I'm used to .10s tuned either standard or down a half-step on a 24.75" guitar.

I've been wanting to down tune a 25.5" scale guitar down by a whole step, but I'm sure that my usual .10 strings would be far too slack then (even just down tuning half a step with .10s on a 24.75" gets a tad too slack for my liking).

So, would something like .11 or .12 strings be much better on the 25.5" guitar when tuned down a whole step? I'm aiming to get about the same string tension as the .10s in standard on a 24.75".
The shorter scale on the 24.75 is what gives them so much slack. I use tens on a Les Paul And Generally tune Either in Standard, Drop D, or C# standard. They're fine for me, but if its still to much slack for you you can go up to 11's and it will be perfect. Any higher and you'll needa setup though.
Founder of UG's David Bowie Fan Club. Pm to join.

Founder of UG's "Rockers against being freakishly skinny" Club. PM to join.