
SocKo?
Registered User
Join date: Feb 2005
96 IQ
#5
i actually enjoy that "clank" it makes him unique from other bassists and even adds some heaviness, if yuo will.
flyingmarlin
UG's Bill Foster
Join date: Jul 2006
2,435 IQ
#6
Quote by SocKo?
i actually enjoy that "clank" it makes him unique from other bassists and even adds some heaviness, if yuo will.


i get a clank and i use three fingers, its from the index finger hits the string too hard, i have a very bad technique
Yeah, now you're gonna die wearing that stupid little hat. How does it feel?

Help me to live.


I make custom guitar wiring harnesses and I'm pretty damn good at it!
indie-bassist
Second Cap'n Max Sparrow
Join date: Oct 2006
638 IQ
#7
He gets his clank from the strings hitting the frets because he attacks his bass hard. I dont think its a bad thing, its just individuality
Quote by Bumper
Looks like you had a big bowl of Downs Syndrome for breakfast.



Member of the Bass Militia, PM Nutter_101 to join

Lover of Ashdown? Join the Ashdown Army!
Your41Plague12
Eats spam for breakfast!
Join date: Jan 2006
724 IQ
#8
Kudos to Indie! The "CLANK" you hear in his bass sound is made from him pressing very harshly on the strings with his fretting hand, it has nothing to do with his right hand technique (at least that's what I've heard from numerous people, so correct me if I'm wrong).
Quote by PatMcRotch
The term grammer nazi is from the camps in the lolocaust made by Adrofl Hitlol...


Quote by Wasted Bassist
Be sure to rape the blue note (augmented 4th). Rape it hard and exploit it like the skank it is.


Founder of the All-Tube Bass Amp Owners Club. PM me to join.
IRONxPANTERA
Zombie killing pirate
Join date: Aug 2006
1,047 IQ
#9
well i heard steve harris lowers his action

and that works for me

but i really belive that he just plays so damn hard on the strings
he dose play with 2 fingers, and they can go insanley fast, and he can do it for the longest time
DiabloCoche
...needs a band
Join date: Oct 2006
350 IQ
#10
just to disagree i'm going to say he uses three fingers.
regardless

it's a combination of both his style AND where he plays

yes, he absolutely destroys his bass with its attacks.
but still

he plays closer to the neck as opposed to the bridge
which has a tendency to make the string hit the fret, hence the clang

and i think it sounds cool, personally

Ibanez Soundgear 300 DX
Digitech BP 80
Ibanez SW 20 / Ampeg BA 115
Squire Affinity Strat
Line 6 Spider IV 15
Porkie
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2006
32 IQ
#11
Well, I am almost sure , like 85% that I read somewhere that he uses roundwounds or flat wounds and that he doesn't play them like someone who woul dusually play them, but thats what works for him. Maybe thats the thing that make the clang so much.
UtBDan
BA of Music Theory
Join date: May 2004
4,564 IQ
#12
He uses 2 fingers, he has said that in several interviews - that is fact even if I always believed otherwise previously.

and its both... bad technique is style. Look at Flea for crying out loud. Les Claypool, Stanley Clarke, Victor wooten, sheehan, those guys are minimalists and have their own style, but I just mean - unless your technique is so bad no one gets the right idea, your technique (good or bad) is your style.
Quote by casualty01
the RIAA can't shut us down, interpol can't shut us down. the U.S. gov't can't shut us down and CERTAINLY not YOU can shut us down.


BA in Music theory
MusicMan Bongo, SUB -> Orange Terror 1000 stack

Quote by waterproofpie
it's a UtBDan sandwich. Awwww yeah!
Greenday389
BTBAM=Relevant
Join date: Jul 2005
615 IQ
#13
He uses heavy guage flatwounds with a low action and plays close to the bridge. He also has a very hard attack.

So I say it's his sound.
Bass is my life.
vashts80
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2006
46 IQ
#14
Quote by DiabloCoche
just to disagree i'm going to say he uses three fingers.
regardless

it's a combination of both his style AND where he plays

yes, he absolutely destroys his bass with its attacks.
but still

he plays closer to the neck as opposed to the bridge
which has a tendency to make the string hit the fret, hence the clang

and i think it sounds cool, personally


He uses two fingers and plays over the P pickup with heavy gauge (.110-.050) flatwounds and a low action. The only time he plays close to the neck is when he plays chords. He has a VERY hard attack though which gives him his signature clack-clack tone.
Gear:
SX SJB62-5 5-String Fretless Jazz Copy (EADGC)
Ibanez GSR200 4-String Fretted (BEAD)
Ibanez IBZ10B 10 Watt Practice Combo Amp
DR Stainless Steel Lo-Riders
Yamaha Air Cell Straps
Leper Affinity
I Love Noodles
Join date: Jan 2007
49 IQ
#15
i think if you get the tone and sound and feel you desire consistently without much mental effort, and get good enough at it to where it is natural, then you have good technique.

when I want to i can get as much clank as i want out of my bass ( medium-low action ) but I can also get a lot of sustain and no clank when I want to as well. Its got to do with what your goal in your tone and sound is and if you can achieve it.

and speaking of technique, many famous bass players have " bad " technique if you go by the " unwritten rules of technique ". Ive seen cliff burton in videos just slap the sh*t out of his bass with his palm, ive seen geddy lee with his thumb way over the top of the neck at times ( pretty much looks like hes going " thumbs up " ) and ive seen people play things with strange hand techniques ( victor wootens double thumping, bill clements tabla-style left hand tapping, fieldy's thumb-pinky slap ( bleh ) ) but they get what they want out of their music.

by any chance is your bass teach Jeff Berlin ( joking ).
TJ1991
Custom User Title
Join date: Feb 2006
3,722 IQ
#16
Quote by DaliLama
It's like pick noise on a guitar, and you can't get rid of that no matter how good you are.

Just do the same as Paul Weller and don't use a pick.

I like Steve's playing, and the clanck just proves he's not miming. And he's just generally awesome, so what does it matter?
myself101
Adagio For Beaker
Join date: Jul 2006
1,375 IQ
#17
I get that "clank" sometimes when i play, i really hate it

any tips on how not to?
"There are millions of people in the world, and none of those people are an extra. They're all leads in their own stories."
<//////>~
indie-bassist
Second Cap'n Max Sparrow
Join date: Oct 2006
638 IQ
#18
Make your action slightly higher, don't attack the bass so hard
Quote by Bumper
Looks like you had a big bowl of Downs Syndrome for breakfast.



Member of the Bass Militia, PM Nutter_101 to join

Lover of Ashdown? Join the Ashdown Army!
myself101
Adagio For Beaker
Join date: Jul 2006
1,375 IQ
#19
Quote by indie-bassist
Make your action slightly higher, don't attack the bass so hard


"There are millions of people in the world, and none of those people are an extra. They're all leads in their own stories."
<//////>~
mistersharp
Registered User
Join date: Apr 2009
21 IQ
#22
well i play a lot of maiden and can get the exact same sound by playing with high treble and ocasionally using my nails (i discovered this accidentaly, im guessing thats how steve does it: pluck with the edges of the fingers very slightly and ocasionaly hit harder and letting your nails grace the strings, you get the EXACT same click sound)

ps: i use his bass and his strings, that helps to get his sound
capslockisnton
Barmed
Join date: Aug 2008
120 IQ
#23
this thread be one and a half years old, matey, arrrrrrrr

/pirate
-
-
--
---
-----
--------
-------------
Yay fibonacci!