af_the_fragile
Banned
Join date: Aug 2006
1,289 IQ
#1
This discussion seems to be goin on for ever. Why are bands like Rise Against, Anti-Flag not considered punk by loads of people on this forum? Just cuz they are not as trashy as the original punk bands and they made it to the mainstream? They are still as politically motivated as any punk band. Their music is as energetic as any punk band. They are only being herd by more people now by being in the mainstream, how does that strip them of the "punk" label??!

Is punk only bout creating fast, trashy music which only a small group of people listen to in the underground??

Edit: I guess Alkaline Trio shouldnt have been there.. I just couldnt think more more bands like rise against and anti-flag to put in there...
Last edited by af_the_fragile at Feb 10, 2007,
revan1013
Registered User
Join date: Jul 2006
512 IQ
#2
hear this kinda thing with metal too, it's ridiculous, people need to grow up and stop caring about genre labels
Oppression, quiet and Repressed
Swept under the seams
the bed of the acquiesced
where we sleep, insomniac dreams
jesusgonewrong
His Awesomeness Andy
Join date: Sep 2005
454 IQ
#3
Punk is defined differently. Essentially, it's rebellious, against the establishment, hence when a band get's signed and make mass record's and get fame etc. they're called selling out as they go against the core punk rule.

Of course though, people can debate it.
Member of The Bass Militia. PM DinkyDaisy to join.
Co-Founding member of the Save the Funk club. PM jimmypage27 or me to join.
Founding Member of "Using gay as an insult proclaims your idiocy" club.
Member #11 of the UG RIP Cliff Burton Club
Stevie B
UG's #1 Eagles fan
Join date: Feb 2006
530 IQ
#4
Yes. To be very specific. Punk has generally been an underground thing. Although it was really just a musical scene in the 70's. Nowadays punk rock is just seen as bands creating the same sort of sound as those bands. Modern punk is kinda hard to define though. Fast paced, political and "trashy" is probably the best way of determining a Punk band i guess.
Also... when have Alkaline Trio ever been punk? Rise against and Anti flag i still consider to be some form of punk but Alkaline Trio?
My Gear:
Epiphone SG
Vintage SG
Stagg Strat (With replaced hardware and a Duncan Invader )
Hohner Strat
No name Acoustic
Jim Dunlop Crybaby
Boss MT-2
Boss DS-1
Roland Cube 60
Wires and patch cords and stuff..
Last edited by Stevie B at Feb 10, 2007,
af_the_fragile
Banned
Join date: Aug 2006
1,289 IQ
#5
Ain't Rise Against and Anti-Flag rebellious and against the establishment? They're only being herd more by getting signed. Whats wrong with that? They still make the same sorta music? Its just the underground punk bands get jealous of them cuz their music is not good enuf to get signed and they cant be herd by as many people as the mainstream punk bands do. So they call those bands as not punk!!
Iluvpowerchords
Flau-BEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR
Join date: Jan 2005
1,364 IQ
#6
Politics has little to do with defining punk music.

In fact, in the beggining most punk was about Nihilism, which is pretty much a way of saying nothing really matters.

Punk rock is a stripped down form of Rock music prevalent in the 70's which favors three chord progression, and plays down the blues aspect generally associated with rock.

It was rooted in the American Garage rock of the 60's.
Last edited by Iluvpowerchords at Feb 10, 2007,
Prince
born to lose
Join date: Jul 2004
390 IQ
#7
punk rock is agressive rock n roll

rise against and anti-flag arnt aggressive
af_the_fragile
Banned
Join date: Aug 2006
1,289 IQ
#9
Quote by Prince
punk rock is agressive rock n roll

rise against and anti-flag arnt aggressive


If you say Rise Against arn't aggressive, you haven't herd them well enuf! I think Rise Against is one of the most aggressive band out there. The only difference is they dont behave as bad asses. You dont hafta be a bad ass to be hardcore and aggressive! Something you kids should understand!!
sargasm
1977 and we are going mad
Join date: May 2003
1,817 IQ
#10
Rise Against and Anti-Flag aren't punk because they don't even know who the Vampire Cats are.
waterproofpie
breakfast connoisseur
Join date: Dec 2003
2,962 IQ
#11
Vampires Catz new album dropz Feb. 20!


I mean...
This is against FAQ
*closed*
Quote by CowsWithGuns
I've been busy getting drunk and yelling at endangered species for being pussies. It's a dehydrating job but someone has to do it.