leodark_sr
Registered User
Join date: Feb 2008
21 IQ
#1
always with my classmates talk about guitarist..and they always sayme
Hendrix is the best guitarist ever , but why?
i need more explains...because i ever listen Eddie and Eddie is better...
only because Hendrix is before Van Halen and for respect him?
BleedDeathMetal
No longer so death metal
Join date: Apr 2007
1,046 IQ
#3
Hendrix
/thread
One of the most innovative guitarists of all time. Eddie Van Halen is good, but I wouldn't consider him great. No feeling as opposed to Hendrix which is full of it. Hendrix was raw, dirty, experimental and down to earth.
Quote by doggy_hat
This chick that looked like shrek ****ed me while I was passed out on xanax. I screamed when I woke up.
MetalliRage
Registered User
Join date: Aug 2007
189 IQ
#5
i hate when ppl say hendrix is better than hammett. page vs hendrix r better arguments. i personally prefer page
St.Loony
Banned
Join date: Aug 2007
367 IQ
#6
Hendrix was a huge influance back in the day
And still is to many guitarists today
He was amazign with his effects and what not
Just cuz he didn't play fast, that means he aint good... He created great music
Without Hendrix some guitarists today would be no where
And playing guitar isn't a sport... there is no "best" guitarist
axis56
UG Newbie
Join date: Feb 2008
71 IQ
#8
hendrix + zeppelin influences + other Yard birds guitarists = Foundation of rock

EVH = tapping technique stolen from stanley jordan used in metal instead

im with hendrix
Quote by Lord-O-Donuts
'Nine out of ten people actually enjoy gang rape.'
Megallica666
UG Newbie
Join date: Dec 2007
65 IQ
#9
so is van halen or at least the band is. i hate them, but eddie is really good. so is hendrix, of course steve vai is better then both
think11270
UG Addict
Join date: Oct 2002
165 IQ
#10
People say Hendrix was the best guitarist ever because he was quite a bit of an innovator when it comes to music at the time, and some of his songs are a challenge to play as well.
In my eyes, Hendrix is better his style and playing is very..interesting. I can't stand EVH- Sure he plays faster uses cool techniques but he's not that good of a songwriter and it's quite apparent he knows little theory. You can't really compare two different era and style guitarists like that, they both have their good and bad points really. It's all a matter of opinion.
Also, classmates tend to just think what other's say without any opinion of their own.
Ask them..
I think they're both pretty overrated, really.
Sorry everyone.


myspace.com/weasheroesband
Last edited by think11270 at Feb 9, 2008,
Mark-O1987666
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2006
81 IQ
#13
In terms of technical skill, Van Halen was more polished, but Hendrix was more innovative
swampthing1117
Registered User
Join date: Sep 2006
18 IQ
#14
these are seriously the stupidest discussions ever. Stop now, you all look like idiots. No guitarist is "better" than another, they are just different with different techniques. If you wanna compare technique, EVH is lightyears ahead of hendrix in pure technique. When it comes to music you can't judge which is better, just which you LIKE more.

Stop these dumb discussions now, just makes you look ignorant.
rebeltildeth87
†мєтal†
Join date: Jan 2008
523 IQ
#15
How can you say whos the better musician? There two different styles of rock guitar playing. If you want to say whos better technially, Eddie Van Halen is. If you want to say better soulfully, Hendrix is. You need not focus on whos a better musician because music isnt a competition. There both better than the other at what they do.
Originally Posted by fatdanny
Also, check out Autopsy, the vocalist sounds like hes about to eat your grandmother while f
punkmetalA7X91
young metal head
Join date: Oct 2007
72 IQ
#16
hendrix
eddie van halen is the most overrated guitarist in the history of music all he did was use double tapping in his solos and people like randie rhodes did it better anyway
Mark-O1987666
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2006
81 IQ
#17
Quote by punkmetalA7X91
hendrix
eddie van halen is the most overrated guitarist in the history of music all he did was use double tapping in his solos and people like randie rhodes did it better anyway


You're probably the stupidest person to make a comment here.
BOC15
Money... It's a crime.
Join date: Jul 2007
114 IQ
#18
forget them and keep this discussion... everyone else enjoys it, i dont understand why you have to go out your way to tell how crappy these threads are.. wow.. seriously..

anyway i prefer eddie van halen over hendrix.. yes hendrix is one of the best.. and was better than anyone at his time and is still practiaclly.. but EVH didnt create the tappin process.. but revolutionized it. Also, his is much more better to listen to.. although Hendrix's is good, most of his songs are alsmot to experimental sounding, other than some like electric ladyland, i love that song, but all together i have to agree with EVH.
Cptbeefheart
UG's Captain of Beef
Join date: Jul 2005
33 IQ
#19
*reported*

No Vs. threads allowed.
Co-Founder of the Creedence Clearwater Revival Fanclub...PM me or Pi3h-B0y to join!

Member #17 of the UG Queen Fanclub!...PM Hanzi_G to join!

The Sinister Minister of Zeppelinism...Pm TheHeartbreaker to join.
urgey_rock
Guitar Original #7
Join date: Feb 2004
928 IQ
#20
This is the same age old argument that's been around for decades. Here's the bottom line: people don't understand the difference between the words greatest and best. When a guitarist is great, that generally means that they have had a huge influence on the guitar. When one says best, they are generally saying that one is the best technical player. There is a huge difference.

What pisses me off is when people talk about how Hendrix would kick the **** out of all of the other guitarists of the modern age. Hendrix was probably the "greatest" guitarist, but by no means is he technically equipped to face off against those of today. Guitarists like Eddie Van Halen or Steve Vai have a lot more technical skill to their playing, no matter which way you look at it. And you definitely can't say that Van Halen knew nothing of theory either... The fact is, he probably knew more about it than Hendrix, as he was musically trained on the piano, and Hendrix had no training (not saying that this true for certain, but it definitely is a valid argument).

Let's face it, if Jimi Hendrix had never been born until 10 or so years ago, nobody today would probably think he's as technically adept as they do now. But I'm also not saying that he wasn't important, or doesn't deserve any credit either.

In short:
Hendrix=Greatest (most influential).
Eddie Van Halen= One of the best (from a technical perspective)

This post will be subject to a lot of hate mail, but quite frankly, I don't give a ****. It had to be said.
!VAN HALEN FOR EVER!
BOC15
Money... It's a crime.
Join date: Jul 2007
114 IQ
#21
thats the problem there buddy... if you have a problem with it just shut the **** up.... none of us want to hear it... if we want to debate about it, let us do it and stop being such a bitch about it... im not directing this to you personally, so no offense or nothin man, but that goes for everyone.
urgey_rock
Guitar Original #7
Join date: Feb 2004
928 IQ
#22
hahaha the anger... well, I was merely expressing my opinion on the argument, in accordance with the debate. I don't believe in these arguments, but I was expressing another side of the argument, so it was not meant to offend you, but if it did, then I apologize... Personally, if you want my short response to the argument, I like EVH better.
!VAN HALEN FOR EVER!
Supernaut2k
Blackmore Worshipper
Join date: Sep 2007
64 IQ
#24
i think both are overrated as players, as a human being, hendrix is an all around legend, so he gets my vote.
leodark_sr
Registered User
Join date: Feb 2008
21 IQ
#25
look... Hendrix is really overrated... because the innovation that him did in his time...
But EVH did the same thing... nobody can plays like Eddie also in his time...

why te people say the lie '' Hendrix is the more greates guitarist ever'' why ???
i think Van Halen is equal than Hendrix but the people don`t wanna view that...