Pastorius666
Banned
Join date: Nov 2007
812 IQ
#1
Just want to know what everyones opinion on him is. Personally, I agree with the "Clapton is God." But I have a guitarist friend who listens to everything and says that he hates clapton. I was humming wonderful tonight and he smacked me. He says everyting clapton plays sounds the same. Opinions?
CraigKing
UG's English guy
Join date: Mar 2006
725 IQ
#2
Then he's silly, most of Claptons song are far different, from reggae, to blues to rock. He's probably saying he doesn't like him because he wants to be "different".
Irontallica09
Banned
Join date: Dec 2007
20 IQ
#4
Quote by deepestpurple
Your friend is a dick.


^ +1

Clapton is great guitar player but not only that is is a great songwriter, I think anyone who is serious about guitar likes clapton, or at least has some respect for his playing. I don't listen to claptons stuff all the time but it is really great to sit and relax and listen too.
Blake99
Registered User
Join date: Feb 2008
100 IQ
#5
CLAPTON's music sounding the same is like sayin iron maidens music doesnt sound the same....clapton rocks no matter what song it is and yea some people probably just wanna be different but i'll never want to be so different that i dissed Clapton man thats unamerican
Goldenad
Registered User
Join date: Dec 2007
32 IQ
#7
Quote by Blake99
CLAPTON's music sounding the same is like sayin iron maidens music doesnt sound the same....clapton rocks no matter what song it is and yea some people probably just wanna be different but i'll never want to be so different that i dissed Clapton man thats unamerican



maybe...but clapton is british so its ok
ECwomantoneman
The Blues-Rockin' Giant
Join date: Oct 2006
157 IQ
#8
Quote by deepestpurple
Your friend is a dick.


+2


As us Brits say, "your mate sounds like a bit of a titwank arsehole to me"

CLAPTON IS GOD! PRAISE BE TO GOD!


sorry. I'll stop now.
ze monsta
I wonder why I stay
Join date: May 2007
419 IQ
#9
Meh! Ypur friend is a bit of a dip**** then. 'Cos Clapton numbers don't sound the same; there is so much variation that I believe your friend has some form of mental disease.
claptonfan55
Bluesius Maximus
Join date: Aug 2006
408 IQ
#10
Quote by deepestpurple
Your friend is a dick.

+1, and I would bet that at least a few of his favorite guitarists have cited clapton as an influence.
"Notes are expensive. . .use them wisely"-B.B. King

"It's been very important throughout my career that I've met all the guys I've copied, because at each stage they've said, 'Don't play like me, play like you."-Eric Clapton
Irontallica09
Banned
Join date: Dec 2007
20 IQ
#11
Quote by Blake99
CLAPTON's music sounding the same is like sayin iron maidens music doesnt sound the same....clapton rocks no matter what song it is and yea some people probably just wanna be different but i'll never want to be so different that i dissed Clapton man thats unamerican


oh so bashing Clapton is wrong? how about bashing maiden
Jearl
yr bird.
Join date: Sep 2004
118 IQ
#12
Quote by Pastorius666
Just want to know what everyones opinion on him is. Personally, I agree with the "Clapton is God." But I have a guitarist friend who listens to everything and says that he hates clapton. I was humming wonderful tonight and he smacked me. He says everyting clapton plays sounds the same. Opinions?


well, if he knew you were humming Wonderful Tonight, his whole point is out the window.


and besides, Cream doesnt sound at all like the Yardbirds which doesnt sound like Derek & the Dominos. i could go on.
aig91
Annie
Join date: Sep 2006
8,809 IQ
#13
Quote by deepestpurple
Your friend is a dick.


+ 4

Clapton's songs don't sound the same. And if he smacked you for humming a song you like then he's obviously a dick and a control freak.
gopherthegreat
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2007
592 IQ
#14
how can he possibley say they all sound the same?!


hes an amazing player

Jack my swag
Dimebag22
☮ ♥ ♫
Join date: Mar 2006
505 IQ
#15
Man, thats messed up. Clapton has so many different styles. Tell him to listen to 'Wonderful Tonight' then listen to 'Hey Hey' then listen to 'Spoonful'. I could go on forever. He covers a way too many genres and styles.
Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day
You fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way
Kicking around on a piece of ground in your home town
Waiting for someone or something to show you the way
heavybloozer
Registered User
Join date: Oct 2006
512 IQ
#16
ec definitely is one of the most diverse guitar players ever. while i think that his newer and more commercial work is nothing compared to his pioneer work in the 60s he from time to time makes a comeback to the blues-for example with the record from the cradle or the robert johnson tribute-.
when ec lets his blues hang out or when his back with good ole rock then he smokes but the commercial stuff like his terrible last record or the boring road to escondido just doesnt get it for me.
President of the Jeff Beck Club(PM me to join)

Sergeant Destroyer Member Of the KISS army

PM sloopy to join
Beakwithteeth
Wild and Reckless Hobo
Join date: Nov 2007
671 IQ
#17
Quote by deepestpurple
Your friend is a dick.



I couldn't think of anything to say so I will just agree with this.
tincho729
Registered User
Join date: May 2007
384 IQ
#18
Quote by Blake99
CLAPTON's music sounding the same is like sayin iron maidens music doesnt sound the same....clapton rocks no matter what song it is and yea some people probably just wanna be different but i'll never want to be so different that i dissed Clapton man thats unamerican



Someone probably said alredy that he's british


...and if you consider critizicing something "unamerican", and you leave it alone even though it's not ok, you'll never improve.

Finally, it also seems really dum to me that you think some bands are good just because they're really known..maybe someone doesn't like iron maiden. It's called taste
--F-F-T-S---
--EbOla----
---name pending?--

Quote by PlayMadness
No. Everybody dies. And one day, given that your relationship doesn't crash and burn like so many do, one of you will end up deep in sorrow while watching the other one die.


gopherthegreat
Registered User
Join date: Jan 2007
592 IQ
#19
Quote by tincho729
Finally, it also seems really dum to me that you think some bands are good just because they're really known..maybe someone doesn't like iron maiden. It's called taste

most us us dont care about what other people listen to, but saying everything clapton plays sounds the same is just stupid

Jack my swag