Doesn't like breakadowns
Join date: Sep 2006
769 IQ
ok, so heres the thing: I play in a band with three of my friends from school. Me and the rhythm guitarist play great together and our drummer fits in fine, but our lead guitarist is the problem.. He's a great lead player, but his rhythm playing is sloppy and he always try to turn in a metalcore direction which we other three don't want at all. I feel like we need to let him go to progress as a band, but he is a good friend I don't wanna lose him as a friend either. I've spoken to the other guys and they feel the same way. Any suggestions?
guitar nooblet
Complete Noob
Join date: Jun 2007
315 IQ
Did you tell him how you guys feel yet? that should be the first thing you do.
Quote by Iamonfire
Dear sweet zombie Jesus, I just creamed my pants.
d3mon slay
Registered User
Join date: Apr 2007
1,343 IQ
Well you just have to let him know that he is a good guitarist but he isn't right for the band
C&C Magik
The Crowing of UG
Join date: Jul 2007
165 IQ
what guitar nooblet said.
Member #16 of the "Claudio Sanchez is god" Club. PM stepco12345 to join
The Mizfit
Registered User
Join date: Jun 2006
1,019 IQ
The best thing to do is talk to him. Tell him what direction u 3 want to go in. if he doesn't want to play that type of music then say its better off if we part ways.
call me JBoogie
Join date: Oct 2006
1,192 IQ
#6 should just turn into metalcore.
but thats just me...

just tell him how you guys feel about what the band should be. and if he doesnt like it...ask him to change or leave.
guitar nooblet
Complete Noob
Join date: Jun 2007
315 IQ
Quote by C&C Magik
what guitar nooblet said.

Quote by Iamonfire
Dear sweet zombie Jesus, I just creamed my pants.
Registered User
Join date: Jun 2007
155 IQ
if he's your friend, then im sure he'll understand.
Fender American Telecaster N7
Yamaha CG150
Line 6 Tonecore Echopark
Behringer VAMP 2.0

"There's only two colors around the world. That's pink and green. Making love and making money." - Blacks20
looking for groupies
Join date: Aug 2007
184 IQ
you should tell him straight up how you and your bandmates feel - don't beat around the bush. then tell him that the reality is that he either needs to shape up or move along. a band is a band, and your friendship shouldn't get in the way of the progression your band. BUT that applies visa-versa as well. don't let your band f*ck up your friendships, cuz your friendships will most likely outlive your band by a long shot. just be real with him.
"I can picture in my mind a world without war, a world without hate. And I can picture us attacking that world, because they'd never expect it."
UG Newbie
Join date: Oct 2004
217 IQ
just tell him what you think he might go fine **** you im gone or he might settle down and think about it if hes a great lead player you don't wanna let him go that quickly but if he can't get his rythem down then whats the point of keeping him. As Flaming Youth quoted "A Band Is A Band And Your Friendships Shouldn't Get In The Way Of Where You Wanna Progress To".
Lighthouse Man
Join date: Oct 2006
297 IQ
Let him play what he wants to play mate. Seriously, that's what each of you have different influences for...
Quote by death_metaller
**** burzum XD

there i said it...kinda

edit: i do realise they are not i kinda didnt say it...

Chick Magnet
Join date: Nov 2006
2,838 IQ
i had the same problem.
i just recently kicked out my best friend out of the band.
because he was pretty much useless.
he couldnt play for ****.
i didnt know he would take it so hard.
but i had to do what i had to do, and i had no intensions of breaking our friendship.
i still talk to him but he always brings it up, and hes not the same friend as he used to be.
you really have to be careful of how you present it to him, i wasnt and look where i ended up.
Ibanez RG7321
Dean Evo Special 7
Agile AL-2000
Peavey Vypyr 30
General of the 7 String/ERG Legion

Quote by Bentheemo
Thats probably some of the best advice I've ever received on here.
Join date: Jul 2006
653 IQ
How close friends are you with him?
If you guys are close it shouldn't be a problem and he should understand, but make sure you tell him to his face, if you just send him a mail he'll probably think you don't care at all about him.
Patrick Curley
Registered User
Join date: Apr 2007
169 IQ
Band politics is really hard, I've been on both sides over the years and I'd never kick anyone out now. Talk to the guy, if he's any good and wants to keep playing with you he'll go with the group thing and pursue his metalcore stuff elsewhere, otherwise he'll leave himself and be glad you had the guts to bring it up with him. The absolute worst thing you can do is keep talking about it without him, make it into something bigger than it is and then spring it on him one day when he doesn't expect it.
Registered User
Join date: Nov 2007
122 IQ
One day, have a discussion about band/friendship and how they don't necessarily go hand in hand. Next day point out that he is not right for the band. If first talk sunk in, he will take it at face value and hopefully not show up later and kill you all.
outlaw metaler
UG's resident whatever
Join date: Sep 2006
2,255 IQ
just say that you guys want to play this style and that you need to try and stay in that style

if he wants to play metalcore he is free to start his own metalcore band
Gretsch corvette
Epiphone SG special

big muff pi
crybaby wah
RC-2 loop station

Spider II 15W
Bugera 333XL 212
R.I.P Jeff Buckley
Join date: Aug 2006
418 IQ
yay! another "how to kick X person out of my band" thread
Who decided that pie would be sold on Tuesday but not Wednesday?
live and let die
Join date: Oct 2007
45 IQ
ive had to do the same thing you wont lose them as a friend but dont just say your fired give a good logical explanation