Page 1 of 2
#1
Me and my friend are fighting over which band has a better guitarist. Jade Puget or Doyle from the Misfits. I know that AFI is better. but i just looked up a bunch of tabs and found that Doyle uses alot of powerchords. very simple chords. i was able to master the songs first try! With AFI, no, i can't do that.

so tell my friend which guitarist is better?
#2
well obviously the AFI one if you cant do it your first try, compared to being able to lol
I personally think both of them aren't that great but thats just my opinion, I hate both of those bands. But more on topic, AFI
#6
the misfits are a better band, but afi songs are more complex i guess. *shrug*






I CAN TOTALLY EXPLAIN THAT... I HAD... uh... UNPROTECTED SEX WITH A PORCUPINE
#7
Jade Puget definitely. I love the Misfits dearly, but Puget is the better guitarist.
Cory is a girl's name too.

myspace.com/corysmash

aim me at corysmash196
#9
Misfits>That pathetic excuse for punk.
Telecaster - SG - Jaguar
Princeton Reverb, Extra Reverb
P-Bass - Mustang Bass
Apogee Duet 2 - Ableton Suite
#10
I.......don't think it matters. I'd always pick Misfits because they have much better songs, I love the guitar that much more.
www.myspace.com/theoncefuturekings

Let me know what ya think!

MUFC

And it'll haunt you, my honey bee,
anyone who's anyone has had that same dream,
where you're falling, or where you're flying,
or were you calling out, or were you dying?
#11
I like the misfits a lot more than afi, but in terms of sheer technical ability I'd say Jade Puget is better.
#12
I love afi the misfits are awsome too

What i like about the misfits are that they wernt great at their instruments and their recordings sounded like ****. But just something about them that works and they inspired so many other bands and there just awsome.
#16
Both are somewhat mediocre in my eyes, but I would say the AFI fellow, although I am an avid Misfits fan. Although Doyle sounds decent on "American Psycho" and "Famous Monsters".
666 BRO
#17
I would say Jade Puget is better, though I do love the Misfits.
Quote by JoNnHannah
I'm homeschooled because I got tired of the corporate conformist administration.

So I have a pretty crime free school, unless i decide to kill someone.



The Search [GP5] C4C
#19
my aunt who has never picked up a guitar before can play Misfits songs. The only good thing about that band is Danzig's voice. The rest is utter trash. AFI i do hate as well, distastefully ripping off Bauhaus and The Misfits. But the guitarist is way better than Doyle.

#20
they both suck ass, when they can do somthing resembling a sweep arpeggio or a soulful blues solo, then we'll talk

n00b
Endorsed by Framus Amps


Quote by primusfan
you shoulda lynched that nigger.

*spits in spittoon and feels up his cousin*
#21
I'd like to see Jade play guitar as fast and as furiously as Doyle. Doyle uses mostly all downstrokes, and beats the **** out of his guitar when he plays it.

All in all theyve both got thier own skills
Was it polemically sent,
I Wanna know what you meant
I Wanna know,
I Wanna know what you meant
#22
The Afi guitarist is probly better but neither are very good. Misfits are a way better band tho
R.I.P Samantha

My Gear
Esp Ltd M-400
Randall Rg75W Amp
Dunlop Crybaby Wah
Fender Stratocaster
Yamaha something Acoustic
Several other cheap guitars/basses/Amps
#23
Quote by LastCaress88
I'd like to see Jade play guitar as fast and as furiously as Doyle. Doyle uses mostly all downstrokes, and beats the **** out of his guitar when he plays it.

All in all theyve both got thier own skills

Its really not that hard to pound out power chords as fast as you can.

Obviously AFI's guitar is more technical. I like the Misfits a lot more, though.

But just because someone plays only power chords doesn't necessarily mean that's all they can play. Like why the hell would you sweep pick in a punk band?

At least I would hope that after playing guitar for over 20 years Doyle can play more than just power chords.
Quote by XMetallica73X
I hate racists, but seriously Koreans/Chinese are ****ed up.

Quote by IbanezPlayer27

THOSE FUCKING MEXICANS?!@#! I HATE EM!!

I'm not racist
#24
The Misfits are n00b, Danzig was the only talented member. I haven't heard much AFI, but I can't imagine it'd be very hard to be better at guitar than the guy from The Misfits.
#25
Quote by axeslinger01
they both suck ass, when they can do somthing resembling a sweep arpeggio or a soulful blues solo, then we'll talk

n00b



I'm sure they probably both can. Just because they don't do it on their CDs doesn't mean they can't. It means that they see no place in the music they play for one, nor is there any place for a sweep arpeggio in punk/alternative music.

Grow up and realize that not everyone wants to sound like Steve Vai.

n00b.
Proud Owner of a Fender Jazz 24 V

Private Simmons of the Red vs. Blue club. PM Fret13 to join.

Things to come:
Carvin or Trace-elliot rig
EBS Valvedrive (Newest edition )
#26
i love em both, but take it to the punk thread
Quote by TinPants
ramen is the greatest achievement of mankind since pornographic photography.
#27
Quote by Sid McCall
Misfits>That pathetic excuse for punk.

i agree, and your avatar makes me wanna sing "Unity"
... For A Pair Of Brown Eyes

Quote by Bladez22
smoke, you get more awesome by the minute..... You have an epic beard, live near woods, listen to metal, grill stuff using makeshift bbqs out of old cans, and now we find out you have stabbed someone in the dick
#30
Neither are very great when it comes to guitar skill, but Doyle wrote catchier riffs and things like that, where as I dont even notice Puget's playing in AFI.
Spastic Ink
#32
Quote by Sid McCall
Misfits>That pathetic excuse for punk.

Yeah

How can you even compare them?
#34
Quote by Dont Leave Me
Dude.. Doyle 0wns Jade.
I like both the misfits and AFI..
but thats like yeahh.. definetly Doyle.


+1
And I love your username. I've always thought 1039 was Green Day's best record.
#35
Quote by UMadeMeRealise
+1
And I love your username. I've always thought 1039 was Green Day's best record.


Dude.. i wasnt talking about green day.
I was talking about my girlfriend.
#37
Quote by UMadeMeRealise
Oh. Well I feel rather ridiculous.


Lol... i made you realize.. i wasnt talking about green day.
ha!
its supposed to be funny.
you know.. your name..
Page 1 of 2