I was just wondering in what order the Redwall books are meant to be read, the chronological order or by the publication order. I have most of them but Im missing Lord Brocktree.

Nobody needs to bother critizing the books, if you dont like the books, thats good for you but I dont need to know.

I think you're supposed to start with 'Redwall', as that was the first one published, and then it doesn't matter all that much which order you read them in after that.

I thought they were pretty good at first, but after a while they just ended up getting a bit too samey; there's only so much you can do with the concept, really.

Although 'Redwall' and 'The Taggerung' are very good.
H aha! I read loads of these years ago. I remember them being kind of violent, which was good! I think you can red them in any order really. The cartoon of it is gash.
"It's not nice when people call you darling and that"
Quote by Jackolas
Is 18 too old to enjoy these books?

I'd say yes. I quite enjoyed them at 10-12 but afterwards they got kinda generic and then I grew out of them. Hehe still got them sitting on my bookshelf though =p Cool books at the time - good killing/violence!